A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Joey Haber

Torah Lecture

How to raise good kids, while you're under so much pressure

Lectured by Rabbi Joey Haber

Published
March 22, 2012
Duration
46:28
Lecture code
JH349

The pressure of raising children

  • Rabbi Joey Haber frames the subject as raising children while parents are under intense pressure. Many parents are already stretched thin while trying to raise several children well.
  • He recalls a friend from yeshiva who had advanced at Goldman Sachs, earning more and receiving substantial bonuses. When they spoke on Purim, however, the friend said his salary was down about 40%, he sometimes worked until 10 p.m., his wife earned more than he did, he had given up on buying a house, and he was simply trying to survive.
  • Rabbi Haber says many people are facing heavy pressure. The period from Purim to Pesach is especially demanding, with the expense and preparation involved in getting the home and family ready.
  • The challenges are widely shared, he says; he hears about them by speaking with people. He also describes coming home at 9:45 p.m., going almost straight to sleep, and being busy until 1 a.m., leaving little time for his children.
  • He plans to offer three things not to do and three things to do when raising children under stress. The parasha is Vayakhel-Pekudei.

Three things not to do

1. Don’t overreact when disciplining a child

  • The rishonim, acharonim, and other commentaries ask why the Egyptians were punished for enslaving the Jewish people if God had told Avraham Avinu that his descendants would suffer in Egypt.
  • The Ramban and the Malbim offer similar explanations. One is that the Egyptians were meant to make the Jews work, but went beyond what was required, imposing extra pressure and suffering. Another explanation is that their intention was to cause suffering, not to fulfill God’s will.
  • Rabbi Haber applies this to parenting: a parent may need to correct or punish a child, but must not add extra anger or hurt because of unrelated stress.
  • He compares this to a driver who makes a mistake: a honk, a reprimand, or calling the police after an accident might be proportionate; shooting the other driver would be an absurdly excessive response.
  • Parents sometimes “shoot” their children in this figurative sense by pouring accumulated frustration onto them. A child’s small mistake can receive a vastly disproportionate reaction.
  • He recounts a case involving a family’s sixteen-year-old son, Ike. After plans to take him out with the family became difficult, the mother suggested that the father take Ike alone. The father responded, “You want me to go out to eat with that idiot in front of the kids?”
  • Rabbi Haber relates the father’s remark to the pressures he was carrying—financial strain, work, and frustration—while noting that the son was also a difficult, but perhaps ordinary, teenager. The father’s anger was far beyond what the situation called for.
  • Similar situations occur in many homes, he says, with financial, health-related, or other stress spilling onto a child. A parent should instruct, guide, and discipline, but the response must fit what the child did: don’t give a child more than they deserve because you are having a hard time.

2. Disagree with your spouse in the right way

  • Rabbi Haber says it would be ideal never to disagree in front of the children, but he considers that unrealistic. The important distinction is between an ordinary disagreement and one that becomes aggressive or hurtful.
  • The Midrash describes a deer breaking off its horns before entering a forest, so they will not catch in the trees. It compares this to people needing to work on their character before entering adult life.
  • A trait such as attitude, obnoxiousness, laziness, or aggression may be manageable in one’s teenage years, but can become damaging in marriage and family life. Unchecked “horns” can cause a person to get caught up in conflict at every turn.
  • Rabbi Haber illustrates the difference with a disagreement over holiday clothing. A husband asks why his wife bought outfits when money is needed for bills; she says she bought four, not the fourteen he accuses her of buying. That disagreement may be ordinary.
  • It crosses a line when he calls her a spoiled brat and complains that she spends while he works twelve-hour days, and she counters that her friends eat out twice a week while she barely does so monthly, then tells him to see whether another woman would put up with him.
  • Children watching such an exchange may not know how to interpret it. Rabbi Haber says children often blame themselves when their parents divorce, although they were not told it was their fault; he suggests this reflects how differently children can understand the conflict they witness.
  • He has also heard children say they think their parents are getting divorced after hearing or seeing an argument, even though the parents remained married five years later.
  • He uses “violent” to mean aggressive speech, not physical violence. Parents may disagree, including about money, but should avoid speech and behavior that make the disagreement frightening or incomprehensible to their children.
  • His practical point is not to pretend that spouses never disagree, but to manage one’s character and keep the disagreement from escalating into damaging behavior in front of the children.

3. Do your best not to bring a bad mood into the home

  • Rabbi Haber acknowledges that staying in a good mood is difficult and may sound unrealistic, but says the mood in the home matters.
  • The Gemara quotes the pasuk in Mishlei, “K'mayim hapanim la'panim, ken lev ha'adam la'adam.” Its simple interpretation is reciprocity between people: as one person treats another, the other responds in kind.
  • In Yevamot, the Gemara applies the pasuk to teaching: according to Rashi’s explanation, a teacher should teach with a smile and happiness, because the child absorbs that happiness.
  • The Gemara in Ta'anit says that when a child’s learning does not take hold and the child is “like iron,” it is because the teachers are not teaching with love and happiness.
  • Rabbi Haber applies the principle to the home: a happy home gives children the conditions to grow, like a seed receiving sunlight. He says an unhappy home makes healthy growth very difficult.
  • He describes how his view of his own life can change within twenty minutes—from gratitude for his wife, children, home, and work to feeling that everything is unbearable because of bills and pressure. A friend joked that there was a pill for that. Rabbi Haber says many people experience similar shifts.
  • If the atmosphere at home changes with each work problem, doctor’s visit, or child’s report card, the home becomes unstable and is not a good place for children to grow.
  • As an example of deliberately creating happiness, Rabbi Haber describes his wife preparing for Purim when he expected about 200 boys at their home. She fried 200 kibbeh, made 200 lahmajin and about 200 franks and blankets, and prepared six large tins of chicken nuggets.
  • Their theme was Pomegranate: they arranged aisles for takeout, mazza, snacks and drinks, and bakery goods; decorated with large posters and signs; and had the children wear green sweatshirts and handmade burgundy aprons with “the Haber people” stickers.
  • Rabbi Haber says he had little to do with the preparations, but they created happiness in the home for two weeks. Even when preparations became tense, the children repeatedly experienced that shared excitement.
  • He says that, though this is hard, parents have a responsibility to provide the “sun” of happiness. Children can live without new shoes, but they cannot thrive in a home dominated by darkness, pressure, or sadness.

Three things to do

1. Prepare yourself before you see your children

  • Responding to the difficulty of coming home tired and not feeling cheerful, Rabbi Haber says that sometimes it may be better not to engage immediately; he then offers a related practice of preparing oneself before interacting.
  • The Ben Ish Chai writes that before entering a shul to pray, a person should pause at the door and think, “Right now I’m entering a shul.” Rabbi Haber suggests doing something similar before children come home.
  • If a child arrives at 4:30, he recommends stopping at 4:25—or, ideally, 4:20—to prepare mentally. Parents can adjust their mood and get ready for what their children may need.
  • He compares this to preparing for a business meeting: a person would not walk into one without thinking about what to bring or say, yet parents may enter the important “meeting” with their children without preparing how to respond.
  • He also urges parents returning from work to turn off the radio, music, and phone before reaching home, and to take a few minutes to shift mentally and emotionally from work to family. Turning off the phone only at the door is not enough.
  • Rabbi Haber calls children a parent’s most important “customers”: other customers may be gone in five years, while, inshallah, the children will still be there. Parents should remain tuned in to them.
  • Yaakov Avinu reprimanded his three oldest children before his death, though he blessed most of his children. Rabbeinu Bachya notes that Yaakov reprimanded Reuven for a sin from fifty years earlier. Rabbi Haber presents this as an example of a parent recognizing a mistake and waiting until the appropriate time to address it; he remarks, “Fifty years means 2062.”
  • Parents do not need to change their entire day, he says; even a few minutes of preparation before the children arrive can help them be attentive. Children generally need focus and attention more than money, holiday outfits, or new shoes.
  • He illustrates the need to notice quieter children with a story about his approximately seven-year-old middle son, who helped a man put away siddurim in shul on Saturday night. When the man praised him and asked whether he should tell the boy’s father, the boy agreed, then suggested that his father call the man. The quiet child, like the others, wanted his father’s attention.
  • Life need not be perfect, Rabbi Haber says, but parents should be tuned in; even this short preparation could make a substantial difference.

2. Make sure you have a life of your own

  • Rabbi Haber says parents need regular ways to relax and unwind, with or without their spouse. The form will differ from person to person.
  • Possibilities include taking Saturday night or late-night time for oneself, exercising, walking with a friend, listening to music for half an hour, reading each night, or going out with friends.
  • The activity need not cost money. The point is to feel some control over one’s life rather than living under pressure every hour of every day.
  • If parents have no life outside the stress, they and the people around them will suffer. If they feel healthy, strong, and able to relax—rather than feeling that life is 24/7 pressure—they can give their children more of what they need.

3. Talk with your children and let them learn from challenges

  • Rabbi Haber says parents should talk to their children about what is happening, especially when the family is under stress. Children should not be left to guess, since they often guess incorrectly. Parents can explain some of the situation without giving every frightening detail.
  • For example, if finances are tight because another child has entered school and tuition has increased by about $20,000 before book fees, parents can explain that the family is financially okay, Baruch Hashem, but will need to do some things differently because costs have risen.
  • If one child is sick and needs extra attention, parents can explain that this child is unwell, reassure the other children that Mommy and Daddy still love them, and explain that they will still receive individual attention every Sunday, even if Mommy sometimes needs to be on the phone during dinner.
  • Rabbi Haber asks people to think of their clearest and best memory of their parents. He says such memories often involve seeing parents face a challenge and watching how they handled it.
  • Parents can sit down with their children, explain that the family is going through a hard time, and describe how they are trying to manage it. Children can learn from watching the process.
  • He argues that a childhood without problems is not necessarily a good childhood, because it can leave children unprepared for life. Difficulties and “bumps” can give parents an opportunity to show children what is happening and how to respond.
  • In Vayakhel-Pekudei, the Mishkan is being built. The Aron Kodesh bears two keruvim, a boy and a girl, facing each other with their wings raised.
  • The Kli Yakar explains that the wings point upward to represent attention to God, while the keruvim face each other to represent care for other people: both the relationship between people and the connection to God matter.
  • Rabbi Haber connects this to Moshe Rabbeinu raising his hands while fighting Amalek, and to the kohanim facing the congregation and raising their hands during Birkat Kohanim: facing people represents the relationship between people, and raised hands represent the connection to God.
  • Parents can use challenges to teach children about honesty and dishonesty, how real life works, and how Hashem helps even during hardship—lessons that are especially meaningful when they can be seen in practice.
  • Parents should not hide everything in an effort to protect their children. They should share an age-appropriate amount, without exposing them to every gruesome detail, and help them understand that a difficulty is real but not necessarily frightening or catastrophic. For example, Pesach may be different this year, but it is not the end of the world.
  • Children may still complain, Rabbi Haber notes, but understanding the situation can help them learn from it. He calls childhood challenges a blessing because they help prepare children for life.

Rabbi Haber’s six takeaways

  • When reprimanding a child, do not let anger make the response more severe than the child’s mistake warrants.
  • When disagreeing with your spouse, avoid aggressive or hurtful behavior that children cannot understand.
  • Do your best to keep a bad mood from defining the home; children need a happy environment in which to grow.
  • Before the children come home—and before you return home—take five minutes to focus, plan, and tune in.
  • Make sure you have a life of your own so that you have the strength and capacity to give your children one.
  • Use stress and difficulty as opportunities to communicate, connect, teach, and train. Rabbi Haber says everyone faces stress, whether now, six months from now, or six months ago, and remarks that it feels as though people were dealing with a great deal of it in 2012.
Words in this lecture2
Gemaraגמרא
Terms Gemara, the Talmud's discussion of the Mishnah. English: Commentary on the Mishnah
Also written: Gemarah, G'mara, Guemara, gmara
Plural: gemarot, gemaras
Pasukפסוק
Terms Pasuk, a verse. English: Biblical verse
Also written: Passuk, posuk, psuq
Plural: Pesukim, psukim, p'sukim, psuqim, Pesukei, psukeem