A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Rachamim Aboud

Torah Lecture

Siman 336, Seif 1, Laws of Shabbat: Using Trees and Attached Objects

Lectured by Rabbi Rachamim Aboud

Published
February 8, 2026
Duration
22:11
Lecture code
RRA-54

Prohibition of Climbing Trees and Using Attached Objects

  • Siman 336, Seif 1 prohibits climbing a tree whether it is moist or dry. Even a completely dried-out tree with no leaves, branches, or fruit may not be climbed; the decree applies to all trees, without distinguishing among them.
  • One may not use anything attached to the ground, as a safeguard against plucking leaves, branches, or fruit. Plucking intentionally is a Torah prohibition; if done inadvertently, one is liable to bring a sin-offering.

Climbing a Tree on Shabbat

  • If someone climbed a tree inadvertently, he may come down, even though descending involves using the tree. He might pluck something while coming down, but he does not intend to do so.
  • If he climbed intentionally, he may not come down until after Shabbat; this is a penalty. The lecture notes two opinions about whether he may come down once Shabbat is over.
  • Rabbi Shlomo Zalman Auerbach wanted to come down and jumped down. Climbing down would involve using the tree, whereas jumping without using it is different.

Climbing Before Shabbat

  • If someone climbed the tree before Shabbat, the first opinion permits him to come down once it is dark, even if he intended to remain there until then. The penalty applies only when the prohibited act—climbing—was done while it was forbidden; he climbed while it was still permitted.
  • The second opinion permits him to come down only if he had intended to do so before dark. If he had intended to remain there, he may not come down once it is dark. The lecture describes this as a severe penalty.
  • The halachah follows the first opinion: one who climbed before Shabbat may come down on Shabbat.

Objects Placed on Trees

  • The rule for someone who climbed a tree does not apply in the same way to an object placed on it before Shabbat: he may not take the object down on Shabbat, because doing so involves using the tree.
  • There is no prohibition in an object merely resting on something attached to the ground; the concern is taking it down. Even so, one may not place an object on a tree before Shabbat with the intention of using it on Shabbat.
  • “Using” an attached object includes leaning on a tree, placing an object on it or removing one, and tying an animal to it.

Leaning on Trees and the Three-Handbreadth Measure

  • The prohibition against leaning on a tree applies to any tree, not only a fruit tree. The lecture cites, “Your rod and Your staff, they comfort me,” and distinguishes a dead tree, which one may lean on.
  • The decree applies to a tree more than three handbreadths above the ground. If it is within three handbreadths, one may place something there.
  • The decree also applies to a small tree or other small object that has reached the minimum size for use. This is a decree, not a penalty.

Treehouses and a Tallit Caught in a Tree

  • Climbing a tree to enter a treehouse is forbidden because it involves using the tree. Using a ladder does not change the ruling if doing so involves the tree.
  • The Shevet HaLevi writes that a tallit caught in a tree may be removed when there is no concern that the person will climb the tree—for example, if the tree is no more than three handbreadths high. Since the tallit became caught against its owner’s wishes, and can be removed easily, removing it is not considered using the tree; there is also no concern that the person will climb the tree.

Reeds and Similar Plants

  • Soft reeds that never become hard and remain like vegetables may be used while attached to the ground. The decree does not apply to them, even when they grow taller than three handbreadths.
  • Many authorities say that reeds can eventually become hard. If they do, they are included in the prohibition; the exception applies only to reeds and similar plants that never harden.