Ladies and gentlemen, Shemoh HaTov, Shemoh, Shemoh, Shemoh, Shemoh, Shemoh, Shemuel, karpef, an area that's surrounded by mechitzot (partitions), surrounded by walls, but has no ceiling, no roof. What's karpef? Makom shehukaf mechitzot v'lo kiruy k'mo hatzer (a place enclosed by partitions and not roofed, like a courtyard). But it's not a Reshut HaYachid (private domain). Why? You tell me: beit satayim (an area of two se'ah)—it's so big, more than two beit satayim. And it was not surrounded by a wall for the sake of living purposes. That means, for example, maybe a corral, okay, a barn—I was going to say something like that. It's not meant to live in, but we'll see what living means.
A lot of times they use this. Let's say you have a wall around the city. One of the things it was for was protection, not that you should live in there. So even if you end up living in there, that does not become a Reshut HaYachid. It's a karpef, and it's assur (prohibited) according to the Rabbanan (the rabbis) to carry in there four amot (cubits). It's not Hakamim from Tel Boer, and I talk about amot only within four amot. But it's like a Karmelit (a rabbinic domain). I can carry from this Karmelit to the next Karmelit; there's a Karmelit next to it, and I could do it. Let's see, he explains why.
On the mountains. Let's see what he says now. It's talking about a cage that has 70 amot and two-thirds by 70 and two-thirds square. So how big is that? Not that big. So we said an amah is one and a half to two feet, right? 70 and two-thirds. An amah is what? One and a half. One and a half, right? So it's 105, 105 feet. A hundred by a hundred. A hundred by a hundred. About. A hundred by a hundred. Hello, your house land is bigger than that. I know. I know. Not big at all.
All right, so that, or karpef, which is yoter mibeit satayim shelo hukaf ledira (more than a beit satayim that was not enclosed for dwelling), Mishnubu Tel Vav. Yon Shahed Atul Intowa, Ol Izraq HaGavna. When he made the fence, his intention was to plant, not to live in it. So he went in there. He's back out to live? Huh? Your backyard is to live, you're saying. Is that called? I don't know. We'll see. Here, he was trying to plant, so he put a fence around it.
Aslo ha-chamim, Ted Zion. She came and she was got all cold, kach. Hathim rakhla b'shut harabim. Va'asuhu Chachamim (the sages) k'karmelit. Since it's so big, what Chazal (the Sages) looked at as that big, it could be compared to Reshut HaRabim (public domain). He'd be confused. Therefore, Chachamim made it into Karmelit. But you'd like to go from that to another Karmelit.
See, the Hiddush (novel insight) is a very big, strong Hiddush. This is: you have a corral fence around a certain big-sized area. I fenced it. My house is like this. I fenced it; nobody else comes in, so it's private and it has a fence all around it. No, but you didn't do it to live there. You did it to plant, and it has that amount of space. It looks too public. It's fenced. Doesn't matter. Therefore, you cannot walk in there more and more and more. But you can go from there to another Karmelit.
Why is that? That's his question. A guy who throws from there into the street is chayav d'oraita (biblically liable). I took a ball, and you say it's yachid (private domain), so therefore it's called Yachid Rabim. How am I allowed to go into Karmelit, Reshut HaYachid, Karmelit? How am I allowed to go into Karmelit? Why? The rabbis wanted to make sure that you don't carry in this area. So in order to force you to accept that we're making it so you can't carry, we have to give you a leniency and say you can carry from here to another Karmelit.
“Oh, I go from here to Karmelit; it must be not a Reshut HaYachid. Really, it's a Reshut HaYachid. We don't want you to consider it that, and then you walk around the whole time because he'll make a mistake, so we'll give you the leeway to carry from there to Karmelit. Oh, it must be Karmelit. I don't know how to carry like we had before, you know, Karmelit to ocean to valley.” What did they do? I don't know. It's a Chazal-made Karmelit. They made it into Karmelit because it looks too much like a Reshut HaRabim. It looks like a Reshut HaRabim.
So now, why am I allowed to carry from me into Karmelit? They're both really Makom Patur (exempt place). “Wrong, it's a yachid.” So right, that's a yachid. So yachid to Karmelit means that it's assur to carry because they're Rabbanan. “Yeah, but it's assur. Why?” In order to keep—because the rule is that you shouldn't carry in this thing for a moment, okay? Because then, once they're going to carry it here, other people, Fatamim, are going to say, “I saw the guy carrying in this big area, so I'm going to carry in the street also. What's the difference? He's just a black hat and a white hat. What's the difference?” Once it's not enclosed for living purposes, people look at it like it's a public area, like an open area. So a guy going from there to there will be allowed.
That means like this: imagine Van Cortlandt Park over here had a fence around it. Imagine they put a fence; it's called karpef. Nobody was supposed to live there, so halakha (Jewish law) is you can't carry in there for four amot inside, even though the guy says, “What?” Okay, let's say we get out of that problem. Say the mayor—the mayor buys it. The guy wants to carry from there to the street next to it. The street next to it is Karmelit. Why is the street next to it Karmelit? So Karmelit is okay, but this is not really Karmelit. We're making it like you can carry it. Let's go to the sketch. Let's go to the Rema now.
It's going to be a big enough community for people who live there and leave their keys outside. They want to carry the key to open the door in the house. They didn't have push-button locks in those days. On the porch, on the tank. Correct. I'm going to take the key from a Karmelit in front of the garden like this. The guy has a garden in front of his house like every nice person. They have a nice flower garden, and it's big, and there's a fence. What's the flower garden called? This, it's called the karpef. Don't say, “No, it's my yard. It's a Reshut HaYachid.” It's enclosed, not for the sake of living. Nobody lives in the garden, not for the sake of living. It's karpef. You can have a karpef. It's not my house—my house is a Reshut HaYachid. This in front of my house, my garden. What if it's fenced? It is a fence. We talk about a fence. No, it's talking about the whole property. What's the whole property? It doesn't matter. This fence is called this fence, not for the purpose of living.
So right outside there, I'm in Karmelit, and I left my key there. So I have my key there in order to stick it into the door of my ginah (garden), which is karpef, which I know I cannot have. I have no idea what that is—a platform, platform—but it's like that. It's not... it's like an iskupah, like the thing in front of the step, the porch. Take a look at it. This is cool.
Okay, oh, you mean the over, the over not owning, it's cool. It's usually a step between the top part or the bottom part. Top part, so it's covered on top, keep from the rain. Now maybe it's the bottom. I'm sorry, it could be it's the bottom. The iskupah is the steps, the platform. So in theory, you have a front porch. Let me talk, go she give us ten high, ten different height, four, four wide. Then it becomes—has two walls on the side, or it has the top part. There's two walls on the side and a roof on top which is four. So either the steps are ten tefachim (handbreadths) high, either the steps are 10 tefachim high, or, if they're not 10 tefachim high or 4 by 4 wide, they have these two mechitzot on the side and an overhang on top, mashkof (lintel) on top, ceiling overhang on top.
So there you cannot carry from the garden, from the Karmelit, to get the key into the garden, because you're passing through a Reshut HaYachid. You can't go from a Karmelit to yachid to get to a karpef. We don't let you go from these steps into yachid or the other way around. We're afraid that if not, this will be considered whatever is in front of it. Like we said before, in front of another they merge; they become one with the other, like we had before: one Karmelit, another Karmelit.
“Now can I ask a question?” Anything you want. “My backyard, my three sons.” What about your backyard? What is it called? Princeton. It's not. Yeah. It's this. Nobody lives out there. Of course. It's cut a pipe slow. Got to do that. Correct. So right now, if I decide on Shabbat, I want to walk out with a couple of coffees—“You have a problem.” As of now, you have a problem. Except I will find you a heter (permission) there now. Finish it. I'll find you a heter there. There's a question. I can't hear what you're saying. I'm back. Don't be dramatic. Don't be dramatic. People are dying. Matt, I would say it.
The guy had a fence. What's Eruv? What's Eruv? Eruv is around your property. There's a roof around your property. There's a roof around your property. The guy had his own fence in his backyard. I asked you a question. They got an Eruv; it's a make-believe fence. The guy has a real fence. Okay, so it's Eruv. So we just said a ginah—you can't carry in a ginah, right? We have to find the heter that maybe, since it's attached to the house, we'll go there. Let's see. Give it a chance. Give the man a chance.
Lachen (therefore), Mishnah Berurah, you're dead. I know. Stop it. Mishnah Berurah, you're dead. Lachen, mutar lehotzi, haynu af lehachnis ha-derech (permitted to take out, that is, also to bring in through the way). The guy is taking the key, sticking it into the door and opening the door inside into the—no, the ginah. He's in the Karmelit. He left the key in the Karmelit. He's talking to the door: “Open now,” the key inside, as long as—which is, I want to say, the door of the garden is not the same as the door of shvel (threshold). You know what shvel is? Miftan.
Do you know what Miftan is? Say it. Everyone does it like this. Say what it is. What is Miftan? He goes like this. He saves it all. He saves it all. He asked the guy, “You know what a circular stairway is?” The guy goes, “Yeah.” Everyone is going like this. It's a famous thing. The guy starts going like this. I asked you to explain what it is without hands. I shut the lights. He can't see you. What's a miftan? In front of the door. It's a step in front of the door. A ledge. “The door.” “Saddle.” No, no, more than the saddle. Saddle is too thin. It's just on the carpet. This is higher, when you walk into a landing, like a landing like that. That's shvel, shvel, shvel. I know that's Yiddish, Yiddish, Yiddish, Adoli Yiddish. Oh, that's Yiddish. Oh, Yiddish. Do you know what that shvel is? I don't know what shvel is.
No, because that has whatever it is, it's going to become a Reshut HaYachid. We want to make sure this Reshut HaYachid should not interrupt between the Karmelit and the bik'ah (open plain). You're going from Karmelit to yachid and yachid to Karmelit. We can't all have that.