A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Joey Haber

Torah Lecture

Why Do They Get To Go To The Hospital?

Lectured by Rabbi Joey Haber

Published
December 18, 2025
Duration
5:40
Lecture code
Q5-JH1149

The Family’s Dilemma

  • A parent described a very frum, yeshiva-type family with 10 children and almost no technology: no television, movies, social media, or other unfiltered media.
  • One son was a little shaky about staying on the derech and wanted more action than the quiet household offered. He wanted to watch football at someone’s house on Sundays.
  • The parents believed he needed this, and felt that if football were the worst thing he did, allowing it could even be a mitzvah. But they worried that his older and younger brothers would also want to go, turning it into a regular practice for the whole family.
  • Rabbi Joey Haber noted that families can mishandle this kind of situation: an exception for one child who is off the path can make that child a role model for the others, leading the whole family to abandon its standards.

The Chatam Sofer on Treating Children Differently

  • Rabbi Joey Haber’s advice draws on the Chatam Sofer, who discusses the Gemara’s teaching never to differentiate between one child and another.
  • The Chatam Sofer says this applies when the children are the same. He reads the Gemara’s wording—“one son amongst other sons”—as referring to sons who are alike.
  • When one child is different—whom the Chatam Sofer describes as uniquely talented, holy, or wise—the Chatam Sofer says there is no jealousy.
  • Rabbi Joey Haber asks why that would be so, since giving one child more could seem to invite jealousy. He explains that parents can talk openly with their children: everyone is treated equally in love, even when children have different needs.

Explaining Different Needs to Children

  • Rabbi Joey Haber compares an emotional need to a physical one: if a child had to go to the hospital every week, the parents could explain that the child needs care, and that they would take any child to the hospital if that child needed it. There might still be complaints, but the reason would be understandable.
  • He says that the same principle applies even more strongly to an emotional problem. Parents can tell their children that they are proud of the children who are inspired, learning, growing, and following the family’s way, while explaining that another child is less involved and needs an exception.
  • He also gives the example of parents speaking to their three married children: everyone is functioning, but one sibling is not, so the parents have decided to help that sibling more. If another sibling needed that help, the parents would give it to them too.
  • The key is to make clear that a child receiving different treatment is not loved, cherished, or valued more. Children may accept different rules; what can make them resentful is believing that the difference means their parents value someone else more.
  • A parent can explain: “Right now she’s in need, and she’s the one we’re addressing. If two months from now you’d be in need, you’d be the one we’re addressing.” Rabbi Joey Haber describes this as healthy parenting.

Applying the Principle to the Football Request

  • Rabbi Joey Haber’s advice is to tell the children that the family does not watch TV or football at home and that this is not what the family does.
  • The parents can also acknowledge that this son is visibly different from the rest of the family, including in his clothes and haircut, and explain that they love him just the same.
  • Because he needs to watch football, they will arrange for him to go to someone’s house to watch it. Rabbi Joey Haber says the other children will understand when the parents explain that the exception is being made because this child needs it.