A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Shmuel Choueka

Torah Lecture

Mishna Berura Hilchot Shabbat Siman 306 Seif 4

Lectured by Rabbi Shmuel Choueka

Published
March 13, 2025
Duration
17:47
Lecture code
RSC-3144

Hiring Workers and Havla’ah

  • Rabbi Shmuel Choueka reviews the distinction in se’if dalet: a worker hired for a single day may not be hired to work on Shabbat, whereas hiring him for a week, month, or year can make the Shabbat wages part of a larger payment through havla’ah.
  • He recalls the Rama’s distinction between hiring someone day by day, which is sechir yom, and hiring someone for a longer period. Paying a worker by the day may suggest that the employer can decide each day whether to continue, which may be why the arrangement is asur.
  • By contrast, when someone is hired for a month or another fixed period, the employer is less likely to change his mind; Rabbi Choueka presents this as a possible basis for relying on the longer-term arrangement, even when wages are paid for multiple days that include Shabbat.

Shabbat Work, Chazanim, and Other Workers

  • Rabbi Choueka asks how merchants can hire a Jew on Friday to guard their wagons on Shabbat. Although the guard may not be doing anything wrong, his wages include Shabbat.
  • He explains that when work also takes place on Friday and Sunday, the payment can cover more than Shabbat. Hiring for a month or a year is an example of havla’ah; he also notes that there are yesh matirim.
  • He discusses chazanim hired for Shabbat. One reason given for allowing their wages is that they also pray during the week, and sometimes on Hanukkah or other days; their work is therefore not limited to Shabbat.
  • The minhag is to hire for Shabbat. Someone who wants to be machmir can avoid setting a fixed price: instead of agreeing on wages, the payment can be given as a gift based on what the person is considered worth.
  • Rabbi Choueka raises the case of a midwife or doula called on Shabbat. He notes the concern that if she is not paid, she may not come, and compares this practical concern to Hatzalah: if responders could not return home, they might not come. He presents the issue as a difficulty rather than giving a separate ruling.

Speech About Mitzvah and Community Matters

  • Rabbi Choueka distinguishes discussion from actually hiring someone or directing someone to do work on Shabbat. He mentions that people may discuss shul renovations, fundraising for tzedakah, committee plans for a garden or an upstairs area, and other cheshbonot shel mitzvah.
  • He also mentions discussing a shidduch. These examples concern talking about matters, not carrying out prohibited work.
  • Regarding teaching an orphan a trade, one may discuss the idea of arranging a teacher, but should not actually hire the person on Shabbat; the payment discussion can be left until afterward.

Pledges, Donations, and Public Announcements

  • Rabbi Choueka discusses Mi Sheberach announcements connected with an aliyah, a chazan, or a baal koreh. He says not to state a specific amount when making the announcement.
  • He distinguishes a shul’s furnishings from items associated with the Beit HaMikdash, noting that a table or similar item donated to a shul is not an item for the Beit HaMikdash.
  • For a Sefer Torah or another significant donation, he says not to initiate the gift on Shabbat. The donor can make the gift before Shabbat and announce it on Shabbat; the announcement then publicizes a commitment already made.
  • He also distinguishes pledging an amount from actually transferring money: saying how much one intends to give is not itself giving the money.
  • Checking the community’s needs and discussing what something will cost for a mitzvah purpose are treated differently from doing melacha or engaging in shevut. The actual work or hiring still may not be done on Shabbat.

Selling Aliyot and Seats

  • Rabbi Choueka says there are yesh osrim and yesh matirim regarding selling aliyot on Shabbat. He notes that the practice in many places is to allow it, on the reasoning that this is not the sale of an ordinary item.
  • Selling seats is different in his discussion: it is a business transaction involving something being sold. He emphasizes that selling an item is more problematic than merely pledging money.

Gifts on Shabbat

  • Rabbi Choueka notes that a gift can resemble a business transaction even when no money changes hands. He distinguishes this from giving a guest food from one’s own property to eat, which he says is allowed.
  • He applies the concern to gifts for a chatan or for a bar mitzvah. One can arrange before Shabbat to have the gift picked up, or show the recipient the gift on Shabbat while making clear that it is not being given until later.
Words in this lecture1
Hanukkahחנוכה
Terms Chanukah, the eight-day festival of lights celebrating the Maccabees' victory and the miracle of the oil. English: Festival of dedication
Also written: Chanukah, Hanukah