A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Yaakov Hillel

Torah Lecture

Yortzit Of Rabbenu Ha’Ari Z”L -

Lectured by Rabbi Yaakov Hillel

Published
August 6, 2019
Duration
101:53
Lecture code
RYH-71

The Halachic Background: Night, Day, and Tzitzit

  • Rabbi Yaakov Hillel begins by explaining that the Ari and the Rashash’s words about an inner and outer act are not discussed at length in the seven discourses on tzitzit in Sha’ar ha-Kavanot. The relevant explanation appears in the discourses on the morning prayers, which describe the rectification of the four worlds, ABY’A, through four actions: tzitzit katan, tzitzit gadol, hand tefilin, and head tefilin. The four parts of prayer—korbanot, zemirot, yotzer, and the Amidah—also rectify inner and outer aspects of the worlds.
  • The starting point for the halachah is the Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chayim 18:1: “Night is not the time for tzitzit,” based on “And you shall see it.”
  • The Rambam and the Rosh disagree about whether the garment or the time determines the obligation:
  • The Rambam holds that anything worn at night is exempt, even a garment designated for daytime; anything worn during the day is obligated, even if designated as a night garment.
  • The Rosh holds that the garment’s designation determines the obligation: a garment designated for sleeping at night is exempt even when worn by day, while a day garment remains obligated even when worn at night.
  • The Rema rules that, because of doubt about blessings, one blesses only when wearing a garment that is designated for the day and is being worn during the day.
  • A tallit katan appears to be a garment designated for both day and night. Under the Shulchan Aruch’s ruling in siman 18, one blesses on it when wearing it during the day, but not at night.
  • However, the Shulchan Aruch later rules, in siman 8:17, that one who sleeps in a tallit at night must bless over it in the morning even if he did not remove it. It is good to touch the tzitzit at the time of the blessing, as a renewed awareness of the mitzvah.
  • This ruling is based on a responsum of the Rosh. It appears to conflict with the Rosh’s halachic work, which distinguishes between day and night garments. The Beit Yosef resolves the apparent contradiction: everyone agrees that night exempts a garment designated for night; the Rosh’s responsum concerns a day garment, for which the night interrupts and requires a new blessing in the morning. The Shulchan Aruch follows the responsum of the Rosh.
  • The Magen Avraham, the Eliyah Rabbah, the Sheyarei Keneset HaGedolah, and later authorities including the Mishnah Berurah are concerned about the doubt over blessing on a tallit katan worn during sleep. Their practical solution is not to bless separately on it in the morning, but to include it in the blessing on the tallit gadol.
  • Thus, the Shulchan Aruch’s ruling follows the Rosh’s responsum, while the Tur, Bach, and others disagree. Later authorities generally avoid a separate blessing because of the dispute.
  • The Yad David and Rabbi Ya’akov Algazi, in Shalmei Tzibbur, report testimony from Mohara Yitzchaki, author of Sefer Shut Zera Yitzchak, who said he saw a responsum in Maran’s handwriting in which Maran had changed his mind and ruled not to bless. Rabbi Hillel questions whether a report, even one conveyed by a great authority, can overturn the ruling in the Shulchan Aruch—especially since the Beit Yosef himself raised and resolved the apparent contradiction.

The Ari and the Rashash on the Two Tallitot

  • Rabbi Hillel turns to the Ari’s account in Sha’ar ha-Kavanot, the third discourse on the morning prayer. The Ari describes the two tallitot as rectifications in the world of Formation: the tallit katan corresponds to its inner aspect, and the tallit gadol to its outer aspect.
  • The act of wearing relates to the or ha-penimi, while the blessings rectify the or makif of each tallit. The Ari’s account describes a blessing for the tallit katan as well as for the tallit gadol.
  • The Rashash writes similarly in Nahar Shalom: through wearing and blessing on the tallit katan, one rectifies its relevant aspects; wearing and blessing on the tallit gadol rectifies the outer aspect. Rabbi Hillel understands the Ari and Rashash to require a blessing each day on both tallitot, since each is a separate rectification.
  • Rabbi Hillel notes a question about the Rashash’s wording, “through wearing the tallit katan”: does it refer to putting it on anew in the morning, or to blessing on a tallit that has remained on the person overnight? Rabbi Hillel says the straightforward meaning is the act of putting it on, but the text does not settle the question by itself.

The Ari’s View That Tzitzit Katan Applies at Night

  • Rabbi Hillel cites the Ari’s first discourse on the night in Sha’ar ha-Kavanot: although the Gemara says night is not the time for tzitzit, the Ari says this applies only to the tallit gadol, in which a person wraps his head and arms.
  • The Ari explains that the tallit gadol is associated with the surrounding light drawn during prayer and with Ze’ir Anpin, the attribute of day. At night, the flow departs, and the tallit gadol’s surrounding light does not apply.
  • The tallit katan, by contrast, corresponds to the state of pregnancy, when Ze’ir Anpin is in a state of smallness and lacks mental lights. It is worn only on the body, like the folded fetus described by Chazal, whose head and limbs are enclosed in its body. This aspect remains even at night.
  • According to the Ari, when blessing on the tallit katan one should wrap oneself in it in the Ishmaelite manner, as with a tallit gadol, and then wear it on the body without covering the head or arms. The Ari’s blessing is “to wrap oneself in tzitzit”; the blessing “concerning the commandment of tzitzit” is attributed to the early authorities, not to the Sages.
  • Rabbi Hillel says the tallit katan should not be removed during the day or night, including when going to bed. The exception he gives is going to the bathhouse. Asked whether the Ben Ish Chai describes a special garment for marital relations, he says he has not heard of such a practice.
  • The Ari’s position is that the tallit katan remains a mitzvah at night, while the tallit gadol does not. “Night is not the time for tzitzit” refers to the tallit gadol.

David in the Bathhouse and the Nighttime Mitzvah

  • The Ari supports his view with the Gemara in Menachot 43b. When David entered the bathhouse and found himself naked, he said, “Woe is me, for I am naked of mitzvot.” He then remembered his circumcision and was comforted.
  • The Gemara identifies tzitzit, tefilin, and mezuzah as mitzvot that provide protection; circumcision also provided David protection. The Ari asks why David was not distressed when he slept, if sleeping meant being without the mitzvah of tzitzit katan. Rabbi Hillel understands the Ari to mean that David slept wearing a tallit katan, so he remained protected.
  • Rabbi Hillel distinguishes the mitzvah’s own rectification from the daily rectification through the four actions. A mitzvah may have its own rectification in Atzilut, Beriah, Yetzirah, and Asiyah, while only some mitzvot also participate in the daily rectifications associated with prayer.
  • For example, the Rashash describes relieving oneself as fulfilling the prohibition against making oneself repulsive, whose mitzvah rectification is in Emanation; in the daily order, however, relieving oneself belongs to the world of Action. Tzitzit likewise has its own mitzvah rectification, while in the daily four-world system it participates in the outer aspect of Yetzirah and below. These are two distinct rectifications.
  • Rabbi Hillel argues that the Ari’s question about David’s sleep supports the nighttime mitzvah itself: if David had removed the tallit katan, the same concern about being without mitzvot would have arisen at night. At night, the four-action daily rectification is not in operation in the same way; the nighttime tikun is through the mitzvah.
  • In the wording of Sha’ar ha-Tefillah, the Ari asks why David was not distressed while sleeping if he was without the mitzvah of tzitzit katan. Rabbi Hillel says this explicitly indicates that David fulfilled the mitzvah by wearing it at night. The mitzvah’s protective power depends on it being an actual mitzvah.
  • From this, Rabbi Hillel understands that the Ari’s proof establishes both that tallit katan applies at night and that the Gemara’s statement about night refers to tallit gadol. Since the mitzvah is real at night, it can also participate in the daily rectification through the mental lights of pregnancy.
  • The Rashash’s instruction to prepare before the blessing on tzitzit is relevant here. Although mitzvot ordinarily cause the ascent of feminine waters and the drawing down of mental lights, this mitzvah has both its own rectification and a daily-world rectification. The intention to perform the mitzvah gives the blessing power to effect the daily rectification; merely wearing a garment that is not being worn as a mitzvah would not do so.
  • Rabbi Hillel notes that the Ari and Rashash use related wording about tefilin and the recitation of Shema as well as tzitzit, in connection with mitzvot that participate in the daily worlds.
  • He also raises the mitzvah of “And you shall see it.” The Ramban regards looking at the tzitzit as a positive commandment from the Torah, and Rabbi Hillel asks whether this aspect is a rectification in Emanation. The discussion considers whether fringes must be visible at night; Rabbi Hillel notes that one can take them out and look at them, while also observing that a person may not actually see them in darkness or when they are covered.
  • Asked about women, Rabbi Hillel says the Ari clearly holds that women have no connection to the mitzvah of tzitzit, by day or by night. Although night is associated with Nukva, the tallit katan’s nighttime aspect is Ze’ir Anpin in pregnancy. The apparent implication that a nighttime obligation would make tzitzit not time-dependent is discussed; Rabbi Hillel distinguishes the plain halachic discussion from the Ari’s explanation and says the Ari treats the mitzvah as time-dependent, with women not obligated.

Blessing in the Morning and the New Daily Rectification

  • Rabbi Hillel asks how, according to the Ari, one blesses in the morning if the nighttime obligation of tallit katan was not interrupted. He suggests that the new day creates a new obligation and a new daily rectification, even though the person wore the tallit katan throughout the night.
  • He compares this to Birchot HaTorah: the Magen Avraham says that even someone who did not sleep all night blesses at dawn because a new day brings a new obligation. Sleep can create an interruption, but the obligation of the new day is a separate consideration.
  • Rabbi Akiva Eiger, in his comments on Orach Chayim 21, sees support for the Rosh’s view in the Ari’s teaching that one wears a tallit katan at night and fulfills an actual mitzvah through it. The Levushei Serad explains that the Magen Avraham uses the Ari to support the Rosh’s position that a day garment is obligated at night.
  • Rabbi Hillel distinguishes the reasons for the morning blessing: for the Rosh, the night interrupts the mitzvah; according to the Ari, the new day requires a new rectification, even if the nighttime obligation continued.
  • On this basis, Rabbi Hillel says that if someone takes off the tallit katan for a long time at night, diverts his attention from it, or changes to another one, the Rosh’s view would require a blessing when he puts it on again, because a day garment is obligated at night.
  • He also sees support for blessing in the morning after sleeping in the tallit katan from the Rosh’s responsum, as recorded by Maran in the Beit Yosef and Shulchan Aruch. The night is an interruption according to that ruling; the Ari’s explanation, however, is the new day and its rectification.
  • Rabbi Hillel says that this approach can accommodate the Ari’s view alongside the Rosh and Maran’s ruling.

Yom Kippur: The Exception for Tallit Gadol at Night

  • The Ari calls the custom of wearing a tallit gadol on the eve of Yom Kippur a proper custom. Rabbi Hillel explains that the tallit is generally a surrounding light of Ze’ir Anpin, whether in the aspect of tallit katan associated with pregnancy or nursing, or tallit gadol associated with maturity.
  • On Yom Kippur night, Rachel has dominion and rises before Ze’ir Anpin until the afternoon prayer; from the afternoon prayer onward, Ze’ir Anpin ascends. In the Ari’s account, this is the one time in the year when the tallit gadol relates to the Nukva, so one wraps in it.
  • Rabbi Hillel contrasts this with the Rashash’s explanation. The Rashash treats the Yom Kippur service as work on a fifth point, a different set of worlds: after the work of Rosh Hashanah and the Ten Days of Repentance on the fourth point, Yom Kippur works to bring the fifth point to the level of the fourth. Rabbi Hillel says the Ari’s passage is not using the Rashash’s framework.
  • Rabbi Hillel explains that the tallit gadol on Yom Kippur night is connected to Rachel’s ascent to the head of Tevunah, where the Supernal Mother surrounds her with tzitzit. On other nights, the Nukva does not ascend in this way, so there is no corresponding tallit gadol.
  • No blessing is said on the Yom Kippur night tallit gadol because the rectification occurs on its own, not through the person’s action. Rabbi Hillel notes that the question of blessing after sunset is separate; those who delay are concerned about doubt in blessings.
  • He draws a contrast: on ordinary nights, if a person puts on a tallit katan, the rectification occurs through wearing it as a mitzvah, so the reasoning he presents supports blessing on it. On Yom Kippur night, the rectification is accomplished independently, so no blessing is said.

Prayerbooks and the Separate Blessings for Each Tallit

  • Rabbi Hillel cites Rabbi Avraham Tubiana, author of Chesed Le’Avraham, as a clear authority supporting the Ari’s position. Tubiana acknowledges the dispute about blessing in the morning after sleeping in a tallit katan: the Shulchan Aruch requires a blessing, while the Rosh, Bach, and Taz do not; the Magen Avraham and Rabbi Chaim HaKohen, a student of the Rachav, say that the tallit gadol exempts it.
  • Despite the dispute, Tubiana concludes from the Ari’s words that a separate blessing is required on the tallit katan, as well as on the tallit gadol. Without the tallit katan blessing, he argues, the surrounding light described as being rectified through that blessing would not be rectified.
  • Tubiana also cites the Mishnat Chassidim, which assigns distinct vocalizations of the Divine Name to the blessings on the two tallitot: patach and tzerah for the tallit katan, and kamatz and cholam for the tallit gadol. Its source is a note at the end of chapter 6 of the Gate of Tzitzit in Pri Etz Chayim. Rabbi Hillel takes this distinction as evidence of separate blessings and separate intentions.
  • Rabbi Hillel says the printed prayerbooks of the Ari explicitly give two blessings. In the Zolkiew prayerbook, when the day dawns a person touches the tallit katan, intends its rectification of the inner aspects of Netzach and Hod of Yetzirah, and blesses “to wrap oneself in tzitzit,” even if he slept in it and is already wearing it.
  • The Zolkiew prayerbook then gives a distinct tallit gadol intention, associated with the outer aspects of Netzach and Hod of Yetzirah, and a second “to wrap oneself in tzitzit” blessing. Rabbi Hillel identifies this as the prayerbook of the Ramaf, Rabbi Meir Poppers, who says in his introduction that he received the intentions from Rabbi Ya’akov Tzemach, who copied them from Rabbeinu Chaim Vital’s prayerbook.
  • Rabbi Hillel recalls seeing, about 45 years earlier, the Ramaf’s handwritten prayerbook, like the Zolkiew edition, bearing the Rashash’s signature and notes. He also cites the Siddur Rav Shabtai and prayerbooks by Sephardic Sages, including the Remaz, as giving two blessings and distinct vocalizations.
  • In the printed prayerbook of the Rashash, Rabbi Shaul Dwek’s edition from Taf-Resh-Ayin-Alef and the complete edition of Hacham Yom Tov Yedid and his son Rabbi Eliezer Yedid from Taf-Resh-Ayin-Vav give the blessing text once, followed by the intentions for the tallit katan and then the tallit gadol.
  • Rabbi Hillel says the Rashash’s position is nevertheless clear from Nahar Shalom: a blessing is needed for each tallit. He explains that the Rashash prayerbook’s long blessing text may be printed once for economy and then used for multiple mitzvot; some handwritten prayerbooks likewise give one blessing text before intentions for tallit katan, tallit gadol, hand tefilin, and head tefilin.

The Beit El Prayerbook’s Different Approach

  • Rabbi Hillel says that Yereh changed the order in the prayerbooks of the Sages of Beit El, apparently holding that one does not bless on the tallit katan. In his initial arrangement, he gives the tallit katan intentions without a blessing and then the blessing and intentions for the tallit gadol.
  • A later note says that those whose custom is not to remove the tallit katan even in bed at night do not bless over it in the morning. It nevertheless recommends intending the tallit katan intentions before putting on the tallit gadol, to illuminate the mental lights of smallness so that the mental lights of maturity drawn through the tallit gadol can rest upon them.
  • Rabbi Hillel regards this as a novel approach against the Ari and Rashash. As he understands their prayerbooks, the tallit katan intentions draw down the mental lights through the mitzvah; the Beit El explanation instead treats them as illuminating previously existing lights, not drawing down new ones, because it does not regard the tallit katan as a new mitzvah in this case.
  • He says that interpreting the wording as “illuminate” rather than “draw down” is only a way to judge Yereh favorably. In Rabbi Hillel’s view, the Ari and Rashash clearly connect the drawing down to the mitzvah and its blessing, and the prayerbooks do not support reversing that meaning.
  • Rabbi Hillel suggests that the authorities may have been influenced by Shalmei Tzibbur, which says a blessing on tallit katan is made only when coming out of the ritual bath. He finds it difficult that learned authorities did not address the explicit words of the Ari and Rashash, while allowing that there may be a distinction between continuing with the same tallit katan and changing to a different one.
  • As an extra measure of care, Rabbi Hillel recommends wearing a different tallit katan each day, but not designating one solely for nighttime use. He says this is his own practice: he blesses every day and changes garments daily as a stringency. If he had only one tallit, he would bless on the one he had.

Further Support and Questions About the Gemara’s Proof

  • Rabbi Hillel says he has a longer discussion supporting the view that each new day requires the blessings and rectifications anew, as with Birchot HaShachar. The Ari attributes the renewal to the custom of the upper worlds, where the rectifications of the blessings are renewed each day.
  • He finds *Shalmei Tzibbur*’s conclusion—that the Ari did not bless on tallit katan in the morning, but only after removing it at the ritual bath—puzzling and contrary to the Ari’s and Rashash’s wording.
  • He notes objections raised by later authorities to the Gemara’s proof from David: perhaps David had a mezuzah, although it may have been outside the bathhouse and not protective inside; perhaps a mezuzah was present when he slept at home. The Ya’avetz responds that royal palaces had problematic doorways and it might not have been clear where to place a mezuzah. Rabbi Hillel also mentions the suggestion that David, as a soldier, slept in fields or caves. He says these discussions do not produce a practical halachic difference.

The Ari’s Tallit at Sunset and Kabbalat Shabbat

  • Rabbi Hillel recounts that the Ari would leave Safed, go into the surrounding fields, ascend a hill, and say Kabbalat Shabbat facing west. When he saw the sun going down, he said “Come, bride” three times, then returned through the fields to his home.
  • Rabbi Hillel estimates that the psalms and walk took time—roughly ten minutes for Kabbalat Shabbat and another ten minutes to return, even if the Ari hurried. He speculates that the Ari was about 35, 36, or 37 years old at the time.
  • At home, the Ari wrapped himself in a tallit and made a circuit around the table while repeating Kabbalat Shabbat. The account does not say that he removed the tallit afterward; he went to the synagogue, arriving when the congregation was saying the Kaddish before Barechu or Barechu. Before leaving, he had also read four chapters of Mishnah.
  • This raises a difficulty because the Ari is described as removing his tallit and tefilin after weekday Minchah when he saw the sun had set, yet apparently wearing a tallit again after sunset for the second Kabbalat Shabbat.
  • Rabbi Hillel considers whether the Ari followed Rabbeinu Tam, which would remove the difficulty, but says the evidence is not conclusive. Maharchu’s testimony that the Ari removed the tallit when he saw the sun setting may indicate sunset according to the Geonim. Rav Pe’alim, in Sod Yesharim 3:13, also understands the Ari as following the Geonim, while addressing the difficulty that his long, intention-filled Minchah could extend into night.
  • The Ben Ish Chai, however, says that the Ari accepted Shabbat about half an hour before sunset. Rabbi Hillel also cites Rabbi Amani and other authorities who place the Ari with the Geonim, and concludes that one cannot state definitively that the Ari followed Rabbeinu Tam.
  • One proposed explanation among halachic authorities and Kabbalists is that twilight is a suitable time to wrap in tzitzit because the fringes can still be seen. Rabbi Hillel asks why this would resolve the contrast between weekday removal of the tallit after sunset and the tallit worn for Kabbalat Shabbat.
  • He distinguishes the Ari’s wording: for Kabbalat Shabbat in the field, the Ari specifies the time of the sun’s actual setting, when one accepts the additional holiness of Shabbat. For removing the tallit after Minchah, the Ari says to remove it if the person sees that the sun has already set. Rabbi Hillel reads this as possibly referring to a time after the actual moment of sunset.
  • Other passages say that the Ari often prayed Minchah close to sunset. In Sha’ar ha-Mitzvot, he is described as delaying Minchah in order to borrow money to pay a worker his wages, then paying the worker and praying quickly. Sefer HaLikutim says he delayed until after sunset; Sefer Me’orot Natan also records Minchah after sunset.
  • Pri Etz Chayim says the Ari was careful to pray Minchah wearing tallit and tefilin and not remove them until after Aleinu. Sefer Me’orot Natan likewise says he was careful to pray at sunset, even after sunset, and to remain in tallit and tefilin. Rabbi Hillel also cites Mishnat Chassidim on not delaying payment of a worker’s wages for Minchah and on praying in tallit and tefilin even if the prayer must be delayed until after sunset.
  • These accounts, Rabbi Hillel argues, show that the Ari was not necessarily strict about removing tallit and tefilin immediately at sunset. This helps resolve the apparent conflict with his wearing a tallit for Kabbalat Shabbat.
  • Rabbi Hillel also raises the view, cited by the Beit Yosef in the name of the Mordechai and by other authorities, that tzitzit depends on seeing the fringes rather than on daytime as such. On that view, whenever one can see the fringes, one may wrap and bless; twilight still permits this.
  • The discussion asks how “And you shall see it” applies to tallit katan at night. Rabbi Hillel answers that a person can use a lamp and look, and that the fringes can be taken out even if the garment is under other clothing. He also notes the question of what seeing means when the fringes are covered or it is dark.
  • Another possible explanation is that twilight remains day according to Rabbi Yosi, with stringency regarding Shabbat following Rabbi Yehudah. Rabbi Hillel refers to Bi’ur Halachah and Shut Or LeTziyon, which discusses and supports the Rambam’s view that the halachah follows Rabbi Yosi, with stringency applied for Shabbat.
  • Rabbi Hillel proposes another possible parallel: Shabbat night may resemble Yom Kippur night, when the Nukva ascends without Ze’ir Anpin, and a tallit may therefore apply. The Ari wore one, although this is not the general Friday-night practice.
  • Rabbi Eliyahu Mani questioned the Beit El custom of removing the tallit at sunset and shifting Kabbalat Shabbat earlier to do so. He argued that from the time of the Rashash onward, people had worn the tallit after sunset.

Practical Conclusions and Remaining Cases

  • Rabbi Hillel’s stated conclusion is that tallit katan should be worn at night, and a blessing may be said on it in the morning even if it was worn throughout the night. He suggests that according to the Rosh, since a day garment is obligated at night, a person who wakes before dawn may be able to bless then.
  • Asked whether this would be too early for the daily rectification, Rabbi Hillel compares it to Birchot HaShachar, which can be recited after midnight. The morning blessings begin the rectification of the daily configuration in the world of Action; tallit katan can likewise be part of that rectification.
  • Asked about removing a tallit katan for a shower and putting it back on, Rabbi Hillel discusses hesech hadaat. The Ben Ish Chai’s concern is associated with going to the ritual bath; the Ari’s extended kavanot could involve a two- or three-hour interruption. Rabbi Hillel says a prolonged interruption may warrant a blessing, including after swimming, but recommends changing to a new tallit katan each day to satisfy the different opinions. He says that, when done to resolve a doubt, this is not an unnecessary blessing.