Good morning, Rabotai (gentlemen). We’re continuing our study of Eshet Chayil. We’re in Pasuk Kaf (verse twenty).
When discussing chesed (kindness), we cannot give the subject proper respect without discussing today’s subject. Chesed is not only what we normally describe as someone giving to someone else in different forms, whether money, time, or other ways of doing for others. It is a whole lifestyle called chesed. A lifestyle is not a specific act; a lifestyle is the essence of the person.
When Avraham Avinu, as we learned in this week’s parasha, was old, sick, and hot, and he was still very much hungry for chesed, that was a sign that chesed was part of his life. Sometimes you see that Avraham Avinu couldn’t go a day without chesed. For us, it’s hard to understand that. “Just do it tomorrow.” But we wouldn’t ask that question when a person tells us he’s starving after Kippur. We wouldn’t say, “Okay, big deal, eat tomorrow.” So you don’t eat today; you eat tomorrow. What’s the big deal? We wouldn’t ask that question. The person is starving for food. He needs to eat. It’s part of his ability to live life normally. If he goes hungry without food, he’s not able to move on in a normal fashion.
When the Torah tells us that Avraham Avinu was mitzta’er, that he was in pain because he wasn’t able to help somebody, even though it was hard for him, we have a hard time understanding it because chesed is what we do. Baruch Hashem, we have a lot of chesed that the people here are involved in. But there is another level of chesed: chesed is who you are. When chesed becomes who you are, then it’s no different from going a day without dinner, lunch, and breakfast: you’re going to feel weak, and you’re going to be extremely hungry to put something in your mouth. It would be no different if you went a day without doing for others; you would feel that same pain.
Again, probably we don’t have such feelings because chesed is something that we do, but it hasn’t necessarily become who we are. There’s a level of chesed where a person becomes an ish chesed. He becomes a piece of chesed. For that person, not being able to do for others, even for one day, causes a feeling of starvation, and he may need to be moser nefesh. He may have to go and do something difficult just to be able to satisfy his hunger, the same way a person might be starving for food or thirsty for water.
So we have to realize that there are levels in chesed. No matter how much we talk about it—and we’ve been talking about it—there are rungs on the ladder. The highest rung on the ladder is a person whose chesed is part and parcel of who he is. Today I’d like to discuss how a person can turn his life into chesed. If you turn your life into chesed, then it’s possible to be that person. Again, if a person does chesed whenever chesed is called for, like when somebody is asking for something or you see a need, that’s a beautiful, beautiful way of living life, but that’s not going to turn a person into a piece of chesed. When a person lives every moment of his life with kindness, then he could become such a person. So the question is: How is it possible for a person to live every moment of his life with chesed? Is that possible?
There are certain principles in life. Gabe, are you discussing the class? Okay, good, that’s fine. You have some information for us.
Now, there are certain realities that a person lives with in life that may not be called an act of kindness in the world, but they certainly can be, with the right mindset. First of all, let’s be very clear: when we speak about giving and taking, there are two types of people: givers and takers. And actually, in every act of giving, there is usually a taker on the other side. Takers and givers are opposite ends of the same transaction. If there’s a giver, there has to be a taker. When there is a taker, there is a giver. That’s the way Hashem made the world: givers and takers.
But don’t be fooled into thinking that givers and takers are described by the direction of a person’s arm, so to speak. Simply speaking, givers are the ones extending their arm from themselves to someone else, and takers are extending their arms to receive and bringing it back to themselves. That’s the normal picture. The scene of a giver and taker is about which way your arm is moving. Is it going from within you to someone else? Or are you going from someone else to yourself? That’s the picture.
But don’t be fooled. This is a very, very deceiving picture. Most people look at giving and taking this way. When they think of givers and takers, right away a picture comes up of the movements of the hands. But don’t be fooled by it, because this picture has destroyed the possibility of real kindness for most of humanity. This picture is very deceiving. When you automatically think that the motion of your hand decides if you’re a giver or a taker, this image that comes up when you hear the concept has destroyed most people’s understanding of kindness. Why has it destroyed it? Because they could misunderstand the subject. And when they misunderstand it, they could be involved in something they thought was kindness their whole life, and it turns out they were involved in something else entirely.
So if a person knows the value of chesed and all his life thinks he’s doing chesed, maybe he’ll get some points for trying. But lema’aseh (in practice), he didn’t do chesed his whole life. And this is a reality for most of humanity. Most of humanity does not really do chesed most of the time. Why? Because they misunderstand what kindness means. One mistake in this world of kindness can basically misguide a person completely—so misguided that he’ll never even know it. Sometimes you’re misguided, but at least you know you’re misguided. But this person is misguided in a way that only someone who knows better would recognize. The guy himself is 100% clear. There isn’t even a question in his mind. This is a big mistake right here.
So the number one principle you need to keep in mind is that the direction of your hand, so to speak, has nothing to do with describing your act. Whether you’re a giver or a taker has nothing to do with it. Do not misunderstand. You could be a person who gives all day long, with your emotion going from you to someone else, and you could be involved in taking all day long. All day long you’re writing checks, helping people, doing things for others, and every one of those motions is called taking. So you came home that night and said, “What a day. All day long, I’m giving, I’m helping, I’m doing.” In reality, all day long, you are taking.
Let’s give you a simple example. I’ll start with a very simple example. If you had never seen a pizza store or an eatery in your life, and someone took you with a camera and focused on the guy behind the counter, he might say, “I want to show you something you’ve never seen in your life.” The guy comes in at 5 a.m., preparing the dough, cleaning his establishment, getting everything ready. He brings in the sauce, all the different spices, and the cheese, preparing for hours. Then you see him making pizza all day long. He’s moving fast, sweating, working. Every person who comes in is hungry: a slice, another slice, five slices. One guy gives him three pies. One guy gives him six boxes. All day long, from 5 a.m. he’s at it, until finally, at 9 p.m., the guy is exhausted. He can’t do any more. He needs to rest, and he goes home. What an image.
As you are talking about how great this man is, and that he should become one of the major pillars of kindness, someone shows you a bigger picture of what’s going on. Now you get to see the cash register. At first, you only saw the guy working. All of a sudden, you see the cash register. All day long, he’s taking cash. He told you he was giving the guy six boxes. He got a few hundred dollars for that. According to how much the guy gives him, that’s how much he gives back.
Now, this guy could, in reality, be a very big tzaddik (righteous person), and maybe he really is involved in feeding people, and they happen to give him some money so he can stay open, because he can’t survive otherwise. He could be doing this to feed people. But most likely, this person really just wants the people’s money. A guy walks into the store, and the seller wants to get money out of his pocket. As a normal way of life, people don’t give you money for no reason. So he’s thinking, “How do I get money out of this guy’s pocket? How do I do it? Oh, if I give him a slice of pizza, I’ll be able to take the money from him.”
So in reality, this fellow, from 5 a.m. till 9 p.m., was doing nothing but taking, because his entire purpose in giving was to take. When you give in order to take, that’s called taking. It’s not called giving. So don’t be fooled by the pizza man. This is not only an example about pizza. That’s an obvious example.
Any time in life a person gives for any purpose other than having the other person receive, he is taking. For example, let’s say you’re giving because you want the person to recognize you. Let’s say you’re giving because you want someone else to recognize you. Let’s say you’re giving because one day you’re hoping he will give back to you. Let’s say you’re giving because you want a shidduch (match) for your daughter, so you want people to look at you as a ba’al chesed (man of kindness). Under the wedding canopy, what are they going to say under the chuppah (wedding canopy) when they’re talking about you? “You don’t give anything.” What are they going to say? So in order for them to say something about you, he needs to have a good name. He wants to have a shem tov (good name). He wants people to look kindly on him. All of these ideas and all of these things that motivate a person to give make him a taker.
If a guy says, “You know, I’m giving because I want to go to Olam Haba (World to Come),” he’s a taker. Again, it’s a good deal. It’s a good deal. But don’t fool yourself. He’s not involved in chesed. He’s involved in taking Olam Haba for himself. It’s a good investment; I’m not saying it isn’t. But you’re definitely involved in taking. There’s no second way to understand that.
Therefore, if you’re giving because you want something back—anything back, from the smallest to the largest, from physical things or spiritual things—all of that means you are involved in taking. So all day long you are taking. Now, the fact that you feel good doesn’t make you a taker. If you’re doing it because you feel good, that’s what makes you a taker. Don’t confuse the two: if you feel good because you give, there’s nothing wrong with that; it doesn’t make you a taker. But if you’re doing it because it makes you feel good—“I love to help; it makes me feel great”—you’re a taker.
With this understanding, we have just turned pretty much all kindness on planet Earth into an act of taking. I’m not saying anything. It’s very hard to understand logical things. It’s hard to hear this because we love to think of ourselves as givers. But ultimately, when you have this reality facing you, you realize, yeah, it’s not called giving. Your hands might be giving, but in reality, if you’re doing it to get something back, whatever it might be, you’re involved in taking.
Now, it’s better to be involved in taking by helping others than not to do it at all. I’m not saying you’re a bad person, and for sure in Shamayim (heaven) you get credit for that too. At least you helped somebody; at least you did. We’re not taking away from the person who is doing good. He’s definitely better than others who don’t give. But in reality, this is not called a life of giving.
In the same way that the motion of the hand doesn’t show if you’re a giver or a taker, on the other end, when you are taking, when you’re receiving, it doesn’t necessarily mean you’re a taker. Shlomo HaMelech says that if you want to live a good life, you should hate gifts. Hate them. Most people love gifts. Half of business in America is based on gifts. But Shlomo HaMelech says you should hate gifts from your father, your mother, your grandpa, your cousin, your rabbi, from anyone. You should be a person who hates gifts. Then you’ll live a great life. Because if you’re a person who loves gifts, it means you’re a person who likes to be a taker. And to live a life as a taker is an ugly life. You should hate it. He doesn’t say you shouldn’t take them. You should have an emotional disgust for it, because being a taker is ugly. Being a taker is this terrible thing. You ever see a really selfish person? Really, really selfish, obviously selfish. It’s horrible to look at. Shlomo HaMelech says you should hate gifts, because if you love gifts, it means you’re a taker. If you’re waiting for the gift your father is going to give you, if that excites you—
Sometimes in life you may have no choice but to take. There’s no choice. And by the way, Shlomo HaMelech does not say you shouldn’t take gifts. He doesn’t say that, because sometimes in life there’s no choice. You have to take, you have to live, you have to survive. If that’s the situation, what are you going to do? If a person, God forbid, doesn’t feel good, he’s going to the doctor, he’s taking from the doctor, but he has no choice. See, he doesn’t say don’t take. He’s saying you should hate taking. That means even if you take, it should be something that had to be done because there’s no choice.
But be careful. Sometimes you can actually take and be involved in giving. Could you imagine that? You’re taking and you’re called a giver. How could that be? You can receive as a giver only if you really hate gifts. Only if you hate gifts can this happen. If you don’t hate gifts, then it’s not for you. But if you develop yourself to hate gifts because you understand the ugliness of living a life of taking, and therefore you don’t like gifts, you don’t like handouts in any way, then you could be a giver by taking. How?
Let’s say someone buys you a gift. Let’s say someone who really appreciates you spent a day thinking about what he can get for you to show you his appreciation. It could be your wife, your children, your friend, your neighbor, a student, a rabbi. He really wanted to show you how much he loves you. How is he going to express it? He goes ahead and thinks and thinks and works and finds what he thinks is the perfect item that you would love.
Now you are a person who hates gifts, so you took the words of Shlomo HaMelech and told the guy, “I’m sorry, I appreciate the thought, but I can’t accept it.” He asks, “Why?” You open Mishlei and say, “Look, sorry, I can’t.” So that would be a mistake. Why? If you’re taking it because you love it, that’s being a taker. If you’re taking it even though you hate it, why are you taking it? If you hate it, why are you taking it? You’re taking it because you want the person to feel good that you received his gift. Oh! If that’s the reason you took it, because you want him to feel good that he was able to give you a gift, then by taking you’re actually giving. Unbelievable. By taking the gift, you’re actually giving the person satisfaction.
You know who does that in the most gorgeous way? Hashem. Hashem says, “Bring me a korban (sacrifice), bring him a korban.” Hashem takes our korbanot. He takes our sacrifices. Hashem says, “Give me this, give me that.” What is that all about? I thought we were supposed to hate gifts. Why does Hashem want things from us? Hashem is giving us the opportunity and the satisfaction of being able to give Him something, even though He doesn’t need anything, even though He would, so to speak, hate gifts. He’s not a taker, but He wants us to feel good that we’re able to pay Him back. Mah ashiv laHashem? What can I pay you back? Hashem says, “Oh, you want to pay me back? Give me this.” You say, “Wow, Hashem, you really want that?” The answer is, He doesn’t really want that; He doesn’t need it. He wants to give you that satisfaction. Hashem is involved in giving.
So in reality, there’s a giver and a taker, as we described in the beginning of the class. Every giving has taking, and every taking has giving. But that’s not really true. Whatever we said in the beginning is a mistake. It’s not true. You can have two people who are both takers, or both people who are givers. The transaction at the pizza store involves two takers. One guy is taking pizza, and one guy is taking money. So even though one is giving and one is taking, they are both takers. There is no giving involved at all. Or you can both be givers. I want to show you how much I appreciate you, and you want to show me that you appreciate me. So even though I gave you and you received, we are both givers.
So don’t make the tragic mistake of humanity in today’s lesson. Don’t make the tragic mistake of thinking that giving and taking are described by the motion of your hands. It has nothing to do with that. It has to do with what’s actually happening. Are you involved in giving or taking? Giving has to do with your intent, not with your motion.
That’s the number one lesson for tonight. If we were able to correct that, you can have a pizza store and be giving all day long. And you can still be a good businessman. If a person really says, “You know what? I want to be involved in feeding people. People come in; they’re hungry. I want to feed them. Not only do I want to feed them, I want them to enjoy it. Now, of course, I have to live. I have to make money. If I don’t make money, I can’t feed my family. If I don’t make money, I can’t keep this store open. So of course I need money to be able to survive. But in reality, I’m involved in feeding others.”
The fact that you make money to survive doesn’t go against the fact that you want to give. You could be selling shoes all day long. “I’m selling shoes.” Why are you selling shoes? Most people, I would imagine, when they sell shoes, it’s all about money. You sell a product. Now, I know this might seem a little bit unreal to most businessmen, but you sell products. You could look at your product as a kindness that you’re doing for your customers. Again, of course, you need to get paid. And you’re allowed to get paid, and you’re allowed to make a good living. But what’s your first intent? I think it’s very hard for the average businessman to say his first intent is to help others, and then, of course, he needs to make money.
But in theory, if you’re able to change your mindset and become an Avraham Avinu, if he had a pizza shop, he would be excited about feeding people. He may have to get paid to stay in business. But he’s giving pizza all day long, or you’re giving shoes all day long, or you’re selling housewares, or clothing, or whatever it might be. You’re renting out apartments. Whatever you’re doing all day long, we’re in a world of transaction. If you’re not doing transactions in your life, then you’re probably dead or in a coma. Everything’s a transaction. You’re always giving and taking. Depending on where your head is at, that’s what describes you as a giver or a taker.
You could be doing the same thing all day and be a taker, or doing the same thing and be a giver. It’s all about how a person views his mindset and his responsibilities, and what kind of person he wants to become. It’s definitely a very, very far distance from the way most of us live. So far that you say it’s probably impossible. But it’s not impossible. For the person who lives kindness, it’s a goal. It’s a goal to change the way we do things. Again, we may do the exact same things, but they just change from something else to a much upgraded act.
Today we have more to do: how a person is able to live his entire day with kindness. But today we made a very big dent—not in the whole entire day, perhaps, but in every transaction, at least. Our life is full of transactions. Whether it’s a hello—that’s a transaction—or something that we’re doing for somebody, whatever transaction we’re involved in can be an act of kindness. We’ve solved one portion of our day. All transactions could change.
So today, if you’re going to work and you’re selling a product, think of how much you’re doing for your customer. Think of how much joy you’re bringing your customer. By the way, if you do that, you become a better businessman, just as a side point. Don’t do it for that reason; then you become a taker. It happens to be that if you think about making your customer happy, you start to think for your customer, and you become a better businessman. But that’s a side point. Today we’re not giving business advice. Today we’re giving advice on how to become a giver. All you have to do is look at your product and look at the people who will enjoy your product. Then you’re able to facilitate that, and that becomes your mindset. It’s training. It’s day after day, and then that will roll over into everything else that you’re doing. Tomorrow is part two. Have a good day.

