A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Joey Haber

Torah Lecture

Your Job Is To Figure It Out!

Lectured by Rabbi Joey Haber

Published
October 23, 2025
Duration
5:41
Lecture code
Q1-JH1142

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

Yaakov Kamenetsky has a sermon called Emet L'Yaakov. It's a commentary on Chumash, and on the first page, on Parashat Noach, he says this idea. He says, “You want to know why we knock Noach?” He says, “We knock Noach in comparison to Avraham Avinu, because Avraham Avinu was able to change the generation. Noach couldn't save anybody.” So he says, “Why couldn't Noach save anybody?” And you'll understand the point in a minute.

Why couldn't Noach save anybody? He says, “What do you mean? The Midrash (rabbinic interpretation) says that Noach tried. Noach was a good man. Noach told people, ‘I'm building a teivah (ark) for 120 years.’ He built a teivah, and he told people, ‘How are you worshipping idols, empty-headed people? You're worshipping a dry stick? You're worshipping a piece of wood? And you're not following God?’” He tried.

He says, “What did Noach do wrong?” Some say he didn't pray for him; that's not his answer. He says, “Why did Noach do wrong?” He says, “Why did Noach do wrong?” He says, “Because people weren't worshipping idols because they wanted to worship idols. They were worshipping idols because they wanted to be immoral. And they didn't want to be loyal to their relationships, and they didn't want to be loyal to their marriages. So the whole point of worshipping idols is to say, basically, ‘Not care about God, not care about Hashem,’ and then be immoral. The point of the problem was not idol worship. And now, when you're yelling and screaming about idol worship, you missed the point. The point of the problem was immorality. The point of the problem was that they wanted not to care and to do whatever their heart desired. They wanted to follow every temptation in the world.”

So now Rabbi Yaakov Kamenetsky says, “One second, so he missed the point. So the poor man, he tried. He tried. He just didn't understand what the people really were doing it for. He thought they wanted to worship idols, so he was yelling about worshipping idols. But really, it's immorality, and he missed it. So okay, that's not his fault. He's still a good person. He's still trying his hardest.”

And here's the words he says. He says, “No, no, no. If you're missing the wisdom to get it, and you're missing the wisdom to understand it, and you're missing the talent to communicate it, and you don't get what's really on their mind, it's a lack of righteousness. A lot of times you have people who are not doing proper well in life. And you say, ‘Why?’ ‘Oh, I don't know how to talk. I don't know how. I'm not stuck.’ The person just doesn't know how to be a great wife. She doesn't know how to really be a great mother. What are you supposed to do? Her mother wasn't a great mother, so she's not such a great mother. She's trying. She's a wonderful person. Sometimes you see people—oh, they look so innocent. They're really good-hearted. Trying and good-hearted is not an excuse.” That's what he's saying.

He's saying that if you have a responsibility not just to try, you have a responsibility to be effective. “But what do you mean? But I'm trying. My heart is in the right place.” Your heart is not good enough. It's a great start, but it's not good enough. Your job is not just to have your heart in the right place. Your job is to figure it out.

So many times you look at a person and you say, “Oh, the person, he doesn't know how to take care of his spouse. He doesn't know how to be there for his spouse. He just doesn't know how to talk to his spouse. That's it, the guy tried, and he just doesn't know how.” Tried is not good enough. That's his point. Noach also tried. But it wasn't good enough, because Avraham Avinu tried and was effective. Noach tried and was not effective. Noach was missing the point when he was trying.

Sometimes you have a teacher. You say, “Oh, the teacher is a good rabbi. He's a good teacher. He's a good person. But the kids aren't listening, and the kids aren't enjoying, and the kids aren't inspired, and the kids aren't learning.” But he's a good guy. A good guy is not good enough. Effective is what we're responsible for.

Now, effective doesn't mean you're always getting perfect results. But you have to know how to be effective. And these are his words: “If you were trying, if you were trying your fullest and your hardest, you would figure it out.” So I don't want to hear about the man who's not a great husband because he was never taught. Someone knows. There's a book somewhere. There's a rabbi somewhere. There's a therapist somewhere. Someone has the information. Figure it out.

I don't want to hear. What? He wanted this person. He's a good person, but he's not a good father. Figure it out. If you had kids, Hashem, there's somewhere in the world—the skill set is there. It's available. It might be you could listen to a class. It might be you could go get someone's advice. Your job is to figure it out.

Don't tell me you tried. Don't be a teacher who doesn't know how to teach. Don't be a mother who doesn't know how to mother. Don't be a father who doesn't know how to guide. Don't be a husband who doesn't know how to relate. Don't be a wife who doesn't know how to care. You can't. You can't do that. Don't be a child who doesn't know how to be there for your parents. There is someone who's got instructions for you. Figure it out.

Noach's heart might have been in the right place, just like Avraham Avinu's heart was. But the Torah doesn't consider them the same, because Avraham Avinu was effective and Noach was ineffective, even though it wasn't because of a lack of trying. But a lack of wisdom is a lack of trying.