These two paragraphs are about perishut: what kind of perishut are we talking about now? Social perishut. Again, this can be misunderstood. It can be very dangerous, but when properly understood, it is very healthy for a person in many ways. Perishut means abstaining. What is social perishut? His words are: “A person having the capability to separate themselves from the Chevra (a good group).” What does it mean to separate from the Chevra? What does that mean? It means a person says, “I don’t need to be fully social at all times. I’m not so connected to my social surroundings.” What is the balance? I have to have friends, of course, but I don’t need to be so socially connected. That’s considered some degree of separating from the Chevra.
Now, he gives you many introductions to explain it. This is not a real thing where a person should say, “Okay, I’m going to become a hermit.” I’d say it’s okay, right? Don’t tell me I have a Torah giving me the right to seclude myself. We all know where those people go. An important condition concerns the other person’s shame. Our minds, our thinking, should be along with other people. They should be combined with other people.
There’s a sword on the neck of those who are badim—those who learn alone. That means learning is related to social life, as we’ll see in a second. Those who learn alone: not only is it not good, it’s considered destructive for our people. To learn alone is considered a very negative thing. We call people who sit and learn alone enemies of the Rabbis. A guy learns Torah all day. He learns alone, according to the statement. He’s considered an enemy, according to the Gemara. He’s a badim. People who sit and learn Torah alone, secluded, are not only considered not as good—not only considered, you know, not the best—they’re considered terrible. Clearly, a person has to associate with others; they have to be friendly with others.
By the way, many people make the argument, “When I learn alone, it’s more peaceful. When I learn alone, there are no distractions. When I sit and study alone, there’s no one who’s going to get me into a side schmooze for hours.” It makes sense to learn alone. And the Gemara is telling you that not only is that incorrect, the opposite is true. Learning alone is way more destructive for the Torah than learning with a group.
There’s also something about learning a commentator and considering the law. Oh. Many people who learn alone today are receiving something along with the sefarim (books). So that’s something, but not great. Still not great. This is all pointing to the fact that this is about learning, but it’s also true socially. We definitely need to have a social surrounding. We need to be with people, whether we’re learning or just generally having friends.
So what is this happy medium? He started off by saying there’s a concept out there called being Poresh (separating), having a degree of getting away from your friends. But at the same time, he brings sources from other places about how bad it is for a person to be secluded. How we find the balance is difficult. Let’s see in a second. A person should connect to good people for a certain amount of time, whatever is necessary for his learning or for his income. And then he should also… in order to connect to Hashem. So he should be social, but independent. How do you find this balance? Social, but independent. And with this independent mindset, he says, “Don’t be such a talker, and avoid just having random… And don’t look at everything you see.” A person can turn themselves into a very social person as a second nature. Avoid that.
So how do you have this balance? Should I be social, when he’s telling me that if you’re a loner, you’re in big trouble? Or should I be independent? What’s the balance? The mindset is this. I’ll give it to you in a few ways. There’s a concept that a person should have a good Chevra, a good group. So what does that mean? Should I be alone or not? That is the thought.
The way it works is this: if a person is really secluded, if you’re alone, what ends up happening is that your mind goes loony. You lose your practical way of thinking. In a certain sense, it’s related to politics. Some of the wealthiest people, mostly elite people, have some of the craziest ideas in politics. It seems to me that they have zero connection to the reality of what they’re talking about. So they might live in L.A. in a secluded community, right? In a gated area where they have no connection at all to the minorities they care about, or whatever they’re talking about. They would never even look at them. They have nothing to do with them. They have no relation to the world at large. They don’t walk the streets, and they don’t really deal with people that way. Because of that, their minds can go crazy. That’s one example: people with their opinions. Who are the people that have the craziest opinions? Usually, people who have nothing to do with reality, right?
A guy has an opinion about how a school should run. The guy’s got a shita (opinion) about how a school should run. Chances are, if his opinion is outlandish, it’s because he was never on a board of a school, never on a committee, never did anything as a volunteer. He doesn’t understand the ins and outs. The more you are separated from something, the more your mind can go off the rails in any area. This is how it works, right? People have opinions about school. Usually, those are outlandish opinions. Everyone’s got the tuition crisis figured out. Who are the geniuses who have the tuition crisis figured out? The guy who never saw the balance sheet of a school. The other guy might also be anti-tuition, but he knows the reality. He knows what he’s up against. He knows how difficult it’s going to be to figure it out. That guy has looked at the balance sheet all the time, and he knows what’s going on. He knows it’s going to take a lot to shift the numbers.
Being part of society, being part of the mix, allows us, enables us, to have a normal, rational, regular way of thinking, right? So this points to the fact that being part of a group is a good thing. How does it relate to learning? Why is learning alone so bad? Learning alone is so bad because, when you sit down and learn, you have an idea and continue to go with that idea, build on it, build on it, build on it, and create a concept. There you go. You create a concept all based on your own mind. When you have people bouncing ideas around, you have a group. You say it to them. Someone shoots it down and says, “That’s really extreme.” Now you look for more proofs. Now you look for more confirmation. Now you make sure that it makes sense. Now you clarify whether it can be repeated. And if it can be repeated to a group and it’s going to get by, it’s logical. It’s rational. It’s normal. It’s accepted. You’re good to go. If you’re alone, you say your ideas. You’re all loony, and they end up going off the rails. That’s the mindset. That’s why you need to have a group. That’s pro-group.
So where’s the idea of being Poresh? Why must the person be separated from the unit if he’s telling you—we just established clearly—that a person should be part of a Chaburah (group)? Here’s why. If an individual’s legacy is that he’s a good member of the group, he’s limited. If all you are is part of the group, you’re limited. Any of us who are part of a group are limited. Why are we limited? Because there’s no way I’m going to exceed anyone else. There’s no way I’m going to shine past any other person. There’s no element of myself that’s unique. If all I am is a good part of the group, I’m limited. Certain people are super social, and that is their entire existence: how social they are. If you’re that kind of person, chances are there aren’t so many things that make you stand out. You’re very likable. You’re easy to get along with. But there aren’t so many things that make you stand out. That’s not what we want, because we want to have our own legacy. You want to have your legacy. I want to have my legacy.
Now, how do I do this? If I’m part of the unit, which is what he told me to do, and I’m thinking along with the group and working along with the group, and my ideas are rational because I’m part of them, how then do I have my independence? This is the perfect balance you need to have. You need to be a person who’s social, who is perfectly comfortable being alone. That’s the balance: a person who likes getting along with other people but has no problem with, and likes, spending time just thinking. That is the perfect balance he’s telling you about. You have those people to bounce ideas off of. You have those people to work your ideas out with. But you also have your own mind. That’s great.
The greatest people out there have that balance. On the one hand, they work with others. They figure out ideas based on others. They develop concepts by working with what other people think is normal. But at the same time, they’re unique. They’re independent thinkers. They can build an independent idea. You can’t be an inventor, you can’t be someone who can open a new idea, if all you’re thinking about all day long is how other people think. Because if they think and I think like them, how am I going to be unique? It’s not possible. Even in learning Torah, I can’t just bounce off their ideas of learning and say, “Let my idea be like theirs.” Because then I’m never going to come up with a chidush (novel insight) in my life. How can I have a chidush if all I’m saying is what they’re saying, right? Instead, you need this balance. The balance is a social person: a guy who gets along with others, a person who gets out, a person who sees other people, a person who bounces ideas off of other people. But at the same time, you’re extremely independently driven. That means you take walks, you do things yourself, you think for yourself, you spend time alone, and you just allow your own mind to work itself.
No two people have the same face. We know that from the Gemara. No two people have the same mind either. Every person, because of their own makeup, can come up with things that I’ll never come up with. And there are things that I’ll come up with that you’ll never come up with. Every one of us. How is that possible? It’s not possible because either one of us is smarter than the other. It’s because our makeup, our background, our education, our parents, our temperament—everything about each one of us—creates our own self.
And that self—you know, AI is awesome. I was in the car last night. My kids found out a way to call AI, so they can get by. They get right past, you know, the iPhone. You can call AI on the phone, with a phone number, and ask questions. You know that? So I have two cars. This is how it works. I have two cars. My car is a Honda. My wife’s car is a minivan, a Toyota. Okay? You can imagine which child, huh? Toyota. You can imagine which child—one of my kids wants more. He’s pro me having, at least at the minimum, a Tesla. He’s really inching up for a Cybertruck. That’s his goal. No, it’s not going to work. I tried to tell him, “Robert’s not going to have a Cybertruck.” He can keep trying.
So he calls up AI, okay? He calls up AI, and you can imagine. He asks it questions. It’s not working out. Anyhow, one of the questions he asked it is, “What are the best car companies?” It’s on speaker in the car. My wife and I are in the front, and he’s in the back seat. On speaker in the car: “What are the best car companies?” No joke. AI answers. A lady answers. She says, “Well, Toyota and Honda are the most reliable companies out there.” I say, “Never mind, never mind. Never mind.” But AI is going to be awesome. It’s going to be awesome.
But it will never be one individual’s way of thinking. It’ll be a lot of people’s way of thinking, but you’ll always retain your unique mind. And every person’s unique mind can create something special. How does that happen? If he’s too socially connected in an unhealthy way—if everything that goes into his mind makes him say, “What are others going to say? What are they going to think? How do they think?”—then he’s limited. He’s held back, and he can never grow.
You know this in work. You’re trying to be unique in work. You’re trying to be unique in life. You’re trying to make more money, and that has to come from a unique element. If you always think about what other people think, there’s no way to be unique. You have to develop your own independent thinking. At the same time, we have to be held back in a good way by normal logic. If we go too far into our own minds, to an extreme, God put ideas that are ridiculous and insane, and ways of thinking like that for life as well. Every person needs to have a way of thinking in order to be unique. This is a very healthy balance.
So he’s telling you, Poresh: separate. Don’t be so connected or reliant on the group around you. At the same time, you need to have independence. You have to be alone at times. You have to think on your own. Every novel idea comes from this combination of what others think and bouncing ideas off of others. Whenever people say that an idea was a knockoff of somebody else, it’s true. Every single idea is a knockoff. There’s no guy that comes up with a brand new idea from scratch. They build on something else, but they use their own unique way to see things in a certain light. Anything in any area of life, whether it’s learning or anything else, is a knockoff. Every single one is based on someone else’s way of thinking, with a unique twist.
Every invention is also a knockoff. They’re based on a certain mechanism, and someone came up with a new idea. Any idea that an institution builds on—okay, I can tell you from the back end of running a shul (synagogue): any idea that an institution comes up with, every single one is that combination of a knockoff with a unique twist. Every single one. You’re never going to come up with a brand new idea from scratch. It’s not normal. It doesn’t happen. And by the way, chances are it’s not healthy either. You need to have that blend in your mind, in your institution, in your family. We’re part of the masses. We’re part of the group. But we have our own unique way of thinking. That combination can lift you further than anyone else can get to. If you have your own unique way, you never take it down a drop.
You know, they love to talk about independence and people allowing people to express themselves. Every person has to be allowed to express themselves as part of the mainstream, not as part of craziness. That combination is the perfect person. It’s not like this.