A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Raymond Beyda

Torah Lecture

Torah Tuesday / Lashon Hara / Feb 7, 2024

Lectured by Rabbi Raymond Beyda

Published
February 13, 2024
Duration
10:45
Lecture code
C1464

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

Good morning. Welcome back to Torah Tuesday, our weekly get-together with several shiurim (lectures) on various topics. At 11.45 each week, we check in on our speech. Proper speech is a subject. Some people call it lashon hara. I call it Lashon HaTov. It’s learning how to speak properly.

In the cycle of the Chafetz Chaim, in a leap year, the days are different. But when I open to today’s date in a year that’s not a leap year, I come upon a halakha (Jewish law) that I think is worthy of our discussion. It says in the Chafetz Chaim that... We’ll start at the top. There is no distinction, no difference in the facts he speaks about. A person comes and volunteers negative information or harmful information about somebody. That’s called speaking lashon hara. But he did it because he felt like doing it. How about if somebody came and pressured you to speak negatively about somebody? The Chafetz Chaim says that, in any event, it’s forbidden. Even if it’s somebody he’s required to respect, like his father or his rabbi, he has to fear them and respect them, and not contradict them. If they ask him to speak about subject A, which is negative information about another person, he knows there’s no way to tell this particular incident without lashon hara. This includes even what we’ve called in the past the dust of lashon hara. Not his father, not his rabbi, and not his boss.

Even if he has already accepted upon himself not to speak negatively about anybody Jewish, or to engage in any other types of forbidden speech, such as lying or flattering, if he sees that person, he may say, “Perhaps if he doesn’t give in, there will be a resulting great financial loss of Parnasato.” He works for others, and they’re not exactly called observant. He knows that when it comes to improperness, when it comes to improper speech, they’re not only not good, they’re very bad. They see somebody who’s careful with their speech. They don’t like to insult people. They don’t like to say negative things about people. “Oh, I’m sorry. I don’t want to...” They’ll consider him as lacking smarts. He’s not as sharp as them. But if they say... They might even... They might even release him from his employment. And he won’t be able to find a means of livelihood for his family.

Even at the cost of your job, it’s asur (forbidden). It’s like any other lav (negative commandment). He has to give everything. He has to give everything. He has to give everything not to violate an aveira (transgression), like it says in Yoreh De’ah.

Let’s say a guy works for somebody, and the boss comes over to him and says, “Look, there’s a big show with major customers. It could be in any business. It doesn’t have to be merchandise; it could be services. But they’re all going to be at this show. And the show is this coming Saturday. Or next Saturday. Or any Saturday.” To the boss, it’s just another day of the week. But to us, it’s Shabbat Kodesh, the Holy Shabbat. So imagine a Torah-observing person being told that they want him to represent the company at a place on Shabbat, which will involve, without any escape hatch, violating Shabbat. He will desecrate... And if not, it will cost him his job.

In the early 1900s, as European Jews came to America: “If you don’t come Saturday, don’t come Monday.” There was no work on Sunday in those days. “If you don’t come Saturday, don’t come Monday. Go look for another job.” And how many Jews had multiple employment opportunities only because, when Shabbat came, they sacrificed their Parnasa for Shabbat? He comes and tells us, “You’re supposed to do that.” And when I put it in terms of Shabbat, you would do that.

How about if you’re working with somebody who says, “If you don’t join us at this taref meal and eat pork with us, roasted or whatever, however they cook it, we’re going to fire you”? The person would not participate in eating such a disgusting item to the Jewish nefesh (soul) and neshama (soul).

So if you’re a salesman, and you’re selling something, and the boss gives you ammunition, which is negative speech about a competitor, you’re not allowed to use it. And if the boss says, “You must use it,” you’re still not allowed to use it. Because every word of lashon hara is tantamount to every bite of taref, or every Chilul Shabbat (desecration of Shabbat). If a person is willing to lose his job for Shabbat, he has to be willing to lose his job for proper speech. He cannot participate in conversations that ultimately will lead to lashon hara, or that regularly contain clear lashon hara.

The person should look at it and say, “How could I ever do this on Shabbat?” I knew people 30 and 40 and 50 years ago who were not book-learned, not even so up on the totality of the Halakha of Shabbat. But there are certain things they wouldn’t do. They wouldn’t get in a car, because it’s Shabbat. They wouldn’t go to work; it’s Shabbat. They wouldn’t shave, because it’s Shabbat. Shabbat is Shabbat. And if somebody came along and said, “You have to shave, or you’ll lose your job,” they probably wouldn’t shave. And if they would, they’re wrong.

Because we learn that if there’s a negative commandment, and you’re told to violate it, and you don’t want to violate it, it doesn’t matter. You must not violate it at the cost of employment, at the cost of financial sustenance. You have to keep the Halakha and lose the job, or lose the money. It says in the Chafetz Chaim that lashon hara is no different. It says, “Don’t eat taref.” It says, “Don’t do this on Shabbat.” “Don’t light a fire on Shabbat.” Good. It also says, “Don’t speak lashon hara”: Lo telech rachil be’amecha. Lo, lo, lo.

And so today’s lesson is that, at the cost of loss, a person is still required to follow the laws of proper speech. Violating them in the face of threats, violating these laws in the face of obvious, imminent financial loss, is no excuse. You must keep the laws of proper speech regardless. It’s a Halakha like any other Halakha. You’re not allowed to violate it because of financial considerations.

We’ll take a short break and be back at 12. An interesting subject today has to do with the Parashah: Midvar sheker tirchak (From a false matter, keep far away).