A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Joseph Dana

Torah Lecture

Mishnah Kelim 8-2

Lectured by Rabbi Joseph Dana

Published
July 8, 2026
Duration
4:23
Lecture code
RJD-MKELIM-8-2

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

After we list the Sheratzim (creeping creatures) that are tamei (impure) in the Torah, the pasuk (verse) says that from those words, betokho (inside it), we learn that if a Sheretz (creeping creature) falls into an earthenware vessel, that vessel becomes impure. But if it falls into an earthenware vessel that's within something else, like an oven, the oven would not become impure; only the inner vessel becomes impure. As long as it's a Kli (vessel) within a Kli, only that first Kli, the one, the innermost one that the Sheretz is actually in, becomes impure.

We spoke about the laws of a broken basket, which no longer has the status of a Kli, in the previous Mishnah. Here we'll talk about a basket that is not broken and therefore is still considered to be a Kli. The Mishnah says that if a basket hanging in the oven was whole and therefore considered to be a Kli, the same applies if there was a box instead of a basket, or a flask instead of a basket. In all these cases, we're dealing with an actual Kli, and therefore halacha (Jewish law) is as follows.

Ha-sheretz betochah ha-tanur tahor (The creeping creature is inside it; the oven is pure). Ha-sheretz is in the Kli, and it's hanging in the oven. The oven stays tahor. The Kli is not inside the oven, but inside the inside of the oven, like we spoke about. The Sheretz is in the innermost utensil. Therefore, that's what becomes impure. But now that the utensil is in an oven, the oven does not become impure.

Ha-sheretz ba-tanur ochalin she-betochah tehorin (The sheretz is in the oven; the foods inside it are pure). The same thing applies if a Sheretz is in the oven: the foods in the Kli are tahor because they're not inside the oven, but rather inside the inside of the oven, which is within this utensil. So there's a separation between the two of them.

Now we'll talk about what happens if these containers that the Sheretz or the food are in develop a hole. How large a hole makes the container broken, so that, like the broken basket of the last Mishnah, it is no longer considered to be within a separate container, but is now broken and therefore as if it is within the oven? Nikvu, if they develop a hole. For any of these containers that develop a hole, it now depends on what the container was used for. Ha'asui la'ochalin shi'uro bezayitim. If a container was made for holding solid foods, the size of the hole goes by an olive. If the hole is large enough for olives to fall out, the container is no longer considered to be a Kli, and the airspace is no longer considered to be separate from the ovens, like the broken basket we had. A Sheretz in the container will now make the oven tamei, and the foods in the container will now become tamei if the oven becomes tamei.

If the container was made for holding liquids, the size of the hole is measured by its ability to hold liquids. If the hole is large enough for liquids to fall out, the container is no longer considered to be a Kli, and therefore the airspace is no longer considered to be separate from the ovens. A Sheretz in the container will now make the oven tamei. If there are foods that are tamei and the oven is tamei, then the foods inside this container will become tamei as well.

If the container was made for both holding food and liquids, we apply the strict way to it of allowing liquid to enter as opposed to olives falling out. If the hole is large enough to allow liquid to enter the container, it's considered broken and no longer a Kli, and the Sheretz in the container will now make the oven tamei, and food in the container would become tamei from the tamei oven. So we go to the chumra. We go stricter and say that we'll go by the liquids in that case, which is a smaller hole, when they are both made for food and for drinking.