A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Moshe Haber

Torah Lecture

The Art of Balanced Living: Social Yet Independent

Lectured by Rabbi Moshe Haber

Published
July 30, 2025
Duration
17:25
Lecture code
RMH-MY-62

What Social Perishut Means

  • Rabbi Moshe Haber explains that the perishut under discussion is social perishut: the ability to separate oneself, to some degree, from the Chevra (a good group). It does not mean having no friends, but not needing to be fully socially connected at all times.
  • This idea can be misunderstood and become harmful. It is not permission to become a hermit or to withdraw from other people. An important condition is concern for another person’s shame; our thoughts should remain connected with other people.
  • A person should spend enough time with good people for the needs of learning or income, while also making space to connect with Hashem. The goal is to be social yet independent—not to become habitually talkative, engage in random schmoozing, or look at everything one sees.

Why Community Matters, Especially in Learning

  • The Gemara warns that a sword hangs over the badim—those who learn alone—and describes them as enemies of the Rabbis. Rabbi Haber stresses that learning alone is not merely less ideal; he presents it as destructive for Torah and for the Jewish people.
  • Although studying alone may seem quieter and less distracting than learning with others, the Gemara’s teaching, as Rabbi Haber presents it, is that learning alone is more damaging to Torah than learning with a group.
  • He briefly notes that some people who learn alone today receive something along with their sefarim (books), but says this is still not ideal. The broader point applies to social life as well as learning: people need friends and a social surrounding.

How a Group Keeps Thinking Grounded

  • Rabbi Haber asks how to reconcile the need for a degree of separation with the danger of seclusion. He explains that prolonged isolation can undermine practical, rational thinking.
  • As an example, he points to wealthy or elite people who may live in secluded communities, have little contact with the people they discuss in political debates, and rarely engage with the wider world. He suggests that this distance from reality can contribute to extreme or detached opinions.
  • He gives a similar example about opinions on how schools should operate. Someone who has never served on a school board or committee, volunteered, or dealt with the school’s practical constraints may hold an outlandish view because they do not know the details.
  • The tuition crisis is another example: people who claim to have an easy solution may never have seen a school’s balance sheet. Someone who has examined the finances may also oppose tuition, but understands the reality and how difficult it is to change the numbers.
  • Being involved in society helps people think normally and rationally because they encounter the realities behind their opinions.
  • This also explains why learning with others matters. A learner working alone can build an idea upon their own initial thought without testing it. In a group, others can challenge an extreme idea, prompting the learner to seek proof, check whether the reasoning holds up, and clarify whether the idea is repeatable and logical.

Why a Person Also Needs Independence

  • Being only a good member of a group can limit a person’s ability to develop a distinctive contribution. A person whose whole identity is being socially agreeable may be likable and easy to get along with, but may have little that stands out. Rabbi Haber says people also need their own legacy.
  • The balance is to be comfortable with others and also comfortable spending time alone. A person can use a group to exchange and work through ideas while retaining the ability to think independently.
  • Rabbi Haber says that the greatest people combine these qualities: they develop ideas with others, but remain independent thinkers. In Torah learning, simply repeating other people’s ideas will not produce a chidush (novel insight); a person needs room to develop their own thinking.
  • In practice, that means getting along with others, going out and seeing people, and bouncing ideas off them, while also taking walks, spending time alone, and allowing one’s own mind to work.

Individuality and the Sources of New Ideas

  • The Gemara is cited for the fact that no two people have the same face. Rabbi Haber adds that people do not have identical minds either: each person’s makeup, background, education, parents, and temperament shape a distinct perspective. One person may think of something another never would, regardless of which is smarter.
  • He illustrates this with a story about his children calling AI from a phone. His family has a Honda and his wife has a Toyota minivan; one child wants him to get at least a Tesla and is pressing for a Cybertruck, despite Rabbi Haber telling the child, “Robert’s not going to have a Cybertruck.” Asked which car companies are best, the AI answered that Toyota and Honda are among the most reliable.
  • AI, he says, can draw on many people’s ways of thinking, but it does not replace an individual’s unique mind. If someone is so socially influenced that every thought is filtered through what others will say or think, that person’s capacity to grow and contribute something distinctive is limited.
  • The same applies to work and making money: a person seeking to be unique needs independent thought. At the same time, independence needs the grounding of normal logic; taking one’s own thinking to an extreme can lead to ridiculous or insane ideas.
  • Rabbi Haber says that ideas are not created entirely from scratch. Ideas, inventions, and institutional innovations build on earlier thinking or mechanisms, then add a person’s distinctive way of seeing things. Drawing on his experience running a shul (synagogue), he says this combination of borrowing and adding a unique twist applies to institutions, families, and other areas of life.
  • His conclusion is that people should be part of the group while retaining their own way of thinking. People should be able to express themselves within the mainstream, rather than through craziness; the balance of social connection and individuality is what allows a person to go further.