A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Joseph Dana

Torah Lecture

Mishnah Kelim 8-9

Lectured by Rabbi Joseph Dana

Published
July 8, 2026
Duration
4:30
Lecture code
RJD-MKELIM-8-9

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

We learned above that there’s a yotze min ha-klal, there’s a differing rule when it comes to how an oven or a stove becomes tamei (impure). It’s not a normal container that could become tamei under the normal rules for earthenware containers. It has no bottom or because it’s meant to be used together with the ground or when it’s attached to it. So, technically, there would be no reason to say that an oven or a stove becomes tamei, but we have a special gezerat ha-katuv, a special Torah that tells us that an oven or a stove can become tamei. This Mishnah will talk about certain types of ovens or stoves that aren’t normal, and we’ll consider whether they could become tamei or not. We’ll mention ones that are similar to ovens and stoves but have different details about them, so we don’t know whether they should be included or not. That’s what we’ll discuss.

The Mishnah says that a pit lined with clay, with a place to set down a pot on top of it, is tamei. It’s like a stove and can become tamei, even though it’s in the ground, since it’s used to cook. Similar to a stove, a pot is put on top of it. It’s considered to be a stove and can become tamei. If the clay-lined pit is made for people who make glass, to prepare their materials for making glass, they heat it up inside the pit. If it has a spot to set down a pot on top of it, it’s like a stove and can become tamei. The main use of the pit here is not for cooking food, but to prepare glass. But we say that even though that’s the case, it still has a function that allows it to cook food. Therefore, since it’s sometimes used for that purpose, it’s considered to be a stove and could become tamei.

A furnace used by lime makers, a furnace used by glass makers where the actual glass is made, or a furnace used by potters is tehorah (pure). It’s not considered to be an oven or a stove for cooking food. The heat here is so intense that people would never cook food in it or on top of it. Therefore, it’s not considered to be an oven or a stove, and it’s tehorah. It cannot become impure because it’s not a standard oven.

Another type of oven is a purnah. A purnah is an earthenware oven, which is a large oven with an opening on one side. It’s used for cooking on its floor rather than for baking bread on its wall. A typical oven or a stove mentioned by the Torah. An oven is used to bake bread. Bread would be pasted to the wall and heated by whatever is there, and it would be left there until it finished baking. With the stove, a pot of food is set down on top of it, and the stove itself cooks it.

Here, a purnah is different. A purnah that has no ledge, as we’ll mention in a moment, has the food cook on the ground itself, which is not part of the purnah. Since the purnah is different from the oven or a stove because the food is not cooking on it, if it has no ledge, we say that it’s going to be tehorah. But if it has a ledge, then the food cooks on the ledge on the purnah. Therefore, it’s similar to the stove of the Torah, and we would say that in that case, it’s a keli (vessel), and therefore it’s tamei. That’s what we say: “im yesh lah lizbaz (ledge), tame'ah.” If it has a ledge along the bottom of the inside, it could become tamei, but if it does not have a ledge, it cannot become tamei.

Other Tannaim (Mishnaic sages) give the same ruling in different words, using different names for the ledge of the purnah. Rabbi Yehuda says, “im yesh lah astegiyot.” Rabban Gamliel says, “im yesh lah sefayot.” Rabbi Yehuda says the purnah can become tamei if it has astegiyot, which is a ledge running around the bottom of the inside. Rabban Gamliel says that if it has sefayot—lips running around the bottom of the inside—that is other wording the Hakhamim (sages) use here to teach you that if it has a ledge, it could become tamei.