Good morning, everybody. We are continuing our study of refuah (medication) on Shabbat. Today we are dealing with a question that often arises. One has been prescribed medication for a number of days. Let’s say a person has an allergy. As we’ve discussed, a normal allergy is not a reason to allow medication on Shabbat. But this person already began taking the medication before Shabbat, on Thursday or Friday, and now he wants to continue taking it on Shabbat as well. Is there any reason to allow this medication on Shabbat because he already started taking it on Thursday or Friday?
In truth, we have a halacha (Jewish law) that is similar to this. The Rambam writes that when it comes to medication that one began taking on Thursday or Friday, if there’s a risk that he’ll become a choleh—he’ll become ill—if he stops taking it on Shabbat, then one would be allowed to take it on Shabbat in order to prevent that chance of becoming ill. However, our question today is about when there’s no real danger of becoming ill just because one didn’t take the medication. It’s just that on the day he doesn’t take it, he will be in tza’ar (a lot of pain). Would we allow a person to take the medication on Shabbat because he’ll be in tza’ar, just because he had already started taking the medication before Shabbat?
There is a sefer called Sefer HaChaim, and he brings this up. He writes that people, for some reason, think that if a person already started taking medication before Shabbat, then they would be allowed to take it on Shabbat. But if they didn’t start before Shabbat, then they can’t take it on Shabbat. He says that, in truth, we don’t know where they got this halacha from. As we said, the Rambam that we just mentioned is not a real source for this, because the Rambam is only saying that when a person will become sick, become a choleh. But here, these people are taking it even if there’s no such risk. Where are they getting this from? Just because you started before Shabbat, you’re allowed to go ahead and take it on Shabbat?
He says maybe their proof is from the following halacha in Shulchan Aruch. In se'if kaf heh (section 25), Shulchan Aruch writes: Retiyah she-naflah me'al gabei ha-makah: one has some sort of bandage applied for medication on top of a cut or some sort of wound on his body. Let’s say he put it on before Shabbat, and then it fell on Shabbat. Shulchan Aruch says you can’t put it back on Shabbat. The Acharonim explain, as the Rosh says, that the issue of putting it back on Shabbat has nothing to do with refuah. There is some other reason not to put it back. The Rosh says you can’t put it back on Shabbat because of a different melacha (forbidden labor) on Shabbat. But as far as the gezerah (decree) of medicine on Shabbat, it would be allowed to put it back. That’s not a problem. Since you had it on before Shabbat, you would be allowed to put it back on Shabbat even though it fell. So, says Rav Kugel, you see from here that since you started the medication before Shabbat, you would be allowed to continue on Shabbat.
Now, even though there is a clear difference between the two cases, when the bandage falls on Shabbat, we would allow you to put it back because you’re not putting a new bandage on Shabbat. The same bandage you put on before Shabbat is the one you’re putting back on Shabbat. So that would make sense. However, the Sefer HaChaim does make a comparison, even though he says that you could, of course, make this chiluk (distinction) that we said. But he makes such a comparison, and he gives a reason as well. In other words, why would it be that way? If you took medication before Shabbat, why would we allow you to take it on Shabbat? What happened to the gezerah? He explains that the whole gezerah is that when a person is going to take medication, he’s going to go and grind the herbs. But if we already started taking the medication before Shabbat, generally speaking, one prepares the medication for himself beforehand. So once it’s taken before Shabbat, we can assume that the medication has already been prepared, and we’re not worried that he’s going to end up doing the shechikat samemanim (grind the herbs) on Shabbat. That would be the logic for that.
Now, not everybody agrees with this halacha brought down by the Sefer HaChaim. Some others say there’s no such heter (permission): just because you started doing it before Shabbat, we would not allow you to do it on Shabbat. However, there are many Acharonim who do agree with this opinion, especially in a situation where a person has tza'ar, will have a lot of pain if he does not take the medication. If he started before Shabbat, one would have what to rely on to take the medication on Shabbat because he started.

