Today, the Talmud recounts a story about Reb Chiya and Reb Yonatan, who were both walking through a cemetery. Reb Yonatan’s tzitzit were not fully tucked in, and they were actually being dragged upon the graves. That means the fringes of his tzitzit were dragging on the graves. So Reb Chiya told him, “Lift them up!” Reb Yonatan answered, “Why do I need to lift them? Do the dead know what goes on in this world? There’s a verse in Kohelet that King Solomon writes, and he says that the dead don’t know anything.” Meaning, once they pass on and they’re in the world to come, they don’t know what goes on in this world.
Reb Chiya answered, “That is not the proper way to understand that verse. Go back and learn it. And if you learned it, review it. And if you reviewed it, review it another time. And if you still don’t know, well, come back and I’ll explain to you the way to understand that verse.” And he does. Reb Chiya goes back to the beginning of that verse, which says, and I quote, “For the living know that they will die, but the dead know nothing.” This is the way the Talmud explains this verse. The first part, saying that the living know when they will die, is talking about tzaddikim, righteous people: even when they die—meaning, even when they die in this world—they still continue to live. The opposite is true. He explains that “the dead know nothing” is talking about wicked people: even when they’re alive, breathing, and in this world, they’re still considered to be dead.
When I read this, I try to look at it and ask, how do I understand this? I see righteous people who pass away. We all go to their funeral. They’re no longer here. We see wicked people, and they’re fully living. They’re breathing, they’re eating, they’re having a great time. What does it mean when the Talmud is explaining to us that righteous people are really alive even after they die, and that wicked people are really dead when they are alive? Let’s understand each of these statements independently first, and we’ll see how they tie together.
A righteous person is someone who is obviously righteous: they’re doing the right thing, they’re accomplished. When they pass on, well, they still live through their memory and the honor of those they affected during their lifetime. This continues. This continues even after they die. Likewise, as we see with Jacob, our patriarch, the Talmud in Ta’anit tells us that Jacob really never died. How could that be? Well, the truth is that righteous people don’t die. Yes, their bodies may die. Their bodies expire in this world, but they continue to live on with their children and protect them. So that’s what it means that a righteous person is still considered alive.
Now let’s look at a wicked individual. Someone who’s wicked is someone who’s making the wrong choices over and over and over. In the world of nature and science, something that isn’t growing is by definition dead. We see this with all living creatures. We see this with vegetation, insects, animals, and humans. The definition of dead is not growing. So, consequently, the definition of life is growing. As Jews, we always need to be looking for opportunities to grow. Every right decision we make, every good deed, every time we connect to God, learn Torah, or spread His light—we are actually growing. So let us strive to always grow and not be the unfortunate dead. Meaning, let’s always aim to be righteous so we can live not only in this world, but continuously, and not the opposite. Unfortunately, if someone is wicked and is considered dead—again, because they are not growing...
