A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Joseph Dana

Torah Lecture

Mishnah Meilah 3-3

Lectured by Rabbi Joseph Dana

Published
March 24, 2026
Duration
4:20
Lecture code
RJD-MMEILAH-3-3

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

We'll talk about how Me'ilah (misappropriation of consecrated property) applies to the blood of korbanot (offerings) and to nesachim, the wine or water that's poured onto the Mizbeach (altar). Nesachim of wine are brought with certain korbanot. Wine could also be donated on its own. The water libation is performed on the days of the holiday of Sukkot, directly onto the Mizbeach.

The water is poured into a silver bowl at the bottom of the Mizbeach. From there, it flows out of a spout and down through the Mizbeach to a cavity known as the shitin. The Mishnah says: “The law of Me'ilah with blood is lenient in the beginning and stringent in the end.” It's lenient where it would be exempt from Me'ilah. It's lenient in the beginning and strict in that it becomes subject to Me'ilah later on. And with nesachim, the law of Me'ilah here is lenient in the beginning and stringent in the end.

At first, before the Zerikah, the blood of korbanot is not subject to Me'ilah. From the moment the blood comes out of the neck of the korban at the time it's slaughtered until the Zerikah, the blood is not subject to Me'ilah. We learn this from a pasuk (verse): “Yatza la-nachal Kidron (Kidron Valley) mo'alin bo.” But once it leaves the courtyard of the Beit HaMikdash and flows into the Kidron Valley, it's subject to Me'ilah.

After the Zerikah, after the throwing of the blood onto the Mizbeach, it drains through the courtyard to the Kidron Valley. Once the blood reaches that point, it is subject to Me'ilah on a rabbinic level, not on a biblical level, because once a consecrated item has been used for the mitzvah (commandment) it was needed for, it's not subject to Me'ilah anymore. The blood flows into the Kidron Valley, and anyone had the ability to use it. The rabbis were nervous that if people went and used it for fertilizer or something like that, they might eventually commit Me'ilah, with other consequences, because they had consecrated items whose mitzvah had not yet been performed. Therefore, they made a decree that there is Me'ilah with this blood on a rabbinic level, and a person would have to redeem it before benefiting from it. They did not make a decree, though, that Me'ilah applies to the blood before it flows out of that area, because the rabbis didn't want to be so difficult with their decrees in the Beit HaMikdash. So when it comes to the blood, it's only subject to Me'ilah afterward, after it leaves the property of the Beit HaMikdash. The end is more stringent than the beginning.

The nesachim, on the other hand, are subject to Me'ilah before the water or wine is poured for the mitzvah. They are Kodshei Kodashim (most holy offerings), and from the moment they're consecrated, they're subject to Me'ilah. “Yardu la-shitin, ein mo'alin bahem.” But once they flow down to the shitin under the Mizbeach, they're not subject to Me'ilah anymore. The end here is more lenient than the beginning. Once the nesachim are poured onto the Mizbeach and enter the shitin, the mitzvah is complete, and there's no more Me'ilah.

So if a person caught the wine in a vessel before it went down to the depths, and he benefited from it, he did not commit Me'ilah. There's no decree on a rabbinic level here after the nesachim are poured, because unlike the blood that flows into the Kidron Valley, the nesachim weren't available to everybody, only to Kohanim (priests), and only on rare occasions when they cleaned out the shitin. So the rabbis are not going to make a decree for a very uncommon situation. Here they did not decree that Me'ilah applies to everything, all the nesachim that were poured.