A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Netanel Meoded

Torah Lecture

Moses, the soul of the Torah, yearned to enter Israel like a bird—why?

Lectured by Rabbi Netanel Meoded

Published
July 26, 2023
Duration
12:24
Lecture code
RNM-P-53

Repairing Baseless Hatred Through Love and Favorable Judgment

  • After the Nine Days and the fast of Tisha B’Av, Rabbi Netanel Meoded says the first repair needed for the rebuilding of the Temple and Jerusalem is baseless hatred.
  • He shares an idea about reaching baseless love and judging every person favorably: when a Jew’s tefillin fall, he bends down, lifts them, and kisses them.
  • The passages in God’s tefillin say, “Who is like Your people Israel, one nation on earth.” Accordingly, when a Jew sees another Jew fall—sometimes spiritually—he should not laugh or harm him, but should lift him up and “kiss” him, as he would tefillin.
  • A person is made in the image of God, so if we lift and kiss tefillin written by human hands, all the more should we lift and kiss a Jew who has fallen. Seeing every Jew as, in a sense, God’s tefillin makes it easier to love and help each Jew.
  • Rabbi Netanel Meoded asks why Abraham was chosen from all generations to bring God’s light into the world. The Midrash explains this through the words, “You loved righteousness”—vindicating God’s creatures—and “hated wickedness”—finding them guilty in judgment. “Therefore God, your God, anointed you with the oil of joy above your companions.”
  • Abraham’s love for so many nations helped make him known throughout the world. The lesson to take from the Three Weeks, the Nine Days, and Tisha B’Av is not merely to repeat the observance next year, but to follow Abraham’s example of vindicating others. As with tefillin, when a Jew falls, we should lift him up and kiss him.

Moses’ Yearning to Enter the Land of Israel

  • In Parashat Va’etchanan, Moses pleads repeatedly with God to let him enter the Land of Israel. God tells him, “You will see the land from a distance, but you will not enter there.”
  • Maran Ben Ish Chai, in Od Yosef Chai, raises several questions:
  • If “from a distance,” as Rashi explains, already means that Moses would not enter the land, why does the verse add, “but you will not enter there”?
  • Why did Moses pray so persistently, as though he did not want to leave this world, when he knew that everyone must die and no one could save him?
  • When his prayers, tears, supplications, and merits—including his pleas on behalf of the Jewish people—did not help, why did Moses ask to enter the land as a wild animal or a bird, as the Midrash says? Why would the master of the prophets want to enter in that form?
  • Maran Ben Ish Chai explains that Moses did not want to live as a bird or animal for its own sake. His soul and prophetic level were so exalted that, after leaving this world, he would be in such high spiritual worlds that he would have no connection to the Jewish people.
  • Because of his great love and self-sacrifice for the Jewish people, Moses wanted to remain connected to this world—even as a bird or wild animal—so he could continue to pray and plead on their behalf. He sought this connection for the people, not for himself.

Moses, Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, and the Torah of the Land of Israel

  • Maran Ben Ish Chai brings the Zohar’s account of Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai saying that he saw things no person had seen since Moses departed from the world. Rabbi Shimon says that Moses did not know that the skin of his face shone, whereas he himself knew.
  • Maran Ben Ish Chai asks how Rabbi Shimon could say this without implying that he was greater than Moses. He explains that it was a spark of Moses’ soul, reincarnated in Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai’s soul, that knew.
  • In Maran Ben Ish Chai’s explanation, Moses did not know while he was outside the Land of Israel. Through the spark of his soul in Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, he merited the Torah of the Land of Israel and greater things. Maran Ben Ish Chai says that he can explain this much, but beyond this he has no permission to speak, because it is one of the mysteries of the world.
  • Maran Ben Ish Chai also explains “You will see the land from a distance, but you will not enter there” through a wordplay: “there” can be rearranged to spell “Moses.” Moses, in the form of his name, would not merit to enter the land; in the future, a spark of his soul would enter through Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai and study the Torah of the Land of Israel.
  • Rabbi Netanel Meoded connects this explanation to the great and growing crowds at Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai’s hilula. Moses’ soul was a collective soul of the Jewish people, he says, which helps explain why people feel drawn there. He also explains that this hilula differs from those for other righteous people because it celebrates Moses’ merit in learning Torah through Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai—the Torah of the Land of Israel.

Moses as “the Soul of the Torah”

  • Rabbi Netanel Meoded concludes that the Zohar calls Moses “the soul of the Torah,” and connects this distinction to Moses’ self-sacrifice and the breadth of his prayers.
  • He contrasts Noah, Abraham, and Moses: when God told Noah He would bring a flood, Noah did not pray; Abraham prayed, but only for the righteous. Moses prayed not only for the righteous but also for the wicked.
  • Rabbi Netanel Meoded says that one reason Moses was buried outside the Land of Israel was so that he could bring the generation of the wilderness with him. Moses’ burial would help bring that generation, which was not made up of righteous people, to its resting place, to the Land of Israel, and to the Torah of Israel.
  • This care for the whole people, including the wicked, is why Moses merited to be called “the soul of the Torah.” The concluding hope is that people will see every Jew as God’s tefillin and that the complete redemption will come speedily.