Good morning. Torah Tuesday, our session on proper speech. Rosh Chodesh (new month) Shevat was the beginning of the second cycle in the Lesson a Day Chafetz Chaim study, as established by the great Rabbi Yehudah Segal in Manchester in the last century. If you began on Rosh Hashanah, you would have finished Erev (eve of) Rosh Chodesh Shevat and begun anew. Then you’ll be able to complete the Sefer again and start in time to complete it a third time on Erev Rosh Hashanah itself.
In the beginning, in the Petichah (opening), the Chafetz Chaim lists a lot of lavin, meaning negative commandments, and also introduces many positive commandments, which are violated in combination with regular Lashon Hara, improper speech. Today, which would be day 13, he says the Torah tells us that a minimum of two witnesses is needed in order to have testimony that’s valid in a court of law. A Jewish court requires two or three or more witnesses. And so now, if somebody has something to say as part of a testimony, if it’s not exaggerated, if it’s not out of animosity or other things, it’s probably not—even though it might be negative, and it might be harmful to the victim of the speech. However, if a person is speaking on their own, it can never add up to a testimony because you need two.
So now I come to court and say, “So-and-so did such-and-such a thing,” or “So-and-so behaved in such-and-such a way,” and it’s negative, and there’s no edut (testimony). How does that work? He says if somebody comes to a Bet Din, a rabbinical court, and only one person testifies in the Bet Din, the Bet Din would not be allowed to accept that testimony. It certainly would not be accepted as truth; it would not be accepted at all, because a case can be established based on two or three witnesses, but you can’t establish any fact based on one person. So the testimony would serve no constructive purpose because it can’t be used by the court of law. Instead, it would be considered: “I only came; I tried to help. I was telling the court...” No, no, no, no, no, no. If it’s not going to be upheld as a fact, if it’s not going to bring about any constructive purpose, the witness would, in addition, violate the injunction against having a single witness in a case. It says, “A single witness shall not stand up against any man for any wrongdoing,” and that’s in Sefer Devarim, Perek Yud-Tet (chapter 19). So one witness should not stand up. Now you did so; you violated that commandment as well.
Now the Chafetz Chaim goes further. He says when a person’s life in this world ends, the average person will come before what we call Bet Din Shel Ma’alah, the heavenly court, and that person will be accused or brought to account for all the Lashon Hara they spoke in their lifetime. I don’t know how they’re going to find time. The average person will have one simple defense: “I was a victim of circumstance. I had no interest in speaking Lashon Hara. It’s not like I robbed something that I wanted. It’s not like I ate something I couldn’t resist. I have no gain here, and I certainly didn’t want to speak Lashon Hara. But everybody was just talking. It was a dinner party. It was a wedding. It was shul (synagogue). People were standing around talking on the corner, waiting for the bus, or on the bus.” Well, guess what? The fact that everybody’s doing it is not a defense. This is not a way out of trouble. You can’t claim you were a victim of circumstance. You can’t say, “I had no real interest, but other people were doing it. What do you want from me? I really had no choice.” You did have a choice. In effect, he will say, “Society made me do it. The crowd I was with made me do it. The shul I pray in made me do it. The office I work in made me do it.” It’s not a defense.
In fact, rather than a defense, it may serve as a further indictment, because if you go to places where speaking Lashon Hara is popular, or to a place conducive to that type of behavior, what do you expect to happen? Your job is not to go there. Your job is not to choose that. Your position in life is, “I don’t do that.” You’ll never catch me sitting in a wrestling match. You’ll never catch me in a Broadway show. But if you go to a place and see or hear things you’re not supposed to see or hear, if that’s what they do in that place, what did you expect? What did you think was going to happen? The responsibility is on the person to anticipate in advance. “It’s not for me, Allah Shalom.” Like all kids, my siblings and I had one real way of dealing with our parents: “But Ma, everybody’s going.” “But Dad, everybody has one.” The comeback was a classic: “You’re probably right, but we don’t do that.” What an answer. You’re right. There are a lot of people doing things out there that we don’t do. Goyim (non-Jews) live their lives totally differently than we do. People in Scotland don’t live like people in Argentina. People in Argentina don’t live like people in Bombay. True. But if you move to Bombay, you can be sure some of Bombay will stick to you. So your job is, as we say, when you want to avoid trouble, don’t go there. Don’t go to a place where the behavior is not in keeping with Torah values.
So the Chafetz Chaim says, don’t say, “I couldn’t do anything.” You could—you can do it in advance. He warns us. He says there’s going to be an accounting. There’s going to be a Bet Din Shel Ma’alah. You’re going to be held accountable for every word that came out of your mouth. And if you go to a place where they speak Lashon Hara, you can’t say, “What did you want me to do? They were talking about it.” You went there. He teaches us to assess the situation before you get involved. See how the people are in regard to this specifically. How do they speak? In other places, you can say, “How do you want me not to look? They weren’t wearing anything. I mean, I don’t know how women dress that way.” Why’d you go there? Didn’t you know that at this type of function or this type of place, that’s how they’re going to be dressed? You went to a beach that had men and women, and you didn’t expect the women to be in bathing suits? Excuse me, what’d you expect them to wear, for a coat? So he says the same thing about speech. Speech is a matter of anticipation, anticipation. What could happen? If it’s something that you should not participate in, that you should not be a party to, don’t go there. Or, as my mother-in-law used to say, “We don’t do that.”

