A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Yaakov Mizrahi

Torah Lecture

Ben ish Hai-Hacham Ovadiah.Yitro 6-8 Sitting and walking near someone in Amida

Lectured by Rabbi Yaakov Mizrahi

Published
February 2, 2024
Duration
24:22
Lecture code
RYM-BIH-63

Why the area around the Amidah requires care

  • Rabbi Yaakov Mizrahi explains that one must be careful about sitting, standing, or walking near someone praying the Amidah: movement can distract the person, and the person praying creates Kedushah within the four amot around them. That area should be treated respectfully.
  • The four amot are described as about six feet in every direction.

Sitting near someone praying

  • In ot vav, the Ben Ish Chai says one may not sit within four amot of someone praying the Amidah, whether in front, behind, or to the sides. This applies whether the person praying is a man or a woman.
  • For example, a husband may not sit two feet from his wife while she prays the Amidah, even if he is on the couch spending time with the children.
  • Sitting beyond four amot may be permitted. Some opinions are stricter about sitting in front of the person praying even beyond four amot if the person can see you; this concern is relevant in shul, where others may be praying.
  • Rabbi Yaakov Mizrahi distinguishes sitting idly from sitting while engaged in prayer. If someone is praying himself, sitting near another person’s Amidah is permitted: he is not idle or behaving disrespectfully, and his sitting does not distract the other person. This applies during the different parts of his own tefillah. For example, he may continue praying Le David while someone nearby is still in the Amidah.
  • Listening to the Chazara is not necessarily considered praying oneself. During the Chazara, one must still consider whether someone nearby is praying the Amidah, including the Chazan.
  • If a person is learning Torah and needs to sit within four amot because there is nowhere else to sit, the speaker says one may be lenient.
  • The lecture also discusses the special difficulties of praying on a plane. Passengers have space for their seats, not the aisle or other shared areas; a Minyan that obstructs other passengers or crew may cause chilul Hashem. The concern may arise even on El Al if the Minyan blocks stewards and stewardesses from serving passengers, and it is especially significant on a non-Jewish airline.
  • Rabbi Shlomo Zalman Auerbach and many poskim have discussed prayer on planes. Depending on the circumstances, praying seated may be permitted and may even be preferable: standing can take up space that should remain available to others and may undermine Kavanah. Rabbi Yaakov Mizrahi stresses that the ruling depends on the circumstances.
  • If a husband is seated next to his wife on a plane and she begins the Amidah, the rules about whether he needs to move depend on whether he was already there and whether the location is designated for prayer. Since he was seated there first and a plane is not a Beit Knesset, he does not have to move or begin learning; if he can move, that is an option. His wife does not have to wake him if he is sleeping or interrupt what he was doing.

Whether someone already seated must move

  • The Ben Ish Chai’s discussion distinguishes a Beit Knesset from a place not designated for prayer, such as a home. If someone was already there before another person began praying, the fact that he was there first matters; in a home, the place is also not designated for tefillah. Even there, however, it is commendable to get up and move.
  • If someone comes to shul during Mincha, does not need to pray again, and has no room to move, the lecture discusses sitting beside someone who is praying. If he must sit there, he can occupy himself with prayer or other mizmorim rather than sit idly.
  • Hacham Ovadia says that if someone was already sitting and engaged in Torah or tefillah when another person began the Amidah in front of him, he need not move. Hacham Ovadia treats Torah and tefillah alike in this case. He says there is not even a midat chasidut in getting up; rather, one should be concerned about bitul Torah.
  • For example, someone learning Gemara in shul between the 7 o’clock and 8 o’clock Minyanim may continue learning when the later Minyan reaches the Amidah. He is not sitting idle, so he does not need to move.
  • If the person was sitting idle—for example, eating cake—he should move if this happens in a synagogue, even if he was there first. At home, he does not have to move, though it is still good to leave the four amot.
  • These rules concern someone who was already sitting before the other person began the Amidah. One should avoid entering the four amot when one was not there first; the speaker also distinguishes the case where the person sitting there is engaged in prayer or Torah study from one where he is doing neither.

Walking near someone praying

  • In ot zayin, the Ben Ish Chai says, “Asur la’avor betoch arba amot shel mitpalel”: one may not pass within four amot of someone praying. The rules for walking differ from those for sitting.
  • According to the Ben Ish Chai’s discussion of the four-amot restriction, one may walk behind someone praying if one does not disturb them. Walking at the side also requires care not to push or distract the person. The restriction against sitting within four amot does not automatically mean that walking or standing there is forbidden; walking in front is treated separately.
  • The Ben Ish Chai cites the Zohar’s stricter view: one may not walk in front of someone praying as long as one is visible to them, even beyond four amot. The lecture describes a dispute between Peshat and Kabbalah; to be careful for the Zohar, it says not to pass in front while visible and to stay outside four amot when passing at the side.
  • The Ben Ish Chai says a mechitzah ten tefachim high and four tefachim wide does not permit passing in front of the person praying. He also says not to pass in front of a Chazan who is occupied with other parts of the prayer, even when the Chazan is not standing in the Amidah.
  • Rabbi Yaakov Mizrahi applies this concern to a glass wall: if someone can see a person praying behind it, one should not walk in front of the glass. He gives the example of an airport terminal where someone is praying behind a glass wall. The concern is that the movement may distract the person, so one should wait until the Amidah is finished.

Hacham Ovadia’s ruling and the three steps

  • Hacham Ovadia follows Peshat rather than the Zohar’s broader restriction: walking in front of someone is forbidden within four amot, but permitted beyond four amot. Walking behind or at the side is permitted even within four amot.
  • Before taking the three steps back at the end of the Amidah, one should look behind to see whether someone is praying there. If the steps would place him within that person’s four amot, he should wait until the person finishes. If he will be behind or at the side of the person, he may take the steps.
  • The person should not keep turning around repeatedly to check. That could make the person praying uncomfortable and distract them; the point of waiting is to avoid disturbing them.
  • Rabbi Yaakov Mizrahi notes that waiting a few minutes is manageable: a person may stand for 20 minutes on Yom Kippur, and someone who has already prayed for 4, 5, or 6 minutes can wait a little longer.

The Chazan’s three steps

  • If a Chazan finishes the Amidah and someone behind him is still praying, he should not take the three steps back into that person’s four amot. Rather, he should begin the Chazarat immediately with “Amonai sefatai tiftach” and rely on taking the three steps after the repetition, at Kaddish Titkabal.
  • If the person has finished praying but cannot take the steps back, and the Chazan is waiting because he has not seen the steps, he should tell the Chazan that he has finished but cannot step back.

Sources covered

  • The lecture discusses the Ben Ish Chai’s ot vav and ot zayin, Hacham Ovadia’s rulings, and the laws of passing in front of someone praying in Siman Kuf Bet of Shulchan Aruch. The next lesson will continue with ot tet.
Words in this lecture1
Gemaraגמרא
Terms Gemara, the Talmud's discussion of the Mishnah. English: Commentary on the Mishnah
Also written: Gemarah, G'mara, Guemara, gmara
Plural: gemarot, gemaras