A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Shmuel Choueka

Torah Lecture

Mishna Berura Hilchot Shabbat Siman 349 Seif 1

Lectured by Rabbi Shmuel Choueka

Published
December 21, 2025
Duration
15:53
Lecture code
RSC-4248

Four Amot and the Diagonal

  • Rabbi Shmuel Choueka reviews the rule that each person has four amot (cubits) in the reshut harabim (public domain). Se'if bet says that “four amot” includes their diagonal, making the total diagonal measure five amot and three-fifths.
  • Some opinions treat movement beyond four amot but within five and three-fifths as patur aval asur (exempt but forbidden).
  • Citing the Bi'ur HaGra, Rabbi Shmuel explains that even the Rambam agrees that when a person has chosen and established his four amot, he may use the diagonal extent of five and three-fifths lechatchila. The disagreement concerns a case where the person has not established his four amot.
  • The direction of movement matters: in a straight direction aligned with the directions of the world, the limit is four amot; on a diagonal, it is five and three-fifths.
  • If a person has not yet designated his four amot and is simply in the street, he has only four amot, including the diagonal.
  • Liability depends on the distance between where the object was picked up and where it was put down. If the object is placed beyond the permitted distance, the person is chayav; if it remains within the applicable limit, he is patur.

Passing an Object Along a Chain

  • Rabbi Shmuel describes a line of people in the street, each passing an object less than four amot to the next person, so that it travels a much greater distance overall. He notes that there are differing opinions about whether this is permitted.
  • He asks why someone could not instead carry the object himself in repeated intervals of less than four amot, stopping between each interval. For someone stranded on Shabbat with a wallet, the preferred alternatives include giving it to a goy or placing it on an animal. If there is no alternative, carrying it pachot pachot (less than four cubits at a time) is a last resort. This may be done in an emergency, but Chazal do not want it used as a general practice.
  • The same last-resort approach applies to someone who finds tefillin in the street: if there is no other choice, he may move them in intervals of less than four amot, stopping between them. Rabbi Shmuel contrasts this with passing an object along a chain, which he says is more problematic.
  • Rabbi Shmuel cites Siman Shin Aleph, where Maran permits passing an object along a chain. In the case of tefillin, however, Maran follows the first opinion. He notes that here the text presents a stam and a yesh, whereas there Maran follows the stam. For an ordinary item such as a banana, with no mitzvah involved, he cautions against being lenient.

Techum and the Limits of the Heter

  • The chain arrangement does not overcome techum restrictions. An owned object cannot be sent beyond its techum; a person cannot use the chain to bring an object into a different techum.
  • Rabbi Shmuel explains that a hefker object has no techum or shevita while it remains ownerless. If someone along the chain becomes zocheh in it, it acquires that person’s techum, and those farther along cannot take it beyond that limit.
  • The heter applies within the reshut harabim or a karmelit; it does not permit transferring an object between domains. Rabbi Shmuel warns that it cannot be used to take an object from a yachid into another domain, or vice versa.
  • He applies this to attempts to bring a new Sefer Torah from a private home to the beit haknesset on Shabbat by passing it from person to person. The chain heter does not allow this, since the object crosses a domain boundary; even moving a small item such as a needle across the boundary presents the issue. Rabbi Shmuel also cautions against doing this through a goy, noting that it is a significant shaila.
  • He distinguishes this from a possible separate discussion concerning milah, such as bringing a baby or a knife, and refers to Mishnah se'if dalet.

Overlapping Four-Amot Areas

  • Rabbi Shmuel explains that two people six amot apart have overlapping four-amot areas: two amot belong to both areas. One person may bring food to that shared area, where the other may eat it, but the recipient may not take it back to his own resting place, since that would move it beyond the permitted distance.
  • He then considers three people, with eight amot in the example. The middle person’s four-amot area reaches into the areas of both others—two amot toward each—so he may take food from either of them. The two people on the ends may not transfer food directly between themselves.