A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Yaakov Rahimi

Torah Lecture

Can You Give Chicken or Meat to Children? Can You Buy Meat in the 9 Days?

Lectured by Rabbi Yaakov Rahimi

Published
August 5, 2024
Duration
4:23
Lecture code
RYR-147

Meat and Chicken During the Nine Days

  • Rabbi Yaakov Rahimi explains that during the next nine days, one should not eat meat or chicken, or food cooked together with meat or chicken.
  • A pareve soup cooked in a clean pot, with no meat or chicken in it, is permitted; it is not considered meat or chicken.
  • By contrast, chicken soup made with actual chicken, meat soup, or vegetables cooked with stuffed ground meat are considered meat even if the meat or chicken is removed afterward. Eating them has the din of eating meat, including the requirement to wait six hours, and they are not permitted during the nine days.

Buying Meat During the Nine Days

  • A person may buy meat or chicken during the nine days. For example, they may purchase it to cook later, save it, or take it on a trip for Tisha B'Av.

Children and Meat or Chicken

  • Rabbi Yaakov Rahimi says that most people can manage without meat or chicken, and that vitamins and certain vegetables can provide the same types of vitamins. While unusual cases may require meat or chicken—even for an adult—and have heterim, he says the average person does not need to regard going without it as an emergency.
  • The goal is to educate children about mourning the Churban of the Beit HaMikdash, since they are the next generation and should learn what that mourning means.
  • The practice is to try not to give children meat or chicken during the nine days, including children under nine, so they can learn to mourn the Beit HaMikdash. If a child understands the concept of avelut, the family should try to avoid giving them meat or chicken; the age at which children understand varies.
  • A very young baby who needs chicken for health reasons may be given it. Rabbi Yaakov Rahimi says that avoiding it for such a baby would be too much of a chumra, though it is fine to avoid it if possible.
  • If a child under nine does not understand the concept of mourning, and meat or chicken is the only food available or is needed for health reasons, it may be given. Rabbi Yaakov Rahimi says the halacha permits giving meat or chicken to a child under nine when needed.
  • Some rabbis are more machmir and say the child must be under seven, since they consider a seven-year-old able to understand the mourning. Rabbi Yaakov Rahimi acknowledges that households differ, and distinguishes the allowance under nine from the minhag to avoid meat and chicken and educate children about mourning the Beit HaMikdash.