A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Zvi Aryeh Rosenfeld ZTL

Torah Lecture

Navi 03 (Clip) - Shoftim; The Merit of Gidon

Lectured by Rabbi Zvi Aryeh Rosenfeld ZTL

Published
December 21, 2023
Duration
9:36
Lecture code
RZR-N-SH01

The Shoftim and the Midianite Oppression

  • Rabbi Zvi Aryeh Rosenfeld places the story in the history of Navi: after Moshe Rabbeinu’s passing, Yehoshua led the Jews into Eretz Yisrael, where they fought the 31 kings and conquered Canaan.
  • After Yehoshua and his generation passed away, the next generation turned from Hashem to idols. Rabbi Rosenfeld explains that this followed the Jews’ failure to obey Hashem’s command to eradicate the seven nations living in the land. Although kindness is a mitzvah, allegiance to Hashem takes precedence: if Hashem commands otherwise, kindness must be set aside.
  • The remaining members of those nations grew in strength and eventually defeated and subjugated the Jews. The Jews suffered torment and persecution under their rule, and this brought them to repentance. Hashem helped them regain their position, and a leader arose to bring them victory; after that leader died, the Jews again turned to evil. This cycle continued until the time of King David.
  • The leaders of this period were the shoftim. The previous leader, the prophetess Devorah, had brought the Jews 40 years of peace. After her passing, they returned to idol worship, and Hashem gave the Midianites power over them for seven years. The Midianites destroyed their fields, killed their cattle, and imposed heavy taxes. The Jews finally cried out and prayed to Hashem.
  • Rabbi Rosenfeld emphasizes that no sin is beyond repair: Hashem is infinite, and His kindness and patience are likewise without limit. A Jew who returns to Hashem and pleads for forgiveness and kindness can receive it, even after committing the worst sins repeatedly. The repeated turning away and return of the Jews is therefore no cause for wonder; each time, Hashem took them back and a new leader arose.

Gideon’s Merit and His Encounter with the Malach

  • While the Jews were crying out to Hashem, a malach appeared in the garden of Gideon, son of Yoash, of the tribe of Menasheh.
  • Gideon’s notable quality was his deep respect and loyalty to his father, fulfilling Kibbud Av to the utmost. Knowing the Midianites might attack, he told his father to remain hidden while Gideon worked the fields to gather and conceal as much produce as possible.
  • The malach greeted him: “Hashem is with you, you valiant warrior.” Rabbi Rosenfeld explains the greeting through the idea that a human being has three partners: the father and mother produce the physical body, and Hashem gives it the five senses and, above all, the spirit of life. Hashem considers respect shown to His partners as respect shown to Him.
  • The greeting also refers to the meaning of a gibbor: a powerful person is one who overcomes temptation and fulfills Hashem’s mitzvot.
  • Gideon asked the malach why, if Hashem was with the Jews, these troubles had befallen them and where Hashem’s protection was. He argued that the Jews’ actions did not remove their claim to Hashem’s help: if the Jews who left Egyptian slavery were righteous, their merits should still protect their descendants; if they were wicked, their rescue shows that Hashem helps the wicked, and so He should help the Jews now as well. Gideon therefore asked, regardless of which category the Jews belonged to, “You say Hashem is with us—where?”

Hashem’s Charge and the Explanation of the Zera Kodesh

  • The Torah relates that the malach did not answer Gideon. Hashem Himself then spoke to him, telling him to use the strength he had to help the Jews defeat the Midianites. Hashem was sending him to lead them.
  • The Gemara, especially the Zohar, asks why Hashem spoke directly to Gideon when he was not such a great tzaddik as to merit the rare privilege of an angel speaking to him.
  • The Zera Kodesh answers that Gideon had just performed an act that surpassed Eliyahu Hanavi’s: rather than attack the Jews for their idol worship, Gideon defended them and fought on their behalf.
  • Rabbi Rosenfeld contrasts this with Eliyahu Hanavi, who sought to avenge the desecration of Hashem’s honor by the idol-worshipping Jews and brought famine and drought upon them. Hashem wanted a leader who would defend the Jews, like Moshe Rabbeinu.
  • Rabbi Rosenfeld explains the comparison through the Gemara’s description of the giving of the Torah as a wedding between Hashem and the Jews. When the Jews worshipped the golden calf, it was like a bride turning from her groom and committing adultery. Moshe nevertheless defended them, telling Hashem that if even one Jew were to be harmed, Hashem should kill him first.
  • Hashem’s response to Gideon’s defense of the Jews was that this was the kind of leader He wanted for His children. He told Gideon to go with his strength and lead the Jews to victory.
Words in this lecture1
Kena'anכנען
1.Places The land promised to Avraham and his descendants, west of the Yarden, whose borders are set out in Bamidbar 34. Bereshit 12:5–7; 17:8. English: Canaan
2.Biblical figures Son of Cham, cursed by Noach to be a slave to his brothers; father of Tzidon, Chet and the peoples of Kena'an. Bereshit 9:18-27; 10:15-19. English: Canaan
Also written: Canaan, Eretz Kena'an, Kana'an