A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Moshe Haber

Torah Lecture

The Sukkah: Embrace, Shade, and Spirituality

Lectured by Rabbi Moshe Haber

Published
October 13, 2025
Duration
19:20
Lecture code
rmh-holy-07

The Sukkah’s spiritual character

  • Rabbi Moshe Haber describes the Sukkah as an exceptionally spiritual place, perhaps the most spiritual place on earth. The Zohar’s idea of Ushpizin—welcoming a different guest on each of the seven days, including Abraham, Yitzhak, and Yaakov—expresses this spiritual character.
  • The Sukkah is called Tzila d'Meheimnuta, “the shade of Hashem.” Rabbi Moshe Haber says that even apart from any special designation for service, a Sukkah is holy simply by virtue of being a Sukkah. One should therefore avoid inappropriate conversation inside it.
  • He also relates the Sukkah’s structure—two walls and a drop—to an embrace: the walls and partial wall suggest being held in Hashem’s embrace.

Shade, nature, and Hashem’s protection

  • Halakha requires the Schach to provide more shade than sunlight, while still allowing some sun to enter and not leaving major gaps. Rabbi Moshe Haber presents this requirement as both a literal law and a deeper idea: a person should be more in Hashem’s shade than under the sun.
  • In his explanation, the sun represents nature and material concerns, including income; shade represents placing oneself in Hashem’s hands. Entering the Sukkah therefore symbolizes moving away from reliance on nature’s automatic systems and toward Hashem.

The Gemara about the sheet

  • Rabbi Moshe Haber introduces a Gemara with Tanu Rabbanan and Ma'aseh. A rabbi sitting in another person’s Sukkah asks whether he may put a sheet over it because the sun is shining in; Rabbi Moshe Haber says that putting a sheet over the Sukkah on Shabbat is permitted.
  • The Gemara’s answers seem unrelated to the question: the first rabbi responds that no tribe of the Jewish people ever lacked a judge. As the sun grows stronger and the question is asked again, the answer is that no tribe ever lacked a prophet. When the sun becomes especially intense, the man stops asking and covers the Sukkah himself.
  • Rabbi Moshe Haber says that the exchange sounds baffling if understood only as a question about the sun and a sheet. He offers a figurative reading: the wealthy rabbi was asking whether he should reduce his involvement in business and devote more time to Torah learning.
  • On this reading, the answer about every tribe having a judge means that people have different roles and leaders, and he should not abandon the role suited to him. The answer about every tribe having a prophet similarly means that Hashem placed him in a particular situation: he should continue his business while also learning Torah.
  • As the “sun” grows stronger in the story, Rabbi Moshe Haber reads this as the man becoming increasingly wealthy and feeling increasingly drawn toward materialism. When it becomes extreme, the rabbi covers the Sukkah himself. He may have decided on his own that he had enough wealth and should step back from business; Rabbi Moshe Haber notes that the Gemara’s account leaves open whether he was told to do so or made the decision himself.
  • Rabbi Moshe Haber draws a lesson from the story: someone in a distinctive situation, such as a wealthy rabbi with both business responsibilities and the ability to learn, should not assume that he must give everything up and change roles. He should accept the role Hashem gave him; only when the situation becomes extreme might a change be warranted.

The Sukkah, fluctuating income, and trust

  • Rabbi Moshe Haber returns to the sun-and-shade metaphor. The sun is steady and whole, while the moon has ups and downs; similarly, nature and material income can seem automatic and consistent, whereas life under Hashem’s care may be less predictable.
  • Income often rises and falls. Being in the Sukkah’s shade means accepting that one’s income may not be as steady as the sun, while recognizing that one is in Hashem’s embrace.
  • People often wish for business or income to remain constant because predictability brings calm. In a discussion about why people are not given that steadiness, the idea of Hashem reassuring a person not to worry about the coming year is raised. Rabbi Moshe Haber then points to two drawbacks of complete steadiness: when someone feels settled and secure, it can be harder to think about Hashem; and a degree of uncertainty can contribute to personal development.
  • Tamar’s point, as Rabbi Moshe Haber presents it, is that insecurity can keep a person alert and developing. The discussion acknowledges that relying on change is frightening, but Rabbi Moshe Haber says that people in every kind of business face fluctuations.
  • He contrasts volatile business with government work, which may provide a smaller but steadier income. Although volatility is frustrating, he says it can make a person stronger and a better businessperson by keeping them alert and prompting new ideas. Repeatedly seeing things work out despite not knowing what the next two weeks will bring can also deepen one’s belief in Hashem.
  • The Sukkah therefore represents choosing Hashem’s embrace over the apparent steadiness of nature. Its income may not seem guaranteed from a human perspective, Rabbi Moshe Haber says, but its source is Hashem, which can bring a person calm.
  • He concludes that the Sukkah is like entering Hashem’s home: it represents a world that may be volatile and less predictable than nature, yet is more comforting because it is in Hashem’s hands.
Words in this lecture2
Gemaraגמרא
Terms Gemara, the Talmud's discussion of the Mishnah. English: Commentary on the Mishnah
Also written: Gemarah, G'mara, Guemara, gmara
Plural: gemarot, gemaras
Pasukפסוק
Terms Pasuk, a verse. English: Biblical verse
Also written: Passuk, posuk, psuq
Plural: Pesukim, psukim, p'sukim, psuqim, Pesukei, psukeem