A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Yossi Saadeh

Torah Lecture

Beshalach - Our Ups and Downs Are All Part of a Beautiful Song

Lectured by Rabbi Yossi Saadeh

Published
January 30, 2026
Duration
19:09
Lecture code
RYS-PAR75

Shabbat Shira and the Question of Timing

  • Parashat Beshalach is called Shabbat Shira because it contains “Az Yashir Moshe u'Vnei Yisrael et hashira hazot”: Moshe and the children of Israel sang after Hashem split the Yam Suf.
  • The Ben Ish Chai asks why the Jewish people waited until Keriat Yam Suf to sing. They left Mitzrayim on the 15th of Nisan, after 210 years of bondage, and Keriat Yam Suf took place seven days later, on Shevi'i shel Pesach. Why did they not sing as soon as they were freed?
  • Rabbi Yossi Saadeh suggests that expressing gratitude to Hashem was not the song’s main purpose; if it were, they could have sung when they left Mitzrayim. The song conveyed a deeper lesson that became clear at Keriat Yam Suf.

The Sea: From Apparent Enemy to Ally

  • At the Yam Suf, the Jewish people were trapped, with the sea in front of them and the Egyptian army pursuing them from behind. The sea seemed to be an enemy blocking their escape and threatening them.
  • When Hashem split the sea, it not only ceased to be an obstacle: the water drowned the Egyptians. What had seemed like their enemy became their ally, and what looked like a difficulty turned out to be good for them.
  • The people responded with Shira to express what they had learned: even when something seems like a problem or an enemy, Borei Olam may have a good reason for it. It may be a low point, but it can still be part of a beautiful song.

The Meaning of the Word “Az”

  • The Baal HaTurim asks why the song begins with “Az”: “Az Yashir Moshe.”
  • When Moshe Rabbeinu went to Paro to ask that the people be allowed to leave, Paro made their work harder, and the people complained to Moshe that he had made matters worse. Moshe then complained to Borei Olam that from the time he came to Paro, things had become more difficult, using the word “Az.”
  • The Baal HaTurim explains that Moshe used that same word to begin the song: “Be'oto Lashon,” in that very language. Rabbi Yossi Saadeh connects this to the lesson of Keriat Yam Suf: Moshe could now sing with the word he had used when he saw difficulty, because what had seemed bad might in fact be good. The “Az” of hardship could also be the beginning of a song.

Each Life as a Song

  • Rabbi Yossi Saadeh says that each person’s life is like a song, with its own “musical notes”: high notes, low notes, and sometimes turbulence. Even the difficult parts and low points belong to the song, although it may be hard to see that at the time.
  • He describes each person as being born with a pamphlet containing the notes of their life. Its cover might read, “This is the song of Jacob,” “This is the song of Ralph,” “This is the song of Rami,” or “This is your song.” The ups and downs are all part of that person’s life-song.

The Drums and Miriam’s Tof

  • At a wedding with a large band, Rabbi Yossi Saadeh calls the drums the most important instrument: they establish the beat and bring life to the party. Other instruments may be beautiful, but without the drums, people would not dance.
  • The drums are also the instrument that gets beaten the most. While a violin receives what he likens to a “massage,” and a keyboard or piano receives finger movements, the drum set is the ba'al yisurim of the band—yet it brings the party to life.
  • After Keriat Yam Suf, Miriam took a tof (tambourine) and the women followed her in song. Rabbi Yossi Saadeh presents the tof as a way of conveying the lesson they had learned: even when a person feels beaten up by life, something good may emerge from that experience.
  • As with the drum that is struck but gives life to the music, a difficult period in someone’s life may be what brings life to the whole. We may not know how, but the low notes and hard times remain part of the person’s song.

Praising Elokim with Song

  • David HaMelech says in Tehillim that he praises the name of Elokim with song. Rabbi Yossi Saadeh contrasts Yud-Kei-Vav-Kei, associated with Rachamim, with Elokim, associated with Din, and asks why one would sing praise specifically in connection with Din.
  • He explains that the song is a response to difficulty: just as a song’s low notes are part of its beauty, a person’s experience of Din and hardship can be part of something beautiful. One may not understand why it is happening, but can believe that something good will come from it.

The Lesson of Shabbat Shira

  • Rabbi Yossi Saadeh concludes that Shabbat Shira is named for the significance of this lesson: life has ups and downs, and even the downs are part of the beautiful song Borei Olam has in mind for each person.
  • When facing a hard time, a person should remember the lesson of Keriat Yam Suf: even a difficulty that seems painful or hostile may be part of that song.
Words in this lecture1
Pasukפסוק
Terms Pasuk, a verse. English: Biblical verse
Also written: Passuk, posuk, psuq
Plural: Pesukim, psukim, p'sukim, psuqim, Pesukei, psukeem