A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Raymond Beyda

Torah Lecture

Torah Tuesday / Lashon Hara / Feb 13, 2024

Lectured by Rabbi Raymond Beyda

Published
February 13, 2024
Duration
14:10
Lecture code
C1468

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

The laws of proper speech. Yes, there are laws about how to speak. These are halachot (laws). It's like putting on tefillin (phylacteries) and not eating taref (not kosher). We have a brief, brief contact. I was reading the Chafetz Chaim one day last week, and he mentioned that a lot of people don't realize this is one of the mitzvot (commandments) of the Torah, so they treat it differently from other negative behaviors. Imagine if you saw a friend come out of a taref place, maybe unaware, holding, let's say, a frankfurter, or better known as a hot dog, and the hot dog wasn't kosher. So he comes out. It's not for [unclear reference] here, because you watch him, and he takes a bite, and he's chewing, like my friend Eli. He chews every week. So he comes and says, "Well, you know, that's taref," but he doesn't do anything about it. He lets the guy take another bite. When he's finished with the entire hot dog, he tells him, "You know, that place you came out of is taref." The guy goes, "What do you mean? I don't eat taref." It used to be kosher, but they lost the hashgachah (kosher certification), and now it's a goy (non-Jew) place, whatever it is. But why did you wait? You probably wouldn't. There's no way you would, says the Chafetz Chaim. You see it. You have to wait six hours? He sees it. He sees a friend, and the friend is doing an aveirah (transgression), like eating taref. He stops him immediately. The Chafetz Chaim says, "So how come when a person's speaking Lashon Hara (evil speech), you listen and let him finish? He's eating taref. Every word is an aveirah. Maybe more than one." And we learned in the beginning, in the introduction, that maybe it encompasses many other aveirot. So why are you sitting back and letting him finish? It's because most people don't feel it's an aveirah like taref. The Chafetz Chaim says it's worse than taref. Then he goes into a hagahah, a footnote that goes on for more than a page, telling us why it's worse.

Anyhow, it came into my mind as we came on today that these are halachot. Let's say you open up Sefer Chafetz Chaim to Kelal Bet, the second of the chapters. There's point nine and point ten. Let's say there's a group of people, and you've been in this situation. You've been part of this scene many times. They're starting to discuss party A: Mr. and Mrs., Miss, Miss, young man, young lady. Since they're getting into it, everybody becomes a psychoanalyst. Everybody knows. Everybody's an expert. This didn't just, by chance, encompass this person we're speaking about, or become the behavior pattern of this individual who's the subject of our conversation. We become armchair analysts: the background, the upbringing, the education. The Torah forbids us to include unsolicited analysis in our conversations.

Somebody's behaving in a negative way. Somebody habitually does things that don't meet our approval. Somebody is not observant. Worse, speaking about it, if it's true, is Lashon Hara. And unless we fulfill, as we've mentioned so many times, the seven requirements that make it to'elet, constructive negative speech, it's Lashon Hara. But you can go one step further. How about, why is the person this way? If you knew her mother, you'd know why she's this way. You would understand her better. Because she's the daughter of... Or you have... You deflected to the family. You deflected to somebody else. How about what we call a backhand? It's a great stroke in tennis. Not good in Lashon Hara. "Look how far this person has come. If the starting off life, A, B, C, D. Who would have imagined? They'd be at this point in life today." Even if a less than admirable past is pretty well known, you're not allowed to bring it up. You're not allowed to mention it. You're not allowed to make it the subject of your conversation. They've come a long way.

Sometimes it happens in a way that's totally destructive. Somebody calls about a shidduch (match), and they want to know about it. Is this person a candidate for matching up with their daughter or their sister? Or their brother? It could be the male, it could be the female. And the information is shared in a way: "If you knew his father, you wouldn't consider him stingy." "Stingy? His father wasn't good? Whoa, I have to look into this more." And before you know it, they hang up the phone. "Thank you." And the shidduch is off. You've just changed the life of a person with unnecessary and sometimes unjust comments.

There was a time when somebody called up because their daughter wanted to date someone who was divorced. So they asked the local rabbi, "Rabbi, I understand this person was divorced, and somebody told me that it was his doing that brought about the breakup of the first marriage. Why? He was abusive to his wife." The rabbi had heard something. It wasn't one of his cases. He wasn't involved. So he told the person, "I don't know. If you heard it, it might require investigation. But as far as asking me, do I know it? I don't know." Not too long after, in HaShamayim (Heaven), this rabbi—oh—and the guy told him, "Look into it, please." He said, "Okay, call me in about a week." The man said, "I'm in no rush. It's more important for me to be right than in a hurry." It's okay. He ran into the mother of the young man's ex-wife, and he happened to bring it up in conversation. He asked, "How's your daughter doing?" She said, "Yeah." He said, "Well, I heard she got a divorce." She said, "Yeah." He said, "Well, people are talking about the reason. Her husband seemed like a nice guy to me, but I understand he might have been abusive." And in a backhanded way, the mother says, "Well, you know, my daughter has a way sometimes of bringing that out in people." Thereby verifying the rumor somewhat.

Now, it's not true. Now, it's not firsthand. We got all the requirements. But somewhat, the rabbi now feels an obligation to tell the person. So he asked his rabbi. Rabbis have rabbis. His rabbi said, "You're not allowed to do that." Well, to make a long story short, the phone did ring about a week later. The person asked, "Rabbi, did you find out anything?" He said, "Actually, no, nothing with certainty," which was true. Then he said, "But I want to tell you something. Your daughter is a young girl. She's from a good family. There's nothing wrong with her physically. She does well overall with friendships, with school. She's 17, 18. What are you rushing for? If it was my daughter, I don't know if I'd get involved if there were rumors. I'm not desperate. It's not a 28-year-old. It's not somebody with one leg. It's a good catch. So I would do my homework. Well, maybe if it was me, I would pass."

He wanted to give the advice. How surprised was he when the man who acted like he trusted him so much called up to invite him to the engagement party? They got engaged. Baruch Hashem, I know the case. They got married. They had a good marriage. His second marriage is much better than the first. And they brought children and grandchildren to that person who took a chance. But the point of the story was that he didn't say no. He didn't say yes. He said, "Maybe do your homework. I don't know," because he wasn't allowed to relate negative information that might break up a shidduch.