A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Raymond Beyda

Torah Lecture

Torah Tuesday / Lashon Hara / Nov 11, 2025

Lectured by Rabbi Raymond Beyda

Published
November 11, 2025
Duration
10:31
Lecture code
C1768

The Listener’s Role in Lashon Hara

  • Rabbi Raymond Beyda introduces the sixth Klal and sixth chapter of the Chafetz Chaim’s Sefer, focusing on its first two points about the listener. The ongoing study concerns proper speech, which he calls Lashon HaTov (good speech); since Rosh Hashanah, the lessons have focused on speaking Lashon Hara.
  • Lashon Hara is not a private sin: it involves both a speaker and a listener. Accepting derogatory information as true is itself a De'oraita (Torah-level) sin. The parasha teaching this seems to indicate that accepting Lashon Hara may carry a greater punishment than speaking it.
  • The listener is therefore also a violator if he accepts the report as fact. Merely saying that one does not intend to believe a speaker—for example, because the speaker has often been wrong—does not erase the distinction between listening and accepting. The lecture cautions that listening with an intention not to believe is still liable, while distinguishing it from acceptance.

Listening for a Constructive Purpose

  • Derogatory information may sometimes be needed for protection. A person considering hiring someone, marrying someone, or entering a business partnership may need relevant information to avoid being harmed. Listening for this constructive purpose is called To'elet (protective).
  • In business, someone may need to assess whether a prospective partner is reliable, diligent, honest, and likely to deliver. The purpose must be to protect oneself if the report is true—not to decide that it is true. If the information raises concern, one should investigate further; one may not accept it as fact.
  • A speaker may state at the outset that the information is being shared only for To'elet. Alternatively, a listener may arrive after the speaker has already begun telling someone else. Since Lashon Hara involves both a speaker and a listener, the arriving listener need not prompt or encourage the speaker to continue.
  • Listening for To'elet may also be allowed when the information concerns a friend or relative and could prevent that person from entering a harmful situation. However, the listener may not pass the information on until its accuracy has been checked and verified.
  • One may also listen to a report that a friend has done something wrong if listening could create an opportunity to help him mend his ways or correct an injustice.
  • These constructive purposes include protecting oneself, correcting the person speaking, correcting the person being discussed, or helping someone harmed by that person.

The Limits of Permitted Listening

  • Even when listening for a constructive purpose is allowed, the boundary is narrow: one may not accept the report as fact. One may use it as a reason to investigate further and determine whether it is true.
  • Even for To'elet, the listener must distinguish fact from fiction and initially reject the report as established truth until it can be verified.