A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Meyer Yedid

Torah Lecture

Daily Morning Class: The Darkest Decree 1 (Vayeshev/Hanukah)

Lectured by Rabbi Meyer Yedid

Published
December 29, 2023
Duration
49:05
Lecture code
RMY-DMC107

Hanukkah, Greece, and Darkness

  • Rabbi Meyer Yedid contrasts Hanukkah with Purim: Purim commemorates Haman’s decree to physically destroy the Jewish people, while the Greeks did not seek physical annihilation. Their decrees were spiritual, and the conflict was a battle of philosophy and ways of life.
  • The first appearance of Choshech (darkness) in Sefer Bereshit prompts the Chachamim to identify it with Malchut Yavan, the Greek Empire. Rabbi Meyer Yedid asks why the Greeks and their worldview are described as darkness.

Differences That Do—and Don’t—Make a Difference

  • The central idea is that not every difference makes a meaningful difference. A blue shopping bag and a green one are different, but the difference has no real consequence.
  • People naturally seek to elevate themselves and feel special by standing apart from others. They may do so through money, sports, artistic talents such as piano, guitar, or singing, clothing, watches, cars, social status, knowledge, a distinctive home, or life experiences and vacations.
  • The drive to stand out can appear in experiences, too: someone may take pride in having attended an event while others watched from home, even enduring hours in the cold. Rabbi Meyer Yedid recalls a 15-year-old friend who impressed his classmates by saying he had used the bathroom in the Yankee Stadium locker room.
  • These distinctions may feel like accomplishments, but they do not necessarily produce a successful or happy life. A beautiful home or money does not guarantee happiness; money can even be destructive. Social status can bring misery by creating pressure to protect one’s standing and sensitivity about who is included or consulted first.
  • Rabbi Meyer Yedid is not saying that money, a nice home, sports, or other pursuits are bad or unimportant. His point is that making them the goal of one’s elevation and expecting them to provide fulfillment can lead to disappointment. Even excellent basketball ability does not make someone’s life successful by itself.
  • He offers Yaakov’s ladder as a possible hint: people may think they are climbing upward, when in reality their choices are leading them downward.

What Makes a Person a Hacham?

  • Rabbi Meyer Yedid says that there is only one kind of elevation that truly makes a difference. Marriage and children can feel like achievements relative to others, but they do not make a person elevated if they are pursued as status. The same is true of knowledge and Torah wisdom.
  • Chazal ask, Eizehu Hacham? (“Who is a wise person?”). The question is not answered simply by intelligence: being smart—remembering well, understanding quickly, or thinking deeply—is a God-given ability, but it does not make someone wise.
  • Nor does knowing a great deal make someone a Hacham. This remains true even if the knowledge is accurate, comes from a good source, or includes the wisdom of Torah, Shlomo HaMelech, parents, and rabbis. The question remains: if neither mental ability nor accumulated wisdom makes a person a Hacham, what does?
  • Chazal answer: *Eizehu Hacham? Haro'eh et hanolad*—the wise person is one who sees what will come about. Rabbi Meyer Yedid explains this as seeing the results of one’s actions before they happen.
  • He compares this to driving without headlights: without seeing the road ahead, a crash is only a matter of time; with headlights, a driver can see when to turn or stop. Likewise, seeing consequences can guide what to say and do, including in marriage, finances, and relationships.
  • People often get into trouble because they cannot see where a friendship, a habit, an uncontrolled behavior, or their words are leading. Rabbi Meyer Yedid also says that life is meant to be characterized by shlemut and simcha, and that marriage is meant to be Gan Eden all the time; people fall short when they do not see the consequences of their actions.
  • Possessions and circumstances do not guarantee a good outcome. Wisdom can help a person make use of either a small or a large home, and without that guidance, something pursued for elevation can even become destructive. The ability to see ahead matters in every area of life, at every age and in good, difficult, busy, or quiet times.

Wisdom as One’s Leader: Da'at

  • Rabbi Meyer Yedid addresses an apparent contradiction: he has said that knowing wisdom does not elevate someone, yet he now calls wisdom the most important thing. The distinction is between knowing wisdom and actually using it as one’s guide.
  • A person can learn daily and know many things without letting that knowledge lead their decisions. Being a Hacham means turning to wisdom when making choices and committing to follow its guidance.
  • He connects this to the first Beracha of the Amidah: Atah chonen le'adam da'at. The prayer asks Hashem for da'at, not merely Chochmah. Rabbi Meyer Yedid explains da'at as commitment to wisdom’s leadership—consulting it before acting, rather than knowing what is right and then doing one’s own thing.
  • The Gemara says that a Talmid Chacham without da'at is worse than a dead animal. Such a person may know and quote many sources, including the Zohar and its commentaries, and impress others, while failing to live by what he knows.
  • Rabbi Meyer Yedid explains that this person is dangerous because he looks and sounds admirable, attracting people who may want to imitate him. A dead animal is visibly repellent, so people stay away; the scholar without da'at can appear worthy of following while not living according to wisdom.
  • Whether a person has much or little money, status, or other advantages, wisdom as a leader can help them respond well to what they have and to the challenges they face.

Seeing the Nolad by Learning from Life

  • Rabbi Meyer Yedid notes that nolad can mean both “that which will be born” and “that which was born.” This raises the question of how an ordinary person can see the future without being a fortune teller, magician, or prophet.
  • His answer is that people’s circumstances differ, but human struggles are often similar. Teenagers, for example, may share the same swings between feeling popular and unpopular, high and low, or being affected by whether someone gave them the right compliment. Hashem made people different in many ways, yet similar enough that they can learn from one another.
  • Studying what has already happened—the past *nolad*—helps a person see what may happen again. The same patterns that shaped earlier generations can recur, even though people, places, and technology change.
  • Life experience is one place to learn. Hearing about someone with a troubled marriage, addiction, or alcoholism should prompt questions about the steps that led there; such an outcome did not appear all at once. Similarly, when seeing people with a good marriage, life, or simcha, one should ask what produced it rather than merely wishing for the same result.
  • Rabbi Meyer Yedid says that life involves cause and effect, but people often observe good and bad outcomes without connecting them to what preceded them. Learning those connections provides “headlights” for one’s own choices; by the time a person crashes, it may be too late.
  • He urges listeners to be students of life: when they encounter something excellent, ordinary, or terrible, they should ask how it came about and learn from it. The process has two steps: identify the *nolad*—the connection between causes and outcomes—and commit to its leadership.
  • Torah learning also requires application. A person can learn stories, principles, and values, close the book, and feel pleased to have gained knowledge without letting it affect their life. Rabbi Meyer Yedid describes recognizing that a turning point for him was asking, whenever he learned something, “How does this apply to me?”
  • Thus, haro'eh et hanolad means seeing what is coming by examining what has already happened, and then allowing that lesson to guide one’s actions. Rabbi Meyer Yedid says this is the difference that truly elevates a person and can guide them toward success, happiness, and fulfillment whatever their circumstances.

The Greek Darkness and the Hanukkah Lights

  • Rabbi Meyer Yedid describes the Greeks’ world as dark because people pursued forms of distinction that did not, by themselves, lead to genuine success. He points to the Olympics, where people receive gold medals for lifting weights, running fast, or jumping high: these achievements can set people apart, but the medal alone does not establish that they have succeeded in life.
  • The pursuits themselves are not necessarily bad; without the light of wisdom to guide how they are used, they do not make a real difference. He connects this to Vechoshech al penei tehom (“And darkness was upon the face of the deep”).
  • On Hanukkah, Jews commemorate the Greeks’ darkness by lighting Nerot: one light, then another, and another. Rabbi Meyer Yedid presents these lights as a reminder to see what truly matters, study, learn, and use wisdom as one’s leader.
  • He concludes that Hanukkah celebrates a difference that makes a difference: living with wisdom as da'at, consistently asking what wisdom recommends. He says this brings tremendous success in life.
Words in this lecture1
Hanukkahחנוכה
Terms Chanukah, the eight-day festival of lights celebrating the Maccabees' victory and the miracle of the oil. English: Festival of dedication
Also written: Chanukah, Hanukah