A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Moshe Haber

Torah Lecture

Daily Halachot - Timing of Eating in the Evening and Shemah

Lectured by Rabbi Moshe Haber

Published
April 28, 2026
Duration
1:55
Lecture code
rmh-dh-64

Eating Before Nighttime Shema

  • The usual practice is to begin the meal before the half-hour period preceding the zman (time) of a nighttime mitzvah. One should not begin a meal with bread within that half-hour.
  • Rabbi Moshe Haber raises the question: If the Shema recited during earlier tefillah, before sunset, does not fully fulfill the mitzvah and must be repeated at night, why may one begin a meal with bread within a half-hour of nighttime?
  • The Beit Yosef addresses this question: Some consider the earlier Shema to have significance. One may rely on that and need not take the extra precaution of waiting until the proper time before starting the meal.
  • Once nighttime arrives, the proper practice is to say Shema before beginning the meal. However, one need not avoid starting the meal during the preceding half-hour, because the earlier Shema recited in tefillah is relied upon for this halacha.