A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Shmuel Choueka

Torah Lecture

Mishna Berura Hilchot Shabbat Siman 302 Seif 7

Lectured by Rabbi Shmuel Choueka

Published
February 13, 2025
Duration
11:27
Lecture code
RSC-3087

Siman Shin-Bet, Se'if Zayin: Mud on a Garment

  • Rabbi Shmuel Choueka explains that mud may be rubbed off a garment from the inside, by holding the garment opposite the mud and rubbing the fabric until the mud falls off. Rubbing from the outside is forbidden because it looks like melaben, whitening or cleaning the garment.
  • The Mishnah Berurah says this applies equally to silk, linen, and wool.
  • Although rubbing a kerchief was forbidden even from the inside in se'if heh, that case is different: there, the person intends to whiten and clean the kerchief. Here, the intention is only to remove the mud.
  • Mud may also be scraped off with a fingernail. Some explain that this is permitted only when the mud is moist. If it is dry, scraping or rubbing it—even from the inside—is forbidden because it may constitute tochen: the mud clump is broken into pieces or powder.
  • The Mishnah Berurah explains that this is only similar to melaben, not actual melaben, since no water is applied. Scraping with a fingernail is not considered libun; the same applies to scraping with a knife. The transcript notes that some allow using the back of a knife, and possibly even its blade.
  • Even though the dry-mud case is melachah she'einah tzrichah legufah—the person does not want the resulting powder—the Mishnah Berurah says it is still an issur derabbanan. It may be done by a non-Jew when necessary.
  • The Taz limits the tochen concern to a garment with actual mud on it, where scraping causes pieces of mud to fall away. If there is only the appearance of a mud stain, with no actual mud substance, removing the mark is not tochen.
  • On that basis, the Taz permits someone whose garment has dry excrement on it, but no actual substance remains, to scrape off its appearance with a fingernail so that he can pray cleanly.
  • The Mishnah Berurah questions the Taz’s leniency: even without tochen, the person intends to beautify and clean the garment, which is like melaben. He refers the reader to the Bi'ur Halachah for the fuller discussion.
  • The Mishnah Berurah further says that even according to the Taz, scraping or rubbing to remove such a mark is permitted only from the inside; doing so from the outside is forbidden.
  • Rabbi Shmuel Choueka’s practical distinction is to ask whether actual material is present: a dried clump of cholent or potato may be flicked off, but rubbing the garment is only permitted from the inside. One must also consider whether the action is effectively cleaning the garment; if so, there is a melaben concern.

Se'if Chet: Scraping a Shoe

  • Scraping a shoe with a knife or fingernail is forbidden, whether the shoe is new or old, because it can peel the leather and constitute mochek.
  • Even if the intention is only to remove mud, scraping leather has an inevitable result of smoothing it, a psik reisha. This applies even when using the back of a knife.
  • The Mishnah Berurah discusses the metal shoe-scrapers placed outside some shuls, used to remove mud from shoes. The implement should be broad rather than narrow, since a narrow edge can smooth the leather. He also recalls that scraping against a wall was permitted in the earlier discussion, and cites the Magen Avraham as saying that even a thick blade should not be used.
  • These restrictions concern leather shoes. Rabbi Shmuel Choueka notes that they do not apply to rubber-soled shoes or sneakers.