A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Meyer Yedid / Halacha

Torah Lecture

Halacha O"H 208 / When One Of The Ingredients Is From The 5 Grains

Lectured by Rabbi Meyer Yedid / Halacha

Published
May 14, 2009
Duration
08:22
Lecture code
Y-H06

The General Rule and the Five Grains

  • When two foods are mixed, the usual rule is to make the Beracha according to the majority: for example, peas with rice get Ha'adamah if peas are the majority, and Mezonot if rice is the majority.
  • Shulchan Aruch rules differently when one of the five grains is an ingredient: even if honey or another ingredient is the majority, one makes Borei Minei Mezonot, because the grains are considered chashuv, satiating foods.
  • The lecture also notes that Al HaMichyah may apply afterward, but says its requirements depend on how the food is eaten and will need separate discussion.

When Grain Is Not a Primary Ingredient

  • The grain does not determine the Beracha if it was added only for a functional purpose, such as helping meat kibbeh hold together—not to be eaten, add taste, or satiate.
  • The later Aharonim also discuss adding grain merely to provide color or smell; these purposes do not make it primary.
  • Grain is primary for this rule when it is included so that it will be eaten, add taste, or satiate.

Breading on Chicken or Fish

  • If chicken is coated with corn flour, the Beracha is Shehakol, since both the chicken and corn flour are Shehakol.
  • A very light coating of flour or breadcrumbs added only to prevent the food from burning is not primary, so the Beracha is Shehakol.
  • If the coating is substantial and intended to be eaten, one makes Borei Minei Mezonot, even though the chicken or fish is the majority.

Chocolate, Rice, Crackers, and Cheese

  • If chocolate is the majority in a cake or cookie but the five-grain ingredient is included to be eaten, one still makes Borei Minei Mezonot.
  • This rule does not apply to rice: although rice is Mezonot, it is not one of the five grains, so chocolate mixed with rice is Shehakol when chocolate is the majority.
  • When eating a cracker together with a larger piece of cheese, one makes Mezonot.

Cheesecake and Eating the Ingredients Separately

  • If cheesecake crust is present only to hold the cheese, it is batel; if it is included to provide taste, one makes Borei Minei Mezonot when eating the cheesecake together.
  • The combined-food rule applies when the ingredients are eaten together—for example, when the first bite includes both crust and cheese.
  • If someone eats the top of the cheesecake first and reaches the crust only in a later bite, the first bite gets Shehakol; upon reaching the crust, one makes Mezonot.