A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Joseph Dana

Torah Lecture

Mishnah Kelim 2-6

Lectured by Rabbi Joseph Dana

Published
June 1, 2026
Duration
3:44
Lecture code
RJD-MKELIM-2-6

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

We mentioned earlier that a broken utensil made of earthenware could still be considered a keli (utensil) if it is fit to hold a certain amount. A broken piece of this kind is known as a gistera, something that was split in two, and it still has a din (status) of a keli. The Mishnah is going to teach that, in order for this broken keli to be considered a gistera and still have the potential to become tameh (ritually impure), it must come from a utensil that was considered to be a keli before it broke. If it wasn't considered a keli, then it doesn't retain its status as a keli. It has to be a keli to still have the potential to be a keli, or else it's not a keli at all. There's a rule that a keli does not become a keli until it's complete, until its manufacturing process is complete. With earthenware, that only happens when it's in a kiln and put to fire, and it's turned into a hard object. It's at a very high temperature, and now it's complete. The Mishnah is going to tell us about a case of a utensil that broke while it was being fired inside the kiln, and one of the parts is still usable. The Mishnah says: If the utensil broke before its completion, manufacturing was complete, before it was hardened, then the gistera is pure; it cannot become tameh. But if the utensil broke after the manufacturing process was complete, when it was already hardened, then it does have the ability to become tameh. If it is a keli now because it was manufactured, and then it broke afterward and it's a gistera, it does have the potential to become tameh.

Now we'll talk about a utensil that was used for watering plants. There are many holes on the bottom of it and a small opening on top. After it was filled with water, the person would cover the opening on top with his finger so water didn't flow out through the holes in the bottom. This type of utensil needs air to enter to replace the water. So if a person is holding his finger on top, there's nothing going to come out of the bottom. He then went to the plants to water them and removed his finger, so now the water flows out through the holes. This is called a titrus. That's the name of the utensil. There is a machloket (dispute) about the titrus, this clay that's used for watering plants. Rabbi Eliezer bar Tzadok metaher. Rabbi Eliezer bar Tzadok says it's pure because it has holes on the bottom that prevent it from holding water, so it's therefore not really a utensil. That's a container; it doesn't hold on to anything. Even though temporarily it does, since there are holes on the bottom, it doesn't hold anything long-term. Rabbi Yose metameh mipnei shehu kemotzi perutot. Rabbi Yose says it's tameh; it has the potential to become tameh because it can hold water as long as he keeps the covering covered with his finger. When he removes it, it lets that liquid out only drop by drop. So therefore, it has a din of a container because it could hold on to the liquid. And it does: if his finger's there, it does hold on to it. Then, even when he removes it, it doesn't gush out. It drips out slowly, and therefore it's considered to be a container, and it has the potential to become tameh. That's the overall rule. It could be a keli, just to review that. If it could hold water, it's a receptacle; it's then considered to be a keli. If it's a keli, then it has the potential to become tameh.