A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Raymond Beyda

Torah Lecture

Torah Tuesday / Lashon Hara / Nov 11, 2025

Lectured by Rabbi Raymond Beyda

Published
November 11, 2025
Duration
10:31
Lecture code
C1768

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

Good evening, Tel Aviv. Good evening. On Torah Tuesday, we discuss, basically, the teachings of the Chafetz Chaim called proper speech. I like to call it Lashon HaTov (good speech). Today, we're going to discuss the sixth Klal (rule), the sixth chapter of the Sefer Chafetz Chaim, and the first two points he makes in that chapter.

One of the factors that makes Lashon Hara (derogatory information) such a serious sin is that sin itself involves interaction. You don't have one violator; you have a team. You have a speaker and a listener. The speaker and the listener bring us to the point that Lashon Hara is not a private type of Avera (sin). It's a joint effort. So, in this particular area of the Sefer Chafetz Chaim, the Chafetz Chaim wants to deal with the listener's role, because up to now, since we started our new cycle of Rosh Hashanah, we have been speaking about speaking Lashon Hara. As a matter of fact, it's a sin to believe Lashon Hara, or, as we say, accept it. Somebody who does has violated a De'oraita (Torah-level) sin. In fact, the Chafetz Chaim outlines...

“Can I ask a question about this?” “No, there's not a discussion.” The parasha that teaches this seems to indicate that accepting Lashon Hara as true carries either a greater punishment than the one who speaks it. That's the first point he makes in the sixth chapter: the listener is also a violator so long as he accepts it as fact.

Continuing along, let's say somebody is listening to a story. He doesn't intend to accept the information. “Ah, this guy—I don't hear what he's saying because he's talking to somebody. You know, I never hold him as a reliable source of information. So many times he's been wrong.” No. So I'm listening, not to accept it. However, he's still liable, because there is a difference between listening and accepting—and listening with the intention of not believing what he's about to hear.

So now we get into a very complex situation. What exactly does he mean by listening with the intent to believe or not with the intent to believe? Derogatory information or harmful information is Lashon Hara. But sometimes you need that information. Sometimes even listening to it is protective. It's protective. A person is hiring somebody. A person is planning to engage and marry somebody. Somebody is getting involved with another person in a partnership, whatever it may be. And so information is crucial. If I had known, I never would have gotten involved. If I had known, I never would have been harmed. If I had known. Listening to information that may be helpful for you to make a decision is protective. That is called To'elet (protective). The information you're about to hear is derogatory information, but it might have a constructive purpose.

The two areas I mentioned are the most common. One is business, and one is Shidduchim (prospective marriage matches), Zivugim (prospective marriage matches), or bazras. When it comes to business, it's pretty common for a person to want to know whether the person is reliable, not lazy, honest, and going to deliver. So it's not really gossip. If I hear somebody say, “Did you know that?” and the negative information is listened to and accepted, the primary purpose must be to protect myself if it's true, not to decide that it is, in fact, true. If the man is really not honest, I shouldn't be involved with him. I better check it out further. If the man is really not honest, I prefer not to get involved with him. But the fact of the matter is, I can't accept it as fact.

Sometimes you have a case where the speaker indicates at the opening of the conversation, “I'm talking about something, but I want to make it clear: I'm relating this only for the purpose of To'elet.” Or another case would be that the listener arrives, and the speaker has already started telling the negative information to someone else. And so you need two hands to clap. You need a speaker and a listener for Lashon Hara. You're not prompting or aiding the speaker to say, “I'm not talking about To'elet. I'm talking about To'elet. I'm talking about To'elet. I'm talking about To'elet.” He's not pursuing it because he already has somebody.

So the allowance for listening for a constructive purpose extends even further. One can listen to important information that applies to another and applies to his friend or relative, to prevent them from falling into a bad situation. Now, of course, you can't pass it on until you check the accuracy. You can't pass it on until you verify that what you heard is true. But at least you're listening with the intent, because you heard him say, “You know, I'm thinking of going out with—seems like a nice person, maybe, who knows? Or I'm thinking of going into business with, or buying from, or selling to.”

One can also listen to a report that his friend has committed something wrong. If he feels, “By listening, I might have an opportunity to help him, to convince him to mend his ways, maybe correct an injustice.” All these are situations where a person knows negative information is going to be related about a particular person or situation. Even though he sees it coming—or, let's say, hears it coming—he can listen, but only for the constructive purpose of protecting yourself, correcting the person who's speaking, correcting the person it's about, or helping out a victim of that person.

Now, even when we're allowed to listen to negative information, it's a very fine line, and we have to be careful. You're not allowed to accept it. You're not allowed to accept it as fact. You're allowed to use it to go one step further: to investigate further to see if it is, in fact, true. And that's really where we stand when it comes to this type of information. We have plausible information, but we also have the ability to distinguish between fact and fiction. And we as people have to use that ability to determine what we're hearing, whether it's valid or not, and at the outset, to reject it until we can verify it, even if it's for To'elet.