For some reason, you didn’t fully appreciate and understand the words of the Ari (the Arizal) and the Rashash (Rabbi Shalom Sharabi): bekavanah ma’aseh penimi vechitzoni (with intention, an inner and an outer act). It could be because the drushei (discourses on) tzitzit (ritual fringes) are seven long discourses in Sha’ar ha-Kavanot (Gate of Intentions), where everything is discussed, but this specific point is not really mentioned in the discourses on tzitzit. It is mentioned in the discourses on the morning prayers, concerning the tikun (rectification) of the four worlds, ABY’A (four worlds), through four actions: inwardly, tzitzit katan (small prayer garment), tzitzit gadol (large prayer shawl), the hand tefilin (phylacteries) and the head tefilin; and in the external and internal aspects of the worlds, the four parts of prayer: korbanot (offerings), zemirot (songs), yotzer (the formation blessing), and the Amidah. There, the Ari made very clear statements concerning this question.
Of course, the first place you have to look concerning this halachah (Jewish law) is in the Shulchan Aruch. Maran (our master) writes in Orach Chayim (Path of Life), siman (section) yud-chet, se’if (paragraph) alef: lailah lav zeman tzitzit hu (Night is not the time for tzitzit), de’chtiv ur’item oto (as it is written, “And you shall see it”), as the Gemara says. Concerning this, there is a machloket (dispute) between the Rambam (Maimonides) and the Rosh (Rabbeinu Asher). The Rambam says, kol mah shelovesh balailah patur, afilu hu beged meyuchad leyom (anything worn at night is exempt, even if it is a garment designated for the day). Even if you wear at night the clothes you wear during the day, you are exempt from tzitzit because night is not the time for tzitzit. Whatever you wear during the day, even if it is a night garment, is obligated, since you are wearing it during the day, and the day obligates it. That is the Rambam’s view.
But the Rosh says that it does not depend on day and night. It depends on the type of garment: kesut hameyuchad lalailah (a garment designated for the night)—if it is a garment you sleep in at night, it is exempt even if you wear it during the day. Vechesut hameyuchad leyom (and a garment designated for the day)—if it is something you wear during the day and at night, and you can also sleep in it, it is obligated even if you wear it at night. You are obligated to have tzitzit on this garment even if you are wearing it at night. That means it is not night and day that determine the matter, but the type of garment.
The Rema (Rabbi Moses Isserles) writes there that safek berachot lehakeil (in a doubt about blessings, rule leniently), and therefore, ein levarech alav ela keshelovesh bayom vehu meyuchad gam ken leyom (one should bless over it only when wearing it during the day and when it is also designated for the day). You have to satisfy all the opinions. You say a blessing on a tzitzit garment only if it is a day garment and you are wearing it during the day. There is no blessing on the garment otherwise.
It would appear, then, that the tallit katan—the small prayer garments that we wear—are considered garments designated for day and night. According to the ruling of the author of the Shulchan Aruch mentioned above, if you wear one during the day, you have to bless over it; if you wear it at night, you do not have to bless over it.
However, elsewhere, in the laws of tzitzit, siman chet, se’if tet-zayin, the Shulchan Aruch writes: halan betalito balailah tzarich levarech alav baboker af im lo peshato (one who sleeps wearing his tallit at night must bless over it in the morning, even if he did not remove it). Even if he did not take it off, and wore it all night, and the entire night was an interruption, he still has to say a blessing over it. Vetov lemashmesh bo besha’at haberachah (and it is good to feel it at the time of the blessing). You should kiss the tzitzit or touch the handle of it before you make the blessing, as if you are making some new beginning in the mitzvah (commandment). You slept with it, and now you are aware of it.
This ruling of Maran is based on a responsum of the Rosh. The first ruling of the Rosh we mentioned was in his halachic work; this ruling is from his responsa. According to this, if someone wore a tallit katan during the day and at night, he has to bless over it when he gets up in the morning, even though he did not take it off at night.
How do we understand the Rosh’s position? Apparently, there is a contradiction in the Rosh between his halachic work and his responsa. In his halachic work, he said it depends on whether it is a day garment or a night garment. If it is a night garment, you would not say a blessing over it. In his responsa, he said that even if you slept in it, if it is a garment designated for day and night, you do say a blessing in the morning.
The Beit Yosef explains the Rosh’s view: dekeivan delegabei kesut lailah, halailah poter lekulei alma (since, concerning a night garment, the night exempts according to everyone). That is, if we are speaking about a night garment, a garment you wear only at night, the night exempts according to everyone. Even the Rosh agrees. Therefore, the Rosh’s view is that even regarding a day garment, the night interrupts between day and night, and you have to return and bless over it. Since we find that the night interrupts regarding a day garment, the night has the power to interrupt even regarding a day garment. There is an interruption between day and night, and you have to return and bless. This is the ruling of the Shulchan Aruch in siman yod-vav.
We find that the Magen Avraham, in se’if katan chaf-alef, was concerned about the doubt concerning blessings in the case of someone who slept in a tallit katan. He says the solution is to intend to exempt the tallit katan with the blessing on the tallit gadol. Others say the same: the Eliyah Rabbah and the Sheyarei Keneset HaGedolah, like the Magen Avraham. The great later authorities, among them the Mishnah Berurah, also conclude that if someone slept in his tallit katan, when he wakes up in the morning he does not have to say a blessing over it, because of the doubt about blessings and the dispute. The only solution is that when you say a blessing on the tallit gadol, you include the tallit katan in it.
In other words, the great later authorities did not rule according to the Rosh’s view in his responsa. According to the Rosh, since we find that the night interrupts for a night garment, you have to say a blessing when you wake up in the morning, because the night interrupts. The conclusion according to the authorities is that there is a dispute concerning someone who slept in his tallit katan at night: when he wakes up in the morning, does he say a blessing or not? The Shulchan Aruch, in practice, ruled like the responsum of the Rosh: the night is an interruption in any case regarding daytime tzitzit, and therefore you have to bless over it when you get up in the morning. The Tur, the Bach, and others disagree.
The Yad David, and then the Yom Tov Rabbi, Rabbi Ya’akov Algazi, in Shalmei Tzibbur, mentions testimony he heard in the name of Mohara Yitzchaki, author of Sefer Shut Zera Yitzchak, who saw a responsum in Maran’s own handwriting saying that he had changed his mind and ruled that one should not bless. Those are his words.
I would comment that, since this is something he heard as a report, I do not know if a report—even one heard by a great person from another great person—is strong enough to annul Maran’s ruling in the Shulchan Aruch. This is especially so since he raised this contradiction in the Beit Yosef and resolved it, saying that there is no contradiction.
That is just the introduction according to halachah. Now, what about the view of the Ari?
“This is all talking about the same tzitzit he wore? If he switches the tallit katan for something else, then there’s no question?” “Yes, we’ll discuss that later.”
Now, what about the view of the Ari? I quote here from Sha’ar ha-Kavanot, the third discourse on the morning prayer, daf yud-daled, amud bet, chamesh amudim. The Ari first says that there are two actions of relieving oneself and rectifying the world of action. Then there are mochin (mental lights), to bring down the husks. Then we come to a higher level, the world of Formation. It says: ve’achar kach al yedei shtei hatallitot, tallit katan vegadol, hem shenei tikkunim el shalosh acharonot, tov, zeh Olam ha-Yetzirah vechulei (afterward, through the two tallitot, small and large, there are two rectifications for the three lower [sefirot], in the world of Formation, and so on). The tallit katan corresponds to the inner aspect of the world of Formation. The tallit gadol corresponds to its outer aspect. Then, through their two blessings—a blessing on the tallit katan and a blessing on the tallit gadol—their or makif (surrounding light) is rectified. That is the passage.
The action relates to the or ha-penimi (inner light), whether in a tallit katan or a tallit gadol, but the blessing relates to the surrounding light of the tallit katan and tallit gadol. The difference between the tallit katan and the tallit gadol is that the tallit katan relates to the inner aspect of the worlds, the inner aspect of Formation; the tallit gadol relates to the outer aspect of the worlds, the outer aspect of Formation.
I would comment that Sha’ar ha-Kavanot does not say whether we are talking about someone who slept in the tallit katan or not. We will discuss that later. In any case, according to the Ari, we see that every day, just as you say a blessing on the tallit gadol, you have to say a blessing on the tallit katan.
The Rashash wrote the same in his Nahar Shalom, daf kaf-dalet. He was faithful to the words of the Ari: ve’achar kach (afterward), after relieving oneself and so on, through wearing the tallit katan around his neck, one should intend to separate the husks called the inner aspect of the outer aspect of Formation. Through the blessing on the tallit gadol—tallit katan, I mean—and through the blessing on the tallit katan, one should intend to draw mental lights into them from the inner aspect. Through wearing the tallit gadol, the same thing is done: a rectification in the outer aspect, through the act of wrapping and the blessing.
The Rashash also wrote quite clearly that just as you say a blessing on the tallit gadol, you say a blessing on the tallit katan. There is no question. It was clear and obvious to our teacher, the Ari, and to the Rashash that we have to bless every day on the tallit katan and also on the tallit gadol, because each one is a separate rectification.
I would add that there is room to wonder about the Rashash’s wording, when he says “through wearing the tallit katan,” and “through the blessing,” and so on. Can we learn from his words that one puts it on anew in the morning, since he says “wearing the tallit katan,” and therefore blesses over it? Or was it already being worn at night, and he still blesses over it in the morning?
For our question, we have to bring proof that even if you slept in the tallit katan, and it is the same tallit katan you wear during the day, do you say a blessing because the night interrupted, or is he speaking about someone who puts on a new tallit katan in the morning, since he says “through wearing it”? Could we understand “wearing” to mean that he is still wearing it, that it remains on his body? No, I think the simple meaning is that it is the act of putting it on, not merely having it on.
Now we have to understand, according to all this, the view of the Ari, which he wrote in the discourses on the night in Sha’ar ha-Kavanot. His view is that when the Sages said, “Night is not the time for tzitzit,” this refers to the tallit gadol. But for the tallit katan, it is the time for tzitzit. This is a major point. Obviously, it is not what anyone before understood from the Gemara. But he brings a proof from the Gemara. It is interesting that quite often the Ari will give the reason according to the hidden wisdom, and that is enough for him. Here, though, he brings a proof from the Gemara.
His wording is in the first discourse on the night, daf mem-bet, amud dalet: de’af ki lailah lav zeman tzitzit hu, kenizkar baGemara, omnam ein zeh ela be’inyan hatallit gadol shebo mit’atef ha’adam rosho uzero’otav (although night is not the time for tzitzit, as mentioned in the Gemara, this is only concerning the tallit gadol, in which a person wraps his head and arms). He says the reason is that the tallit gadol is the aspect of surrounding light, the surrounding light drawn during the prayers because a new flow comes during prayer, with great influences for the aspect of Ze’ir Anpin (the small face), who is called the attribute of day. But the aspect of Nukva (the feminine), which is the attribute of night, does not have the aspect of surrounding light there, because at night the flow departs.
However, we already explained in the discourses on tzitzit that the tallit katan is from the aspect of the time of smallness. That is why it does not cover the head or arms: the fetus is folded up, sitting curled inside its mother, as Chazal (the Sages) said, like a tightly folded fetus, with its head and legs included in its body. It is the fetal position. There is no head and no hands.
Therefore, the tallit katan is always worn only on the body. When we say a blessing, according to the Ari, Chazal instituted wrapping oneself in tzitzit, and there is no other blessing. The blessing “concerning the commandment of tzitzit” is an enactment of the early authorities and is not mentioned by the Sages. The Ari holds that you have to wrap yourself as with a tallit gadol, in the Ishmaelite manner of wrapping, when you say the blessing, but then you wear it only on your body. When you wear it, it does not cover your head or your arms.
For this reason, the tallit katan applies even at night, since at night Ze’ir Anpin sleeps in the mystery of pregnancy, because the flow departs, and Ze’ir Anpin is in the aspect of pregnancy without mental lights. For this reason, the tallit katan applies here; the tallit katan is the aspect of pregnancy, and this aspect is not nullified even at night. Only the tallit gadol is nullified at night, because we say, “Night is not the time for tzitzit.” We are not in the same state of prayer and influence, with the great surrounding light.
That being said, the tallit katan is not nullified at night. So, would someone make a blessing on a garment designated for the night? He has a garment designated for the night. I do not know why that would be a problem anyway, because then you are making it a night garment. One should not do that. Even those who change should wear one of them each day; they should change and wear another tallit katan. They do that.
“Does the Ben Ish Chai (Son of a Living Man) mention, so to speak, a special tzitzit for the night, for marital relations?” “I don’t think so.” “We heard he has—I thought he said a special garment for marital relations.” “I’ve never heard of such a thing. I didn’t hear.” “What is the explanation? ‘Do not remove it from him, even at the time of marital relations.’ How can that be?”
Therefore, one has to be careful not to remove the tallit katan, either during the day or at night. That is the Ari’s view. When he lies down in bed, he should leave the tallit katan on and sleep with it. He should leave it on himself and sleep with it. There is only one time when you would take off the tallit katan: when you go to the bathhouse.
Now he brings a proof for this ruling from the Gemara. This is still all the words of the Ari. The proof is from the Gemara in Menachot, daf mem-gimel, amud bet: when David entered the bathhouse and saw himself naked, he said, “Woe is me, for I am naked of mitzvot.”
David knew that he needed protection, a very special protection. He needed mitzvot for many reasons, including the root of his soul. When he realized that in the bathhouse he had no protection, he said, “Woe is me, for I am naked of mitzvot.” Not all mitzvot—yes, the commandment of sending away the mother bird is not protection. Chazal in the Gemara mention tzitzit, tefilin, and mezuzah as mitzvot of protection. So when he was in the bathhouse, he had no protection. Then he looked at his circumcision and was happy; he had the mitzvah of protection. Circumcision is also protection.
The Ari says: if, when he was sleeping, he was also without the mitzvah of tzitzit katan, why was he not distressed when he slept, being naked of all mitzvot? He only said this when he was in the bathhouse. That is the Ari’s wording.
We see that the Ari brought this proof from the Gemara: the night does not exempt a person from the obligation of the tallit katan, and the mitzvah of tallit katan itself applies at night. His wording is, “Even when he was sleeping, he was without the mitzvah of tzitzit katan.” He is speaking about a tallit katan, and he is saying that David, of course, wore a tallit katan when he went to sleep. That is why he was not worried, “I am without protection.”
We see from here the Ari’s view: during the day, which is the aspect of Ze’ir Anpin, there is an obligation of tallit gadol. But at night, the time of the departure of the mental lights, when the aspect of Ze’ir Anpin is in a state of pregnancy, there is an obligation of tallit katan even though it is night. Although night is the attribute of night, corresponding to the aspect of Nukva, Ze’ir Anpin is in pregnancy, and in pregnancy there is a tallit katan. But the tallit gadol certainly does not apply at night, because night is the aspect of Nukva. A tallit gadol does not apply to Ze’ir Anpin because it is in pregnancy. The Nukva receives the flow at night, during its time of dominion, but even so, the great surrounding light does not apply to it, because the mental lights immediately leave all the worlds after the evening prayer.
When the Sages said, “Night is not the time for tzitzit,” the intention is the tallit gadol. This is the Ari’s view.
Further, we bring the Ari’s view from this discourse on the wording of the prayer, daf nun-alef, amud alef. He says that in the afternoon prayer, if it was said close to sunset, and he saw that the sun had already set, he should immediately remove the head tefilin, and afterward lower the tallit from his head onto his shoulders. Since a tallit gadol has to be on your head, if you take it off your head, it is no longer a tallit gadol. You do not have to take it off completely. Taking it off completely would mean that he is removing the tallit before he removes the tefilin, and the order should always be that you take them off in the reverse order from putting them on. So he says, just put it on your shoulders, and that is enough. It is as if you are not covered with a tallit. “Since a tallit gadol does not apply at night, it is enough to remove it from his head,” and so on.
Then he goes on to say that it will be explained later in the order of the night that the tallit katan should always be on a person during the day and at night, and he should sleep with it, and so on. Again, we see that the Ari’s view is clearly that the mitzvah of tallit gadol does not apply at night. Even so, he wrote that one has to sleep with the tallit katan. It is clear that the tallit katan applies at night, as explained above.
I would make another observation here. We know that in all the mitzvot—not all, but some mitzvot—there is the rectification of the mitzvah itself, one of the taryag mitzvot, with each mitzvah having its own set of worlds: Atzilut (Emanation), Beriah (Creation), Yetzirah (Formation), and Asiyah (Action), corresponding to that mitzvah. Through the mitzvah, we make a complete rectification of the influences and mental lights throughout the worlds of that mitzvah. Besides this, some mitzvot are also connected to the daily rectification, but not all mitzvot.
As we just said, relieving oneself, tzitzit katan and gadol, the hand tefilin, and the head tefilin are aspects that are completely different. For example, the Rashash says that by relieving oneself you fulfill the prohibition against making oneself repulsive, which is a Torah prohibition. For every prohibition or positive commandment, the rectification is in Emanation. But here, in the order of prayer, relieving oneself is in the world of Action. Now, the mitzvah of tzitzit, whether tallit katan or tallit gadol, would be rectified in Emanation, but in what they call the daily four worlds, whose rectification takes place through prayer, they are only in the outer aspect of the world of Formation and downward. We see that there are two rectifications.
So I am asking this: we see that when David went to the bathhouse, he saw himself without a mitzvah to protect him, and was comforted only when he remembered his circumcision. The Ari asked why this question was not also asked when David slept at night. Surely every night one could ask the same thing: did David remove the tallit katan from himself when he went to sleep? If he really took it off, the same question would apply at night. It must be that David was accustomed to sleeping in a tallit katan, since his mitzvah also applied at night.
That is the point for now. At night, we do not have the second rectification of separating the husks from the outer worlds through the four actions. It is not part of the daily configurations. The entire tikun at night is only through the mitzvah.
I say that this is explicit in the wording of Sha’ar ha-Tefillah. As you all know, we have now printed the authentic wording of Sha’ar ha-Kavanot, Sha’ar ha-Tefillah, and there it says: “If, when he was sleeping, he was without the mitzvah of tzitzit katan, why was he not distressed when he slept, being naked of all mitzvot?” The Ari says that at night he fulfilled the mitzvah of wearing a tallit katan, and that it applies even at night. The mitzvah provides protection. For it to have the power of protection, it has to be a mitzvah. If it is not a mitzvah, it cannot protect.
From this itself, the Ari proved that the tallit katan applies at night, and that when it says “Night is not the time for tzitzit,” it means the tallit gadol. We must conclude that his intention was to teach us that specifically because a person fulfills the actual mitzvah at night by wearing a tallit katan, the mitzvah has the power to act and rectify the daily configurations through the mental lights of pregnancy that exist at night. There is a rectification in the daily worlds through the mental lights of pregnancy because there is a mitzvah. If there is a mitzvah, you can say that it also has a rectification in the daily worlds. We have many proofs for this.
Based on the Ari, the Rashash writes, for example, before the blessing on tzitzit, that one should intend that he is ready and prepared to wrap himself in tzitzit as required by Jewish law and to bless over it. Through this intention of preparation—that he is ready to wrap himself and bless—his blessing will have the power to raise the feminine waters and draw down the mental lights.
Why do we need this? Every mitzvah a person performs automatically brings about the ascent of the feminine waters and the mental lights. So what does this mean? Here, however, this mitzvah has two rectifications: in the worlds of the mitzvah and in the daily worlds. He is saying that since you have the mitzvah, and intend to fulfill the mitzvah of the tallit gadol or tallit katan, this gives the blessing the power to raise the feminine waters and draw down the mental lights of the daily worlds. It needs the power of the mitzvah. But if it is not a mitzvah, the mere fact that you have some sort of garment, a tallit katan, makes no difference. It will not accomplish anything if it is not a mitzvah.
The Ari wrote the same wording about tefilin, and the Siddur of the Rashash uses the same wording. He also writes this concerning the recitation of the Shema. These are the three places where he writes this wording. Why are these particular mitzvot connected to the daily worlds? Yes, the mitzvah applies, and everything brought in Sha’ar ha-Kavanot refers to these rectifications in the daily worlds. Prayer? Yes, look in the Siddur. Yes, in that regard.
I write here in Hebrew, and according to this, let us see in the Ari’s intention there that the mitzvah of “And you shall see it” is also properly fulfilled at night by looking at the fringes of the tallit katan. He wrote that by wearing a tallit katan at night, one fulfills the mitzvah of tzitzit. The purpose of the mitzvah of tzitzit is to see the fringes and thereby remember all the mitzvot in order to do them.
So the Ari brought proof that the mitzvah of tzitzit katan applies at night. Apparently, it is also a mitzvah to look. When one looks, is that also a rectification in the daily worlds, or is that rectification in Emanation? The looking itself?
The Ramban writes that looking at the tzitzit is a positive commandment from the Torah. Is this part of the mitzvah in Emanation? Yes, Emanation. It is from the Torah. This could be an idea for not leaving the tzitzit inside, because at night you cannot see the fringes either.
“So you have to take them out to look at them. You don’t see them at night.” “It’s no different from the day when you don’t see them. They’re still with you, whether you’re looking at ‘And you shall see it.’ They’re outside all the time, in the pitch dark.” “Right, they don’t see anything.” “But still, you fulfill ‘And you shall see it.’ Somehow you have to—no different from when you wear it during the day. It’s also hard to look at it.” “Right, just like when it’s covered.” “Yes.”
“How come women are not obligated in a tallit katan?” The Ari says clearly that women have no connection to the mitzvah of tzitzit, neither during the day nor at night. The reason is that even though night is the attribute of night, which is Nukva, it is not because of Nukva, but because of Ze’ir Anpin in pregnancy. That is the aspect of the tallit katan.
On Yom Kippur, the Ari writes that there is only one time during the year when the tallit gadol is different, when the tallit gadol applies at night—I made a mistake—which is Yom Kippur. All I have here is discussion of a difficulty and a resolution. I think we do not have to go into it. The question was that it is no longer a positive commandment dependent on time. Again? The question was that if they are obligated in tzitzit at night, then it is not dependent on time. Yes, that is according to the plain meaning, and they ruled as the Shulchan Aruch does. Now we are discussing this according to the Ari. The Ari brings proof from the Gemara that they are obligated at night. If so, it is not dependent on time, and women are obligated in tzitzit.
“Not during the day or during the night?” The way he explained it is that this is a positive commandment dependent on time; women have no connection to the mitzvah at all, neither during the day nor during the night. They have nothing to do with it at all.
Now the question is, according to the Ari, since the tallit katan applies at night—the actual mitzvah of the tallit katan—then it needs explanation: how do you bless over the tallit in the morning if the night does not interrupt the obligation of the tallit katan?
I write that it appears to be his view that the new day obligates a blessing, even though the night did not interrupt the obligation to wear the tallit katan. We bring proof for this further down. The obligation is because of the day. Every day, we have to have all these rectifications, and it is a new rectification. So the fact that you had the tallit on all night, and were obligated to wear it, does not exempt you for the day.
Further down, I bring proof from the blessing over the Torah: even someone who did not sleep all night says it again at dawn. The Magen Avraham writes that this is because it is a new day, and a new day brings a new obligation, even though there was no interruption because of sleep. If a person had a regular sleep, there is an interruption. But if he did not sleep, why should he say a blessing?
There is support for the words of the Arizal, that one is obligated to wear a tallit katan at night, from the view of the Rosh in his halachic work, mentioned above: a day garment is obligated at night. Rabbi Akiva Eiger writes explicitly in his novellae on Orach Chayim, siman kaf-alef, concerning what the Magen Avraham wrote there, se’if katan bet, that the words of the Arizal show that one must wear a tallit katan at night and fulfills an actual mitzvah with it. That is how the Magen Avraham phrases it: one fulfills an actual mitzvah with it. David wore a tallit katan at night, and therefore he was not concerned that when he slept he would remain naked of mitzvot, since he was then fulfilling the mitzvah of tallit katan. This proves the Rosh’s view that a day garment is obligated at night.
See Levushei Serad, se’if katan heh, who explains that the Magen Avraham’s intention is to prove that the view of Rabbeinu Arizal is like the Rosh: a day garment is obligated at night.
This is how Rabbi Akiva Eiger understood the halachah: in practice, the Ari’s view has support from the Rosh. Even though there is an interruption—he says, from here we know that the halachah is like the Rosh. Yes. Even though it is an interruption, how can we follow the Rosh? One cannot make an interruption in blessings. Yes, this proves the Rosh’s view that a day garment is obligated at night. From the Ari, Rabbi Akiva Eiger says, one can prove the Rosh’s position.
Accordingly, I write that it appears that at night one is obligated in the tallit katan. If a person took off the tallit katan at night for a long time and diverted his attention from it, or changed his tallit and wore another one, when he puts it on at night he has to bless over it. That is the Rosh’s view. Yes, according to the Rosh, even though it is night, a day garment is obligated, and he has to bless over it at night when he puts it on.
As for what the Arizal wrote, that one has to intend concerning the tallit katan when getting up in the morning, even though he slept in it at night—no, what the Arizal wrote is that one has to bless over the tallit katan when getting up in the morning, even though he slept in it at night—there is also support for this from the Rosh’s responsum, whose ruling Maran set down in the Beit Yosef and the Shulchan Aruch. In any case, the night is considered an interruption, so that he has to bless over it in the morning.
In this way, we fulfill the view of the Ari according to the Rosh and the ruling of Maran.
“And the interruption according to the Rosh and according to the Ari is—it’s a new day, Rabbi?” “What?” “The interruption according to the Ari, Rabbi, is that it’s a new day.” “Right, like when you come to a new day with the blessing over the Torah.” “Yes, a new day.” “Right, it’s not really an interruption; it’s also a new day. You need a blessing in the morning because you have to make the rectification.” “Right, right. It’s not the interruption of the Rosh.” “No, right, not that interruption. The Rosh’s interruption is that you went from nothing to something.” “Right, you need a blessing in the morning because it is part of the daily rectification.” “Right. Because it’s a new day, that’s why. The rectification of the configurations.” “That’s not the interruption of the Rosh. The Rosh’s interruption is that the mitzvah ended.”
“How come David was comforted even at night? Why? He has the covenant of circumcision. When he was in the bathhouse, he was comforted when he remembered his circumcision. He didn’t ask the question. The proof is that he didn’t feel—You don’t make a blessing on the rectification—Why did he ask the question only in the bathhouse? He should ask it at night.” “He didn’t ask it. He was comforted by it at night.” “He was comforted by it in the bathhouse.” “He didn’t have tzitzit; it was the same thing.” “He was upset. What difference does it make? Let him finish.” “What can we do? He says, ‘Come, let us listen to David.’ Which king? David. Afterward, he also slept all night. Where were the tzitzit?”
Regarding Yom Kippur, the Ari writes: the custom of wrapping oneself in a tallit gadol on the eve of Yom Kippur is a proper custom. Why is it a custom? Because the secret of the tallit is always surrounding light for Ze’ir Anpin, whether in the aspect of a tallit katan of pregnancy or nursing, or in the aspect of the tallit gadol of maturity. On the night of Yom Kippur, when the Nukva Rachel has dominion, the Ari writes that the rectification on Yom Kippur is from the aspect of the Nukva, and the Nukva rises before Ze’ir Anpin until the repetition of the Musaf prayer. Only from the afternoon prayer onward is there an ascent for Ze’ir Anpin.
Here the Ari is writing according to the plain meaning. According to the Rashash, it is an entirely different concept. You cannot give the Nukva an ascent without mental lights, and she has to receive mental lights from Ze’ir Anpin. If Ze’ir Anpin received mental lights, then it also ascended. How can we say that the Nukva ascended during the evening prayer, morning prayer, silent prayer, repetition, Musaf, silent prayer, and repetition, while Ze’ir Anpin did not move, and then from the afternoon prayer onward? It is impossible.
The Rashash explained that the Nukva we are discussing on Yom Kippur is the fifth point, a completely different set of worlds for the fifth point. All the rectification is different. Since on Rosh Hashanah and during the Ten Days of Repentance all the service was in the fourth point, now, on the night of Yom Kippur and during the morning prayer of Yom Kippur, we are working on the fifth point to bring it to the level of the fourth point, which has already been reached through all the Ten Days of Repentance up until Yom Kippur. But the Ari here is not speaking with that intention of the Rashash.
Therefore, on the night of Yom Kippur, when Rachel has dominion, because the attribute of night prevails at night, Rachel ascends to the head of Tevunah, as is known, and then the Supernal Mother surrounds her with tzitzit. It is the only time in the year that the tallit gadol has a connection to the Nukva. Therefore, one has to wrap himself in the tallit gadol. But on the other nights, when the Nukva does not ascend, there is no reality of a tallit gadol, and it does not apply at night, which is the time of the Nukva, the attribute of night.
So why do we not say a blessing on the tallit gadol on the night of Yom Kippur? It is because this rectification, the ascent of the Nukva, is accomplished on its own and not by us; therefore, we do not say a blessing. Now, perhaps one could bless even at night? This is only tzitzit—sunset. Could one bless after sunset? Yes, that is obvious. The first hour is at night according to the Ari. Those who say it before are concerned about the doubt regarding blessings, a later authorities’ innovation. I brought this in connection with what we said before, too.
It follows from this that concerning the other nights, since the Arizal holds that night is the time for tzitzit regarding the tallit katan he wore, we see that because it rises in the aspect of pregnancy, one blesses over it even at night if he puts it on then, just as with the tallit gadol on Yom Kippur. The difference is that there we did not say the blessing because the rectification happens on its own. On ordinary nights, the rectification happens because we wear a tallit katan, so you have to say a blessing over it.
In practice, he is reminding me, I think I bring it—put it down—that the only Kabbalist who clearly says this, as we explain it, is Chesed Le’Avraham Tubiana, Rabbi Avraham Tubiana. In any case, I bring this from the prayer books of the Ari, all the prayer books of the Ari. No, it is here. Here. And so the Siddur of Chesed Le’Avraham Tubiana explains everything we said above. These are his words:
Someone who slept at night in a tallit katan, as the holy Maran, the Ari, wrote that one should sleep at night in a tallit katan, has reason to wonder whether he has to bless over it in the morning. For the Shulchan Aruch writes, “One who sleeps in his tallit at night must bless over it in the morning, even if he did not remove it, and it is good to feel it at the time of the blessing.” That is his wording. The Rosh, the Bach, and the Taz ruled that there is no need to bless. The Magen Avraham wrote that the tallit gadol exempts him. Rabbi Chaim HaKohen, a student of the Rachav, likewise wrote that the tallit gadol exempts him. From this, the matter depends on a dispute among the great authorities, and we do not know what to do.
Do we say a blessing in the morning on the tallit katan if you slept in it, according to the Ari, or not? Nevertheless, it appears explicitly from the words of the holy Maran, the Arizal, that one has to bless over it in the morning, as he wrote in Sefer HaKavvanot: “Afterward, through the two tallitot, the tallit katan and the tallit gadol.” He brings the wording of Sha’ar Nu, Sha’ar Tefillat HaShachar, that one has to say a blessing on the tallit katan just as one says one on the tallit gadol.
You can see that the prophet spoke explicitly: through the blessing of the tallit katan, the surrounding light of the last three [sefirot] of the world of Formation is rectified, and so on. If he does not bless over it, how is the mentioned surrounding light rectified? The same appears from the book of the rabbi, author of Mishnat Chassidim. Why? He says in Mishnah 2, chapter 5, that one has to intend, in the Divine Name of the blessing on the tallit katan, that the masculine letters yud and vav have a patach and the two feminine letters heh have a tzerah. In the Divine Name of the blessing on the tallit gadol, he wrote that one should intend that the masculine letters have a kamatz and the feminine letters a cholam. That is his wording. His source is at the end of chapter 6 of the Gate of Tzitzit in Pri Etz Chayim, in a note.
If so, it must be that there is a special blessing for the tallit katan and a special blessing for the tallit gadol, and the intention in the Divine Name proves that it is different for the tallit katan from the tallit gadol. This is still the wording of Chesed Le’Avraham: “From this, it follows that one has to bless over the tallit katan in the morning, as the holy Maran ruled, based on the responsum of the Rosh, and so on. In any case, it is good to feel it at the time of the blessing.” That is his wording.
“In truth, all the prayer books of the Rashash explicitly write two blessings?” “Yes, yes.” Here we see that Mishnat Chassidim, throughout the intentions for tzitzit, distinguishes between the tallit katan and the tallit gadol, and writes about each separately. The printed prayer books of the Ari also explicitly write this.
I will bring Zolkiew. He writes: “When the day dawns, he should feel the tallit katan and intend that the tallit katan is the aspect of the garment of the world of Formation, and through this the inner aspects of Netzach and Hod of Formation are rectified. Through the blessing of the tallit katan, the surrounding light of the inner aspect is rectified,” and so on. “Afterward, he blesses.” That is his wording. There he arranged the blessing, “to wrap oneself in tzitzit,” even though he is not wrapping himself in it now, since he is already wearing it, because he slept in it. He should feel its tzitzit, as Maran says, and bless, “to wrap oneself in tzitzit.”
He made a special blessing in the prayer book. It says, “Blessed are You, Hashem … to wrap oneself in tzitzit,” for the tallit katan. Then he again wrote the intention for the tallit gadol: the tallit gadol is the secret of the surrounding light of Ze’ir Anpin, and one first wraps oneself in the words “Hear, O Israel.” One should intend to purify through the external action, the outer aspects of Netzach and Hod of Formation, because the tallit gadol rectifies the external aspect. Through the blessing, the surrounding light of the external aspect is rectified, and so on. He then arranged a second blessing, “to wrap oneself in tzitzit,” for the tallit gadol.
So he wrote the blessing, “Blessed are You, Hashem … to wrap oneself in tzitzit,” twice: once for the tallit katan and then for the tallit gadol. “Is this blessing, ‘to wrap oneself in tzitzit,’ also for the tallit katan?” “Yes, according to the Ari’s view.” “I said before that there is no ‘concerning the commandment of tzitzit’?” “No, there is no such thing. Those are the views of the Rishonim. The Ari holds that you have to wrap yourself with the tallit katan and say ‘to wrap oneself in tzitzit,’ which is the enactment of the Sages.”
This Zolkiew prayer book is the prayer book of the Ramaf, Rabbi Meir Poppers, the most authoritative prayer book before the Rashash. In his introduction, he wrote that he received all these intentions from Rabbi Ya’akov Tzemach, who copied them from the prayer book of Rabbeinu Chaim Vital. I know for a fact that I saw, 45 years ago, the handwritten prayer book of the Ramaf, like the Zolkiew edition, which belonged to the Rashash, with his signature and notes. That is all. I have not seen it since. It would be very helpful if I could see it again.
It is the same in all the prayer books of the Ari. The Siddur Rav Shabtai also arranged two blessings, as did many other prayer books of the Ari. I even have a few prayer books of the Ari written by Sephardic Sages, such as the Remaz and others. They also explicitly wrote two blessings and different vocalizations in the Divine Name.
Now we come to the view of the Rashash in his prayer book. We look at the printed prayer book. It was printed in Taf-Resh-Ayin-Alef by Rabbi Shaul Dwek, up to “Hodu,” with his notes. In Taf-Resh-Ayin-Vav, the complete prayer book was printed by Hacham Yom Tov Yedid and his son, Rabbi Eliezer Yedid. In both prayer books we have the intention for tzitzit and the intention for tefilin. Then we have the wording of the blessing: “Blessed are You, Hashem, our God, King of the universe, who sanctified us with His commandments and commanded us to wrap ourselves in tzitzit.” Then come all the intentions for the tallit katan, and afterward, automatically, all the intentions for the tallit gadol.
So, really, the blessing is arranged for the tallit katan, but we know that you say the same blessing again for the tallit gadol. The Rashash’s view is clear, as he wrote in Nahar Shalom: you need a blessing for the tallit katan and for the tallit gadol. Why did he not arrange two blessings like all the prayer books of the Ari? Very simple: to save paper. In the prayer books of the Ari, the entire wording of the blessing is one line with a few hints. In the prayer book of the Rashash, the wording of the blessing can take two or three pages or more. So they always use this technique: if there are several mitzvot and you can use the wording “who sanctified us,” and so on, once, you print it once, and then use it for this, and for this, and for this. You do not have to rewrite the entire wording of the blessing at great length again and again.
In fact, I saw some handwritten prayer books that have one blessing, then the intentions for the tallit katan, the intentions for the tallit gadol, the intentions for the hand tefilin, and the intentions for the head tefilin. Obviously, they are relying on one wording of the blessing.
However, in the prayer books of the Sages and rabbis of Beit El, Yereh changed everything according to his view. His view was apparently that one does not say a blessing on the tallit gadol. He seems not to have been aware of this fact. So he changed the order around. I think he brought the intentions for the tallit katan without a blessing, and then brought the blessing and the intentions for the tallit gadol. That is how he wrote it at first. Later, he added a note, which says: “For us, whose custom is not to remove the tallit katan, even in bed at night, we therefore do not bless over it.” Even so, in other words, although there is no reason to say a blessing on the tallit katan, it is good to intend the intentions of the tallit katan before putting on the tallit gadol, in order to illuminate the mental lights of smallness of the tallit katan, so that afterward, through the tallit gadol, the mental lights of maturity will be drawn down.
He is introducing a novel idea against the Ari and against the Rashash. “One blessing.” Yes, he says that in practice we do not say a blessing on the tallit katan. So what are we going to do with the intentions for the tallit katan that the Rashash arranged in his prayer book? He says that we should look at them not as drawing down, because there is no drawing down, since there is no mitzvah and no new mitzvah. Instead, they prepare the platform of the mental lights of smallness, so that when you say the blessing on the tallit gadol and draw down the mental lights of maturity, they rest on the platform of smallness, and you have maturity and smallness together.
He says clearly—though not as clearly and loudly as he could have—that “for us, whose custom is not to remove the tallit katan, even in bed at night, we therefore do not bless over it in the morning. Even so, it is good to intend the intention of the tallit katan before putting on the tallit gadol, to intend the mental lights of smallness of the tallit katan, in order to illuminate the mental lights of smallness.” What does “illuminate” mean? Not draw down, because you are not performing a mitzvah. Just illuminate them, so that afterward, through the tallit gadol, the drawing down of the mental lights of maturity will come and rest upon the mental lights of smallness. That is his wording.
The prayer book of Hacham Shalom Hedaya has this note, as does the new prayer book printed with the commentary Shemen Sasson, which they printed in Sha’ar ha-Kavanot. The Sages of Beit El also adopted the wording of Rav HaYare. So he not only holds that you do not say a blessing on the tallit katan; he also innovated that the intentions for the tallit katan that the Rashash wrote in his prayer book do not actually draw down the flow, because there is no mitzvah. Rather, by looking at them, you prepare a platform for the mental lights of maturity.
“And you shall see it,” and “you shall see the points”—that is also the Rashash’s wording. What do you do with the Ari? What do you do with the Rashash? Draw down. Drawing down is only through a blessing. “Why did he use the word ‘intend’?” “What?” “Why did he use the word ‘intend’?” It means to look. He says, “It is good to intend the intentions of the tallit katan before putting on the tallit gadol, in order to illuminate the mental lights of smallness.” He explains that the intention is only to illuminate the mental lights of smallness. They are the same mental lights of smallness as yesterday, the day before, and the week before, but one looks at them in order to illuminate them. By looking at them, you illuminate them, but you do not draw them down. This is the opposite of the Ari’s and the Rashash’s intentions.
To interpret it this way is only to judge him favorably. If he intended to draw them down, there is no drawing down without a blessing. And if you interpret him as saying “illuminate” rather than “draw down,” that is also only to judge him favorably, because otherwise, how can one bless? There is no drawing down without a blessing for any mitzvah in the world. “Right.” “The drawing down comes because he is saying the blessing on the tallit gadol anyway.” He blesses, “to wrap oneself in tzitzit,” and through the blessing he makes on the tallit gadol, he draws down both of them.
There is an outer surrounding light. In truth, it is possible to rectify both; it is possible to draw down for both, in two other places. But with tzitzit, both are included together. That is what he holds, that they are not separate. But the Ari does not hold this. What can we do? The prayer book of the Ari is clear. “Vehu, ani, I question him very strongly.” This explanation is very strange and has no basis, because nowhere in the prayer books of Maran is it written, nor in the written intentions, that the intention is to draw down mental lights through fulfilling the mitzvah. As the prayer book says about the tallit katan, one should intend to draw down the mental lights of smallness through fulfilling the mitzvah; the same is true for the tallit gadol, where one should intend to draw them down. To explain that it means only to illuminate them and not draw them down reverses the meaning.
“How did Yare know that it applied at night if not from the Ari?” “No, from halachah; he is going according to halachah.” I think they were all led astray by Shalmei Tzibbur, because Shalmei Tzibbur writes that we never say a blessing on a tallit katan except when coming out of the ritual bath. Everyone knows he was a Kabbalist from Beit El, and they took it at face value. Since this innovation is not written in Kedushat Tzion, but somewhere else, perhaps they did not remember it from one place to another.
That is a great difficulty concerning all these rabbis, knowledgeable rabbis, that none of them asks what the Ari said. You have to say a blessing every day on the tallit katan. The Rashash wrote it in Nahar Shalom. It is so clear. The prayer book is explicit. Rabbi Chesed Le’Avraham was one opinion, yes, but the proof from all the prayer books of the Ari was obvious to them. Perhaps there could be a distinction between the same tallit katan and a different tallit katan. Perhaps not.
In practice, I write at the end that, as an extra measure of care, it would be good to wear a different tallit every day. Switch them. But do not designate one exclusively for the night. That would be a problem. Then you are declaring that it is exclusively for nighttime. Exactly.
“What is the practical conclusion? Rabbi, are you doing it the way they did?” “I always follow the Ari and the Rashash.” “Does Rabbi make a blessing on the tallit katan every day?” “Every day. But, as an extra measure, I wear a different one every day.” “Does Rabbi also wrap himself with the tallit katan?” “No. Wait, so Rabbi alternates each day, switching back and forth, day and night?” “Every day I take one off and wear the other. The next day I take this one off and wear the other.” “In the morning?” “In the morning. Yes, but it is only a stringency. If I forgot, or came to America with one tallit, I would say the blessing on it, on the tallit I had.”
Now, the Ben Ish Chai is a great support for this, because this is the Ari. “No, so what?” “The decisors are the Ari and the Rashash, who say that one is obligated to bless.” “According to Maran, yes.” “So you only have that one because you take this one off and put that one back on.”
Here I am skipping a lengthy discussion to bring proof for the Ari’s view that every new day one has to say the blessings, as with Birchot HaShachar (Morning Blessings). The Rav said that it depends on the custom of the world, meaning the custom of the upper world. Every day, all these rectifications of the blessings are renewed. It is the same with the tallit.
I bring Shalmei Tzibbur. This is puzzling. He did not know what was written in the discourse on Birkat HaShachar. He writes that he brought the dispute among the Rishonim and authorities about whether one says a blessing on the tallit katan if he slept in it, and he wrote that it appears that the Ari’s view was that he did not bless on the tallit katan in the morning, but only when he removed it at the ritual bath. Those are truly puzzling words, the opposite of the words of the Ari and the Rashash.
I have a lengthy discussion of the difficulties raised by the great later authorities regarding this proof from the Gemara. Some ask: even in the ritual bath, he had a mezuzah. They say it was outside, at the outer door, and it did not protect him inside. Then they ask: when he slept at home, he had a mezuzah. But he was a soldier; he always slept in the fields, in caves. “But the palace.” The Ya’avetz writes, “I have been in the palaces of kings; all the doorways are problematic, and they would not know where to put the mezuzah.” It is problematic. I brought all these opinions. There is no practical halachic difference.
Now I am trying to recall this by heart. Concerning Kabbalat Shabbat (Welcoming the Sabbath), the Ari was known to leave his house and the town, cross the fields around Safed, go up the hill, and say Kabbalat Shabbat at the top of the hill. When he saw the sun going down, he said, “Come, bride, come, bride, come, bride”—literally, when he saw the sun going down. Then he came back down the hill, went through the fields, entered the town, and went home. He said the psalms up there. That took time. However fast you are, it took time—ten minutes for all of Kabbalat Shabbat. Then it took another, say, ten minutes to get home. Let us say he ran; he was a young man, 37, 35, or 36 years old, energetic.
In any case, he came to his house, wrapped himself in tzitzit, and performed the circuit around the table. He said Kabbalat Shabbat again with the circuit around the table. Then, it does not say he took it off; he went to the synagogue and arrived when the congregation was saying either Kaddish before Barechu or just Barechu. What happened there is all very strange.
Concerning an ordinary weekday afternoon prayer, it says he was so particular that if he saw the sun set, he took off the tefilin and the tallit. Here we see that perhaps 20 or 25 minutes after sunset he wrapped himself in tzitzit, and it sounds as if this was with a blessing. He explains at length how to perform the wrapping, in the Ishmaelite manner, with the implications. It sounds as if you have to say a blessing. Apparently, that is obvious. It is not explicit in Sha’ar ha-Kavanot, but that is what the passage implies. A tallit gadol.
We still see that he wore the tallit to perform the second Kabbalat Shabbat, and he explicitly says that it is an addition to Shabbat. Only at Barechu is it actual acceptance of Shabbat. So we have to understand: it was certainly after sunset. Maybe it was close to night, and he wore the tallit and performed Kabbalat Shabbat, although he says it was still not Shabbat. Yes, all right, perhaps it was just before sunset.
By the way, before he left his house to go to the synagogue, he read four chapters of Mishnah. Even so, he arrived at the synagogue before the congregation was saying Barechu. I wrote a few answers. One answer was that the Ari’s view was like Rabbeinu Tam, and then there would be no problem at all. Further down, though, I question this.
One of the proofs is the testimony of Maharchu that when the Ari finished the afternoon prayer and saw the sun setting, he immediately took the tallit off his head. That would imply that he was referring to sunset according to the Geonim, when you see the sun going down. Rav Pe’alim writes that it must have been the first sunset, the sunset according to the Geonim. In chelek gimmel of Sod Yesharim, siman yud-gimmel, he holds this view. He asks about the Ari’s custom of praying the afternoon prayer at twilight. Since the Ari certainly concentrated on all the mystical intentions during his prayer, as he wrote in Sha’ar ha-Kavanot, if he began praying the afternoon prayer at twilight, he must have finished it at night.
He says the Ari was such a great person that he had all the intentions in one second. But he explains that the Ari followed the view of the Geonim, not the view of Rabbeinu Tam. Elsewhere he wrote something surprising in Ben Ish Chai: Rabbeinu ha-Ari accepted Shabbat about half an hour before sunset. Sha’ar ha-Kavanot says that when he saw the sun going down, he said, “Come, bride.” So it does not appear that we can say for certain that the Ari followed Rabbeinu Tam. There are other great authorities who hold this view, Rabbi Amani and others, that his opinion was like the Geonim.
Then I bring another view found among the halachic authorities and Kabbalists, and we say that the Ari holds that twilight is a time when one may, ideally, wrap oneself in tzitzit. Why? Because you can still see the tzitzit. You cannot say that “And you shall see it” does not apply.
So I ask: that is fine concerning Kabbalat Shabbat, but concerning wrapping oneself in the tallit, both on a weekday and when moving from weekday to Shabbat, during the week the Ari would remove the tallit from himself when the sun set. Yet on Shabbat evening he would wrap himself in the tallit some time after sunset, close to the appearance of the stars, before we find an explanation for this. To resolve this, I said we should carefully examine the difference in the Ari’s wording concerning removing the tallit after the afternoon prayer, compared with what he wrote about the time of Kabbalat Shabbat in the field.
If we pay attention to his words, we will see that he makes a distinction. Regarding Kabbalat Shabbat in the field, he wrote: “Turn your face toward the west, where the sun sets, and at the time of its actual setting,” and so on. “Concentrate with awe and fear, as one standing before the King, to accept the additional holiness of Shabbat.” That is his wording. We see that he was very precise, so that it would be understood that Kabbalat Shabbat takes place at the moment the sun actually sets.
However, regarding removing the tallit after the afternoon prayer, he wrote: “If he said the afternoon prayer close to sunset, and saw that the sun had already set, he should immediately remove the head tefilin from his head and the tallit, because night is not the time for tzitzit,” and so on. He wrote that if he saw that the sun had already set, he would remove the tallit because night is not the time for tzitzit. From this it appears that he would remove the tallit after the sun had already set. It was not at the actual moment of sunset. But was this the tallit gadol? Yes, the tallit gadol.
I brought other passages from the Ari, such as in Sha’ar ha-Tefillah, daf tzadi tet, amud dalet, the same as Sha’ar ha-Kavanot, daf mem tet. He was also very careful to say the afternoon prayer only close to sunset, every day. The Gemara mentions the verse, “They will fear You with the sun,” which refers to the afternoon prayer.
He also wrote in Sha’ar ha-Mitzvot, concerning the verse, “On that day you shall give him his wages”: my teacher was careful to fulfill this mitzvah to the utmost. When he did not have money to pay the worker, he would delay praying the afternoon prayer until sunset in order to ask for money to pay the worker. He would borrow the money and pay him, and afterward pray the afternoon prayer quickly. That is his wording. In Sefer HaLikutim, the text says he would delay until after sunset. Who else has a version in Sefer Me’orot Natan? “He prayed the afternoon prayer after sunset?” “Yes, yes.”
In Pri Etz Chayim it says that he was careful not to say it except while wearing the tallit, and he did not remove the tallit and tefilin until Aleinu. He was also very careful not to say it except at sunset. In Sefer Me’orot Natan it says he was very careful not to pray the afternoon prayer except at sunset, and he was also very careful even if it was after sunset. Even on the eve of Shabbat, he did not refrain from saying it aloud only; first he said it quietly and afterward repeated it aloud. All of this was after sunset. He was also very careful not to say the afternoon prayer except wearing the tallit and tefilin. “Even on the eve of Shabbat?” “The eve of Shabbat—I don’t know. It means even if he began praying the afternoon prayer after sunset.” “After the fact, no?” “Thirteen and a half minutes?” “Yes, perhaps that is what it means.”
Rav Mishnat Chassidim writes: “The main afternoon prayer should be close to the actual sunset, and one should not pray it under any circumstances before paying a worker his wages if he owes him. Even if he has to delay the afternoon prayer until after sunset in order to ask for money to pay him, and even at that time he should not refrain from saying it wearing the tallit and tefilin.” That is his wording: quietly and in the repetition.
All this makes it clear, as we wrote above, that the main wording of Sha’ar ha-Tefillah is that he was not particular to remove the tallit and tefilin immediately at sunset specifically. Even if it was some time after sunset, he did not remove them until after Aleinu Leshabeach. According to this, we resolve the difficulty about Kabbalat Shabbat.
Then I bring another point: it appears that the Ari’s view on this matter is based on the view of the Rishonim and great halachic authorities who hold that fulfilling the mitzvah of tzitzit depends on seeing, not on daytime. Whenever it is possible to see the fringes, it is the time to wrap oneself and say a blessing. As the Beit Yosef wrote in the name of the Mordechai, tzitzit is not explicitly limited to daytime in the verse; rather, “And you shall see it”—the matter depends on seeing. I bring many authorities who say this. At twilight, one can still see.
“And what is the mitzvah with the tallit katan? Isn’t it ‘And you shall see it’?” “But we said that the tallit katan does apply at night. The mitzvah applies.” “You asked that before.” “It isn’t ‘And you shall see it’; it is a mitzvah.” “Okay, think about it. You’re right. How can you see at night? You also have to see.” “How can it apply at night? A person has a lamp, lights it, and sees. So always, even when the garment is inside another garment, how does he fulfill what the Ari said, that the mitzvah is ‘And you shall see it’? He can take it out and see it.” “Then why only twilight, when he can see? You could always say that.”
It could be that the law follows Rabbi Yosi, that all the time of twilight is still day. We are stringent only regarding the prohibition of Shabbat, like Rabbi Yehudah, as explained in Bi’ur Halachah, and so on. See Shut Or LeTziyon, which discusses all this at length and proves that according to the Rambam, the halachah follows Rabbi Yosi. They were stringent only concerning Shabbat, and so on.
Then I bring another resolution to the question of wrapping oneself in tzitzit for Kabbalat Shabbat after sunset. We could say that it is like Yom Kippur, because it says that on Shabbat night the Nukva ascends, but not Ze’ir Anpin, just as on Yom Kippur. I bring proof that it may apply at that time, like on Yom Kippur. That would mean it applies on Shabbat night. So everyone should wear a tallit on Friday night. The Ari wore one. “I’m saying, but on Friday night we don’t.”
Rabbi Eliyahu Mani writes that he did not understand the custom of Beit El, where they remove the tallit. They changed the time of Kabbalat Shabbat and made it earlier so they could remove the tallit at sunset. He says, “Why did you change the custom? From the Rashash onward, everyone was wearing the tallit after sunset.” All right.
What is the conclusion from what we have said? The tallit katan should be worn at night, and even so, we can say the blessing during the day when we wake up. Apparently, even if we wake up before dawn, since according to the Rosh a day garment is obligated at night, one could say the blessing even before dawn.
“Rabbi, would we be able to make the rectification of the daily configuration if we say it before the time of the rectification of the morning prayer? If you’re making the blessing, how will we—what if it’s too early, before dawn? If we slept and woke up, say, at 3:00 in the morning, and we didn't say, when we slept before chatzot, so now we say Birchot HaShachar completely?” “Yes, because you can rectify the morning blessings at that time, after midnight.” “Okay, so the tallit katan too. We could rectify the tallit katan early?”
The tallit katan, because the morning blessings are also in the world of Action, with intermediate vessels. First comes the action with the outer vessels, and afterward the inner ones; the morning blessings are with the intermediate vessels. You have already begun the rectification of the daily configuration. So with tzitzit too, the tallit katan, you say the blessing and put it on.
“If someone takes a shower at night, puts one on for half an hour, and then puts on a tallit katan, should he make a blessing?” “We don’t do that during the day either. The question is, the Ben Ish Chai says we do not have so much of a diversion of attention. He said it only if a person goes to the ritual bath and comes out. Is there a diversion if we wait two hours?” He says the Ari used to spend a long time on the intentions, and because of the intentions he would divert his attention. It could be that there was an interruption of two or three hours, which everyone would agree to. So we ruled about that before: we would say the blessing in the middle of the night. Even after swimming, why not? Even so, it is better to satisfy everyone, including the Ben Ish Chai. Because of all the opinions and disputes, we can wear a new tallit every day. This is not considered an unnecessary blessing, since it is done to resolve a doubt, with that intention. It is possible to do this.
Chazak uvaruch. “Chazak uvaruch. I’ll give the—”