Good morning again, everybody. We’re continuing what we started yesterday. Yesterday, we started trying to figure out the answer to a very simple question. It may seem obvious to some, but it requires a lot of thought. The question we asked was this: If a person were given a choice in our next lifetime, if they gave us a new lease and the choice to come back and live another hundred years, would we choose to come back as a human or as an animal—as a squirrel, a cow, or a bird? Which one would we choose?
To answer this question, which is really a fundamental question, we have to make a comparison. We’re doing comparison shopping to see the difference between a human’s life and a squirrel’s life. As we explained yesterday, every single one of us wakes up every day in order to achieve a life of pleasure, a life of happiness. Therefore, we must measure this specific area when comparing human life and squirrel life.
Yesterday, we saw one comparison in which the squirrel definitely won by a very wide margin: jealousy. We looked at how much jealousy causes pain to humans, who are constantly suffering, not necessarily because they don’t have what they need, but because they see that others have something they don’t have, even though they don’t necessarily need it and could enjoy their life without it. But jealousy doesn’t allow a person to enjoy their life and have as much pleasure in it as they could. A squirrel doesn’t have that issue.
As we explained yesterday, because a squirrel doesn’t have the issue of jealousy, in a way that makes the squirrel wealthier than a human. We have so many things that we have to satisfy to make ourselves happy: “I need to have this and that, and I’ve got to be ahead of him, and I’ve got to be ahead of her.” A squirrel automatically feels satisfied with what he has. He’s not looking at his friend.
Let’s look at something else that humans have to deal with, which we don’t find in animals: the destructive nature of machloket. Machloket means when there are disputes. We humans have to deal with disputes all the time. We get into fights with so many different types of people, especially those who are very close to us.
We get into machloket with our spouse, which makes the house miserable to live in. We get into machloket with our business partner, which makes our business struggle. Sometimes the business itself loses that beracha (blessing). But even if the business did not lose the beracha, the actual pleasure of going to work and making money is tainted by the fact that now I’m fighting with my partner. I can’t stand to look at him, and he can’t stand to look at me. We’re constantly on edge.
If we’re yelling at each other, that’s one type of machloket. Sometimes the machloket doesn’t involve yelling; it’s silent. We don’t talk to each other. We ignore each other. It makes the day so much less happy. We get into machloket with our friends. We see people, and we become uncomfortable. An unpleasant feeling comes up when I see a certain person who did this to me or that to me. I don’t talk to this person.
We get into machloket with family, with brothers and sisters. As you know, it’s not fun at all. It creates a tremendous amount of unhappiness in a family when brothers don’t talk. It’s especially difficult for parents when they see their children fighting with each other. They’re not even involved in the machloket, but the very fact that they see their children fighting gives them a very difficult time and takes away their pleasure in life.
We’ve been around long enough to see the destructive nature of machloket. It has destroyed families. It has destroyed businesses. We see that even when people pass away, it’s a time for family members to come together, to unite, and, first of all, to honor the person who brought them into this world. When a father or mother passes away, it’s time for the children to come together. The greatest pride, the greatest kavod (honor), that a person can give his parents is for him and his family to be united. So long as they’re united, the father and mother are still here.
What do I mean? When you see brothers and sisters who love each other and treat each other like brothers and sisters, it’s obvious when you look at them that they have a father and a mother. So long as there is shalom (peace) in a family, the father and mother are still here. It’s a great honor to a father and mother when everyone sees that their children are still a family. People say, “Oh, that’s this person’s family. That’s this lady’s family,” because they’re a family.
Hashem says to us, by the way, that we are His children, so to speak. We have a closer relationship to Him. Am Yisrael does. Hashem says, “Banim atem”—You are My children. How do we act as children of Hashem? Hashem says, “Lo titgodedu”: Don’t make two separate parties. Don’t be divided. When we’re divided, we no longer look like Hashem’s children. How does Am Yisrael look like Hashem’s children? When they treat each other like brothers and sisters, then we are Hashem’s children. Everyone can say, “Oh, wow, these people have the same father.”
Machloket can destroy a family even in that situation. When a parent passes away, it’s a time to unite like never before. So often, machloket gets into the mix. There are inheritance questions: “I should have gotten this. How come you got that? Oh, you had a private conversation. No wonder he gave you this. You took that necklace. She took the ring.” If it didn’t happen so often, I wouldn’t talk about it. It happens so many times in so many families—good, decent families that have values. Sometimes we’re even close, and all of a sudden money comes along and destroys the fabric of the entire family. Now brothers aren’t talking to each other. And if they are, it’s extremely cold. Cousins no longer have anything in common. This is happening as we speak. Machloket is so destructive. It takes away blessing in our life and makes life a misery. Simply stated.
How terrible is machloket? It’s always good to remember the story of Avraham Avinu and Lot. We know that Avraham Avinu was Lot’s uncle. When Avraham Avinu was told by Hashem to leave his country, his city, and his family, it was a very big test for him. Imagine if I told you today, after all you’ve accomplished in your home, in your city, and with your family, to pick up and leave. Go somewhere, to a city you’ve never heard of, where you know nobody, and start all over again. That’s not an easy test. Avraham Avinu did well on that test. He passed it with flying colors.
But who came along for the ride? Lot came with him. Lot was not commanded to go, but he had a great desire to learn from his uncle and to be around his uncle, Avraham Avinu. Although he wasn’t commanded to go with Avraham, he decided on his own to join his uncle. “How can I leave him?” As the halacha (Jewish law) says, a person should have a rabbi and should be close to a rabbi. Avraham was Lot’s rabbi. He was his mentor. Lot would not give up this relationship, even if it meant leaving everything behind.
This was one of the ten tests of Avraham Avinu. When we say “ten tests,” Avraham had many tests, like all of us. “Ten” means they were very difficult tests. What’s amazing is that Lot, who didn’t even have the commandment himself, decided to do it. That’s how much he wanted to be around his uncle Avraham Avinu, because he understood the value of being around this great man. We should never underestimate the value of having a relationship with great people. It changed our whole life. Lot understood that.
Then we find a story brought down in the Torah about Lot and Avraham—not even Lot and Avraham, but their shepherds. Their shepherds had some arguments. I don’t know exactly what the arguments were; it’s not necessarily important for now. The point is that they had a machloket. This machloket between the shepherds of Lot and the shepherds of Avraham was the reason Avraham told his nephew Lot the words I’m going to read to you.
It says in the pasuk (verse), “Vayehi riv”—there was a fight. Riv means a fight. Remember that word: “Vayehi riv.” Resh Yud Bet (the letters resh, yud, bet). There was a fight between the shepherds of Avraham and the shepherds of Lot. Look at the next pasuk. I’ll read it to you: “Vayomer Avram el Lot”—Avram tells Lot, “Na tehi merivah”—let there not be a fight. Remember that word, merivah. It’s very similar to the word riv. Avram tells Lot, “Let there not be a fight between us, because we are brothers.” He tells him, “Hipared na, hipared na me’alai.” The land is very big. Pick your choice, wherever you want. But let’s separate. Let’s not be together anymore.
There are a few questions about this reaction. First of all, it seems extreme. A fight takes place between Avraham’s shepherds and Lot’s shepherds, and he says, “Listen, let’s just split up.” Another question: Lot was not the only one who was Moser Nefesh—he sacrificed to be with his uncle. His uncle Avraham also sacrificed to be with Lot.
When did Avraham sacrifice to be with Lot? Chazal (the Sages) tell us that so long as Lot was with Avraham, at some point—I don’t know if it was all the time—Lot was not as holy as he should have been. We’ll put it that way. So long as Lot was close to Avraham, Hashem would not be able to speak to him. Meaning, the Shechina (Divine Presence) left him. That was a huge sacrifice, especially for a man like Avraham Avinu. Now you can’t have that same spiritual high. Why? Because Lot is in your midst. Somehow, Lot brought down the temperature of spirituality in Avraham Avinu’s surroundings, and Hashem could not speak to him.
But that did not cause Avraham to say, “Lot, listen, maybe it’s time for us to split.” Avraham was willing to sacrifice his spirituality, the biggest sacrifice. He was willing to sacrifice his connection to the Almighty. Why? Because he knew that Lot needed him. His nephew needed his help. So he wasn’t ready to tell Lot, “Listen, Lot, you go your way, I’ll go my way.” He didn’t do that. “But Avraham, Hashem is not talking to you because of Lot.” “Listen, we’ve got to help Lot. He’s my nephew. I can’t just let him go.”
And yet, when a small fight erupts between Lot’s shepherds and Avraham’s shepherds, his reaction is, “Lot, let’s not stay together anymore.” What happened? The answer is actually alluded to in the pasuk. Remember I told you to remember the word riv? The word riv means fight: Resh Yud Bet. The word merivah also means fight: Mem Resh Yud Bet He (the letters mem, resh, yud, bet, he). It’s actually the same word: riv, merivah. How come, when the pasuk first introduces the fight, it says, “Vayehi riv”—there was a fight—and then, when Avraham tells Lot, “Al na tehi merivah”—let there not be a fight—he uses a different word?
The commentaries explain beautifully that the word riv is said in Lashon Zachar, male language. Merivah is Lashon Nekevah, female language. What Avraham was telling Lot was, “Right now there’s a riv, a fight. It may be a small fight. It’s like a hole in the wall and there’s a leak of water coming down. It’s only a riv. But if we don’t cut this off now, what’s going to happen is that it’s going to multiply like a female: merivah. The little fight, the riv that exists right now, will become merivah. It will multiply. The hole will no longer be small; it will be huge. In fact, right now we’re fighting about something, but at some point we won’t even know what we’re fighting about. We’ll just be fighting because we’re fighting. It will just be a fight.”
Avraham Avinu understood the destructive nature of machloket. Machloket—disputes—destroys. It’s like a fire that burns. If it’s in a home, it burns the home. Spiritually, the home is being destroyed. One may not see it. One might think, “Oh, I’m winning. I’m doing great.” No, you’re involved in machloket. You’re never winning. Machloket in a business destroys a business. It destroys the fabric and the beracha in that business. Again, you may not see it. You may continue to make money, but there’s no beracha in that money. Machloket is destructive to any relationship that has it.
I’m going to share with you an amazing commentary, a beautiful question in halacha. We’re going to share a halacha together now. There is a halacha that when people have a dispute and come to a Jewish court—for example, they have a financial dispute, one says, “My friend owes me a million dollars,” and the other says, “It’s not so”—the court decides. It happens. Having a dispute doesn’t mean a machloket, by the way. If I have a dispute with somebody, it’s not a machloket. I think you owe me money; you think you don’t owe me money. Okay, no problem. Let’s go to the beit din (rabbinical court), and the beit din will decide what the emet (truth) is. Whatever the emet is, we’ll do it.
In Jewish law, a court is not meant to hurt people. A court is meant to find out the truth, because the person who says that you owe him money also doesn’t want the money if it’s not the right thing. When two Jews go to a beit din the right way—I’m not saying it’s the way it is, but the right way to go to court is not to say, “Oh, I’ve got to get this guy.” The right way to go to court is, “I think the guy owes me money, but I’m not sure. Could you tell me what the truth is? I’m not here to win. I’m here to know what I should do.” Again, I don’t know if that’s the reality. I’m telling you that’s what it’s supposed to be.
Anyway, the halacha says that when two litigants come in front of a judge in a Jewish court, before giving judgment the judge should first try to make a peshara. In Hebrew, it’s called peshara. Peshara means a compromise. He says, “Boys, let’s compromise. You say he owes you a million; you say you don’t owe him anything. Why don’t we compromise? Maybe you give him half. Would you guys agree to half?” You’re not giving the decision yet. The first thing you offer them is a compromise. If they don’t want a compromise, then you give them the din, the law. The law might say you owe all of it, or you owe nothing. But first, as a judge, you try to get the two parties to compromise. That’s halacha lemaaseh (practical halacha).
One of the great commentaries on Shulchan Aruch is known by the name Sma: Sefer Me’irat Einayim. The Sma is a commentary on Shulchan Aruch. He asks a very, very powerful question. How can a judge advise someone to compromise if that person might be the winner? There is a halacha: the Torah tells us that you’re not allowed to put a stumbling block in front of a blind person. The person can’t see; you put a stumbling block there, and he falls. That’s your sin.
That’s one example of a stumbling block, but there are other examples. They tell us that if someone asks you for advice and you give him bad advice, that’s a stumbling block. That’s like tripping a blind man. Someone asks you for directions. Simple: someone says, “By the way, how do I get to the west?” You show him the east. Even if you’re playing a joke, that’s an aveirah (transgression) from the Torah. You can’t give bad advice. You can’t tell someone to invest in a company that you know is not good. You can’t advise someone to go into a deal that isn’t what he thinks it is. Bad advice is assur (forbidden).
The Sma asks: How does the judge, with a straight face, talk to these two guys? One guy might be the obvious winner. He’s owed a million dollars. How does the judge advise him to make a peshara, to make a compromise? The guy is losing half a million dollars. That’s bad advice. This is the Sma’s question. He’s wondering why the judge is not guilty of the pasuk that says you’re not allowed to put a stumbling block in front of a blind man.
The Sma says something that you should never forget. We should never forget this. He says that in reality, even if the person is going to lose half a million dollars because he compromised, it’s still better than being the winner. Here’s why: if he wins, he might have won the money, but he lost the relationship. He lost that brother. He lost his family member. He lost that friend. It’s done. Next time you see him at a wedding, or in shul, or... you’ve lost that relationship.
The Sma says, “So actually, I’m giving you good advice. Yes, you may lose some money, but you gained shalom in your life. You gained peace in your life,” which means you have beracha in your life. If you won the money, financially you’re better off, but maybe the beracha is not going to be there if that’s going to cause a fight, which is very normal to happen. Fighting is a fire that burns. It destroys.
There is a great rabbi, Rabbi Chaim Palachi, who says an unbelievable line. He wrote so many books. He was one of the great Sephardi (Sephardic) rabbis of the last few hundred years. In one of his books, he writes that when he reached maturity, he had never seen any man or woman, family, or community involved in a dispute who did not emerge damaged. Community machloket damages the community. Family machloket damages the family. A business machloket damages the family. Nobody wins in a machloket.
Sometimes the situation is such that a person can’t continue. It’s better to separate than to fight. Of course, it would be great to live together in peace and harmony, to live together b’shalom (in peace), and to work as one heart. But sometimes it’s not possible. It’s just a reality. That’s what Avraham Avinu saw. He saw that there was an extreme danger ahead, and that the entire beracha of Avraham Avinu was at risk because he might get involved in a merivah, in a fight with Lot. Avraham was not willing to risk the beracha in his life. He was not willing to risk the siyata diShmaya, Hashem’s assistance in his life.
So he told Lot, “Please, we’re brothers. It’s not good for us to work together. We have different values. It’s okay. You do your thing, I’ll do my thing. The beracha will stay with me, and the beracha will stay with you. It would be great if we were together, but in this situation it’s better that we’re apart.” Machloket is destructive. Machloket really makes so much of our lives and our relationships miserable.
Don’t have machloket. Have you ever seen a squirrel yelling at another squirrel? Have you ever seen one getting angry at another squirrel? They don’t argue; they don’t hold a grudge. They don’t have such possibilities. It’s not to their credit. We’re not praising them because they don’t have this issue. Hashem didn’t create animals with such a tendency. They just don’t fight with each other. They mind their own business. They don’t work together; they don’t work not together. They do their own thing. There’s no machloket, no raging anger. They do what they have to do.
Imagine I could tell you that you could live a life—you come back and could live a life of a hundred years with no machloket. Growing up in your parents’ home, it’s going to be peaceful. Always shalom, ahava, love, working together, ahdut, together. You’re going to get married—forget about it. It’s going to be ahdut, together, with no fighting. Perfect. You know what a home looks like when there’s no fighting? But guess what? The norm is that there’s fighting. That’s how we humans are. We have a tendency to fight and battle. But we all know that a home that has shalom is a home of pleasure.
So I can tell you that for the next hundred years, you won’t fight with your wife, your children, your friends, your partner, or anybody in life. You won’t have any machloket. Every person you see, give them a hug. No machloket. “Wow, what a life! I can live a life like that? Really? I can live with no machloket?” Yes. If you come back as a squirrel, you could. Guaranteed. Guaranteed. You won’t have any machloket in your life. Save yourself all the headaches of machloket.
So, back to our chart. We were taking—we had a scorecard, trying to see, okay, who’s got the upper hand? When we discussed jealousy yesterday, we saw that the squirrel won. It’s 1–0. Today we went through machloket, the tendency for dispute and fighting. The squirrel’s a big winner. So far, it’s 2–0. B’ezrat Hashem (with Hashem’s help), we’ll continue tomorrow.

