A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Meyer Yedid / Halacha

Torah Lecture

Halacha O"H 328 / Medicines That Were Mixed In Foods Or Drinks Before Shabbat

Lectured by Rabbi Meyer Yedid / Halacha

Published
June 10, 2009
Duration
07:10
Lecture code
Y-H23

Shulchan Aruch: Kilorin prepared before Shabbat

  • In O"H 328, Seif 21, the Shulchan Aruch permits soaking Kilorin, herbs used as medicine, in water before Shabbat and applying that water to the eyes on Shabbat.
  • To an onlooker, the person appears to be washing his eyes with water, since the Kilorin are no longer noticeable.
  • Although the person using it knows that it is a remedy, the Shulchan Aruch explains that the Gezerah against Shechikah—grinding herbs for medicine—does not apply here: preparing it before Shabbat creates a Heker, a recognition that prevents him from making the remedy on Shabbat.

Applying this rule to medicine mixed into food or drink

  • The question is whether a medicine that would otherwise be Asur to take on Shabbat—for example, medication for allergies in a case where medication would not be allowed—could be mixed into food or liquid before Shabbat until it is no longer noticeable, and then taken on Shabbat.
  • On this approach, observers would see only food or drink, and the person taking it would know it had been prepared before Shabbat, providing a Heker.
  • The answer depends on how the Shulchan Aruch’s ruling is understood. The Acharonim offer different approaches, leading to different Halakhot.

Igrot Moshe

  • The Igrot Moshe explains that the Heter is not based simply on the fact that the medicine was prepared before Shabbat. Rather, Kilorin are normally mixed with water and then applied to the eyes; preparing them before Shabbat means that the normal remedy procedure began before Shabbat.
  • Because the procedure began before Shabbat, applying the remedy on Shabbat is permitted, and there is no concern about the Gezerah involving the samanim, or herbs.
  • Accordingly, mixing pharmacy medicines, such as caplets normally taken by themselves, into food before Shabbat would not help. Since mixing them is not their normal method of use, it would not count as beginning the remedy procedure before Shabbat.
  • In practice, according to the Igrot Moshe, medicine may be mixed into food or drink before Shabbat only if it is normally mixed with something before being taken.

Shulchan Shlomo: Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach

  • The Shulchan Shlomo, by Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach, disagrees with the Igrot Moshe. He says that the Gemara and Tosafot make clear that the Kilorin discussed by the Shulchan Aruch are generally applied by themselves, not with water.
  • He understands that mixing them with water before Shabbat creates the Heker: it shows that this is a Refuah that cannot be prepared on Shabbat, and that recognition is enough to prevent concern that the person will handle herbs on Shabbat.
  • Accordingly, any type of medicine may be mixed into food or drink before Shabbat until it is no longer recognizable, and then taken on Shabbat. Others will see only food or drink, while the person taking it knows that it was mixed before Shabbat.
  • Many Acharonim agree with this opinion.