A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Yaakov Rahimi

Torah Lecture

Can You Use an Egg Slicer on Shabbat? Are you allowed to Make Egg Salad?

Lectured by Rabbi Yaakov Rahimi

Published
August 29, 2024
Duration
3:55
Lecture code
RYR-159

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

Welcome to the daily halacha (Jewish law). Can one use an egg slicer on Shabbat? The halacha is that tochen is assur (forbidden) b'Shabbat (on Shabbat). Tochen means you're not allowed to crush vegetables into very, very small pieces on Shabbat, or fruits and anything that grows from the ground, unless you do it right before you're starting to eat a Shabbat meal, like 5 minutes before, 10 minutes before, or at most 30 minutes before. Only then are you allowed to cut vegetables into very small pieces. However, things that are not grown from the ground, like meat, cheese, or eggs, do not violate the issur (prohibition) of tochen. So you're allowed to crush an egg on Shabbat; you're allowed to make eggs on Shabbat, which we're going to discuss exactly how you're allowed to make eggs on Shabbat. But when it comes to an egg slicer, even though there's no tochen, there is a problem called uvdin dechol.

Rav Moshe Feinstein brings down that an egg slicer violates the issur of uvdin dechol. What exactly do the words uvdin dechol? It means there are certain acts on Shabbat that we avoid; we try our best to avoid them in order not to bring us into a working weekday mode. That's basically what uvdin dechol means. When do we say something is uvdin dechol? That's up to the rabbis; they tell us exactly when we say uvdin dechol and when we don't. The maximum you have is 30 minutes before the meal. Specifically, the chachamim (the rabbis) say one should not use an egg slicer on Shabbat because it violates the problem of uvdin dechol. So can one do it? Can one use an egg slicer? The answer is no. According to Rav Moshe Feinstein, the halacha is that one should not use an egg slicer on Shabbat to put an egg inside it because of uvdin dechol.

How are you allowed to make an egg salad on Shabbat? There is a melacha (forbidden labor) called lash. Lash means you're not allowed to make a mixture on Shabbat. You're not allowed to make hummus on Shabbat. You're not allowed to make tahina on Shabbat. Basically, you're not allowed to make any dips on Shabbat. It's called lash. However, if one wants to make a thicker type of mixture, a very, very thick type of dip like an egg salad, how could you do it on Shabbat? The answer is that you have to do two things differently from how you make egg salad during the week. One is that you have to switch the order of how you put it inside the plate. If you usually have crushed eggs on a plate and then put in the mayonnaise, on Shabbat you switch it around. You put the mayonnaise in the bowl first—the empty bowl—and then you put the eggs inside. So that's one shinui. That's one thing you're doing differently on Shabbat.

Another thing that you have to do in order to make egg salad is change the way you mix it. You have to mix it, not the way you mix it the rest of the week. Rather, you mix it by making basically shti va'erev, which basically is a cross. You go left, up, and down. Left to right, up, and down. Left to right, up, and down. Or an M shape. Make the M letter—the actual M, the English alphabet, the actual letter M. That's how you can mix the bowl of egg salad. But regular mixing, when you move it all around in a circle, that's not allowed on Shabbat if you want to make egg salad.

So could you make egg salad on Shabbat? The answer is no. However, if you use those two strategies, which are different from what you do during the week, to make the egg salad, you switch the order of putting it into the bowl. First you put the mayo, then the eggs. Second, you change the way you mix it: you don't mix it regularly. You mix it in the shape of a letter M, going back and forth with a spoon or a knife. Or you go back and forth, left to right, up and down. That type of mixing is allowed. But if a person is going to mix regularly all around in circles, as we do during the week, then they're not going to make the egg salad on Shabbat. That's how a person avoids the issur of lash on Shabbat.

Another condition that Hacham Ovadia brings down is trying to make it right before the meal. So if you're having the meal at 11 o'clock, try to make the egg salad at 10.30 or at 10.45. The closer to the meal, the better. Try to make the egg salad.