So, Sukkot is coming up. In some ways, the Sukkah (booth) may be a pretty underrated place and mitzvah (commandment) on Yom Tov (holiday). I’ll tell you what I mean. The Sukkah itself is a very spiritual place. I’ll give you one example. We have the idea of Ushpizin: each day we welcome in a different guest. Abraham, Yitzhak, Yaakov—seven days, seven guests. It’s a unique idea. What does it mean? You have Abraham coming on one day, Yitzhak coming—Yitzhak on this day. What is this concept? These are words brought down from the Zohar about this concept. But the theme is that the Sukkah has a name: Tzila d'Meheimnuta. Tzila d'Meheimnuta means you’re in the shade of Hashem. That’s the spiritual level of the Sukkah. Like I said, it’s underrated. It’s an unbelievably spiritual place. In fact, I think you can say that the Sukkah, in a way, is the most spiritual place on earth.
Now, these have their own unique qualities. That’s because they’re designated for service. When something is designated for service, it has a very important level as well. For a Sukkah without designation, just the fact that a Sukkah is a Sukkah makes it an extremely spiritual place. For example, a person should avoid talking about inappropriate things in a Sukkah because of that level of spirituality. You should recognize that it’s a very holy place. It’s called the shade of Hashem. Tzila d'Meheimnuta is the shade of Hashem.
Why is it important to know that it’s the shade of Hashem? Here’s the point I want to lead to. We know that a Sukkah is supposed to have more shade than sun. The Schach (sukkah covering) has to leave some sun coming in. You can’t have major gaps where too much sun comes in. You have to have some sun coming in, but there has to be more shade than sun. How does that relate to the first comment? In depth, the idea of having more shade than sun is a literal halakha (Jewish law), but it’s also a very deep concept: a person is supposed to be more in the shade of Hashem than under the sun.
What does that mean? Let’s go a little deeper. The sun represents nature. The sun represents—I don’t want to call it wealth—but it represents basic natural things. When someone goes into more shade than sun, what they’re saying is, “I’m going more into Hashem’s hands than I am into nature.” That’s actually the deeper theme of the Sukkah: you’re stepping into Hashem’s hands more than you are into nature. That’s the idea. You’re putting up more shade than sun. You’re blocking out nature because you’re going into God’s hands.
I’m going to tell you a Gemara. Remember this Gemara? It’s a very odd Gemara, and I think if we break it down, we’ll get clarity. Again, that’s the first point: the Sukkah is an extremely powerful place, and the core of its power is in Hashem’s hand, so to speak.
Tanu Rabbanan (the rabbis taught). On that point, by the way, you know the Sukkah has to be two walls—three walls, really. Two walls and a drop. All right? Two walls and a drop. You know the idea: you’re in Hashem’s embrace. An embrace is like this: one arm, one half of the arm, the other half of the arm, and the hand. So, two walls and a drop. That’s the idea. You’re literally in Hashem’s shade, and you’re in Hashem’s embrace. That’s the idea.
Now listen to this Gemara. It’s going to start off very randomly, but its explanation is deep and relates to this point. Tanu Rabbanan. Ma'aseh—it is a story with a rabbi who is sitting in someone’s Sukkah. The sun started to shine down on the Sukkah. Amar lei (he said to him). One rabbi asked the other rabbi, “Rabbi.” Amar lei, “Let me put a sheet over the Sukkah. The sun is shining down too much. Can I put a sheet over it to block out the sun?” What’s the halakha on Shabbat? You’re allowed to put a sheet over the Sukkah. Amar lei. The rabbi answered with a random statement, completely out of left field: “There hasn’t been a tribe of the Jewish people that never had a judge.” It’s a very strange Gemara. We were changing the subject. The question was, are you allowed to put a sheet over the Sukkah? It’s too much sun. You’re going to relate to it in a second. Are you allowed to put a sheet over a Sukkah? It’s too sunny. Can I put a sheet over it? And the response was, “What are you doing, trying to put a—there has been no tribe without a judge.” What does that have to do with this? What in the world is going on?
Now the sun starts to get stronger. It starts to come over to the center of the Sukkah and beat down even harder. He tells him, “Can I put the sheet over it?” He tells him, “There hasn’t been a tribe that went without a prophet.” “You’re not talking to me. I’m on the end of the hook. Was she ever the same.” He said, “She’ll assume in the beam. I just think.” Then the sun started to beat down really hard. He thought, “I will not even ask him the question and get these ridiculous answers.” He took a sheet, covered the Sukkah, and called it a day.
It’s the strangest Gemara ever. He’s asking, “Are you allowed to put a sheet over the Sukkah because it’s too sunny?” He’s being answered, “Every tribe has had a judge.” He asks the question again because it got more difficult. He’s answered, “Every tribe has had a prophet.” He asks the question a third time because the sun is beating down so much, and he says, “Enough with this.” He covers the Sukkah himself. What in the world is going on in this Gemara?
I wonder what was going on with this Gemara. Charles, do you have any idea? It sounds like left field, right? You hear the words; it gets more and more left field. So listen to this explanation. I told you before that the shade of a Sukkah represents the idea that we’re going into Hashem’s hands and out of nature. That’s what it represents. The sun is nature, and the shade is Hashem. This is a rabbi sitting in a Sukkah literally, but also figuratively. He was a very wealthy rabbi, with a lot of business. He asked, “Can I go more? Can I cover the Sukkah?” Which meant, “Can I cover the Sukkah?” Meaning, “Can I get less involved in my business? Can I get less involved in my natural income and get more involved in Hashem? You know, learn more, not be so busy with my money, because I want to be involved in Hashem. I want to move out of the sun, be less involved in material things, and get more involved with my learning.” This was his question. He was a very wealthy man, and he asked this question.
Charles had a question: “Nothing built to sheet. Nothing built to sheet.” Nothing. He said “sheet.” He said “sheet” covering the sun, but he really meant it as a metaphor. “Can I move out of my current state, where I’m a wealthy person, and get more involved in learning? I’ll get rid of my business and go more into learning.”
The answer was, “Every tribe has had a judge.” What that meant was, figuratively, every single type of person in their state has had a leader. “Don’t leave your role. Your role is perfect for you. I know you have wealth. I know you have business, and you’re trying to get out of it. It’s good for you.”
So he asked the question again because the sun started to get stronger, which meant he got wealthier and had more business. Now he was really feeling bad: “Too much business for me. I want to learn. I don’t want to be this kind of person. Can I cover this sheet? Can I move out of my business and go straight into learning totally, so that I can spend more time in Hashem’s hands?” Now the question is clear. As you follow the question, the rabbi ignored him again. He said, “There hasn’t been a tribe without a prophet.” In other words, “Hashem put you into your role. You’re in a unique situation. You’re a wealthy rabbi, a unique situation. Continue your role. Don’t move out. Continue to make money. Continue to make money and learn. Do your thing.”
Then the sun started to beat down like crazy, which means he became an extremely, extremely wealthy man. Then he decided on his own, right? He said, “Listen to the question. For me personally, I only have 120 years to live on this earth. It’s too much sun.” In other words, “I’m clearly being pulled too much toward materialism. It’s beyond the need for a judge, beyond the need for a prophet. In other words, there’s no need, as a leader, for me to have this much sun. I’m going to make the decision myself. Spread this sheet over the Sukkah,” which meant, “I’m going to move out of my business now because I’m so wealthy. I don’t need it anymore. Maybe I’ll sell the shares, whatever it is. I’m not going to Torah full time.”
The process of this Gemara is showing you that this man was debating, “What do I do in my role? I have a lot of material, and I also have a lot of capability in Torah. I’m a rabbi. What do I do? Do I move out of my business part?” He was told no. The second time, he was told no. Only when he was extremely wealthy, beyond all means, was he able to be told—or perhaps he made the decision on his own—to cover the Sukkah with the sheet. That’s the metaphor of this Gemara. The Gemara itself sounded like Chinese, but this is the metaphor.
Now there are two things to take away from this Gemara. One thing to take away is that if a person is placed in a unique situation—a wealthy rabbi, right? He has a business, and he knows how to learn—don’t think, “I have to do away with this. This is strange. I have to go all the way.” If you’re in a unique situation, God put you there for a reason. Keep it. Only when it’s over the top, when it’s extreme—he only has a certain amount of time to live—does he change the situation. Aside from that, you leave it up to Hashem, and you accept your role as is.
That’s point number one. The Sukkah point is that our Sukkah is literally shade, which blocks us out from materialism. The sun represents materialism. The previous point is that materialism is sun, because if you go a little deeper, there’s a difference between the sun and the moon. What’s the difference between the sun and the moon? The sun is always strong. The sun is always whole. The moon has ups and downs. The sun represents full materialism because materialism is something called nature. Nature is something that’s basically, in a certain sense, very automatic. It’s a system. The idea of going into the Sukkah is that you’re going into the shade of Hashem and getting out of nature. That’s what you see in the sun. That’s the story as well: going into the shade of Hashem, you’re getting out of nature. You’re getting out of materialism. Through sense. That’s the overall idea and the deeper idea of the Sukkah. That’s the previous point.
One last point on this embrace of Hashem, this idea of shade, this idea of getting out of nature: we know that when it comes to income specifically, it can be all over the place. People have ups and downs, good times and bad times. That’s how income works. Part of the idea of going into the shade of Hashem, outside of the sun, is saying this: “I recognize that the sun always beats down the same, which means I want to have it always the same. But I’m in Hashem’s embrace,” which also means I have ups and downs. “I don’t have that same steady, always-the-same income, but I’m good with that.” Because that’s Hashem’s embrace. That’s another thing the Sukkah tells us. Do you follow that point?
That means if you’re in Hashem’s hands, you’re outside of the automatic, natural system of nature. Nature is more automatic, but it’s also not so much colors. Whereas I’m going into Hashem’s embrace when I go into the Sukkah. It’s more a sense of the fact that it may not be as steady, beating down like the sun, but it’s Hashem’s embrace. That’s the final point with this idea of the shade: when you’re in Hashem’s hands, it’s not an automatic system. It’s not always the same every day, but it’s Hashem’s system. That’s better. That’s another thing about the Sukkah.
Let’s pull out these different points. I hope we got that. The opening point was that the idea of a Sukkah being more shade than sun is a way of saying, “I’m going out of the mindset of nature, of automatic materialism. I’m going into Hashem’s hands.” That’s Hashem blocking out the sun. That’s point number one.
All right. The second point is that the Gemara told us a story about the Sukkah, and this rabbi had a side story: through the Sukkah metaphor, he was being told to stick to his role until, in his mind, there was too much materialism. Then the story changed. Aside from that, stick to his role. The final point is that our idea of being in the Sukkah, of being under the shade, is an idea of being in Hashem’s embrace. Even if that means you’re not going to have the same automatic system, everyone says to themselves, people say all the time, “I wish my business were always the same. I wish I could go to sleep and wake up in the morning and it would always be the same.” We all wish that, because you have a certain steadiness, a certain automatic element, an element that gives you calm.
When you go into Hashem’s embrace, called the shade, which is the Sukkah, what you’re saying is, “You’re not going to have, you’re not going to have, you’re not going to have. I know it’s up and down. I know it’s not like the sun, which is steady, but it’s also God’s, and that’s fine with me.” That means there’s a certain level of nervousness and worry that we all have, because income is always up and down. But you recognize that it may not be as steady as the sun, as automatic as the sun, but it’s far greater because it’s Hashem’s embrace.
Our final point is that the Sukkah is literally going into Hashem’s home as it is. When you’re in Hashem’s home, as we said, it may not be as steady, but it’s far greater because you’re in a much more comfortable, guaranteed mindset.
The final point is this: the Sukkah may not seem as guaranteed. The income from Hashem may not seem as guaranteed in our eyes, but it is guaranteed because of who it’s coming from. The Sukkah itself is in Hashem’s embrace. Its source is the greatest source, so it gives you a degree of calm. “Are you calm in business, Joe? Typically, are you calm in business?” “No.” “Why are you not calm?” “Because I’m a nervous wreck.” “Why are you nervous?” You break it down: “I don’t know what’s coming.” Right. The reason you’re always nervous is because you don’t know what’s coming. We don’t know what tomorrow is going to bring. We all wish for this sun mentality. Every one of us, no matter who we are, wishes for this sun. Somehow, for some reason, it never happens. Why is that the case? Why do you think we never get that steadiness, that steadiness and, sort of, calm?
“By God telling us, ‘You’re good. Don’t worry about the next year. You’re good.’” I mean, the steadiness is actually a negative, because when you go backwards, you go forward much stronger, right? The steadiness has two negative elements to it. One: when it comes to your belief in Hashem, it’s harder to fully believe in Hashem when you are resting, settled, and perfectly fine. It’s harder because it’s always, you know, “I feel good, I’m calm.” You don’t think of Hashem as much. When you have a degree of worry, you think of Hashem more.
Secondly, Tamar is this point: your development comes from that level of insecurity, from that degree of—maybe not worry, but that degree of being on your toes, right? “Every—you guys—it’s the only thing that you can rely on is change.” And if you can rely on change, that’s all you can do. You don’t know what’s coming, like they both said. So therefore, you have to rely on it to help, right, to guide you through. “Right. But relying on change is a very scary thing,” is your point. “Yeah.” So when you go into “I don’t want to change,” that’s literally how it works.
We are all, no matter who we are, in a state of flux in any business we’re in. No matter how it works, everyone is in a state of flux, and it’s by far the most frustrating thing. You say to yourself, “I just wish”—you see these guys who are government workers. Exactly. They have this steady income. It might be small, but it’s steady. It’s guaranteed. It’s always the same. You say to yourself, “Why do we have to be in the most volatile, up-and-down mindset business?” But the reality is that being in this volatile mindset makes you stronger as a person. It makes you a better businessman for sure, because you’re always on your toes, coming up with new ideas. And it develops your real belief in Hashem, because over time you start to realize it works out. “I have no idea what two weeks from now is going to bring, but it works out, and it works out, and it works out.” That gives you a far greater connection to God.
So the Sukkah literally represents that. It’s not the sun. It’s not steady nature. It’s not automatic. The sun is automatic. We actually go into a Sukkah. We block out the sun because we’re happier being in the shade. We’re more comfortable being in the unsettled waters of God’s waters than we are in settled waters outside of God. That’s literally how it works. And that’s the Pasuk (verse). The sun is nature. We like to be in the shade under the sun, not in the sun. That’s the idea of the Sukkah. You’re going into Hashem’s house, into Hashem’s embrace, and into Hashem’s sense and comfort. The volatile but comfortable world that we live in is what the Sukkah represents.