A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Joseph Dana

Torah Lecture

Mishnah Meilah 3-1

Lectured by Rabbi Joseph Dana

Published
March 24, 2026
Duration
7:42
Lecture code
RJD-MMEILAH-3-1

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

Masechet Me'ilah, Perek Gimel, Mishnah Aleph. In this Perek, we'll talk about items that are not subject to the laws of Me'ilah (misappropriation of sacred property) on a biblical level, but the rule still applies: you're not allowed to benefit from them. But you still don't violate Me'ilah. The prohibition against benefiting is rabbinic.

This Mishnah talks about the five korbanot (offerings) of chatot (sin-offerings) that are left to die. Whenever we have a korban that we can't use, we usually let it walk around and graze until it develops some sort of blemish. Then we sell or redeem the korban. The five chatot korbanot we're going to mention are exceptions to the rule. It's a tradition that even if they develop a blemish, they're left to die. They're not redeemed. We'll talk about that in a minute, including whether the laws of Me'ilah apply to these chatot.

The Mishnah says that the offspring of a chatat and the temurah, the substitution of a chatat, are left to die. The temurah is an unsanctified animal that was designated as a substitute for a korban. The Torah forbids the substitute and the original animal as well. The temurah has the same status; the temurah animal was sanctified too. The Mishnah also mentions the chatat shemetu ba'aleha, the chatat whose owner died before it was offered. In all of these cases, yamutu, they're left to die. We don't let them graze until they become unfit like a regular korban. We don't actively kill them, but they're locked in a pen. We don't give them food and water. We allow them to die on their own.

The offspring of a chatat is not used as a chatat because it wasn't consecrated to atone for a person's sin. It became holy as a chatat because it has the holiness of its mother. But there's no designation. The temurah of a chatat also cannot be used as a chatat because it's holy because of temurah. And something that became holy through a sin cannot be used to atone for another sin. A chatat whose owner passed away also is not offered because the dead person has no ability to get atonement because he's dead. Therefore, all of these animals are left to die, and there's no way of redeeming them.

The next part of the Mishnah discusses two more cases of a chatat offering that is left to die. We listed three of the five chatot that are left to die. Here we'll talk about two more cases where a korban chatat was lost. Besides getting lost, it became disqualified in different ways. While the animal was lost, the owner took another animal and tried to use it in its place as the chatat. But before he actually used it, the original korban that he had sanctified was found. So now there are two animals: the original one that had sanctity, got lost, and also became disqualified in another way, which we'll elaborate on, and the one that was brought as the replacement.

A chatat, which is a goat or a sheep, has to be less than one year old. Once it turns one year old, you can't really offer it anymore. But that disqualification alone wouldn't be enough to say that we allow the animal to die. The animal also has to get lost. If the animal gets lost, then it's not available to be a korban, and therefore they brought another chatat in its place to be consecrated. The combination of those two things, being lost and also being more than one year old, would change the status of the chatat, and therefore it would have to be left to die. But each one of those problems alone wouldn't be enough.

Back to the Mishnah: a korban chatat whose year has passed. It's more than one year old, and, as we said, it also got lost and was found later. Or a chatat that got lost and was later found with a blemish. While the chatat was lost, the owner also designated another chatat to use instead of it. So it was found when it was less than one year old, so that wasn't the problem here. But it was found with a blemish. The blemish together with the fact that it was lost makes it problematic, and the Mishnah tells us that we're going to let it die.

After finding the lost chatat, the owner atoned for his sin with the second chatat animal. The original chatat is left to die. In both these cases, the original chatat had two defects. It was lost in both cases, and then it became either old or blemished. The owner atoned for his sin with a different chatat, so the original chatat is left to die. That type of animal would not make temurah. If the owner tried to substitute another animal for it, the second animal he tried to bring as a substitution would not become temurah. It would have no holiness. But a person is not allowed to benefit from it. If he did, it's not a problem of Me'ilah. He doesn't have to bring a new korban for Me'ilah. It can't be offered on the Mizbeach (altar) or sold for money. In a way, it lost its holiness. So it can't make another animal temurah, and you can't violate Me'ilah by using it. But the rabbi still said that a person isn't allowed to benefit from it.

The halakha (law) we just learned applies after he found the chatat that was lost, that was blemished or was over one year; the owner offered the original, he offered the second chatat that he had. But if he hadn't offered that second chatat yet, he has other options. If the owner hadn't yet received kaparah (atonement) for his sin with the replacement chatat and wants to make use of the original chatat, he should let the animal graze until it develops a blemish. He should then sell it and bring another chatat with that money.

The owner of the chatat hadn't yet received kaparah for his sin when the animal was found, and he wants to make use of it. It's not a chatat that has to be left to die. It's just an invalid chatat since it's more than one year old or has a blemish. Ve'osot temurah u'mo'alin bahen (they effect substitution and are subject to sacrilege). These chatot can be sold off even though they're blemished, and we don't leave them to die. They are still subject to the regular laws of korbanot, and therefore this type of chatat would make temurah if the owner tried to substitute it for another animal. That substitute would become temurah. It would have the holiness of a korban because the owner hadn't yet received kaparah, so it still had holiness, and therefore the substitute would become temurah. Temurah u'mo'alin bahen (substitution is effected, and they are subject to sacrilege). It's subject to Me'ilah on a biblical level. If a person has any benefit from it, they would have to bring a korban Me'ilah for that benefit. The chatat here could be sold, and the money used for another korban. The korban holiness is there, and therefore someone who uses it violates temurah, as we mentioned, and also Me'ilah on a biblical level.