Miriam and Aaron’s Challenge to Moses
- Rabbi Netanel Meoded begins with Beha’alotcha’s account of Miriam and Aaron speaking against Moses over the Cushite woman he had married. They ask whether the Lord has spoken only through Moses, and note that He has spoken through them as well.
- The Torah says that the Lord heard them and that Moses was exceedingly humble, more than anyone on earth.
What Humility Means
- The Gemara in Tractate Nedarim, page 38, teaches that the Holy One, blessed be He, rests His Divine Presence only upon someone who is wise, mighty, wealthy, and humble.
- The need for humility is understandable: Torah is compared to water, and the Jerusalem Talmud says, “What wisdom made its crown, humility made its sandal”—the highest level of wisdom is the lowest level of humility.
- Rabbi Netanel Meoded asks why being mighty or wealthy should be among the qualities associated with receiving the Divine Presence.
The Chatam Sofer’s Lesson
- A student once asked the Chatam Sofer to teach him the path of humility. The Chatam Sofer said he was busy and told the student to sit in the court until he was free.
- When a couple came with a matter concerning marital harmony, the Chatam Sofer sent them to the student. The student protested that he was young, inexperienced, and unable to help them.
- About half an hour later, wealthy men brought a major business dispute for a monetary ruling. The Chatam Sofer again sent them to the student, who said he did not know monetary law and could not rule on the matter.
- Two hours later, a woman brought a chicken to determine whether it was kosher. The Chatam Sofer asked the student to examine it, but the student said he was not sufficiently knowledgeable to tell what was kosher.
- After these three cases, the Chatam Sofer asked how the student could want to be taught humility when he did not know how to handle marital harmony, a business dispute, or a chicken’s kosher status—and asked what he had to be proud of.
- The Chatam Sofer explained that the Holy One, blessed be He, gave the Torah on Mount Sinai to teach humility. Since Sinai was not a very high mountain and the Torah could have been given on a plain, he asked why that mountain was chosen. He answered that humility is a virtue when someone is as high as a mountain yet behaves humbly.
- The Chatam Sofer once heard of someone behaving with what he considered excessive humility and told him, “You’re not great enough to make yourself so humble.”
Wealth, Greatness, and Moses’ Humility
- Rabbi Netanel Meoded explains that wealth itself is not a virtue that causes the Divine Presence to rest upon someone. Rather, a person who is wealthy, wise, and mighty yet remains humble embodies true humility.
- Humility is not simply having nothing and therefore nothing to be proud of; it is remaining humble despite having great qualities and accomplishments.
- This is the meaning of the Gemara’s list of a person who is wise, mighty, wealthy, and humble.
- Moses attained extraordinary levels—the Torah says, “You have made him little less than God”—yet remained humble. That, Rabbi Netanel Meoded says, is true humility.

