A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Joseph Dana

Torah Lecture

Mishnah Kinnim 1-4

Lectured by Rabbi Joseph Dana

Published
May 4, 2026
Duration
4:14
Lecture code
RJD-MKINNIM-1-4

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

At the end of the last Mishnah, we said that if we have mixed groups, we cannot treat them like one large group, whether they are for one type of Chovah obligation or for two, and whether they were separated by one woman or two. It does not matter; they have to be treated as separate groups. We’ll elaborate on what this means.

The Mishnah says: What do we mean by one type of obligation? The first group of pairs was separated for childbirth obligations, and the second group of pairs was also separated for childbirth obligations. The first pair was separated for a Zivah obligation, and the second pair was also separated for a Zivah obligation. That’s the one type. These are categories; these are pairs that are looked at as one type of obligation. But, like we said, even if the same woman separated different pairs for the same type of obligation, they can’t be treated like one large group unless she separated them at the same time.

What’s meant by two types of obligations? The first group of pairs was separated for childbirth, and the second group of pairs was separated for Zivah. So even if the same woman separated them at the same time, we look at them differently. We don’t treat them like one large group because she separated them for two different obligations.

What’s the case of two women? A yoledet and a yoledet. A zavah and a zavah. Let’s say one woman separated pairs for childbirth obligations, and the second woman also had childbirth obligations in terms of korbanot (offerings). Or the first woman had a Zivah obligation. That means she had a period at an abnormal time, and the second woman had a Zivah obligation. Mishum Echad (one type of obligation): these are the cases of two women who have one type of obligation. The groups cannot be treated like one group because two women separated these pairs, even though they were of a similar category. Mishnei Shemot (two types of obligations): a yoledet and a zavah. What’s the case of two women who have two types of obligations? The first woman has a childbirth obligation, for example, and the second woman has a Zivah obligation. These groups definitely can’t be treated like one group. They can’t be treated like one large group because they’re two different women, first of all, and, second of all, there are also two types of obligations.

Another Tana (sage) says that there are times when two groups can be treated like one large group, even if they were separated by different women and even if they were separated for different types of obligations. Rabbi Yosei omer (says) that two women brought their obligatory pairs, but the pairs were mixed together. Each woman brought a pair of birds, but they didn’t just buy one pair—one pair each. They pooled their money together, and they bought two pairs between them. Or, if they both gave their money for their obligatory pairs to the Kohen (priest) who was in charge of selling birds in the Beit HaMikdash (Temple), and he gave four birds to the two women, directly to the Kohen who was going to offer them on the Mizbeach (altar). The Kohen could then just decide, “I’m going to bring this animal for whichever woman as a chatat (sin offering).” For whichever woman the Kohen wants, he can offer an olah (burnt offering). All the birds here are treated like one large, undesignated group, and the Kohen could take one for a chatat and one for an olah for either woman. Everything will be valid in this case, as long as he offers two of the birds for one woman—a chatat and an olah—and two birds for the other woman—a chatat and an olah.

Bein Mishum Echad, Bein Mishnei Shemot. This applies whether we’re giving the money for one type of obligation or two types of obligations. No matter what, Rabbi Yosei says that the women are pretty much stipulating, when they buy their pairs together, that either pair could be used for either one of them. Since they made that condition, none of the birds become assigned to either woman until the bird is actually offered.