There’s a dilemma that many people struggle with: How do I balance my hishtadlut with my emunah and bitachon in Hashem? We know that we’re commanded to have full faith and belief in Hashem to support us. But we also know that we’re required and obligated to do hishtadlut: to work hard, to put our best foot forward, and to put our effort into making our livelihood.
I think the holiday of Chanukah teaches us this lesson and how to approach it. We know the famous question from the Beit Yosef: Why is the holiday of Chanukah eight nights? If the miracle of the oil lasting was only for seven nights, we know that they found a little jug of oil that had the ability to last one night. So when they lit it for one night, that was nature. The miracle was only on nights two to eight, when something miraculous happened and the oil lasted. So why do we celebrate the first night, when the oil lit according to nature?
The answer we could say is that when Bnei Yisrael lit that first night, it represented our hishtadlut. That represents what’s in our hands to do. That represents what’s natural and what we could put forward. But we’re showing that even when we lit the first light, when we lit that first cup of oil, we said that this oil could only light and only be successful if Hashem blessed it, and that we would only be able to light even the first night if Hashem allowed it to happen. That we have our eyes saying we’re doing our hishtadlut. But even what we think our hishtadlut could produce could only be produced by Hashem. That’s why we celebrate the first night of Chanukah no differently from nights two to eight. Everything is a miracle because anything I put forth could only be successful if Hashem allows it to be successful.
We see the consequence of one who doesn’t have proper emunah and bitachon when they do their hishtadlut in last week’s parasha. It says Yosef HaTzadik was sitting in prison and had just interpreted the dream for the Sar HaMashkim, the wine bearer of Paro. Yosef told him, “You’re going to go back to your post and serve Paro.” He told him, “When you go back, please remember me. When you go to Paro, tell him to release me.” And the Torah tells us that he told the Sar HaMashkim to remember him two times. The rabbis tell us that Yosef was punished with an extra two years in prison because he told the Sar HaMashkim to remember him two times and did not have his emunah in Hashem.
The famous question asked about this episode is: What happened to hishtadlut? Imagine you’re sitting in prison and you have a guy there who owes you one, and that person is going to speak to the king. Wouldn’t it be your hishtadlut? Wouldn’t that be the natural effort you have to put forth—to tell that person to put in a good word for you and remember you? The answer they give is no. Why do you tell him twice? Why do you tell him, “Remember me, remember me”? If you’re doing your hishtadlut, you only have to tell him one time. That’s what your effort requires. Once you put in your effort, now we rely on Hashem. We don’t go above and beyond what our effort requires.
So because Yosef said, “Remember me” twice, that’s why he got punished for two years. But now the question you could ask is: Okay, so I understand he went above and beyond hishtadlut. But he only went one time above. So instead of getting punished for two years, he should have gotten punished for one year, because the first “Remember me” was what he was supposed to do. The rabbis say no. When a person shows that he’s going beyond his hishtadlut, that shows that he doesn’t have his emunah in Hashem. And that now reveals that even the first time he said, “Remember me,” his emunah wasn’t in Hashem. His emunah was in the Sar HaMashkim. A person has to know that when we go to work, we put in hishtadlut. That’s what we’re required to do. But even that first hishtadlut that we put in, the result of that is only if Hashem wants to bless us and make us successful.
I think this is fundamental for every person to have when they pray. When you pray, you say, “Hashem, I’m about to go to work. But please, when I go to work, just know I’m just doing my hishtadlut. Hashem, I’m asking you, please bless me. I’m not relying on anyone or anything else other than your Beracha (blessing).” Have a great day.

