A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Yaakov Rahimi

Torah Lecture

Can One Watch Movies in the Sukkah? Can You Smoke a Cigar Inside a Sukkah?

Lectured by Rabbi Yaakov Rahimi

Published
October 20, 2024
Duration
4:11
Lecture code
RYR-176

Sukkah’s Status and Smoking

  • Rabbi Yaakov Rahimi explains that a sukkah has a status like a synagogue, as discussed in Moed LeKol Chai. Therefore, practices that apply in a shul or Beit Knesset can also apply in a sukkah.
  • Since one cannot smoke a cigar, cigarette, or hookah in a shul, the initial rule would be to smoke outside the sukkah. However, the sukkah must also be treated like one’s home to a certain extent: the Gemara says to leave one’s permanent home and live in a temporary dwelling.
  • Accordingly, the Poskim say that someone who smokes cigarettes, cigars, or hookah inside his home may also smoke them inside the sukkah. If he goes outside his home to smoke, it is better for him to leave the sukkah to smoke.

Speech and Watching Videos in the Sukkah

  • The Mishnah Berurah, Siman Taf Reish Lamed Tet, as well as the Chida and Chacham Ovadia Yosef, teach that one must be careful about what one says inside the sukkah.
  • Devarim Betelim (idle talk) should be avoided, especially Lashon Hara (evil speech) and rechilut (gossip). Cursing, immodest speech, and ka'as (anger) should also not be brought into the sukkah.
  • Because the sukkah has the din of a Beit Knesset, the care required about speech in a synagogue under the Shulchan Aruch applies there as well.
  • The lecture raises whether one may watch a movie or use a phone, including an iPhone, inside the sukkah. Rabbi Yaakov Rahimi says one should try to avoid videos that are not Divrei Torah or sippurei tzaddikim (stories of the righteous), and avoid occupying oneself with divrei chol—non-holy matters—inside the sukkah.

Other Conduct and Items in the Sukkah

  • The sukkah is described as a very holy place. The Poskim say one should try not to invite a goy (non-Jew) inside; the lecture also cautions that one cannot simply invite a goy into the sukkah.
  • One should not change a baby’s diaper inside the sukkah. Many rabbis also say not to keep a garbage can inside, whether it smells or is clean.
  • Many rabbis hold that food should not be brought into the sukkah in pots, but in appropriate utensils. Even for someone lenient about bringing food in pots, once the food is finished, the pots should be taken out. Dirty pots should not be left in the sukkah, even on the table while one remains there, because the sukkah should have a clean, holy, and neat atmosphere.
  • Rabbi Chaim Palachi says that one may not play various games, including card games or games with klafim, inside the sukkah.
  • The practical conclusion is to avoid playing poker, spending too much time on an iPhone, and watching videos about the news, politics, or sports in the sukkah.