Yesterday, we discussed having two foods together, for which we make one Beracha (blessing). Generally, to decide which Beracha is the right one, we take the majority of the ingredients, and whatever the majority is, we make the Beracha on that item. For example, if you have rice and peas mixed together, and the majority is peas, you make Ha'adamah (the earth). If the majority is rice, you make Mezonot (kinds of nourishment). That is generally the rule for deciding what is primary and what is secondary: the rule of the majority.
When it comes to the five grains, which are wheat, you cook them and make a Tavshil (cooked dish) from them, and so on. Even if you add more honey than kemach, more than the flour, the majority is honey or candy, whatever it is, and it's only partially, from these grains. In general, we would have said, “Okay, the majority is Devash (honey), so make Shehakol (Everything was created by His word).” Shulchan Aruch says that in this case, Mevarech alav (blesses over it) Borei Minei Mezonot (Creator of kinds of nourishment). You make Mezonot, and again, you make Al HaMichyah (for sustenance) at the end. That needs to be studied when you make Al HaMichyah, but as for the Beracha Rishonah (first blessing), you make Borei Minei Mezonot. Why is it that way? How come these items are different from anything else? Because these items are chashuv. They are considered very important items; they satiate a person, and therefore, whenever they are in the mixture, they get the Beracha of Mezonot.
However, Shulchan Aruch continues: aval (however), according to this, if we stopped right here, we would say, “Anytime I see any amount of flour or wheat or any of these grains in the ingredients, it’s Mezonot.” Shulchan Aruch gives an exception: if you didn’t put the grain in the food to be eaten—that is, if you only put it there because sometimes you need wheat to hold it together. Say you want to make meat kibbeh. If you just use meat, it’s not going to hold together. How do you make it hold together as one piece? You add a little wheat, a little flour, and it holds it together. The purpose of that flour is not to be eaten, not to give taste, and not to satiate you; you’re using it strictly so you can hold the piece together. In that case, it doesn’t have any significance, or at least not the significance of the chamishah minim (five grains), and therefore it goes back to the general rule, where you make the Beracha on the majority.
It doesn’t only have to be used to hold something together. Later Aharonim (later authorities) bring up another example: a person might put it in to give the food color. That also would not make it primary. Adding it to give the food smell is another purpose that would not make it a primary ingredient. What makes it primary is that the kemach is put there so you should eat it or so that it satiates you.
One example is chicken that is breaded. Be careful: sometimes it’s breaded with corn. If it’s breaded with corn flour, then for sure it’s Shehakol, because both the corn flour and the chicken are Shehakol. However, often it’s breaded with flour or breadcrumbs. Breadcrumbs are Mezonot, right? When they’re cooked, for sure they’re Mezonot. So what Beracha do you make? Here, 95% or 90% of the piece is chicken, Shehakol, but there is grain on the outside. That’s where we can apply our rules. Sometimes they use a very light coating, a very small amount of breadcrumbs, so that when they cook it, when they boil it, it won’t burn. You can’t put it on the fire by itself; it’ll burn. They put it there just so it won’t burn. In that case, you would make Shehakol. That item is not put there to be eaten or to add taste. However, often they make the coating a little thicker. It’s thick. So again, even though it’s much less than the chicken, it’s not the majority, but since it’s put there to be eaten, in that case you make Mezonot. If you have breadcrumbs with chicken or fish, and there’s a significant amount, which shows that you want to eat it—that’s why it’s there—you make a Beracha, Borei Minei Mezonot.
Another example is cookies or cake. Of course, cake is mostly Mezonot, so there’s no question. But let’s say the majority is chocolate, and there’s only some Mezonot inside, a very small quantity. Again, we make the Beracha, Borei Minei Mezonot. Pay attention: this does not apply to rice. Even though rice is Mezonot, it is not from the five grains. If you had chocolate and rice, and the majority was chocolate, you would make Shehakol. But here, with the five grains, even if the grain is a very small part of the ingredients in the item, you make Mezonot.
Another example would be a person eating crackers. Let’s say he has a big piece of cheese, bigger than the cracker, but he’s eating them together. You also make Mezonot on that. These are the rules for Beracha Rishonah. Beracha Rishonah needs to be discussed—how you treat it. Really, it’s supposed to get Al HaMichyah as well, but we have to see how to... You have to eat it in a certain way. As far as Beracha Rishonah is concerned, whenever you see wheat grain in the mixture, as long as it’s there to satiate you or for taste, even if it’s a small percentage of the whole item, you make Borei Minei Mezonot.
One more item that’s also interesting, and sometimes confusing, is cheesecake. Cheesecake is maybe 95%, 98% cheese. Fat, right? Right. And at the bottom, there’s a little piece of crust. If the crust is just there because they need something to hold it—otherwise, you can’t just put your hand in cheese—then in that case it would be batel (nullified). But if it’s there to provide taste, as it often is, you would make Borei Minei Mezonot. However, all these things we just said apply only if you’re eating them together. That means if you’re eating the cheesecake with the cheese and your first bite includes some crust and cheese, you make Mezonot. But let’s say a person eats from the top and doesn’t get to the crust until the next bite, or many bites later. In that case, the blessing for the first bite is Shehakol. So first you make Shehakol, and when you get to the bottom, you make Mezonot. Everything we said about making one Beracha applies provided the items are being eaten together. When the tafel, the secondary item, is eaten by itself first, you make Shehakol.