A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Joseph Dana

Torah Lecture

Parashat Toledot 5787- The Power of Prayer and Chinuch

Lectured by Rabbi Joseph Dana

Published
November 13, 2026
Duration
28:17
Lecture code
RJD-PTLDT-5787-01

Barrenness, Prayer, and the Question of Chinuch

  • Rabbi Joseph Dana notes a recurring pattern in these parashiyot: Sarah was barren before Yitzhak was born, Rivka is barren in this week’s parasha, and Rachel will be barren in next week’s parasha. The Gemara also says that Yitzhak was sterile.
  • The repeated pattern—being unable to conceive, praying, and then having children—raises the question of why the ancestors of the Jewish people had to experience this difficulty.
  • The Gemara in Yevamot, daf Samech Dalet, asks why the forefathers were akurim (barren) and answers that Hashem desires the tefillot of the righteous.
  • Rabbi Joseph Dana asks how this answer fits with Hashem’s being merciful and good: why would Hashem withhold children because He wants the righteous to pray?
  • He connects the question to chinuch and the responsibility of raising children with spirituality and the fundamentals of faith.

Tefillah as Transformation

  • Rabbi Friend, quoting Rav Pam, explains that tefillah is more than fulfilling an obligation by reciting prayers at set times; it is meant to transform the person praying.
  • The Mekubalim describe the tzaddik’s tefillah as a kind of out-of-body experience: the person rises above mundane problems and anxieties, achieves devekut (cleaving to God), and contemplates the purpose of creation and why Hashem brought us into the world.
  • A tzaddik regards tefillah as a privilege: the opportunity to speak directly to Hashem at the kiseh kavod (Throne of Glory).
  • Rabbi Joseph Dana notes that tefillah is commonly translated as “prayer,” but presents its root, peh lamed lamed, as meaning “to judge.” Tefillah is thus self-judgment and introspection: cheshbon hanefesh, examining one’s strengths, weaknesses, shortcomings, and reality in order to grow.
  • Tefillah is described as a central driver of personal growth, intended to raise a person to new spiritual heights.
  • Rabbi Joseph Dana acknowledges the gap between this ideal and ordinary experience: people can struggle to focus, even finding it hard to stay off their phones during tefillah. He says the lofty level of the tzaddikim and Hachamim can be difficult for us to understand.

The Chasidim HaRishonim and the Need to “Decompress”

  • The Gemara in Berachot, daf Lamed Bet, says that the Chasidim HaRishonim would wait one hour in the place where they would pray, pray for one hour, and then wait another hour.
  • Rav Pam understands the hour of preparation as a way to enter the right mindset, and the hour of prayer as time to focus deeply. He asks why they needed to remain for another hour afterward.
  • Rav Pam explains that after reaching a heightened spiritual state, they needed time to return gradually to ordinary life; they could not simply finish praying and immediately go back to work and daily errands.
  • A friend compares this to a diver returning from a deep dive: the diver needs a decompression chamber to reacclimate, or risks “the bends,” including dizziness, nausea, and difficulty walking.
  • The Chasidim HaRishonim likewise needed to decompress after prayer. Their tefillah changed them, and they needed to return to the everyday world in a way that would affect the rest of their day.

Why Hashem Desired the Tefillot of Yitzhak and Rivka

  • Rabbi Joseph Dana applies this understanding to Yitzhak and Rivka: their tefillot were not a low-level request for children but an experience that uplifted and transformed them.
  • Hashem could have enabled them to have children without the repeated difficulty. The point, Rabbi Joseph Dana explains, was that Yitzhak and Rivka should first reach a heightened spiritual state and create a religious atmosphere in which their children would be born and raised.
  • Hashem wanted them to have not merely offspring, but children who could become the avot and imahot of the next generation. Rabbi Joseph Dana says that raising a Yaakov Avinu requires parents who are spiritually engaged and committed to Torah and mitzvot.
  • Children do not develop in a vacuum: their parents’ spiritual state and the behavior they model are part of chinuch.
  • Rabbi Joseph Dana’s resolution of the Gemara is that Hashem does not need the prayers themselves; He wants people to become their best selves, and tefillah is the means through which they grow. That growth prepares them to raise the next generation of Jewish leaders.
  • A person absorbed in Olam Hazeh, the mundane world, cannot expect to raise a child like Yaakov Avinu. Hashem desired the tefillot of the righteous because those prayers would uplift them.
  • Hashem is perfect and lacks nothing; people need tefillah. In particular, parents need to pray for their children’s spiritual development.

The Home, Tefillah, and Children’s Spiritual Needs

  • Rabbi Joseph Dana says that people often devote their lives to providing for their children’s physical needs, but children also need support for their spiritual lives and Olam Haba.
  • Chinuch cannot be outsourced to schools, rabbis, or teachers: the home has the greatest effect on what children become.
  • The Steipler, father of Rabbi Chaim Kanievsky, was asked how to raise children who follow Torah and how to “create a Rabbi Chaim Kanievsky.” He answered that it is “50% tefillah and 50%” an atmosphere of b'shalom bayit (peace in the home).
  • This applies to parents and grandparents, as well as teachers and rabbis whose students are like their children. Their effort, including what they teach and model, is essential, but they are not fully in control of the outcome.
  • The tefillah component means asking Hashem to partner in raising children: to give them chochmah, binah, da'at, spirituality, and inspiration to withstand the challenges of the world.
  • Rabbi Joseph Dana describes the other half as nurture: a home of holiness, mutual love and cooperation, respect between a couple, a beautiful Shabbat table, and stability in the family. Such an atmosphere can inspire children to embrace and continue those values.

The Brisker Rav on Praying for Children

  • Rabbi Joseph Dana recounts bringing Rabbi Diamond to a shiva that week and traveling with him between Deal and Brooklyn. Their conversation turned to chinuch.
  • Rabbi Diamond told the story of the Brisker Rav, whose sons became Roshei Yeshiva and accomplished rabbis. Asked how he had raised them, the Brisker Rav answered, “It’s called tears,” explaining that he had prayed for his children without exception.
  • The story illustrates the Steipler’s point: alongside creating a proper atmosphere at home, parents should invest themselves in tefillah because their children’s futures are not entirely within their control.

Shalom Bayit, Divorce, and the Mizbeach

  • To show the other side of Shalom Bayit, Rav Pam cites the Gemara in Gittin: when a man divorces his first wife, even the Mizbeach (altar), which sees korbanot (sacrifices) every day, sheds tears.
  • Rabbi Joseph Dana notes that divorce is sometimes a reality: some couples are not meant to remain together, and staying together can create more problems for the family. Nevertheless, divorce and instability can bring trouble and sadness to a family.
  • Rav Pam explains that the Mizbeach can bear the korbanot brought every day, but cannot bear the sacrifice of children who grow up amid fighting and tension. Those children can be affected by the situation and become sad; they need additional tefillot and shalom.

Yitzhak and Rivka’s Unity and the Conclusion

  • Rabbi Joseph Dana presents Yitzhak and Rivka as a model of unity: Yitzhak prayed for his wife, and the rabbis say that he prayed in the same room as her. They approached the difficulty as one unit, rather than as separate individual problems.
  • Their achdut and tranquility brought forth Yaakov Avinu, described as Yaakov ish tam, yoshev ohalim, and through him the Shivtei Kah and Shevatim who followed the Borei Olam and formed the Jewish nation.
  • The conclusion is to strengthen tefillah and recognize its effect on the home, while not outsourcing the home’s role: a home should be a place of shalom and tranquility so that children can continue in the ways of Hashem.
Words in this lecture1
Gemaraגמרא
Terms Gemara, the Talmud's discussion of the Mishnah. English: Commentary on the Mishnah
Also written: Gemarah, G'mara, Guemara, gmara
Plural: gemarot, gemaras