For more than 3,300 years, the Jewish people have preserved and transmitted their wisdom about how to live life. From generation to generation, parents taught their children, teachers taught their students, in a living chain that stretches back to the giving of that great wisdom in the Sinai desert. Perhaps never has there been a generation more desperately in need of this ancient wisdom. A wisdom today made available to the English-speaking world by scholars like Lawrence Kelemen. Sit back and enjoy, while Lawrence Kelemen takes you on an adventure into the world of ancient wisdom for modern minds.
When I arrived in Jerusalem, the traditional community there was foreign to me. I had never really experienced them. Although there are all traditional communities like the one in Jerusalem scattered around the United States and other places in the world, I had never experienced them. When I first began to experience them, I saw much of value in their community. But, to be honest, I saw many things that were bizarre. And I kept the list.
Now I think that anybody coming from where I came from—a UCLA- or Harvard-educated individual—is going to find things very strange when they first encounter the traditional community. I won't go through my whole list tonight, everything I found strange in that community. It's irrelevant to the topic we're discussing tonight, which is the lost art of love. But there are a few things on the list that are worth discussing. I'll raise those right now.
For example, when you first encounter the traditional community, you find people who are very impassioned and very devoted to their service of God. Having said that, their obsession with detail—and I think “obsession” is not the wrong word, and I hope you don't find what I'm saying offensive—is over the top, incomprehensible from a rational perspective.
I remember when I first heard that these very traditional Jews put on their right shoe before their left shoe every morning. But, of course, you tie your left shoe before your right shoe. Unless you're a woman, in which case you tie your right shoe before your left shoe. I remember when I first heard that.
For me, the Sabbath—I grew up in a traditional home. When I say traditional home, my home was a right-wing conservative home. In our home, we had something of Shabbat. We had a concept of the Sabbath. So on the Sabbath we rested. I remember my father didn't go to work on Saturdays. These people, on the Sabbath, feel that if you flip on a light switch, then you've done an offense to the Sabbath. The obsession with detail is far out.
When they sit down to eat dinner on Friday night, if you pull the peas away from the corn instead of the corn away from the peas, that's a violation of the Sabbath. The level of obsession with detail is over the top. It's incomprehensible. Many of the things that I admired about their community were carried to such an extreme in terms of detail that they became incomprehensible to me.
I remember when I first learned about the laws of kashrut (kosher dietary laws). The laws of kashrut are actually a very beautiful thing. The way that Jews traditionally kill animals is one of the only painless procedures for killing animals known to mankind. Unless you're going to use drugs, it seems that shechita, which is this very traditional system, is extraordinarily effective at reducing the pain of the animal. The knife has to be so incredibly sharp that there is not a single nick. It's sharper than any surgical instrument. If there's a single nick in the knife, these traditional Jews take the animal they just killed and give it over to non-Jews because they're not allowed to eat it. Because, God forbid, the animal might have felt some pain as the knife was dragged across its neck.
If the person who's slaughtering the animal stops partially through the stroke with the knife, for a moment stops, and then continues again, the animal might have felt that, could have caused a moment of needless pain to the animal if the animal was not kosher by their standards.
Problem number one that I have with the traditional community—and forgive me for listing these problems; I do it with deep respect—is that they are obsessed with detail.
Problem number two. I entered one of their institutions, one of these places called yeshiva, and I—I won't say that I studied there; I sat in on studies. For me it was a very exciting sociological immersion. What I used to do was, I didn't pray, but I would arrive at their yeshiva at about nine o'clock in the morning, when they were done with their prayers, and I would stay from nine o'clock until about one o'clock studying. I remember I called it the Talmud, these great two-thousand-year-old texts, and at one o'clock they prayed again.
Now, I felt it was offensive for me to walk out at that point because I was already in the building. To come late, okay, no one notices, but to walk out at one o'clock, that's already offensive. So I didn't leave when they prayed. What I would do is grab one of the Jewish prayer books, open it up, and stand there reading the Jewish prayer book while they were praying. And the truth is, at that time the ArtScroll prayer book had just come out, and I remember thinking there were all sorts of very interesting things in the ArtScroll, so I was more than sufficiently entertained while they were doing their prayers, and I would sit and read this book.
About three months into my stay at the first yeshiva I ever encountered, right after this afternoon prayer, a fellow, one of the young men who was learning at the yeshiva, walked up to me and said, “Kelemen, you don't pray right.”
I said, “Excuse me, what did you have in mind?”
So he said, “I saw that when you're praying, you're just sitting there with the book open, your eyes are scanning the book, but your mouth's not moving.”
So I intuitively had a sense of where he was going, but I couldn't believe it. I said, “What do you want me to do?”
So he said, “You have to say the words.”
I said, “What do you mean?”
So he said, “When you pray, you have to speak. You have to say the words out loud. You can't just think in your head.”
So I couldn't believe he actually went there, and I said to him, “Wait, are you telling me that your God doesn't know what's going on in my heart, and if I think the prayers, it doesn't count?”
So he had absolutely no training in Jewish outreach whatsoever, which is beautiful, because he was so disingenuous, completely honest with me, and he said, “Yes, you have to say the words or nothing ever happens.”
I said to him, “That's paganism,” at which point he probably didn't know what the word meant, but he got very flustered. He pulled off this massive folio-sized book, opened it up, and started gesticulating and pointing at the book, screaming at me, “You have to say the words, you have to say the words!”
At that point, three or four other yeshiva guys realized that he was in over his head, and they came and grabbed him and dragged him off.
So, the first thing that bothered me was why someone should tell. The second thing that bothered me was, why do you have to say the words? It's such a crazy thing: their God doesn't know what's in my heart? It's bizarre.
Third thing that bothered me—I have a long list, but I'll only go through three tonight. The third thing that bothered me was this. There were a number of very talented, very insightful people working for this particular yeshiva that I stumbled into, and there was one guy in particular who was extraordinarily articulate. Everybody wanted his time, and it was hard to get access to this guy. What I used to do was go every morning at breakfast time and sit with him. I would sit and eat breakfast with him because no one was around, and I could pummel him with my questions. Then after breakfast I would disappear while they prayed, and I would show up again at nine o'clock.
All of my questions basically had the same format. My questions were, “Rabbi, why do we have to do this? Why do we have to do that? How can you justify this? Is this a violation of the best of Renaissance values?” And in every case, for about three months, this rabbi served up the most spectacular intellectual feast. Each time I would ask one of these sorts of questions, he would give me—I mean, we're talking deep response. I was impressed.
Until one morning. I don't know how much else I asked him, but I must have hit a nerve. After I asked my question, this rabbi looked down and sort of smirked. Then he looked up at me and said, “Kelemen, you keep asking the wrong question.”
So my antenna went up immediately, and I was immediately suspicious. I said, “What do you mean?”
“You keep asking, ‘Why do we do this? Why do we do that?’ Don't you know,” he said, “that our theme song, our mantra is”—and he quoted this Hebrew phrase—“we do it,” he said, “even if we don't understand it.”
So what bothered me was not so much that if you scratched behind the surface of this traditional Jew, you found a religious fanatic. That didn't bother me. I think I all along expected that even the most articulate members of this community probably were religious fanatics. What bothered me was that this man was a sensitive person, and he seemed to understand who I was. And yet he said to this UCLA- and Harvard-educated student, “We do it even if we don't understand it,” and he said that proudly, as if that would be something I could appreciate.
What bothered me was: what was this rabbi thinking that made him assume that someone from my background would have any respect for this sort of blind observance, “we do it even if we don't understand it”? That's what bothered me. What was he thinking? What was his impression of who I was?
Problem number one: why so much detail? Problem number two: why did that traditional community think that you have to speak in order to pray? And problem number three: what were they thinking that made them think that I would appreciate “we do it even if we don't understand it”?
Fast-forward ten years. Ten years later, I was in Jerusalem. This whole thing I'm describing now took place in Los Angeles, which was my first stop in this traditional community. Ten years later, I was in Jerusalem, and I had the tremendous privilege of hearing a great Torah sage, one of the leaders of the Jerusalem community, speak. He was an elderly gentleman with a long white beard, had studied from great sages in Europe, and really was an emblem of the traditional community there.
During this particular talk, there were about 150 people crowded into a room that was probably appropriate for about 50. I had heard about the man, but had no idea why so many people wanted to hear him. When I heard what he said, I understood why they wanted to hear him, and I understood a lot more than that.
I had a long list of problems with this man's community when I walked into the room that night. When I walked out of the room, all I had was utter respect because of one principle he introduced, which is the principle I came to speak to you about that night: the lost art of love.
This rabbi tried to make the case, and I should say he did it eloquently, that every single aspect of Torah observance, every single aspect of the details of the lives these traditional Jews led, was a training program for intimacy. Their whole goal was to create within themselves a certain potential that would allow intimacy to happen spontaneously in their lives in a healthy, good way.
And when I say intimacy, I mean it with a capital I. I mean between husband and wife. I mean between parents and children. I mean in communal relations. Even between them and their God, they believe it is possible for there to be total and absolute connection in this world. There doesn't have to be disconnection. There doesn't have to be loneliness. And they believe that every single aspect of Jewish tradition was to create real love and real connection in this world, to create a world where the lion would lie down with the lamb, and the lamb would even get some sleep. That is the goal of Judaism according to them.
It was a very long lecture, with a lot of detail, and I can't share most of it with you. What I will share is that I have been doing various types of counseling, especially marriage counseling, although I do a lot of work with children these days as well. I've been doing marriage counseling for the last 10 years.
Early on in my marriage counseling career, I noticed a certain pattern, which anyone involved in marriage counseling has surely seen as well, or anyone who's just into the study of relationships. Unfortunately, most times couples come to me with problems. They're coming to me because the marriage is on the rocks. They're either on the verge of a divorce, or they're headed in that direction.
When I start to dig to try to understand what went wrong, invariably I never find that relationships break up because the couple differs over major issues. “She's a Republican, I'm a Democrat; I want a divorce.” That never happened. “He forgot my 25th anniversary; I want out.” That's not the way these relationships unravel. Never.
What other relationships unravel over? Now, I can say with absolute confidence that I have counseled at least two dozen couples where the cause of the marital conflict was the temperature for the household thermostat. Should it be 68 or 72? I don't need to tell you who took which position. I'm telling you, at least two dozen couples I've dealt with have been in a conflict over that, and I mean a conflict that's tearing the marriage to pieces.
I had a case where a couple came to speak to me, and they wanted a divorce. I asked them why, and they both spontaneously said, “Because he—she hates me.” So I thought, what an interesting observation: they feel their spouse hates them. I said, “What makes you think that your spouse hates you?”
He said that when they got married, he mentioned to her that he can't stand crumbly toothpaste. And he says to me, “She leaves the cap off on purpose. She knows what I hate, and she leaves it off on purpose.” And she says, “No, I just forget sometimes.” “You don't forget. You hate me.” And he is persuaded that she hates him because of the crumbly toothpaste.
So I turned to her and said, “Why do you feel that he doesn't like you?” She says, “At night, when he goes in to use the restroom, he leaves the cap off on purpose. I go in at night, I slip right in, and he does it on purpose.”
This is a mature, otherwise apparently psychologically normal couple, and the sorts of things they're getting a divorce over are crazy.
I had two cases recently where the man wanted a divorce. It was the man who was pushing for a divorce. Now, in one case, I had actually known the man for several years before he came for counseling, so I can attest that he seemed like a psychologically healthy, normal person. And what did he want the divorce over? In both cases, these two men—why did they want the divorce? In both cases, they both said to me—the latest case was, the fellow came to me and said, “I want to divorce my wife, and I just want to talk to you about it before I do it.”
“Why are you divorcing her?”
He said, “This is the last straw. She doesn't like my beard. I'm going to divorce her.”
So he just started to grow a beard. I said, “Give me a knife. I will cut your beard or your throat. Are you crazy?” Insanity! He's going to divorce a perfectly wonderful woman because she doesn't like the beard. The other guy told me the same thing: she didn't like the beard, so he's going to divorce her. We're talking about people who on the surface seem normal, and yet over the stupidest, most itsy-bitsy, bitty, picayune details, these people are getting divorced.
And I started to notice that all marital conflict is over picayune details. It's like a crazy thing. People feel loved or not loved depending on how much people notice the details in their life.
Every now and then, a couple will come to me—it's rare, but it's wonderfully pleasant—and they'll say, “We'd like some marital tips.” And I'll say, “What's the problem?” They say, “No problem. We'd just like to supercharge our marriage.” I say, “What do you got?”
I have one couple I was counseling. I have an office, but this couple came to my house. They were sitting in my kitchen. I have a sliding door that leads into my kitchen. I knocked on the door and then opened it. They must not have heard me knock because this couple was in the middle of expressing affection. So I coughed, and that didn't deter them. So I walked out, closed the door, and came back a minute later. I walked in, came around, sat in front of them, and said, “Is everything okay?” They said, “Yeah, everything's great.”
So I said to them, “What are you here for?”
They said, “We're here for marriage counseling.”
“You seem like you're doing just fine.”
So they said, “We are doing fine, but we're newly married and we want to make sure that we're married to you as well. So we came here to find out if there's anything that we should be concentrating on that we're not concentrating on now.”
So I said, “It actually seems to be going quite well. Maybe you can give me some advice.”
So I asked them a question because I had this other couple recently where the spouses hate each other. I said to them, “Do you feel that your spouse loves you?” They said, “Yeah.”
So I said, “Why? What makes you think that your spouse loves you?”
He answered and said that when he comes home from work at the end of the day and opens the door, very often, when his spouse looks up at him opening the door, she gives him this big smile. That's how he knows. He said sometimes she'll make him a cup of tea.
I said, “That's it?”
He said, “Yeah.”
So I said to her, “He loves you. How do you know?”
She thought, and then she said, “He leaves me a note on the refrigerator.”
So I said, “That's it?”
So she laughed, but only had three words. That's what makes a great relationship: that he left a note on the refrigerator? That's all the wisdom of being married? That she smiled at him when he opened the door?
What I started to realize is that all marriages, all relationships, rise or, God forbid, fall based on the details. Why? If you remember the 25th anniversary, that doesn't mean that you love her. If you remember the 25th anniversary, that's nice. If you don't remember the 25th anniversary, you should be shot. But the fact that you remember the 25th anniversary doesn't mean a lot.
If you remember that she likes flowers, and not just that she likes flowers, but that she likes the yellow roses with the lavender ribbon and the white poof stuff on top—if you remember that, that's significant. That means you really care when you start paying attention to the details.
So it occurred to me in the last few years that if I was going to set up a self-help system to prepare people for intimacy and relationships, I think what I would do is include in this self-help program—when I write the book, this is what I'm going to do—include a training system that will attune people, that will sensitize people to details. I think what I would do is give a list of, like, 100 or 200 details, 3, 4, 5, 613 details for people to practice attending to, because the more you become attuned to attending to the details, the more competent you are to be involved in a relationship.
This rabbi with the long white beard explained to me that's why there are 613 categories of Jewish law with 15,000 subsections. It turns out to be one of the most comprehensive legal systems on the planet; certainly among religions, it is the most comprehensive legal system. And the reason is because until a person becomes attuned to the small things, until I learn to sweat details, I'm not yet ready to be involved in an intimate relationship. That's the very beginning preparation. Why so many details? Because that's how relationships rise or fall.
Why do you have to speak when you pray? So the rabbi explained that traditional Jewish sources understand that there are two kinds of speech human beings are involved in: masculine speech and feminine speech. And although it's true that women engage in masculine speech as well, and men do engage in feminine speech, men are much more dominant when it comes to masculine speech, and women are much more dominant when it comes to feminine speech. What's the difference?
The way these traditional rabbis explain it, they say that men tend to speak when something needs to be accomplished. “Excuse me, could you pass the ketchup, please? I'll take out the trash. Who's paying the water bill?” This is all classic masculine speech. Men tend to talk when something needs to be said.
Now, that's a nice thing, because if something needs to be said, they will speak. One downside of this habit men have of speaking when something needs to be said is that they tend not to speak when something does not need to be said. And therefore the following scene can often transpire. The two will come home from work and share the details of their day, and she'll say, “And then this happened, and this happened, and this happened. What do you think about that?” And then she'll say, “The situation came up, and I wasn't sure if I should do this or that, and I ended up doing this. What do you think about that?” And he'll say, “Good.”
And after 20 minutes of this, she wants to grab him by the collar and say, “Talk to me! Enough already. Let's have some communication.”
Masculine speech is speech that tends to accomplish physical things in this world. Although women do engage in masculine speech, men always exclusively engage in masculine speech, with exceptions. Feminine speech is different. With feminine speech, what is accomplished is not necessarily in the physical realm.
Over the years, I've come to realize that women are generally more sensitive than men are, with exceptions. Women are generally more sensitive to their position in what I call love space. That is, a woman is much more sensitive to whether or not she's drawing closer in a relationship or moving farther away. She can actually feel the most minor variations in the relationship, generally much more sensitively than men can.
Because of that, women are aware that while it's nice when someone speaks to you, when you speak to somebody else, you actually draw close to them, and the more that you speak to them, the closer you draw. I have theories about why this might be. I think that speech might be one of the most intimate acts you can engage in because you're reaching into the deepest parts of who you are, pulling that up, and sharing it. You end up giving the most precious gift that you own when you speak to somebody because it's your soul that you're pouring out.
These traditional Jews have a line: when you speak often, what you're doing is sharing your heart, and when you give your heart to something, that's an act of extraordinary intimacy.
One of these rabbis told me the hottest spiritual organ in the entire human body. He had the point: where is the organ of intimacy in the human body? He said it's right here, because this is the place where you pour out what's in your heart. That's how you draw close to others. So while it's nice when someone speaks to me, when I speak to somebody else, feminine speech is speech that creates relationship. It draws close because women are sensitive to the fact that when they speak to another, they're drawing close to that other person.
Sometimes in a conversation a woman will say things twice, sometimes even three times. It's wrong? It's 100% fine. They weren't trying to communicate information in the most terse fashion possible; they were trying to actually draw close to the person they were speaking to.
Have you ever seen two women walking down the street and they're both talking simultaneously? Have you ever seen this phenomenon? There's nothing wrong here; this is perfectly normal. Why? Because what's happening is there are two people trying to get close to each other, and there's not necessarily importance in communicating information. The point is they actually become close.
Men also do this. Men are not as good at it. Men tend to be better at the functional. Women tend to be much better when it comes to the realm of relationship, and I believe that's because, again, they're much more sensitive to where they're holding the relationship. Are they drawing closer? Are they moving away?
Within the Torah world, within the world of Judaism, there is something called masculine speech and something called feminine speech. What is masculine speech? According to these traditional Jews, masculine speech is when a person picks up an apple and says a blessing over it: “Can I please have a bite of the apple, God?” When a person says a blessing over a piece of fruit asking God for permission—“May I eat this?”—that's functional, and therefore that's masculine speech. When you're done eating the apple, “Thank you very much,” they say a blessing afterwards, “Thank you.” That's functional, like kids saying please and thank you. It gets them the piece of candy they want and keeps them in good relations with their parents.
There is a kind of feminine speech within Judaism as well, pure feminine speech. How did I discover this? This rabbi with the long white beard was giving a class to the heads of four yeshivas in Jerusalem on how to be a good husband. So I begged, as an academic observer, “Please allow me to watch the class,” and the rabbi with the long white beard allowed me into the inner sanctum. I actually sat while the heads of four yeshivas sat by this old man with a long white beard, and he gave them a very traditional Jewish message about how to be a good husband. It turns out—I discovered this over the three-year class—it was a three-year class, meeting once a week, each time for about two or three hours. It turns out being a good husband is almost as complicated as being a good wife.
In his class he said that if a couple does not spend intimate private time at least twice a week, their marriage is headed for disaster. At this point I had already been in the class for about 18 months, and he was used to having me there as this academic observer. I interrupted and said, “What do you mean?”
So he looked at me like, “Jerk,” but he said that besides moments of physical intimacy, which he said should actually be the crescendo, the zenith of the private time, there should be hours of lead-up where the couple just enjoys each other's company. He described it. I said, “What do you mean? How do you do that? I want to know from your perspective, Rabbi, what does this look like?”
So I think he partially translated it into modern terms for me so I would appreciate what he was talking about, but he said, “For example, what you should do is find a nice restaurant.” I'm a professor at the University of North Texas, so he said, “Find a nice restaurant where you know there will be none of your students. Ask the maitre d' to give you a table in the back, and ask him to set up candles on the table.”
He said, “What you do is take your wife out for dinner,” and he said, “When you go out to dinner with her, sit next to her, right next to her.” And he said, “Throughout the evening you should whisper.”
I said, “Why?”
So he said, “Because don't you feel what happens when you whisper? Feel how small the room becomes.” It's a very interesting thing.
So I see that everything he said made sense. It's all common sense, but he's not the common-sense kind of guy. He's the traditional Jewish practice kind of guy. So I asked him, “Where did you get this?”
So he said, “I got it from the code of Jewish law.”
I said, “Are you telling me that someone in the code of Jewish law says that you should take your wife out to a restaurant and have candles and whisper with her? Like, what's going on?”
So he said, “Yes, it's right here,” and he opens up to the beginning of the code of Jewish law. There are the laws of prayer. So he says, “Look what it says right here. The traditional laws of prayer say that three times a day these traditional Jews do the following. First they go out to a restaurant where there are no students. What does it mean? They take three steps back from the whole world. Okay, now there's no one in the whole world. They take three steps away from their daily lives, the grind, so to speak. Now,” he said, “sit next to your wife.” Then they take three steps forward towards their beloved. Now they're standing right next to their beloved, and then they begin to whisper. And Jewish law says that when you pray, you don't scream like my neighbors in Jerusalem who pray very, very loudly. Orthodox Jews don't do that. They don't pray silently like my Christian neighbors; rather, they whisper.”
He explained why: because this is pure feminine speech, and the whole goal is to draw close. His words to me were, “How loud would you speak? Your ear's right next to your mouth.”
Why do you have to speak? The reason these traditional Jews believe we have to speak is not because God doesn't know what's in my heart. Of course God knows what's in my heart. We're talking about the omnipotent, almighty, omniscient one. Of course he knows what's in my heart. Why do I have to speak? I've got to speak because he's already, and he wants me to join him in that relationship. And the way you fall in love is by reaching inside and giving something very, very precious, and the more you speak, the more you love.
If a woman who had ESP, who could read her husband's mind, was married, and because she could read her husband's mind her husband never had to speak to her—he would think and she would immediately know what he was thinking—but she always had to speak to him in order to express what was on her mind because he didn't have ESP, then in such a relationship the woman would end up falling very deeply in love with her husband. She would be speaking, reaching in and actually saying the words, and the man would end up getting left out of the relationship.
And I think this is part of the reason why women get so concerned when they speak and speak and speak to their husbands and their husbands don't speak back, because the woman who's very sensitive to her position in love space realizes he's not drawing close to me. It's an intuitive feeling. I don't believe it's cognitive, but at an intuitive level we feel that if someone's not speaking to us, they're not drawing close to us, and that's the reality. If we don't speak, we don't draw close.
And therefore the traditional Jews say anyone you ever want to draw close to you, you must speak to, must open up to; you must pour out the words. Why do they speak? Because they think that's the only way to achieve intimacy. Why so much detail? Because that's what relationships rise or fall based on.
But what about this crazy thing, these traditional Jews who say, “We'll do it even if we don't understand it”? What are they thinking? I mean, this is absolute fanaticism, blind faith, a long dive into an empty pool.
I was giving a college course in relationships, and I was lecturing in this particular session on a certain problem that comes up very, very often in relationships: people will not accommodate each other if they don't understand why the other person has this particular request. If it can't be rationally justified, then one spouse will not accommodate the other, and it's a tremendous source of tension in many marriages, many relationships.
When I was in the middle of speaking about how we should accommodate our spouses even if they can't rationally justify their position, the secretary at a college walked in and handed me a note. The note indicated that my wife had left an urgent message, and I read the message: “Sweetie, I'm on my way home from work today. Could you please pick up two packages of seaweed?”
So while I was trying to figure out why my wife wanted seaweed, I crumpled the note up, tucked it in my pocket, completed a lesson about attending to your spouse's wishes even when they're irrational, and then, when I completed the lecture, walked into my office, packed up my bags, and was walking out of the building.
As I was walking out of the building, I started to fantasize and imagine what it would look like if a man who did not understand how relationships worked received such a note. What would his response be? I can imagine a husband getting such a note and thinking, “What does she want seaweed for?” Running to the phone, dialing, no answer. “What about the husband? She asked for seaweed, she won't tell me why. I'm not going to get it for her.” Slam. I can imagine such a thing.
What happened? I walked out of the building and down to the Israeli makolet. If you've never experienced an Israeli makolet, it's sort of like a 7-Eleven run by a gangster. And I made the mistake of requesting seaweed, at which point he said something like in Hebrew, “You're the son of the son of the son of the dog,” which I think in Israeli is not a nice thing. At that point he told me that I should go to a health food store. So I walked out and got on the bus.
To appreciate the bus ride I had immediately after that, you have to understand a little about the background of my family. My wife is the youngest of 4 children, and when my father-in-law was raising his firstborn son, my wife's oldest brother, he was looking for something healthy that he could immerse all the kids in. He found something in Los Angeles called Boy Scouts and enrolled my oldest brother-in-law in Boy Scouts. It's fantastic, healthy, wholesome, beautiful, and it really was a wonderful program. My father-in-law loved it and my brother-in-law loved it, and my father-in-law ended up becoming the Boy Scout troop leader.
When the next boy, the next oldest, was also ready, my father-in-law enrolled him in Boy Scouting as well, and he became the head of all the Boy Scouts in Los Angeles. When the third boy was ready, my father-in-law enrolled him in Boy Scouting as well. By this time the oldest had already become an Eagle Scout, and when the third was enrolled in Boy Scouting, my father had become head of Boy Scouting in California.
When my wife was of age, my father-in-law enrolled her in Girl Scouts, where they sell cookies and go on these cross-country European bike tours, and I'm selling Girl Scout cookies. So she begged and pleaded, and my father-in-law said, “If you promise not to tell anybody, put on a T-shirt and a baseball cap, and you and your brothers will pretend you're a Boy Scout.” So my wife ended up becoming a Boy Scout and went through the whole thing.
So I discovered there are advantages and disadvantages in marrying a Boy Scout. An advantage of marrying a Boy Scout is that she really didn't need very much. When I married my wife, I had a very successful business running. I was in the sound and lighting business and I had money, and I would say to my wife, “I love you, I want to buy you something.” It would frustrate me because she would always say, “No, I just want to be with you.” “No, I want to buy you something,” because she really didn't need, because she was a Boy Scout. So one of the advantages of marrying a Boy Scout is that they don't need very much.
Now, over the years I've discovered certain things that make my wife giggle, that she really, really likes a lot. I have a very, very small but precious list of physical things that I can give her that she really likes, and that list is very, very precious to me because I love her to pieces and all I want to do is really gift her and take care of her. There are things on that list. She likes yellow roses with lavender ribbon. She always tries to tell me what it's called, but I always forget. She likes that stuff. She loves carob. There are certain things that just make her giggle.
That day, when I got on the bus to head into town, going into downtown Jerusalem to pick up a couple of bags of seaweed for her, I had no clue why she wanted seaweed, but I was thrilled because I had something new on my list. I was going to get Chana seaweed.
I arrived at the health food store, walked in, and said, “Do you have any seaweed?” The man said to me, “Oh.”
So I said, “What's ‘oh’?”
He said, “We just sold our last bag,” at which point I said, “Oh.” So he saw I was disturbed. He said, “I'm sure they have it; they always have seaweed.” So I said, “Would you call first?” He called over to the other health food store, and they had seaweed.
So I said, “Could you please help put aside a couple of bags for me?” He told the man, “There's a fellow coming over who looks like he badly needs a couple of bags. Could you put them aside?” So he put aside a couple of bags of seaweed for me.
So I sprinted across Jerusalem to this other place, ran in panting, walked up to the guy, and said, “I'm the man for the seaweed.” So he says, “Do you want anything else?” I'm looking at the man, the bags of seaweed, all these boxes of carob bars, so I reach in, pull out a couple of each type of carob bar, and put them on the counter. I said, “I'll take these as well.” “Anything else?” “No, that's it.”
He wraps up the whole thing, puts it in a bag, and hands it to me. I walk out of the health food store, around the corner, heading back up to the bus, and pass the flower store. I walk back and go into the flower store. I get the yellow roses, lavender ribbon, poof stuff. I explain what that is; yeah, fine. He gives me the whole package. I get back on the bus, head home, get home, and knock on the door. Chana opens the door, and I say, “Hi.”
Now, why did I do that? I had no idea why she wanted the seaweed, and of course the reason I did it was that's what it is when you're in love. It's not that you don't care why she wants the seaweed. I would like to crawl around inside of Chana's head and discover every detail of what she likes and why, because when you love somebody, you want to know all the whys. But I'm not going to refuse to cooperate until I get the whys, because I'm involved in a relationship, I'm in love, and when you're in love, that's how you behave.
And I realized, ten years after the fact, that's what this rabbi was trying to explain to me. What he was saying to me was, “Late, I know you're an academic, but even though you're an academic, you're still a human being. I mean, you love your wife?” That's what he was saying to me: even though I'm intellectual, I'm capable of being involved in intimacy, and the backbone of intimacy is, we do it for her even if we don't understand why. Why? Because it's not a religion; we're involved in a relationship. The whole system is a training system for falling in love.
Now, obviously it's a much longer story. I'm not going to go into all the details tonight. It turned out that over the next 12 years, walking in with this perspective, what I discovered is that every single mitzvah (commandment), every single aspect of this great tradition our ancestors handed down to us, every single aspect of what we stand for, what the Jewish community stands for, is really intimacy. We came here to create a world of intimacy and connection, in the words of this rabbi.
When you open up a newspaper today, you see the world very badly needs the gift that we have to give. We live in a world of total disconnection, of estrangement, of distrust, of isolation, and the stuff that you see in the newspaper is just the international hints of what's really taking place on the interpersonal level.
And I can attest to you, because I do counseling all over the world, that what's going on in Philadelphia is exactly what's going on in LA, in Baltimore, which is exactly what's going on throughout Europe, in South Africa. I've been in Brazil; I was just in Mexico. All over the world, it's the same thing at the interpersonal level, and you just see it played out big time in the headlines in the newspapers.
We live in a world of disconnection right now, but it's not supposed to be that way. We the Jewish people came to this planet to remind people how to practice the lost art of love.

