A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Yossi Saadeh

Torah Lecture

Beha’alotecha - Don’t Complain Only Compliment

Lectured by Rabbi Yossi Saadeh

Published
June 5, 2026
Duration
9:27
Lecture code
RYS-PAR93

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

Good morning, everybody. We are studying today Parashat Beha'alotecha. In this week's parasha, we find something about Moshe Rabbeinu that we don't usually find in the other parashiyot. We know Moshe Rabbeinu went through a very, very difficult time leading Bnei Yisrael. It was not easy. It was not a simple 40 years of being a leader of Am Yisrael. Being a leader of such a nation is a great zekhut (merit), but it came with tremendous challenges, trials, and tribulations. Moshe Rabbeinu did not have it easy. But throughout all the parashiyot, we find that Moshe Rabbeinu was always strong. Moshe Rabbeinu stood for Am Yisrael. Moshe Rabbeinu didn't give up. Moshe Rabbeinu always, always defended Am Yisrael, and he found a way to make it work.

But then comes this week's parasha, and we see Moshe Rabbeinu react in a different way, in a way that is not usual for him. In this week's parasha, we find that Bnei Yisrael complain. They complain about the man (manna). They complain about not having basar, not having meat. Then Moshe Rabbeinu says the following to Hashem: “I can't do this anymore. I cannot continue to carry these people.” Moshe Rabbeinu says to Hashem, “If this is going to continue like this, just kill me, just finish me off. I'm done. I surrender. I can't do this anymore.”

Ask Rabbi Avigdor Miller: What happened all of a sudden to Moshe Rabbeinu? Why do we find Moshe literally giving up over here? He's surrendering. He just wants to be finished with this. “I don't want to have anything to do with them anymore. Just kill me and get rid of me. I don't want this anymore.” What happened to the Moshe Rabbeinu we know from the previous parashiyot, where he always stood for Am Yisrael? He never gave up. He continued to push and push, and he would defend Am Yisrael. All of a sudden, over here, we find Moshe Rabbeinu literally surrendering and giving up.

Ask Rabbi Miller: What happened over here? Rabbi Miller says that the answer lies in one word we find in these Pesukim (verses): mit'onenim, which means complainers. Rabbi Miller says Moshe Rabbeinu saw here that there was complaining when Hashem had blessed them with so much. Here you have the man coming down from Shamayim (heavens) every day. There's water coming out of a rock every single day, but Borei Olam (Creator of the world) is performing miracles. There's the Ananei HaKavod, the clouds of glory. There's the pillar of fire that used to come at night to protect them. Moshe Rabbeinu sees a nation blessed with so much good, and they are mit'onenim, complaining about the man and the situation they're in.

Rabbi Miller says that when Moshe Rabbeinu saw that, with all the blessings they had, they were still complaining—that they were not happy with what they had and were not content with what they had—Moshe Rabbeinu said at that point, “I give up. I can't deal with such people because they will never ever be happy. And there's nothing that I can do to make them happy. If the man coming from Shamayim is not going to make them happy, if the water that comes out of a rock is not going to make them happy, when all these miraculous things are happening, and they're complaining about that, if the clouds of glory and the pillar of fire that they would see on a daily basis are not enough, at that point, this I cannot handle.”

As Rabbi Miller writes, “You can't work with complainers. You can't work with people who are not grateful. You can't work with people who don't have simchat chayim. They don't enjoy what they have. They complain about what they have. They're not content with what they have.” Rabbi Miller says this is what brought Moshe Rabbeinu to the point of surrendering: “Hashem, I can't. I can't deal with this anymore.” Moshe Rabbeinu was not able to handle or tolerate this type of attitude. Therefore, Moshe says, “I can't do this anymore.”

Rabbi Miller is teaching us something very, very important: when you have a person who is a complainer, a person who is not happy with what he has, it's very hard to work with someone who has such an attitude. You can't talk to him. There's nothing that will make him happy. Therefore, Rabbi Miller says, we have to make sure that we stay very, very far from developing such an attitude. We have to work on how we respond to HaKadosh Baruch Hu (The Holy One, blessed is He) for what He has given us: thanking Hashem for what He blesses us with, acknowledging the good, recognizing the good, and being content with what we have. We should not complain and look at what we don't have, but be happy with what we have. We should be a person who is happy with his share, a person who is wealthy. A person who is happy with his share—that's the definition of a person who is... They say the root of the word Ashir is the letters Ayin (letter ayin), Shin (letter shin), and Resh (letter resh), which are exactly the same letters as the word eser. The word eser means the number 10. The number 10 is a complete number. It is not lacking. It's not missing. It's whole and complete. The definition of an Ashir is a person who views his life as a life of eser: he is complete. He is content. He is not missing anything. He is whole. Just like the number 10 is a whole number, he views himself as whole, even though he doesn't have half of the things that other people have. But he's happy with his share, and he feels he is complete.

The Chachamim (sages) say that an Ashir is a person who feels like he is the number 10. He is complete. He is whole. “I'm not missing anything. I'm not lacking anything. I'm happy with what I have.” That is an Ashir. That is a person who is wealthy. When a person lives his life with that perspective, he's not a mit'onen, a complainer. He's not a person who is kafui tovah, ungrateful. Rather, he recognizes all the good that Hashem blesses him with. He is content with it. He is Sameach Bechelko (happy with his share).

The lesson we are taking from this week's parasha is that a person should try to work on himself so that he stays very, very far from acquiring the title of mit'onenim, a complainer. A person should have a positive eye, a good eye. Look at the goodness that Borei Olam gives us. Look at the blessings that Hashem gives us. When Borei Olam sees that this is a person who acknowledges the good and praises Borei Olam for it, Borei Olam will shower that person with even more good, with even more blessings. Borei Olam knows this is a person who is grateful: “If I give him more blessings, he will acknowledge them. If I shower him with more goodness, he will recognize them and praise me for them.” That is the person that Borei Olam loves to shower with goodness and blessings. Have a wonderful day, and Shabbat Shalom.