A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Joseph Dana

Torah Lecture

Mishnah Kelim 8-4

Lectured by Rabbi Joseph Dana

Published
July 8, 2026
Duration
3:27
Lecture code
RJD-MKELIM-8-4

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

Masechet Kelim, Perek Chet (Chapter 8), Mishnah, Dalet (four). Here we’ll talk about things that do not become tamei (ritually impure) through the airspace of an earthenware oven. The Mishnah says, Kederah shehi netunah ba-tanur: If a pot is placed inside of an earthenware oven, ha-sheretz (creeping creature) ba-tanur, ha-kederah tehorah (ritually pure). If a dead sheretz is in the oven, even though the oven becomes tamei, the pot stays tehorah.

Because the rule is that an earthenware vessel, like an oven in our Mishnah’s case, does not make utensils that it touches or that are inside of it tamei. An earthenware vessel can transmit tumah (ritual impurity) to food only, not to people or to utensils. This builds on how we finished the last Mishnah. But now we’ll give an exception where a pot can become tamei from an earthenware oven that is tamei. If there were droplets of liquid in the pot, the droplets are large enough to moisten something, and whatever they moisten can then moisten something else, the liquid becomes tamei because it is in the airspace of the tamei oven. The liquid makes the pot it touches tamei because the rabbis decreed that tamei liquid makes a utensil it touches tamei.

On a de'oraita (Torah law) level, liquid cannot make the pot tamei. Tumah goes down one level each time it is transmitted. So the sheretz is an av (primary source of ritual impurity). It transmits tumah to the oven, making the oven a rishon (first-degree impurity), which then transmits tumah to the liquid, making it a sheni (second-degree impurity). A sheni cannot make a utensil tamei on a Torah level; only an av can. But the rabbis decree that tamei liquid makes a utensil it touches tamei rabbinically. So that’s what we’re saying here. The earthenware vessel can transmit tumah here to food and liquid. So, in this case, if there is an earthenware oven, the oven becomes tamei. It makes the liquid inside the pot tamei. And then the liquid, on a rabbinic level, makes the pot itself tamei because of the rabbis’ decree.

If the pot could talk, it would say to the liquid inside it in surprise, “What made you tamei cannot make me tamei. But you made me tamei.” In a way, talking about how the pot would have talked. The tamei oven cannot make the pot tamei, because an oven cannot make a utensil tamei. But the liquids inside the pot, which became tamei from the oven, now have the ability to make the utensil tamei. That’s the way it works, which is a strange way. This decree works on a rabbinic level: tamei liquids make a utensil tamei, but the source of the liquid’s tumah, which is the oven, could not make the pot tamei, while the liquids can.