How is everybody today? At 12 noon each week, we discuss a relevant topic and the Parashat HaShavua (weekly Torah portion). Many questions, many different answers. Parashat Toledot discusses the twins born to Yitzchak after 20 years of marriage. They grow up. Although they went to the same school or had the same upbringing, Esav turns out to be Ish Sadeh, Ish Tzayid (a hunter or trapper). Ish Tzayid Ish Sadeh means a hunter or trapper who's out in the fields. Yaakov is Ish Tam. Yaakov is one who is quiet. He's not simple in the sense of not smart, but straightforward. Yosef studies Hashem's lessons that he received from his father.
At one point in time, we find out that Esav was having, for him, a good day-for the rest of us, a horrible day: five major sins. He comes home tired and hungry and thirsty, and he finds his brother Yaakov making some type of red dish. It happened to be red lentil soup, and he says, "I didn't have the strength to eat it. Pour it in my throat." And Yaakov makes a bargain to acquire the Bechora (first born status). Although he exited his mother's womb second, he wants to be Bechor (first born son), with all the benefits and all the responsibilities of such a title. And so he makes a deal. Esav ate, he drank, he got up and he left. Very simple. And Esav despised the firstborn status called Bechora.
Now you have to ask yourself a question. It's a position of honor, gets double in the inheritance, some respect as well. What's he got against it? Why did Esav despise the Bechora, the right to be the firstborn son? Ibn Ezra answers that in Esav's eyes there was no benefit to it. Greater portion of what inheritance? And he reveals to us something most of you are not aware of: although Yitzchak inherited the wealth of Avraham, at this point in time he was very poor. He lost the wealth, and there was really not much to inherit. So, says Ibn Ezra, Esav says to himself, "What do I need it for? Double zero is zero."
Now, before you can say something that most people were not aware of—that Yitzchak Avinu (our forefather) was actually poverty-stricken—Ibn Ezra gives a few proofs. One is that Esav actually bought lentil soup from Yaakov. If there was wealth and food in their parents' home, he wouldn't have sold the Bechora to get some stew. Another proof is that Yitzchak would eat from Esav's hunting. The Torah tells us he was in his mouth. So Yitzchak also lacked accessibility to food. He needed to eat from what Esav gave him.
Now there are more proofs of the poverty, but let's just say, without going through every single proof, Yitzchak Avinu at this point in time was broke. And Esav says to himself, "Bechora gets double of the inheritance. What inheritance?" So Ibn Ezra points out a good question, a very good question. Why would Hashem cause Yitzchak to become poor? Usually we're promised all kinds of benefits, wealth, and good. And maybe, if we know the answer to the first question, we can answer the second question. Why did Hashem make Yitzchak Avinu blind?
Now we can't know. Let's start with that. But let's at least acknowledge there's some strange goings-on here. Now the Ramban disagrees with the Ibn Ezra. He says it's impossible to say Yitzchak was poor. With wealth, with properties, with honor, what is the pasuk (verse) talking about if he lost all his money? And even if there are tzadikim (righteous people) who live in poverty, which is a question, when he received an inheritance that was huge and HaKadosh Baruch Hu is the one who said, "I'm going to bless Yitzchak," it can't be that he was broke. So Ramban goes through explanations as to why Esav despised the Bechora. Go look in Ramban. You'll have a chance; you'll see.
Now the Ketav Sofer, zechuto yagen aleinu (may his merit protect us), answers that we can in fact say, like the Ibn Ezra, that Hashem wanted Yitzchak to live in poverty so Esav wouldn't want the Bechora and would sell it to Yaakov for a bowl of soup. It was for Yitzchak's offspring, whose benefit Hashem was considering, that He made Yitzchak poverty-stricken at this point in time. The blessings of Hashem bring wealth, but the way they got that wealth was through the parent spending their time in poverty.
Now the Ketav Sofer says, "I can answer what's bothering Ramban. It's all from Hashem. Hashem should sell the firstborn rights to Yaakov. Yaakov will get the Beracha (blessing) in the end, which is fitting for a Bechor. And if Yitzchak were wealthy, Yitzchak wouldn't sell the Bechora to Yaakov. So for Yitzchak's sake and for the sake of his son the tzadik (righteous person), he had to suffer poverty and sell prompt Esav to despise the Bechora."
We should get chizuk (strengthening), and we should get comfort from this lesson when we say, "Where are Hashem's Berachot (blessings)? Where is it? I go to shul (synagogue), I study Torah, I do mitzvot (commandments), and it says you're going to be wealthy. Not wealthy. Where are the Berachot? Why is it so hard?" And his answer is today's lesson. You have to know that whatever is going on, however it feels, however it tastes—bitter and difficult—it may not be immediately apparent, but it's always, always, without exception, for our good. Always, without exception, for our good.
Now Rabbi Biederman is very popular right now. Rabbi Elimelech Biederman. His pamphlets are being sold all over and given out in Hebrew, English and other languages. And he also feels that the lesson is it's all for the good. For example, Rashi says Avraham died that day, and Yaakov cooked the lentil soup, which is a food for mourners. And why lentils? Because lentils are round, which means what goes around comes around, or because there's no mouth on a lentil. There's no ability to speak when you're subjected to a relative's death. So it became a mourner's food, and that's why Yaakov had lentils to give.
But why is he cooking? Ish Tam Yoshev Ohalim (a straightforward man, dwelling in tents) is a cook; where's Rivka? Isn't she mommy? And if there's a seudat havra'ah (meal of consolation) to feed Yitzchak because his father passed away, where's his wife? The Melitz Yosef, the name of a sefer, explains that Yaakov was not cooking so that Yitzchak would have something to eat. Rather, his primary purpose was to teach himself and others that what goes around comes around. Life is a wheel with ups and downs. Yaakov wanted to involve himself personally in the preparation of the lentils. Not that he had to—he wanted to, so that the lesson would become internalized. A person who understands this will not become arrogant if they have wealth. A person who understands this will not become crushed when things are not going so well. He knows what goes around comes around.
Now, 18 years ago, a financial tragedy struck, and many wealthy people... That was 2008. They have one story where a lot of people invested with somebody who was supposed to increase their wealth, but he was a swindler, and he actually stole their investments. A rabbi from Zurich, Switzerland, tells about an incident with his father. We see from here the point that all suffering and pain, including the loss of substantial wealth, can be for a person's blessing and salvation.
When this man's father was young, he lived in Poland. He was financially secure, and he was able to devote himself to Torah learning as much as he wished. In the year 1929, a famous year, he decided to purchase an apartment building with rental units. His plan was to rent out the apartments and produce income to live on, and after he negotiated the deal with the owner, they came to a price. All that remained was to sign the contract. All he had to do was make it official. For some reason, unbeknownst to him, the signing kept getting postponed.
Eventually a date was set, and one day before the scheduled signing, the stock market crashed in 1929. Day after day, the value of money declined. It decreased until cash became nearly worthless. The man's father was left holding large sums of money, but they lost their value. Tangible assets were worth much more than cash, and so the man who was supposed to sell him the building backed out on the deal. So now his plan, his retirement to Torah study, was spoiled.
He heard, although he lived in Poland, that there was a community in a town in Germany looking for a rabbi. He applied for the position, and soon afterward he moved out of Poland to Germany with his family. And it wasn't long after—because this is 1929-1930—that the Nazis rose to power and started persecuting German Jewry. In 1933, he decided things were not good, especially when he was arrested on false charges and barely escaped death. He was saved through open miracles, and he and his family decided to move. They went from Poland to Germany for a job, and from the job during the Nazis to Zurich in Switzerland. And when the Holocaust happened—that horrible, horrible period when Jews' lives were worthless, when six million were killed, especially in Poland and Germany—he was no longer there. He had moved because he lost his money and he lost the deal.
At the time, it seemed so unpleasant, so unfair, but years later it produced life-saving circumstances. The lentils that Yaakov prepared taught that life is a wheel: what goes around comes around. We say what appears to be a devastating loss is in reality part of a puzzle. It's part of the salvation, and often it takes years for a person to look back and recognize how Hashem was guiding every single step.
So we see in this particular incident a case where, yes, he lost his deal; yes, he had a lot of money that became worthless. Yes, with no money and no income, he was forced to move to a totally different place and start a new life, which became bad—in Germany. But unlike those who could not escape Poland, he had an opportunity to get to Zurich. And while many others—many more than we'd like to acknowledge—perished, he and his family survived. It was good. All the details were positive. All the details were for his benefit, unbeknownst to him years before.
My friends, we're living in a world where communication has become instant and vast. People have thousands of followers. People get texts and emails because they tried to buy something. There are ways of finding you and communicating with you that you never could imagine. And so now it seems like not a day goes by—at least, not a week goes by—when you don't hear of some type of tragedy, some type of unexplainable injustice. It's Hashem.
When a person does puzzles, for example, they buy a jigsaw puzzle with a thousand or two thousand pieces. They pour the pieces on the table. They put them all face up and they start. And you look and you say, "What a bunch of mess." And as they connect the interlocking pieces one by one by one, a picture develops. And so long as even just a few pieces are missing—even if one piece is missing—the beautiful picture is not complete. And somebody who looked at that pile of interlocking pieces coming out of a cardboard box onto a table, when he sees the finished product, realizes, "What a beautiful puzzle. I'm so glad all the pieces are now in place."
Our lives are a puzzle. Hashem created it, and step by step, piece by piece, he's putting it together. And though some pieces look beautiful and taste sweet, and other pieces look terrible and taste bitter or sour, they're all part of one puzzle. When all the pieces are in place, we'll know every piece was necessary to make this beautiful picture. It's all... And that's the lesson.

