Good morning. Siman Shin Mem-Tet (section 349). The Mishnah Berurah told us at the beginning that every person has four amot (cubits) in the reshut harabim (public domain). That means that in the reshut harabim, I could walk less than four cubits. But then we learned, look, se'if bet (subsection 2): “arba amot she'amru hen ve'alakhsonan”—they and their diagonal. “She'nimtza she'hem chamesh amot v'shloshet chummashin.” So it comes out to be five and three-fifths.
Some say that from four amot to five and three-fifths is patur—you should not do it, but you're not going to be chayav (liable). So the Mishnah Berurah has explained now: Ted, patur aval asur (exempt but forbidden), zehudat haRambam, ayin bi'Ve'ur HaGra (the Gra's explanation), shekatar, gam haRambam modeh, dehecha sheberer lo arba amot etartel behem rotser etartel b'alek sonash anaba amot motar etartel behem af sh'olehat chamesh amot shosha chomashin. Wow, Gaon Revinat says that even the Rambam agrees where a person chose his four amot. That's why I'm saying: I'm in the street here, I'm here, okay, this is my four amot. Once you decide this is your four amot, I know where my four amot are. Now I can even carry five and three-fifths lechatchila (ideally), even with the Rambam. Why? Because I already decided.
So when does he argue? In the case where the guy only wants to carry straight, not in a—don't forget, always look at the direction of the world. I'm sitting here, I'm on the north side right here. This is the north. So if I want to go four amot, if I want to carry from here to the north side, I'm only allowed four amot, not five. You can't do five and three-fifths, not a circle. I don't know, you keep saying I don't have this in my head yet. I just—I have five four amot. I'm right here. I do four amot. If I want to go in a diagonal, if I want to go this way, I have five and three-fifths. But if I want to go each way of the direction of the world, I'm only up to four amot.
Oh, I don't have my four amot yet. I'm just in the street; I'm just—I'm random. I didn't yet decide which is my four amot. That's the amot you don't have, including the alakhsonan: only four amot. We have a rule: anyone who carries four amot and the alakhsonan—four amot and the diagonal—in the street is only when the distance between where he picked it up and where he put it down is beyond that amount. You put it beyond that amount. I told you, you have four amot. So when am I ever chayav if I'm here, right here now, and I carry more than four amot and the alakhsonan, and I put the thing outside that? That's when the guy is chayav. But if he has four amot and the alakhsonan and he puts it up to the edge, but within, be-patur. Because he didn't go first. That's patur.
Good. What a beautiful, big, huge—me and you—we have a whole assembly line in the street. Every person next to the other person. Listen carefully. I'm here, my friend's here next to me, 100 people all the way down. The guy all the way down says, “Hello, I need a banana in the street on Shabbat. Anyone have a banana?” I say, “I have a banana.” The guy next to me goes to the next guy, two amot. All the way till a hundred amot. I went all the way to the side. You got to do it. And there is someone who will do it. Stam (an anonymous ruling), mutar (permitted), and there is someone who will do it. Stam says it's forbidden. Let's see what. The buck of the grain. Mutar, Yod, Mishnah Baragimal. I'm Mishnah Yod. Mutar. Da'ab al-Gavdil, Kamat Sevei, Eta, Dadam, Echad, asur, Lory, Hefz, Bahot, Bahot, Marba Amod.
We're going to learn later in this page today that a person—why can't I go two amot, stop, I go two amot and stop, same thing, me, myself, all the way until I want to get home? I should do that. They thought that was Mataram today. People say that: go, stop, go, stop. We did find that if you got stuck on Friday and you have your wallet at home—you got stuck Friday afternoon, the bus was late, you got off the bus, it's Shabbat, and you have your wallet with you—if you have a goy (non-Jew) next to you, give it to the goy. If you have an animal, put it on the goy. If you have nothing, this is the last resort. We do do that: two, two, two. It's mutar, but Chazal (the Sages) don't want you to do that in general.
So that's what he's asking: if I'm allowed to do it myself with that wallet, I may go all four in one shot and not stop in between. So why do we have a lot to give to each guy on the chain here? Since there are so many different people and each guy does less than four, even though through all of them the cheftz (object) moved through a lot of places. Don't forget, you can't go outside the techum (Sabbath boundary). If there's a techum problem, then you don't save anything. Let's say this banana belongs to me and my techum is only up there, but the last guy, 100 and what long, is in a different techum. I can't give my banana, so it's in my techum. Many milin, many milin is always outside the techum, or it could be a cheftz that's hefker (ownerless). A cheftz has no techum, has no shevita (Sabbath resting place). A cheftz is something that belongs to nobody, has no techum, so it could go more than the amount. Let's say this banana is hefker, right? The guy at the end of the line, 100 milin, says, “I need a banana.” So I say, “Okay, I have a banana, hefker.” I keep placing it down. If one guy in the middle decides, “Oh, I'm going to be zocheh (acquire) it. I'm going to be zocheh. I'll be zocheh.” That's it. That becomes his techum. And the other guy can't get it, can't go out there. You'd wait.
Yes, Mishael said, “Why?” And according to this opinion, even when they allow you to carry less than four amot at a time—the one I just told you—someone who got caught in the evening. He got caught at night and it's Shabbat and he's stuck with a wallet. What should he do? Walk pachot pachot (less than four cubits at a time) or Motzei Tefillin. Another case is, you found tefillin (phylacteries) in the street, and Moshe mentioned Aleph. It comes out as a very Hiddush (novel insight). We learned, as he mentioned Aleph: if you found tefillin, walk pachot. If you have no other choice, walk pachot pachot, marba'a mot. Me, myself, and same thing with my wallet: me, myself, I have no choice. Two or more, stop; two or more, stop; two or more, stop. But let's have a lot of people, the chain, a hundred guys, so let me use that. The chain is worse. So yeah, you can't do that; you can only do it yourself. Brings it down. In Shin Aleph, Maran (our master) holds that it is allowed. You can, yes, go with the chain as much as you want. But in the case of tefillin, Maran goes with the first opinion. Here he brought stam and yesh (there is another opinion). Over there he wants stam. If it's just a banana or something, reshut, something voluntary, something, you know, no mitzvah involved, don't be a meikel (lenient person). It's too dangerous. Reda.
Z'ma shidda me'habeha u'l-khaida harbe min'adam enu marif kim li'ayna harukha bit'shut harbe min'karmelit (semi-public domain). Right. This heter (halachic allowance) only allows you in the street or karmelit. I can't go from yachid (private domain) to karmelit, or vice versa. I can't go from yachid to Shabbat. There are certain people in Shabbat who have certain kulot (leniencies), certain congregations that do something which is not proper. Do you know what they do? Sh'notnim sefer Torah (Torah scroll) beit haknesset (synagogue) for khin derghar et hov, sh'yalko parim karmelit, ayidoh sh'atayim yachay l'chaber hov, chod marva'amot.
People want to give a Torah to the Shul. That's what they want to do, a hachnasat sefer Torah (bringing in a Torah scroll) on Shabbat. So what do they do? The guy brings it from your house—you have a new Torah in your house—and you give it to the guy outside, and he gives it to another guy, not a guy, not a guy, not a guy, not a guy, all the way to shul. Don't do that. No, because they think that from yachid he's starting out in yachid and karmelit. You cannot. This heter only goes in the chain, the chain case. Well, here I make it hefker; it's not hefker, not hefker. No, forget hefker. Hefker is only for techum. We just said this whole heter, the one that says you could do the chain, is in reshut harabim, straight, on one side of reshut harabim. He's going from—you go over the border from inside your house to the outside a drop, take a needle across your thing, you're done. The task goes on that halakha. You want to bring the Torah through a goy, even through a goy, don't do it. It seems it's a big shaila (halachic question) over there. Sometimes for a milah (circumcision), to bring a baby or to bring the knife, could be there is a I dig on it. We had a Mishnah, se'if dalet (subsection 4) had two from a small group of this.
Within this group he had two people sitting next to each other, my and that food in one, and you're next to each other. We're in four amot of each other. Let's say six amot. We're in the street, so I have a banana, you don't, and you ask me, “Oh, I'm hungry. Can I have a banana?” Maybe eat more clean. We could bring it in the middle and eat in the middle, because you come to my four amot, your four amot, you're four and he's four in between. Overlap—you overlap my four, so you can eat in the middle. You can't bring, you can't, you can't, you cannot go. Don't forget, you have six amot between us, so the four amot are here and the four amot are there, and there are two amot that overlap each other. That middle ground, you can go there and eat it there. So I can give it to you there and you can eat it there, but you can't take it back to your resting place, because that means my thing went to six amot. No good.
Let's say three people. Beautiful case. Let's say you have three people: me, Eli, and Richie. Now me to reach you, the two other guys, eight or more. No, you're in the middle on the four, you're within. So me to him, I can't send anything. I give to you and he give to you; you give to him, you give to him. No, let's see what he said. One guy, this is going to the first case. One guy has four amot and his one has food in his first amot, right in the beginning. The same guy also has four amot, with food in his four amot, on the other side. This is the first case where there's only six between us, so the middle two amot belong to both of us. I have four, you have four, but we're six apart, so my second two and your second two are the same two. That's okay, so I can bring my food to the end of my four amot, which is part of your four amot, and you can eat over there. It's the overlap case. But the other case, look at Vav (letter vav): I'm trying to move in the hands of three people, and there's eight amot. Three people, eight amot. No problem. No, only the middle guy. The middle guy has food. He's getting from both guys. His four amot go into both. He can go two amot into the guy, two amot into this guy. So the middle guy is allowed to take food from each one of the other ones. The two other ones are not allowed to take food from each other. Amen (so be it).