Someone once approached me and said they have a very, very frum (religiously observant) family. They have 10 kids, a very frum, very yeshiva-type family. There’s barely any technology in the house: obviously no television, no movies, no nothing, no social media, nothing. It’s very filtered. But they have one son who’s a little bit shaky about being on the derech (path)—a little off the derech, a little shaky. So this son kind of needs more action than this boring house has. He wants to go to someone’s house to watch football games on Sundays.
The problem is that he has older and younger brothers, and the parents don’t want all the brothers going to someone’s house. Next thing you know, there are going to be five boys in someone’s house watching football every Sunday. They don’t think that’s appropriate for the other boys. What would you tell these parents? But they believe this kid needs to watch football. This kid needs to see those things. He needs it. It’s football, not the end of the world. If that’s the worst he’s going to do, it’ll be a mitzvah (commandment) for him. What would you tell that parent to do? They come to you and say, “My one kid needs to watch something, but I don’t want it to become an epidemic in my house.”
Many families mismanage this. They have one kid, maybe their second child, who’s a little off the path, and before you know it, their whole family has gone off the rails. Because that kid became a role model for everybody else. Then, once they’re breaking the rules for this one, they break the rules for this one. And then everybody is just completely not what they expected their house to be. What would you suggest?
My suggestion is the words of the Chatam Sofer. Here’s what the Chatam Sofer says. He says, “The Gemara says that you should never, never differentiate between one child and another.” The Chatam Sofer says that’s only if those children are the same. It’s only if they’re exactly the same. That’s why the Gemara’s words were, “Don’t make a differentiation: one son amongst other sons.” Which means one son amongst other sons who are exactly the same.
But when there’s one child who’s different—in this case, the Chatam Sofer means uniquely talented, uniquely holy, uniquely wise—in that case, there’s no jealousy. What does this mean? How does that work? I would say there’s more jealousy. The kid’s wise, now you’re treating him better and giving him more; there’s more jealousy. And here’s what the Chatam Sofer means: You’re allowed to have a conversation with your children. You’re allowed to tell your children, “Hi, guys, we are very fair in this house. Everybody gets treated the same.” Because when it comes to love, everybody’s treated the same.
But this one kid has different needs. If, chas veshalom (God forbid), one child wasn’t well and needed to go to the hospital every week, no kid would complain, “Why do they get off from school and go to the hospital every week?” Maybe they would still complain. But you could explain it easily to them: “This kid has to go to the hospital, and we take care of a kid who has to go to the hospital. And if, chas veshalom, someone else had to go to the hospital, we’d take them to the hospital too.” So if it’s true with regard to a physical problem, it’s even more true with regard to an emotional problem.
You could tell your kids, “You see this kid? He’s a little less into it. I’m so proud of you. You’re into it. You’re inspired. You’re learning. You’re growing. You’re following our way. But this kid is not. So we’re making an exception for this kid because he needs it.” Or you may take your three married children and say, “Guys, everyone here is functioning. You know one of your siblings is not functioning. So we decided we’re going to help them a little more because they’re not functioning. And if you needed it, we’d give it to you too.” That has to be the sentiment.
Because kids don’t mind if it’s different. They don’t mind if the line is higher than the other. What they mind is that the difference means you love them more than me. You cherish them more than me. You value her more than me. “If you value her more than me, I will resent you for the rest of my life.” But if you don’t value her more than me, but you just say, “Listen, I take care of any kid who’s in need. Right now she’s in need, and she’s the one we’re addressing. If two months from now you’d be in need, you’d be the one we’re addressing,” then that parent is a very, very, very healthy parent.
That’s why my advice to that parent was to tell all the kids, “Guys, we don’t watch TV here. We don’t watch football here. It’s not what we do. But this kid—you could obviously tell. You could tell from the clothes he wears. You could tell from the haircut he has. You could tell he’s a little different from the rest of us. But we love him just the same. And therefore, we’re going to provide him with what he needs. And what he needs is to go to someone’s house and watch football.” And I want to tell you something: Kids will understand this.