A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Ariel Mizrahi

Torah Lecture

Emor The Fake Collector

Lectured by Rabbi Ariel Mizrahi

Published
April 30, 2026
Duration
27:21
Lecture code
RAM-227

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

Good morning, everyone, in Chazak Baruch Hu. Thank you for joining us on this beautiful Tuesday morning as we begin Parashat Emor together. Our parasha, of course, is famous because it carries the holidays and their laws, a basic summary of the different holidays that exist.

Of course, it starts with Pesach. The Torah tells us in chapter 23, in this week’s parasha, “Tell the Jewish people, these are My holidays.” It starts, of course, with Shabbat. It tells us a little about the Sabbath. That’s an interesting class in itself: Why does it talk about Shabbat if it’s telling you about the holidays? And then it goes into the holidays. It tells us about the first holiday, Pesach, which is to be observed in the first month, on the 14th, toward the evening. Observe Pesach, Chag HaMatzot. It’s a holiday, and the 7th day is also a holiday.

Then it moves on to the next holiday. What’s the holiday after Pesach? The Omer. The counting of the Omer. We spoke yesterday about the mitzvah (commandment) of the Omer and why it is so important. The Torah says you should count 49 days, and at the end of the 49 days, you shall observe another holiday. What’s that holiday called? It’s called Shavuot. Beautiful.

Then it goes on to the next holiday. The Torah tells us in Pasuk (verse) 23, “Then tell them that on the first of the month, there’s the next holiday of the 7th month.” It’s called Rosh Hashanah. It doesn’t say Rosh Hashanah here. It doesn’t say “Rosh Hashanah,” but it says they shall blow a shofar (ram’s horn). They shall blow a shofar. Don’t do any work. That’s Rosh Hashanah. And then it tells us about the 10th of that month. Which holiday is that? Yom Kippur. You shall inflict your soul—afflict your soul. Don’t eat, right? We know there are five things that we’re not allowed to do.

Very good. Then it goes on to the next holiday and tells us that on the 15th of the month, we are to observe Sukkot, the holiday of Sukkot. We should take the four species: the Etrog (citron), the Hadas (myrtle), and the Aravot (willow branches). This is really an amazing summary. And sit in a sukkah (booth). Sit in a sukkah. Fine, very nice.

So this is the Torah. These are the mitzvot. These are the holidays. Of course, these are the biblical holidays: Pesach, the Omer leading up to Shavuot, Rosh Hashanah, Kippur, and Sukkot. The three pilgrim festivals, the pilgrimage festivals of the Shalosh Regalim (three pilgrim festivals). And then the two in between, Rosh Hashanah and Kippur. All together, that is five.

Of course, we also have holidays from the rabbis: Purim and Hanukkah. They won’t appear in the Torah because that would kind of take away free will. If God were to tell us about future things that were going to happen before they happened, that would be a little trippy. By the way, the very next halakha (Jewish law) after the holiday of Sukkot is in chapter 24. God says to Moshe, “Let them light the menorah (lampstand),” which is very fascinating. A little hint, a little hint, a little hint about the holiday of Hanukkah. God is saying, go and collect oil for the menorah that was in the Beit HaMikdash. So it’s a little wink from God, saying that the next holiday after Sukkot is going to be Hanukkah. Although, again, Hanukkah isn’t actually commanded here explicitly. But it is what we call a nice little remez (allusion). So this is chapter 23, summarizing for us the five holidays.

And yet the Torah comes right here, smack in the middle. Smack in the middle. In chapter 23, Pasuk 22, God says, “And by the way, by the way, just got to tell you this technical halakha: As you are harvesting, don’t harvest the corner of your field.” The Peah, the corner of your field. If anyone here is a farmer, the law is for you: You’re not allowed to cut the entire field. You have to leave a little bit of it for the Ani, the poor man. This has piqued the interest, the curiosity, of many of the commentaries. What in the world is this doing here? Why is the Torah telling us, smack in the middle of the laws of the holidays, about a law of Peah, about leaving the field for the poor man? It’s an important halakha, but what are you telling it to me here?

There are different ideas and many different answers. But all of those ideas and answers fail to answer the following question. Maybe you’ve heard this question before, maybe you’ve even heard an answer before. Maybe an obvious answer, a very beautiful answer to the question, is that the Torah is telling you that although you have mitzvot to observe, mitzvot between man and God, don’t forget about the poor guy. Don’t forget about man to man. Don’t forget about how you treat people. Don’t forget about tzedakah (charity). That’s equally important. Again, that’s a whole class. I’ve given that class in the past. It’s a beautiful idea. But it fails to answer the only remaining question: Why is it right here, between the holiday of Shavuot and Rosh Hashanah? What is it doing in this specific area of the holidays? If you want to tell me that message, you could have stuck it between Rosh Hashanah and Kippur, or Kippur and Sukkot. There are five holidays, so there are maybe four different areas where you could have inserted this halakha. Why are you telling it to me right here, between Rosh Hashanah and Shavuot?

This is the question of Meshech Chochmah, my friends. The Meshech Chochmah takes us today on a beautiful deep dive into why this topic of leaving something for the poor is right here before Rosh Hashanah. The Meshech Chochmah brings a beautiful idea. The Midrash (rabbinic interpretation) makes a very interesting comment. Look what the Midrash says. This Midrash is found in Vayikra Rabbah. The Midrash says, based on the Pasuk in Yirmiyahu, “I will bring destruction upon all the nations.” Look at this: All of the nations completely remove their field. They harvest the entire field. They don’t leave anything over. “I will destroy them. But the Jews, I will not destroy you.” Why? Because you don’t completely destroy your field. Because you leave a corner for the poor, I will not destroy you. And that’s why the Torah juxtaposes this idea of leaving the corner with the very next holiday, Rosh Hashanah.

This is a very intriguing Midrash. To explain what the Midrash means to say: Because you leave the corner, I will not cut you off from this world, so to speak. Let’s think about Rosh Hashanah for a second. Rosh Hashanah, Yom HaDin, the Day of Judgment. The Gemara says every person passes in front of God one at a time, and we’re being judged. What will the year look like? Will we have life? Will we have death? Will we have health or sickness? Parnassah (livelihood) or no Parnassah? Children or no children? Every person is getting judged.

Now, if I were to ask you, out of all the dates of the year, what date would be best? If God is trying to show favoritism, as the Midrash is trying to suggest—God is trying to say, “I’m going to favor the Jews. The Jews, you will not be destroyed. The Goyim (non-Jews) will be destroyed. But you, you will live. You’ll have a good year”—at what point of the year would you say the difference between a Jew and a non-Jew is most pronounced? Let me ask you this: At what point of the year would it be best to judge us, if God were going to judge us and pick a day when our verdict would most likely come out innocent? When would be the best time to judge a person? When they’re on their best behavior, right? The best time to judge a person is when they’ve just spent an entire day or month or period of time learning, doing, right?

Think about the year if you’re a farmer. When is the busy season? When is the not-busy season? For a farmer, the busy season is actually from the spring until almost Sukkot. That’s when you’re harvesting, doing all the work, spreading it out in the field, gathering, and so on. That’s when you’re harvesting, gathering, and selling. The busy season is actually the summer season. It’s ironic that today the summer is relaxing and it’s summer vacation. But in truth, in the farmer’s world, the quiet season is from Sukkot in the winter until Pesach. That’s actually the quiet season; there’s nothing doing.

Historically, you should know that the Jews in that time of year, in the winter season, would catch up on their religion. Most Jews would get their learning done in the winter, because that’s when they were free. They didn’t have farming to do, and they didn’t have Netflix to watch. So what were they going to do? They were going to learn. They used to go to the yeshiva; they used to take some time off and get inspired, right?

Well, if that’s the case, if you’re God, when is the best time of the year to judge a Jew if you want to give him a favorable verdict? It makes sense that you would judge him right after the winter season. In truth, Rosh Hashanah should be at the exact opposite part of the year. Judgment Day should be—if anything, if you were God and you wanted to judge Jews favorably, wouldn’t you pick right after the winter, when the Jew comes with hours and months of Torah under his belt, of learning and praying, when he was living the most spiritual life? Wouldn’t you pick that time of year to judge the Jew?

But we know that’s not the case. Instead, for some reason, God, Hashem, chose the opposite: right after we just spent months doing mundane things, average things, the same as the non-Jew. A Jew and a non-Jew look the same from April until September. Their lives are the same. They’re both planting. They’re both harvesting. They’re both spreading. They’re doing the same things. We’re both out in the fields.

So you would think the difference between a Jew and a non-Jew would be much more highlighted after the winter season. If anything, God should judge us at Pesach time. If I were God, I might think to say Rosh Hashanah should be in April, not September. The judgment would be much more favorable, if anything, no? So why is the best time to judge us in September, right after the harvest?

This, says the Meshech Chochmah, is what the Midrash is coming to answer. The Torah is giving us a little hint: “You know why I picked September? You know why I picked right after the harvest season? Because that’s right as you are leaving the corner of your field.” To understand what that means, Hashem judges and operates according to what we call measure for measure. Hashem interacts with the world through middah keneged middah (measure for measure), right? The way we act is the way Hashem acts with us, and this is true on many, many levels.

As an example, we know that if a person is forgiving, then Hashem will be forgiving. If you’re stubborn, if you’re going to wait for them to apologize, if you’re going to hold on to, you know, “I’m not forgiving. I’m fair. It’s too much. Enough is enough. I keep forgiving them. I’m going to keep doing this.” So if you want to be stubborn, if you want to be fair, if you want to be just, guess what, my friends? Hashem is going to be just with you. Hashem is going to be fair with you. We cannot afford that, right? We don’t want that. We want the heavens to forgive us. We want the heavens to give us a second and a third and a 10,000th chance, right? We want Hashem to give us chance after chance. And so, middah keneged middah, they look and ask, “Okay, well, how are you doing? Are you giving people another chance? Are you forgiving?”

As an example, the Gemara tells us in Rosh Hashanah a fascinating story. The Gemara says there was once a drought. They asked the great rabbi—I believe it was Rabi, who was it?—Rabi Eliezer. Rabi Eliezer got up and prayed for rain. He was praying and fasting and doing Aneinu (answer us) and everything, and nothing—not a single drop of rain. Finally, they said, “Okay, let’s send another rabbi. Maybe he’ll have better luck.” So who did they ask? They asked Rabi Akiva. Rabi Akiva came and said one line: “Avinu Malkeinu (Our Father, our King).” He didn’t even finish the sentence. He said, “Hashem, please”—boom, thunder starts pouring.

Now imagine what everyone started wondering. Everyone started saying, “Of course Rabi Akiva is a much greater rabbi. I’m going to go to him for my berachot (blessings). I’m going to ask him to do my wedding. I’m going to join his shul (synagogue) tomorrow.” His prayer got answered, so rumors went around: Rabi Akiva is greater than Rabi Eliezer. And all of a sudden, it says, a voice from the heavens emanated and said, “No, he’s not necessarily greater.” So why did he get answered? Because he was a more forgiving personality. And so it has only to do with greatness. Maybe indeed the first rabbi was greater, but bottom line, Rabi Akiva was more forgiving. When you’re forgiving, measure for measure, the heavens forgive you. You want rain; you want the heavens to bless you, to forgive you for whatever sins we did. We need to forgive others for what we did. Since Rabi Akiva was more forgiving, the heavens were more forgiving with him on his behalf. Unbelievable. Unbelievable.

So that’s what the Gemara is saying. That’s what the Gemara is saying. The Gemara is telling us that God is measure for measure. Middah keneged middah. Middah keneged middah. Middah keneged middah. Middah keneged middah.

If that’s the case, we want the heavens to judge us favorably on Rosh Hashanah. It makes sense that it should be done at the time of year when we will get the best measure for measure. And like we just said, if we want the heavens to forgive us, it has to be at a time when we’re forgiving. It has to be at a time of year when we are doing, giving, and being kind. If we want kindness from the heavens, we have to be kind to others. Well, let me ask you, my friends: When is the time of year that we’re giving the most kindness?

You’ll say, “Well, what do you mean? You could give tzedakah any day of the year. There is no day that has more kindness than any other.” And that is true as far as charity is concerned. But there are two types, my friends. There are two types of charity, says the Meshech Chochmah. This is gorgeous stuff. There are two types of charity. One level of charity is where you give the Kohen (priest), the Levi (Levite), or the poor guy a gift. And you, as the owner, have the right to decide who is worthy of this gift. Yes?

There are many taxes. Unfortunately, with the government, I don’t get to decide where my taxes go. I have to pay state tax, I have to pay federal tax, and I don’t get to allocate it. The government decides what they think, depending on lobbying, votes, bribes, or whatever—however they get it. They decide where the money goes, right? I don’t get to choose whether my money goes to pay for a newer street or a bridge, or whether it’s going to pay for who knows what nonsense. I don’t get to decide. The government feels these are all worthy causes, and they give it to whom they like, right?

Now, in the Torah, sometimes I get to decide. I get to decide whom I give my tzedakah to. Am I giving it to, you know, a Kohen? Am I giving it to Gindi, to Tawil, to Katz? Which Kohen? Which Kohen do I want to give my gift to? I like this Kohen. I like this Kohen. I like this Kohen. I think he’s more legitimate. That guy’s serious; that guy’s wasting time. He’s always having coffee room. This guy’s a sketch, right? I get to decide which Kohen I think is worthy. I get to decide which Levi I think is worthy. I get to decide which pauper I think is worthy. I have the benefit. I have that right to decide: Who do I want to give my funds, my tzedakah, to? That is one type of charity.

By contrast, there is another form of charity that the Torah requires us to give, where you’re not allowed to decide who’s worthy. You don’t get to pick who gets it. And that is, my friends, what I’m referring to in our parasha: the corner of your field. Why would a person not leave the corner of his field? Why would he not leave the corner of his field? I’ll tell you why. Because he sees, you know, Joe the charlatan. He sees the faker. “That guy’s going to come and take my wheat? That guy’s the biggest sketch. He’s not really poor. He could get a job. He’s freeloading. The guy’s a charlatan. I’m not going to leave him my corner,” right? These are the thoughts that could go on in a farmer’s head: “I’m not leaving the guy to take my stuff.”

Peah is very interesting. It’s the only mitzvah of charity where, in a way, you don’t have a say. You don’t get to choose. And you’re actually even leaving it for someone who maybe, in your head, is unworthy, doesn’t deserve it. It’s going to go to the worst; he’s not giving me the good. And who among us can raise a hand and say, “I deserve, I deserve. Me, pick me, I deserve”? Could anyone here say, “I deserve”? Honestly, we don’t deserve. And Hashem says, “Well, let me see what you did down there.” If we on planet Earth were able to interact in a way that allowed us to give charity even to those we didn’t feel deserved it, then God says, “Well, if that’s the case, I will bless you with a year even though you didn’t deserve. I will shower you with a good verdict even though maybe you’re unworthy.”

Says the Midrash, there’s no better day of the year, no better time of the year, to get judged than actually after the summer season. Because maybe we’re not clean. Maybe we did a lot of averot (sins). Maybe we just did a lot of—we weren’t learning. We weren’t at our best. Maybe we were farming all day. Maybe we were even sinning all day. Maybe we were partying. Maybe we were partying in Ibiza and doing averot who knows where. Maybe we were sinning, right? We were having the sin of our lives.

Think about summertime in general. Not to generalize, but in general, people end up sinning a lot in the summer. People end up sinning a lot in the summer. It’s when the weather is good, when there are people out and about, the beaches, dressing, who knows what, right? We’re not judging, but this is in general, if we have to think about it. That’s when people are probably—think about Rosh Hashanah—we probably have a whole bunch of sins that we just did in the summertime, right? In the summer, the sun’s out and the beaches are open, and I don’t know what happens, right? People probably commit most of their sins in the summer.

If I’m God, why would I pick that day of the year to judge people if I want to give them a good chance? It’s not the best time to judge people. They don’t have to give a verdict. But it says in the Torah it’s actually the best time. You know why? Why? Because right before Rosh Hashanah, what does our parasha tell us? Leave the corner of your field. Leave the corner. And you may not want to leave the corner because you’re going to say to yourself, “Well, I’m going to leave it for Sam. Sam is a wicked guy. I’m going to leave it for Sam, Uncle Sam. Why are you going to give Sam my tzedakah? Sam is a sketch. I’m not going to leave the corner for Sam. I’d rather give it to someone I know. I know the other guy is a better guy. I’m going to leave it for this guy to take.”

It says in the Torah that nonetheless, you’re going to go out of your way and push yourself to give it anyway and leave it for him, even though maybe he’s undeserving, even though he’s unworthy. Ah. So if that’s what you did with people, says the heavens, measure for measure, measure for measure, I will be able to give you a good year, even though maybe you’re unworthy.

I remember many years ago, when I was studying in Kollel (Torah study hall) in Brooklyn, I was praying Shacharit (morning prayer) in the synagogue, and I saw a guy standing there with a nice laminated sign with all the works, all the details: “My father died young,” “this one is sick,” and “my sister’s getting married.” It was a very moving letter that, unfortunately, to be honest, I was very cynical about. I didn’t trust the letter for one second. It was just a vibe, I don’t know, whatever. Obviously, I didn’t call the guy out or say anything to him, but I politely walked by, declining to put my hand in my pocket.

I went to learn in Kollel next door, and as I was sitting and learning, an hour later, who walks in to collect? This man with the sign. I’m not sure what he was doing collecting in the Kollel, you know what I mean? It’s like the wrong place to collect. But either way, he was collecting in the Kollel, walking from table to table, and each guy there gave him a dollar, a dollar, two dollars. Finally, he got to our table. I was studying at the time with the Rosh Yeshiva, Rabbi Yehuda Eliyahu. A great rabbi. He was my chavruta, my study partner.

My rabbi looked at the sign and at the guy, bent over, pulled out a nice 20, and handed it to him. I was shocked, I was shocked. Twenty is very generous. As the guy left, I turned to my rabbi and said, “Rabbi, you bought that? You believe that sign?” My rabbi looked at me and said, “Ariel, you think he’s lying? You think it’s a sketch?” “I know it’s a sketch!” I said. “What?” He said, “I know the guy. I know his father. His father had the same exact sign 20 years ago.” I said, “Whoa. So you know the story is made up, and you still gave him? Why don’t you expose the guy?”

My rabbi told me, my friends, a lesson I’ll never forget. My rabbi looked at me and said, “I give him even though he doesn’t deserve, because I want Hashem to give me even though I don’t deserve.” That means that in life, if we’re going to be precise and exact with everybody, then, God forbid, that’s how the heavens are going to treat us. We can’t afford that. We can’t afford for the heavens to be exact. We want Hashem to give to us even though we’re undeserving, even though we sin, even though we’re not at our best, right? We want Hashem to understand, to forgive. So in life, we have to be that way with other people. We have to forgive. We have to understand. And when we do, we receive the greatest kindnesses, the most forgiveness, the most beautiful blessings from above.

May Hashem bless us to understand this lesson right here, smack in the middle of our parasha, Parashat Emor: an amazing lesson not only about the holidays, but about how, right before the holiday of Rosh Hashanah, God is telling us, “You want a good verdict in life? You want to get good things in life? You want a good year?” And this is not only a Rosh Hashanah lesson. Every day we’re asking Hashem for things. If that is the case, then we have to be able to dig deep within ourselves and realize that the way we treat others is how the heavens will treat us. When we’re able to leave the Peah, when we leave the corner of our fields, even though deep down maybe we’re wondering, curious, and suspicious, we say, “You know what? It doesn’t matter. It doesn’t matter. It doesn’t have to be perfect. It doesn’t have to be perfect. It’s okay, and I’m not perfect either.” And when we live like that, then middah keneged middah, measure for measure, the heavens will shower us with all the most beautiful berachot.