A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Raymond Beyda

Torah Lecture

Torah Tuesday / Lashon Hara / Nov 1, 2022

Lectured by Rabbi Raymond Beyda

Published
November 1, 2022
Duration
13:03
Lecture code
C1236

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

Torah Tuesday, a session on the laws of proper speech. When it comes to proper speech, the classic Sefer Chafetz Chaim explains, law by law and detail by detail, what is considered Lashon Hara, what is not, what is considered Rechilut (talebearing), and what is not. There is also a sefer called Shemirat HaLashon, written by the same great tzaddik (righteous person), the Chafetz Chaim, which outlines Musar (ethical instruction) on the subject.

Today we're going to take a look at Kelal Gimel (Section 3), or what's called Perek Gimel (Chapter 3), and look at a couple of the paragraphs in it—one, two, three, maybe four, five, six—to see a general outline of the laws of proper speech. In his introduction or outline, he says, “She'ein chiluk be'isur Lashon Hara.” It doesn't make a difference regarding whether or not something is considered Lashon Hara. “Bein befanav bein shelo befanav” (in his presence and not in his presence). It could be spoken in front of the person being discussed. In front of that person. In front of the person being discussed. It could also be said outside that person's presence. So we see this even through this law. It could be meant seriously or as a joke—just joking. And even if the person who is the subject is not identified, at least at the time the speech is made.

So, other details. Basically, Kelal Gimel is telling us the parameters of Lashon Hara. One of the basic misconceptions in this section is that a person says, “It's not Lashon Hara because it will never get back to him. It's not Lashon Hara because he'll never know about it.” The Chafetz Chaim says it's forbidden in any event. Even if, in reality, the reported information never gets back to the person the violator is talking about, it's nonetheless full-fledged, wholehearted Lashon Hara.

There's another misconception he wants to dispel in this particular chapter. The second misconception is, “It's not Lashon Hara because even if he were here, I would say it to his face.” Unfortunately for the speaker, according to the Halacha (Jewish law), it's an unacceptable excuse. By making the statement in the person's presence, he may not only be violating Lashon Hara; he may be violating Ona'ah—hurtful speech, insulting speech, depressing speech—to the victim, and maybe even one of the worst violations of the use of the tongue: embarrassing somebody.

The fact that the person is not here does not change the nature of the statement. It only changes whether the statement itself violates one, two, three, four, or five different Aveirot (transgressions).

The Chafetz Chaim is very careful and precise in this great sefer. He says it's also important to note that there are cases where statements could be made in which the subject of the harmful or negative speech is taken into account—his reaction and feelings are taken into account. For example, you say, “Oh, here we go again. Joe's going to be late for sure. He's going to be late for the meeting.” Now, it seems to be just a simple fact. Listen, you're either on time or you're late. So the person says, “Joe's going to be late for the meeting.” Now, it wasn't a judgment call. It wasn't saying it's bad to be late. It wasn't saying it's even what we call socially late or acceptable. It wasn't saying it's bad to be late, socially late. No, no judgment has been spoken, just the fact that the person is late.

The Chafetz Chaim discusses a case where an innocuous statement of fact, which doesn't on its face turn out to be negative. You didn't say he's a crook. You didn't say he's lazy. You just said a fact, going to be late, and it might be permissible depending on how the subject would react. Let's say we also take into account the way it was given over: it's also a fact. Did you make a face? “Here we go again, Joe's going to be late. Never ends.” Your face sort of says, “This guy's always late. We all run to be here on time. Why can't he be on time?” Now, if it was said in a derisive manner, where it was meant to be negative and harmful, it would be like—I just almost said, “Here we go again, Joe's going to be late,” and then I roll my eyes. This expression, in a manner of displeasure, turns it into Lashon Hara.

So what is the measure? What is the barometer that tells us that we're late? Whether a factual statement, not a judgmental statement, is considered Lashon Hara depends on how it comes across. We can take into account body language, tone of voice, and many different factors that would change the way it's heard by the listener: the way the voice is heard, the way the listener feels it was said because of demonstrative signals of what was meant. If it was meant to be negative, if it was meant to be, “I'm upset by this person because this is the way they behave,” then it is categorized as a negative statement that could be harmful. Why? Because the people listening get the feeling that the subject of the haki did something wrong, or that they have a trait that's unacceptable or at least not desirable: laziness, lack of tardiness, sloppiness, disrespect, disregarding the feelings of others, or valuing their desires over other people's time.

The way it's accepted has a lot to do with what it's called. The way it's accepted and the way it's expressed—with all the peripherals, tone of voice, body language, and facial expressions—make it something that will be accepted in a certain way. So, as the Chafetz says, the fact that you could say, “But look, what did I say? He's going to be late. He is going to be late. It's true,” is another mistake. Lashon Hara is true. There's a misconception that if something is true, it's not Lashon Hara.

Let's say somebody's really not so straight; they're crooked in their business deals, and a conversation ensues. “Look how successful this guy is.” And somebody says, “But he's crooked. That's why he's successful. If he played it straight, he would have a problem being successful.” And somebody says, “Why are you talking Lashon Hara? Why are you knocking George or Joe or Harry?” He says, “But it's true. Nothing I'm saying is made up. Everything I'm saying is verifiable, and it's true that he does in fact behave this way.”

A misconception is that this is not Lashon Hara. The fact of the matter is, Lashon Hara is always true. It's a negative or harmful statement about somebody that is true. What if it's made up? What if it's incorrect? What if it's not true? That's not called Lashon Hara. That's not true. That's called Motzi Shem Ra, creating a negative statement, creating a negative impact of your statement. It's something that's not taken lightly by others, but it's not true. So it's Metzora (leper), Motzi Shem Ra. In English, there's a difference between a harmful statement, a negative statement, and slander. Slander is a made-up statement.

So if somebody did something wrong and somebody reports it, and it's true, it's Lashon Hara. Now, sometimes you have to tell. Sometimes it's helpful to tell. Sometimes you're preventing others from being harmed by it. That's called to'elet—positive purpose or constructive purpose. We've learned, and we will learn again and review again and again and again, that there are seven conditions that must be met before a negative statement can be made for a constructive purpose. But if it's not constructive, there are no conditions that would make it permissible.

So we went through several situations: if he were here, I would say it to his face; facial expressions; saying it in a way that's only a statement of fact; and saying it for a constructive purpose. There are many misconceptions that by doing those things you've avoided Lashon Hara, when in fact it is Lashon Hara unless other conditions are met to prevent a violation of the laws of proper speech.

Here at SOM we continue to study, learn, and grow in our sensitivity to Lashon Hara, our observance of proper speech, and our understanding of what we should say before it comes out of our mouth.