
Torah Lecture
Who Is the Ikar and Who Is the Tafel—the Food or the Intention?
Lectured by Rabbi Rachamim Aboud
This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.
The horse was the one leading the people. Usually, people lead the horse, but in this case, the horse was leading the people. The horse was making the person ride on him. So, what are you doing, horse? Come on, go this way. He wasn't listening. So it says, "You're going to lead me." I'm with the horse, and we're going to lead the people. So it means it's up to us. It's up to us. It's up to us. It's up to us. It's up to us. It's up to us. It's up to us. It's up to us. It's up to us. It's up to us. It's up to us. It's up to us. It's up to us. It's up to us. It's up to us. It's up to us. It's up to us. It's up to us. It's up to us. It's up to us. It's up to us. It's up to us.
Eating crackers, you wanted to take away the sharpness, but if you continue eating, that means you want to eat the crackers too, so it's definitely not the main item. So that's the rule: only if you're not interested in the side item. Once you want both, you have to make a blessing on both. If the side item is mezonot, you have to make a blessing on that first before the whiskey.
We cut through the sharpness to stay away from it. You want to take it only to take away the sharpness, but you're also taking it because you want to have some mezonot. If it's bread, you have to wash with a lot of time. You're feeling like now she's putting bread into whiskey, and you're only doing it in order to help with digestion. You're not doing it for a meal; you're only doing it to digest the food.
Yes, but not the bread. So he said hamotzi at the beginning of the meal, and now after he's finished, they're dipping some bread into the scotch. I see, wow, it's only for digestion, so he should say shehakol on the scotch even though he's dipping bread in it and putting soaked bread in his mouth. Wow, the main thing is the main thing. Why should you make a blessing on it? It should be part of the meal. Because you're not doing it for the meal; you're doing it for a different purpose. See? It's not part of the meal now. You need a blessing for the drink.
I see. You make a blessing on the whiskey before you have the bread. Then it's the other way. You're only taking whiskey as a side item. I got it. Because of all the fatty foods he ate, he wants to take that away. Fact. I got you. So that's a side item, and there's no need to make a blessing.
Okay, so let's continue with the halacha. Back to the top. The halacha says, "The one who eats makes a blessing on the main item." This time we make a blessing on the main item and exempt the side item. This is only if you're eating them together or if you eat the main item first. However, if you eat the side item first, like if you want to drink and want to eat first, the only reason for eating is so you don't drink on an empty stomach, so you take a little bit of something.
Or you take some seeds of cherries or something sweet to enhance the drink. So over here, really the main thing is the drink, not the food. But you're taking the food first. You make a blessing on the food first even though it's a side item to the drink. Because you're eating it first. Right. And you don't make a blessing on it; you only make it shehakol. That's a novelty. You're only making it shehakol. We've had this before. Yes. Since it's a side item, it lost its significance.
But it's original blessing, whether it's adama or eitz or anything else. That's the opinion of the Rama. Let's see the bottom. Number six on the bottom. When you eat them together, the main item and the side item, and if you're eating bread with cheese or anything else that you have on top of the bread, even though you like the cheese, and you want to eat them, you only make the blessing on the crackers alone.
The main item is the cracker, and you just want to smear it with butter or peanut butter or whatever. The same applies to anything else when you eat it with something to enhance the bread. The food you eat to enhance is considered only a side item, and you don't make a blessing on the side item. So anytime you eat a sandwich, you don't have to make a blessing on the item that's in it. Even if you have a bun with meat in it, if you have a delicacy, you like both, but you definitely need the bread.
Right. But it's to enhance the bread. So there you don't make a blessing only on the bread, not even if it's mezonot bread. Right, mezonot is also the same. Even if it's meat. Right, significant meat. That's to enhance the bread.
If you made it and afterward you eat a side item to take away the sharpness of the radish, okay? So you don't make a blessing on the olive; you only make a blessing on the radish. Now, the other way. However, if you eat the side item first, he gave you two cases. He's eating seeds before the main item. So he says you have to make a blessing shehakol on the seeds. Or you're eating something before you start drinking.
The whole idea is to sweeten it. If you eat the food first, it's fine to make a blessing on the main item. But if you eat the side item first, it wouldn't make sense to exempt the main item afterward. And you can't have enjoyment without a blessing. This would seem like you would need a blessing on the side item, but it's exempted. The blessing on the main item exempts the side item. But I'm eating the side item first. That's why if you're eating the side item first, you should say shehakol.
Now, what happens if I've seen a rabbi do it? He has coffee and wants sugar in his coffee. Instead of putting the sugar in the coffee, he puts it in his mouth, says shehakol on the sugar, and drinks the coffee on top of it. Now it's shehakol and shehakol. It would seem that that's not a problem, but he's really putting the side item in his mouth before he's putting the main item in his mouth, which is the coffee. How does that work?
I mean, I can't say a blessing on the side item and have it cover the main item. I mean, it's the same blessing. Anyway, it covers it. They both have the same blessing. I see. So now you're saying really if the drink was not coffee, if the drink was orange juice with a lot of pulp, which I would say ha'etz, then I would have to say shehakol on the sugar?
I'm drinking, I'm having sugar and I'm drinking... If you want both. I mean, the rule is if you really want both. So I have to say a blessing on each? Just the side item, yeah. Because I'm really putting the side item in my mouth first. Yeah. You need two blessings. Gotcha, okay.
So the Rama says when you eat the side item first, you have to make shehakol. Since you're only eating the side item for something else, you lose the blessing that it originally had. And you make a blessing shehakol so that you don't have enjoyment without a blessing. The Rama discusses this, and he doesn't mention any distinction, stating it applies in all cases.
However, the Magen Avraham argues on one aspect, saying specifically when drinking liquids that their blessing is shehakol. And he should make shehakol on the liquid to exempt the side item. How do you make the same blessing? This is my question. Is that the same question?
The blessing on the main item is a different matter. For example, if you're drinking wine, which is boreh peri ha-gefen, you make a blessing on the food that comes before the shehakol, just the blessing that is appropriate for it. Wow, what happened? How come it didn't lose its blessing? So what's the reasoning behind that? That it doesn't lose the blessing?
So it's a disagreement. What blessing you're making? The Rama says you're making it shehakol; you lose the blessing. The Magen Avraham says that if the blessings are different, then it doesn't lose it. No, then he's arguing 100% with the Rama, because if the blessing is the same, then you're done. Once you say the blessing shehakol on the side item, that also covers the main item, which has the same blessing.
Yeah, so it's a disagreement. That's what we do. He doesn't have knowledge. So it's a big mess. What blessing do you make? That's the question. The Magen Avraham, what else do you have to make? It's the same blessing. Yeah. He doesn't lose it. He doesn't lose it. The Magen Avraham loses it.
Okay, that's a wrap. We have one more. Do you want to do Yud'alaf? Or Yilva? Who is the side item? We want to make a side item on something else. We make a blessing on it, and it will be fine. That's two times. If the side item is significant, and if the side item is significant, this is only when you're eating it first.
And which the rabbi recommended never to do. Right. Don't be like that, but the significant item gives a reason. So then, you don't even want the main thing anyway. That's the case. You do want to. And you're eating the... No, you're taking whiskey only because of the whiskey.
Okay, so holding now a bet. Thank you. Thank you. Like the rabbi said, that's a wrap.
