Everybody, welcome to Torah Tuesday, a session on proper speech. We don't call it Lashon Hara (evil speech) because we're not learning how to speak Lashon Hara; we're learning how to avoid speaking Lashon Hara. In Klal Hei (rule), paragraph Bet (second), the Chafetz Chaim discusses your opinions. You express a judgment call: somebody is smart, he's a runner, he's powerful in business, he's influential. Those are all opinions. You make an assessment of people regarding their physical or mental attributes. It's very common in everyday conversation to do that. I can't remember a day going by when I didn't hear a comment that fits this MO.
Personal judgments are sometimes flattering. Sometimes they're not nice at all. But there's a danger in the ones that seem to be what we call pareve (neutral). You may make a statement. That's true. We start with true. Lashon Hara is true. It's not slander. It's not Motzi Shem Ra (slander). It's true. But the fact that it's true is no defense if it's negative or causes harm. Now, watch that second part: it causes harm.
If I take a stick and hit somebody, or if you take a knife and stab somebody, or if you trip somebody and they fall down, the effect of what you did is immediate. That immediate effect is not only immediate but noticeable. If you want to one day make Teshuvah (repentance), you feel badly about it. So, you know, I did this to this person. I shoved him, he fell, and he cut his knee. I mean, it wasn't serious, but I feel bad. I wouldn't like somebody to make me cut my knee or whatever. It's because what you did or said and its effect were connected.
But sometimes statements have far-reaching consequences. A person doesn't know where it's going to go. That's why this area of our study requires a lot of study. It's not, “Okay, I heard it,” and then forget it. Absorb it. The direction of this lesson is very important. Many people are not aware that when they assess or analyze a person's attributes or lack of talent, if they express their feelings in a less-than-flattering way, it is Lashon Hara. “But I didn't harm anybody. I didn't say anything negative. I said, ‘He's a simple guy.’” Or, “What would you like me to do? What would you like him to do for you? Because he's a good guy, but he's not so smart.” So, yes, it's true. People argue that it's not Lashon Hara, but it is.
But one may justify the statement by saying, “It's not derogatory to say he's not so smart. I didn't know if you wanted to put him on a computer or have him load trucks. I didn't know if you wanted to give him a job or ask him a favor. I was just telling you, you know, he's a simple guy. He's not so smart. So I didn't know if you wanted to put him on a computer or have him load trucks. I didn't know if you wanted to give him a job or ask him a favor.” So, what did I do? It's not even negative. It's not purely negative.
In truth, it may affect a chance to get married. When somebody says, “I'm thinking they called me for my daughter; who would they suggest?” They suggested Avi. “Well, Avi, yeah, he's a good guy, but he's not so smart.” How do you know? I heard. Second thought, maybe I'll just look for somebody else. A potential wife was taken away from him, and a potential family was taken away. That's damage.
Not only that, it's true that there's nothing wrong with it, but there's a flaw in our evaluation process. Let's say he is a simple guy. He's not so smart. It's a fact, and in this case it doesn't even affect anything that's going to happen to him in the future. Your process is wrong, because Hashem gives everybody what they need to perform their function in His army. Hashem said about it. So, if a person needs money, He gives them money. If a man needs a good voice, He gives him a good voice. If a man is going to be a teacher, He gives him a hand, and so the children like him. He gives them a talent for making difficult concepts simple or attractive.
So, the fact that I don't have what he has is not cause for comment from me, because overall, what he has is what he needs. And if I don't have it, I don't need it, especially when it comes to the makeup of the human being as far as intelligence, size, or strength. Most people do not consider this truth of individual gifts from Hashem when they evaluate a person. If they hear someone is not smart, their esteem and respect for that person automatically drops. But guess what? Hashem didn't make him smart because he doesn't need smarts. He needs strength or something else.
So, the Chafetz Chaim warns us in this Klal, Seif Bet (section). He gives three examples of how saying someone is “not so smart” could work against that person. As we brought up, number one: the person is single, and it might make him less desirable as a shidduch (as a match), as a bazra, as a match. Maybe the person is a crab. Maybe the person is a craftsman, carpenter, painter, or decorator. Or maybe he's a professional. You say, “Well, he's not so smart,” or “His stuff is not so nice.” The same comment might prevent people from even learning from him, approaching him for an opinion, or asking him what the halacha (Jewish law) is. So, you might say, “You know, does this happen because of one thing I said? I said he's not so smart.”
The Chafetz Chaim and another person were traveling together. They stopped at an inn. The hostess recognized the two esteemed rabbis and brought them to a table reserved only for special people. After they finished a delicious meal, the hostess came to the table and said, “Did you enjoy the food?” The Chafetz Chaim said, “It's very good.” His friend said, “It's not so smart.” She said, “It's not so smart.” He said, “It's not so good.” She said, “It was very good, but the soup could have used a little more salt.”
The Chafetz Chaim was distressed. When the woman walked away, his friend asked him, “What's the matter?” He said, “What you said constitutes Lashon Hara. The hostess is probably going to reprimand the cook, who could be a poor widow who has to work to support her family, and who knows if she'll even have a job tomorrow?” His friend, the esteemed rabbi, said, “Come on. I said it could have used a little more salt.” He said, “It's not so smart.” And he said, “It's not so smart.” Could that really happen? The Chafetz Chaim walked the man to that little window outside the kitchen door. Inside, she could see the boss reprimanding the cook, this poor widow, who was in tears. In fact, the rabbi complained when he said, “Oh, I just came in to tell you everything was so delicious.”
So the lesson today is that it may have long-range effects. If you don't feel when you're speaking, like the arrows that we talk about with Lashon Hara, an arrow travels, and the injury may take place very far away from the point of initiation. So watch your mouth before the arrow leaves the bow. Take a slight break and be back in about two minutes with the 12 o'clock session.

