A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Nathan Cohen

Torah Lecture

Messilat Yesharim # 15 Part 1 "Soul CAN Love This World"

Lectured by Rabbi Nathan Cohen

Published
May 20, 2021
Duration
13:01
Lecture code
RNC-MY-15

The Princess and the Villager: The First Reading

  • Rabbi Nathan Cohen revisits the Midrash’s mashal of the Bat Melech, a princess who marries a villager. He gives her everything he can afford, yet she cries alone at night because she is accustomed to the palace and its abundance; what he can provide seems like nothing by comparison.
  • The neshama likewise comes from the Elyonim, from the Kisei HaKavod, seven worlds above ours. On the first reading of Mesillat Yesharim, the neshama does not enjoy this world.
  • Rabbi Nathan Cohen explains that Hashem would not create a neshama so holy that it is naturally disgusted by this world without purpose. Man is created for Olam Haba: the neshama is given to help a person do good in this world, fight nisyonot and ta’avot, and perform mitzvot, so that he can receive reward in the time to come.
  • On this first reading, the point is that the neshama should not be disgusted by this world, but should enjoy what is in the next world.
  • Rabbi Nathan Cohen questions the implication of this approach: if the body is the villager and the neshama is the princess, does that mean the neshama is miserable throughout our 120 years? Even ordinary pleasures, such as eating steak or going swimming, would seem to leave it unhappy. He asks whether there is another way to understand the text.

A Different Girsa: The Neshama Can Enjoy This World

  • Rabbi Nathan Cohen says he found a different girsa in an ArtScroll edition of Mesillat Yesharim. According to this reading, the aim is for the neshama not to be miserable, but to be loved and able to enjoy this world.
  • He asks how the neshama could enjoy this world, given that the guf is physical and the neshama is spiritual. His answer is that a person can use the physical world to serve the neshama: the guf can learn to meet the neshama’s needs, become settled, and allow it to do its work.
  • When material things are used to elevate a person, the guf can recognize their purpose and cooperate. The neshama can then welcome the materialism because it enables spiritual activity.

Naso, the Nazir, and the Wonder of Body and Soul

  • Rabbi Nathan Cohen connects this idea to parasha Naso and the Nazir. For 30 days, the Nazir refrains from eating, drinking wine, and getting a haircut.
  • The Pasuk calls the Nazir a pele, a wonder. Ibn Ezra explains that he is a wonder because most people follow their desires, while the Nazir goes the other way; he is called a pele mahmat Nizro because he became a Nazir.
  • Rabbi Nathan Cohen also refers to Asher Yatzar, where Hashem describes the body as a pele. He cites the Shulchan Aruch’s explanation of the wonder: two opposites—the neshama and the guf—are brought together and live together.
  • A person’s task is a constant struggle between the neshama, which wants spirituality, and the guf, which wants physicality. The task is to bring them together by getting the guf to want to support the neshama’s needs.

Using the Guf to Support Spirituality

  • When the guf is used for the neshama, materialism can become a means of spiritual elevation. The guf can then accept the neshama’s work rather than resist it.
  • Rabbi Nathan Cohen illustrates this with a story about the Chafetz Chaim, who was on his way to his grandson’s funeral. On the way, he checked his watch and said they had to return home because it was lunchtime. He went home to eat and then returned to the funeral.
  • When people questioned why he was thinking about lunch on the way to the funeral, the Chafetz Chaim explained that a funeral is a spiritual time for reflection: to consider why we are in this world and to think about the person who passed away.
  • Rabbi Nathan Cohen contrasts this with people who may text or think about food, business, or other matters during a funeral. The Chafetz Chaim wanted to be fully focused spiritually, and he needed his guf to cooperate.
  • Rabbi Nathan Cohen returns to the princess and villager mashal: the princess is not necessarily rejecting the villager; she is unhappy because what he offers is beneath what she is accustomed to. If he could bring her something from the palace, such as her old clothes or another thing from there, she could be happy with it and with him.
  • Similarly, when a person gets the guf to want to learn Torah, do mitzvot, and do chesed, and uses materialism to do what is right, the material itself is elevated and made holy. The neshama can then enjoy this world, because the physical is being used as a springboard for spirituality. According to the alternate reading, adaraba: the neshama can be made to enjoy this world.

Food and a House as Examples

  • Hashem could have provided only a capsule to keep people alive. Instead, He gives people many foods and tastes. Rabbi Nathan Cohen says to enjoy the food while making a Beracha and eating for a purpose: to gain energy to learn Torah and do mitzvot. Then the guf enjoys the food, and the neshama can enjoy its spiritual use.
  • The same principle applies to a house. Rabbi Nathan Cohen compares Hashem’s giving people homes to a father who gives his son a million dollars to buy a house while the father himself lives on a bench on Ocean Parkway.
  • In the analogy, Hashem gives people the opportunity to enjoy this world, though Hashem does not have the Beit HaMikdash. The instruction is to enjoy the house and use it for good things. In this way, adaraba, the neshama can love this world.