Marks, designs, and attaching letters
- Rabbi Rachamim Aboud explains that making marks or shapes on a wall is not writing letters, but is a derivative of writing, like the marks made by painters, and is liable as writing.
- If someone makes a design on a vessel to enhance it, even completing only part of the design can make him liable for striking the final blow, since he has completed the vessel’s work. Erasing a mark to improve it is similarly a derivative of erasing and is liable.
- Attaching silver letters to a parochet or something similar is forbidden; letters intended for use should be magnetic. Rabbi Rachamim Aboud asks whether making a magnetic Sefirat HaOmer display with a person’s name would make one liable for writing, and says he does not know. Although it is akin to writing, the letters already exist and are only being placed; nevertheless, placing them in a way that also involves erasing is forbidden.
- The Chayei Adam discusses these matters in Klal 37, including erasing and drawing lines. Drawing a line can mean making a guide for writing.
Erasing writing and lines
- One who erases writing or a line in order to write two letters in its place is liable. This applies even if the erased writing was a single large letter, provided there is room for two letters where it was erased.
- In this respect, erasing is more severe than writing: erasing one letter where two could be written is more serious than writing one large letter.
- Erasing to improve something is liable even without an intention to write in that place. For example, erasing even one extra letter from a Torah scroll is liable because it corrects the text.
Handedness and performing a labor in an unusual way
- The Chayei Adam says that, for all the labors except writing, liability applies whether a person uses the right or left hand; erasing appears to be included. Writing is different: liability applies only when a person writes with the hand he normally uses for writing.
- Rabbi Rachamim Aboud mentions people who can write with both hands and the report that Rav Chaim Ozer could write two letters at the same time, though he is unsure whether they were literally simultaneous. The practice was considered useful because writing the Divine Name slowly can pose a problem by writing only part of the Name; writing it all at once would be preferable.
- The Chayei Adam cites the Tosefta in Perek 10: performing a labor with one’s foot or mouth exempts one from liability, but the act remains forbidden.
Drawing lines
- Drawing a line on paper or parchment is liable, especially in the context of a Torah scroll. Erasing a line in order to write two letters beneath it is also liable.
- Drawing a guide before cutting leather or other material is included in drawing lines and is liable. The same applies when carpenters snap a chalk line on a beam to saw it straight, or when stonecutters mark stones so they will split evenly.
- Rabbi Rachamim Aboud explains that drawing a line includes making guides like the lines in a Torah scroll, which keep the letters straight. It is liable whether the line is made with paint or without paint; using paint does not make the act a case of dyeing.
Torah prohibitions and asking a non-Jew
- Rabbi Rachamim Aboud says he has discussed these details to distinguish Torah prohibitions from acts that are exempt but still rabbinically forbidden.
- The distinction matters when considering whether to ask a non-Jew to perform an act for the sake of a mitzvah. According to the ruling in Siman 307, a Torah prohibition may not be permitted through a non-Jew even for a mitzvah. The view of the Ba’al HaItur is used together with other considerations, especially for a great mitzvah or a mitzvah of the community; however, one may not ask a non-Jew to perform a Torah prohibition.
Pinchas and his reward
- Rabbi Rachamim Aboud turns to Pinchas, who acted zealously for ה׳. The verse says that he was zealous for ה׳ among the people and that ה׳ did not destroy the Children of Israel in His zeal. Pinchas both acted for ה׳ and helped prevent כלל ישראל from being destroyed in the plague.
- In the Gemara’s discussion of a “righteous person who is good,” the distinction is that such a person is good toward Heaven and toward people. Pinchas was righteous toward ה׳ and also good toward the people: he acted for ה׳ and atoned for the Children of Israel. The Midrash therefore says, “It is fitting that he receive his reward.”
- He received “My covenant of peace.” One explanation is that he lived a very long time: some say Pinchas was Eliyahu and did not die; another explanation is that he lived for 400 years. Another explanation is that his descendants received eternal priesthood. Pinchas had not been a kohen until then, since he was a grandson, but after this event he became one. The commentators say that most kohanim came from Pinchas, including the Kohanim Gedolim.
- Rabbi Rachamim Aboud asks why the verse says Pinchas should receive his reward. He explains that Pinchas performed a mitzvah that ה׳ had to do; when someone does such a mitzvah, ה׳ gives the reward even in this world. That is the meaning of “It is fitting that he receive his reward.”
The Children of Israel before entering the Land
- The nations of the world said, “Perhaps ה׳ does not really love them.” Rabbi Rachamim Aboud notes that ה׳ addressed this at the end of the forty years, just before the Children of Israel entered the Land of Israel.
- He gives two points: despite the Golden Calf and the spies, the Children of Israel would not be mixed in with the other nations; and, now that they had not joined Moav and had gone through what they had, ה׳ wanted to show that they were distinct. Also, as they were about to enter the Land and receive their inheritance, the inheritance had to be properly assigned.
The almond branch and the haftarah
- The week’s haftarah begins, “The words of Yirmiyahu,” and includes the vision, “I see a branch of an almond tree.” The Yerushalmi’s first explanation is that the almond branch signifies that punishment will come quickly.
- Yirmiyahu is then shown the destruction of the Beit HaMikdash and the exile. The almond branch signals that the calamity will come quickly, but redemption will also come.
- The staff of Aharon also blossomed with almonds; there, too, the almonds signified that punishment would come quickly.
- Rabbi Rachamim Aboud says that Tisha B’Av will become a day of closeness to ה׳, as those days were.
Mourning, the festivals, and redemption
- Mourning over the destruction differs from ordinary mourning: ordinarily, after twelve months a mourner forgets, but what is still alive is never forgotten. Yaakov Avinu did not forget Yosef during the twenty-two years Yosef was away. Likewise, the Beit HaMikdash is mourned year after year because it is still alive and redemption is yet to come.
- Parashat Pinchas lists Pesach, Shavuot, and Sukkot as times when people draw close to ה׳ and come together with the Shechinah. Similarly, the twenty-one days of mourning are days for returning in teshuvah and drawing close to ה׳.
- The verse says, “Even when he is in distress, I am with him.” People can show ה׳ that they want Him; then redemption will come and ה׳ will draw close to them.

