A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Joseph Dana

Torah Lecture

Mishnah Kinnim 2-1

Lectured by Rabbi Joseph Dana

Published
May 4, 2026
Duration
4:53
Lecture code
RJD-MKINNIM-2-1

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

We learned earlier that when a person has to bring a pair of birds as an obligatory korban (offering), one of the birds is a chatat (sin offering) and the other bird is an olah (burnt offering). When a person consecrates the birds, he doesn't have to designate which one is going to be a chatat and which is going to be an olah. He can leave it until the Kohen (priest) actually offers them. When the Kohen offers the birds, they become a chatat when he designates them as such, and the other one automatically becomes an olah, or the inverse. One becomes an olah, and the other one automatically becomes a chatat. Before the birds are designated, they're called a ken setumah, an undesignated pair. They have the sanctity of a korban, but not yet as a chatat or as an olah.

Here the Mishnah is going to talk about an undesignated pair that was dedicated, but one of the birds was lost before it was offered. The Mishnah says: If a person had a pair of birds that was undesignated for his obligation, and one bird flew away into the open sky and we can't find it, or flew into a group of birds that are left to die—for example, let's say you have a chatat that became lost among olah birds. We learned above in the second Mishnah that all of them are left to die because we have a mixture now, and none of the birds in that mixture could be offered anymore. We don't know which is which. So the undesignated bird that flew in also has to now be left to die. Or, shemet echad mehen: none of the birds flew away, but one of them died. In all of these cases, one of the undesignated birds is gone, and we're not going to find it. It's not going to be offered. What happens to the second, undesignated bird that was in that pair? The Mishnah says, yikach zug lasheni. The person does not have to dedicate a new pair of birds. He takes a partner for the second remaining bird in the pair. The fact that the first bird disappeared doesn't disqualify the second one. A person could just bring another bird to form a full pair with the undesignated bird that he already had.

Now we'll talk about the laws concerning a bird in an undesignated pair that became lost among other birds that are also going to be offered: Parach levein hakrovot. What's the halakha (law) if the undesignated bird wasn't lost, but it flew into other undesignated birds that are waiting to be offered? We don't know which bird is which. We say, pasul u'posel echad kenegdo. The halakha is that it's disqualified. It's disqualified from being offered in the new group into which it flew. So one bird in the new group is disqualified. And also, pasul u'posel echad kenegdo, and it disqualifies one other corresponding bird in the first group from which it came. So what we say is, you have one remaining bird that didn't go in; only one flew in. If I offered the one remaining bird as a chatat, the bird that flew in automatically becomes an olah. If I offer the one remaining bird as an olah, the other one automatically becomes a chatat. So now I'm a little bit stuck and in a little bit of a quandary, because I can't bring forth the rest of the korbanot that are already in that group. I'm not sure exactly what is there, and it all depends on what I do with the korban that's still in my hand. So basically, we say one bird in there becomes—you have to mitigate risk here. One bird over there becomes disqualified, and the one that you have in your hands, the one remaining bird, becomes disqualified as well, because I don't really know what the result is going to be.

We have a rule: when a bird that's undesignated flies from one group of undesignated birds to another group, it disqualifies the new group and it disqualifies the bird that corresponded to it in the old group. The Mishnah tells us that when a bird flies from group to group, one bird in each group becomes disqualified and has to remain unoffered, but the rest have to be offered. Just to throw in over here, this is probably one of the most difficult Masechtot (tractates) in Shas. There's a tremendous amount of technical detail that we're not elaborating on because of lack of time, but we should understand that when we don't understand a piece, it's because it is quite difficult.